Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

Can you always tell if a novel has been translated?

31 replies

BooteusMaximus · 25/08/2020 17:02

Afternoon all
I cannot work out if I am overthinking. I am reading a sample of
The silence of the white city and cannot work out if it is the writing that is stilted or because I know it was originally written in Spanish.
It was a big hit there four years ago and I want to buy it for someone but they once complained about The Girl with the dragon tattoo because it was poorly translated. Can you always tell or am I being hypersensitive?
Anyone who fancies looking at the sample on Amazon (Eve Garcia Saenz) and letting me know if it's me or not would be appreciated Grin
This is not a diss on translators either...it's a thankless task and requires a skillset I admire and don't have.

OP posts:
BooteusMaximus · 25/08/2020 20:23

Ooh, do you have an example?

OP posts:
rainyinscotland · 25/08/2020 20:19

Translations are sometimes better than the original.

BooteusMaximus · 25/08/2020 20:14

I think I have worked out what it is - the similes, good as they are, seem a bit clunky. It reminds me of when DD has an assignment checklist in English and puts in metaphors etc willy nilly.

OP posts:
BooteusMaximus · 25/08/2020 17:48

bump

OP posts:
BooteusMaximus · 25/08/2020 17:05

Thanks in advance for any insights Flowers Wine

OP posts:
BooteusMaximus · 25/08/2020 17:04

Oh and I never read the Stig Larsson myself, just watched the original film version with subtitles so that's not my critique. I have no idea whether it translated well into English or not.

OP posts: