Active discussions

Please or to access all these features

Talk
What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

Original poster

Which authors' success is a complete mystery to you?

503 replies

emkana · 13/01/2008 19:15

Tony Parsons

Jodi Picoult

OP posts:
MaryAnnSingleton · 14/01/2008 10:11

I did like Jane Eyre !

redadmiral · 14/01/2008 10:12

Margaret Atwood too 'worthy' for me...

GetOrfMoiLand · 14/01/2008 10:13

Wuthering Heights - couldn't stand it. Hysterical nonsense.

Funnily enough was having a debate with stepson about this last week - he thinks WH is wonderful and I was going on about how crap it was. I think he was a bit shocked that anyone could be so critical about a classic (oh well he is only 20, has time to learn!)

alicefairfax · 14/01/2008 10:17

I have heard people say that you need to read WH as a teenager to get it properly. I must have been too jaded when I read it.

alicefairfax · 14/01/2008 10:18

Poalo Coelho- I thought the Alchamist was rubbish.

TheDuchessOfNorksBride · 14/01/2008 10:21

Wuthering Heights was OK. But it took 6 run-ups before I could finally read it all the way through. Would have been v. early 20s.

Michael Ondaate - vaguely repeating the same line several times really doesn't make things more poignant for me.

MaryAnnSingleton · 14/01/2008 10:47

would I be very bad if I threw in the towel with WH -? seems to me that life is too short to be dismally plodding through a book I don't care for - I only get to read at bedtime and then for a short time and usually look forward to those precious minutes - would much rather be reading something else. If it wasn't for book group I'd have abandonned it at first few pages - in fact,I wouldn't have bothered with it full stop.

TheDuchessOfNorksBride · 14/01/2008 10:52

ms - well it does improve the further you get. But the opening few chapters are hard work - certainly not light bedtime reading. The question is, how judgemental and intellectually-snobby is your book group?

Kewcumber · 14/01/2008 11:03

can I say Martin Amis again? Because he really is very rubbish and deserves several mentions...

Kewcumber · 14/01/2008 11:04

oh yes Wuthering Heights is bollocks too. Rarely give up on a book but lost the will to live during WH

MaryAnnSingleton · 14/01/2008 11:04

oh,they aren't intellectual or snobby in the least ! I just feel I'm being difficult in not wanting to carry on...

paulaplumpbottom · 14/01/2008 11:04

Dean Koontz. He just writes the same book over and over and over again.

Kewcumber · 14/01/2008 11:05

would fight to the death defending Jane Eyre though...

Kewcumber · 14/01/2008 11:06

Dean Koontz books give me the creeps - not in a nice way.

On an aside - I used to work with James Patterson.

redadmiral · 14/01/2008 11:14

Kewcumber. Have you tried his autobiography? (Amis). I love his writing but not always the sentiment behind it, but was 100% won over by the autobiography.

redadmiral · 14/01/2008 11:15

Mind you, not quite sure what's going on with his current dealings with Islam - haven't really been following it though.

Kewcumber · 14/01/2008 11:17

not wanting to be confrontational but I'd rather poke hot needles in my eyes than read martin Amis's autobiography...

UnquietDad · 14/01/2008 11:21

Agree that you have to read "Wuthering Heights" and "Jane Eyre" when a teenager - reading them as a cynical adult just doesn't have the same effect. And WH has serious structural issues!

Same is true of Tolkien - ideal age to read "The Hobbit" is pretty much as soon as you can read stuff without too many pictures, and "Lord of the Rings" maybe 11-14. That way they stay as cherished books all your life and you don't have to cope with them as a cynical adult, after people have banged on about them enough to put you off for life.

Kewcumber · 14/01/2008 11:26

I thought Lord of the rings was only read by pre-pubescent boys!

paulaplumpbottom · 14/01/2008 11:28

I read the Hobbit and the Trilogy when I was 14 and I loved it. I will certainly be recommending it to my dd. I don't know if I would enjoy it as much now though. I think you do need to read it young

UnquietDad · 14/01/2008 11:29

I'm having Hobbit (the computer game) nostalgia on Facebook right now!

MaryAnnSingleton · 14/01/2008 11:37

Unquiet - a male friend recently read WH (in his mid thirties) - he said it was intense and vivid and surprisingly twisted but couldn't see what all the fuss was about really.
Can you elaborate on the structural bits so that I could lob that in at book group to make up for not finishing the damn thing ?

Kewcumber · 14/01/2008 11:39

pmsl at the idea of using Mumsnet to cheat at your book club!

MaryAnnSingleton · 14/01/2008 11:40

arf ! I will confess ! but I will have to say something sensible

quickdrawmcgraw · 14/01/2008 11:48

Just stumbled across this...

Dan Brown
Daisy Meadows
Jk Rowling

re. Dan Brown..I did a cartoon a while back that someone else did the caption for that I thought was funny (see my profile)