Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Authors who are very popular but you just don't get....

211 replies

Corneliawildthing · 21/01/2020 18:38

I read the first Harry Potter book when my kids were little and was rather underwhelmed by it (maybe I wasn't the target audience). I started The Cuckoo's Calling and seemed to have been reading for about 2 hours and had only reached page 25.

My in-laws raved about the Stieg Larsson books but I think I lasted about 20 pages. Confused

OP posts:
Lobsterquadrille2 · 22/01/2020 08:15

Nodding in agreement with many of the above but genuinely surprised at the numbers who don't like Hardy and Lawrence. Can I respectfully recommend Tess of the D'Urbervilles and Sons and Lovers?

jeremypaxo · 22/01/2020 08:12

Deborah Levy. Pretentious pseudo-intellectual twaddle. Her metaphors have all the subtlety of a sledgehammer.

TooGood2BeTrue · 22/01/2020 08:07

@purpleme12 I totally agree with you. Well done for finishing the García Márquez book; I gave up halfway through!

DancelikeEmmaGoldman · 22/01/2020 07:31

I should add DH Lawrence to writers I dislike. All those horny-handed (and not only handed), hairy little men. On the other hand, I think Lawrence is a very fine poet.

DancelikeEmmaGoldman · 22/01/2020 07:28

I do love early Leslie Charteris - The Saint tweaking the nose of policemen. I tend to enjoy vintage thrillers, no matter how over-wrought.

On the other hand, I do not get on with the mid-century Americans. I despaired of Joseph Heller, thought Portnoy needed to get his hand off it, and was bored senseless by Kurt Vonnegut.

testing987654321 · 22/01/2020 07:25

I loved Elena Ferrante's Days of Abandonment but I don't think it's like her other books.

To the person who hadn't read the classics, give Great Expectations a go, quite an easy read.

bohemia14 · 22/01/2020 07:17

For me

Jane Austen
Tolkien
Terry Pratchett
Paolo Coelho

Interesting how we are all different - my favourite book ever is by Thomas Hardy!

ageingdisgracefully · 22/01/2020 07:12

Forgot Paul Auster. Had to read Moon Palace for book club. Drivel.

ageingdisgracefully · 22/01/2020 07:10

Kazuo Ishiguro. Boring.
Paula Hawkins. Overrated.
Terry Pratchett. Wtf?
Kate Mosse. Dull.
JoJo Moyes. Nope.
Anything that gets into the "unmissable" category at the Times. Missable.
Dan Brown. Can't do it.
Patricia Cornwell. Brutal.

I've started rereading all my old Rendell's and Vines as I can't find anyone I like as much.

Charley50 · 22/01/2020 07:10

Oh the Scarpetta books; awful too.
And against my better judgement I've just got an SJ Watson book out of the library. The plot is so ludicrous I'm not sure if I can carry on.

Charley50 · 22/01/2020 07:07

It's Sophie Hannah for me too. Her covers and blurb sound so gripping (so I've read more than one), but the books gave me a headache to read.
Also Paul Auster. I read his New York Trilogy, it was so dull and boring, didn't get the 'depth' of it at all..
Ian McEwan. I only read a few pages of Saturday and gave up.

evilharpyinapeartree · 22/01/2020 07:06

Glad someone mentioned Thomas Hardy, he ruined GCSE English language for me. Awful depressing heavy handed drivel. I’ve tried again several times as an adult... nope.

Agree with a few others mentioned. Tolkien, Pratchett, Patricia Cornwell. Chick lit in genera I just can’t be arsed with.

Martina Cole is one I don’t think has been mentioned. Rubbish. Terrible stilted and unnatural dialogue.

SexIsAProtectedCharacteristic · 22/01/2020 06:57

Any fantasy readers have guidance/recommendations for me?

Lies of Locke Lamora - a great audacious heist novel. If you don't like it there's no hope for you Crown Wink

MrsTerryPratchett · 22/01/2020 02:35

I can't believe the Terry Pratchett hatred. Sad

I agree about Jodie Picoult though. Just awful.

Graphista · 22/01/2020 02:24

As a lit grad some of mine were controversial especially when I was at uni:

Thomas Hardy - boring as! Way too verbose, too much description of scenery just urgh!

Most of the bronte sisters - I love wuthering heights and Jane eyre but the rest nah!

George Eliot - nope! Total yawn fest!

Among modern authors:

Dan brown - I’m not averse to fluff but his stuff is dreadfully written

John Grisham - LOVE the movies but the books are soooo pretentious and waffly

I love crime fiction so someone bought me something by martina Cole - dreadful! Awful writing and it’s clear she’s in awe of despicable gang people who have killed and hurt so many people.

BUT I love

Austen - op p&p is a bit of a slow burner but it gets really good.

Dickens - funny, caricatures, social commentary, “soap” in written form what’s not to like?

Stieg Larsson I read before he was a “thing” recommended by a uni lecturer to me. Loved it.

Marian Keyes is a favourite author...but her earlier stuff I’ve not enjoyed her more recent books as much.

“James Joyce defeated me, but I might try him again.” To be fair defeats most people - somewhat intentionally! I find most modernist writing very unapproachable but I do like Joyce. I suggest starting with the Dubliners as an “easy” intro to Joyce, then perhaps Ulysses but Finnegans wake is really only for the most masochistic! (And lit students aiming for a first! 😂)

@fruitpastille - behind the scenes at the museum was a set text at uni, I was not looking forward to it, the blurb put me off not my kinda book I thought - took a while to get into but then I absolutely loved it!

“Thomas Hardy - really hard going” god I’m glad it’s not just me! I got such a hard time for it at uni!

I must admit I love Agatha Christie and sir Arthur Conan Doyle. I keep meaning to (and have often been told to) try Dorothy l sayers

Sue grafton (rip) - LOVE these books, so easy to read but not insulting to ones intelligence, characters that are easy to like even though flawed... love em.

But yes I think it’s great we all like different things and I loved discussing the likes and dislikes at uni and loved that everyone had their own passions.

I’d like to like fantasy (terry pratchett, jrr Tolkien, Neil gaiman, Phillip Pullman etc but my heart sinks at the thought of the effort to follow a story with backgrounds I don’t already understand, difficult to understand character names and place names and even whole other languages! I guess I’m a lazy reader but I feel I’m missing out because I enjoyed reading fantasy as a child - Enid blyton, cs Lewis, Joan Aiken, Lewis Carrol, Jonathon swift...

Any fantasy readers have guidance/recommendations for me?

Pinkarsedfly · 22/01/2020 02:14

Kazuro Ishiguro.
Sally Rooney.
Terry Pratchett.

alwayscrashinginthesamecar1 · 22/01/2020 02:09

Anything Paulo Coelho turns his hand to is a steaming pile of shite, and that Eat Pray Love woman should be shot. JK Rowling is ok, but seriously over-rated. Dickens is awful, but I love Austen and Hardy.

londonmarathonhalfwaypoint · 22/01/2020 01:43

Irvine Welsh.

MAFIL · 22/01/2020 01:38

Jacqueline Wilson.
When the world is full of so many fantastic children's books written over the centuries I have no idea why schools are so keen on this garbage.

Elbeagle · 22/01/2020 01:26

Kate Atkinson.

ioioitsoff · 22/01/2020 01:13

Steig Larrsson
David Walliams - drivel of the highest order
Kate Atkinson - well written but I don't see what the fuss is about

purpleme12 · 22/01/2020 00:57

Well I've just read Love in the Time of Cholera by Gabriel Garcia Marquez and I have to say I won't be reading any of his again! I cannot understand why it's a classic!

TheSandman · 22/01/2020 00:54

‘Bestselling’ Katie Price! Why?

Best selling maybe but does anyone actually READ them?

I've undertaken a project recently to read books by once fantastically popular (mostly pulp) authors who are now - I suspect well out of fashion: Alistair MacLean, Sax Rohmer, Edgar Wallace, Leslie Charteris - etc.

Most have them have been dreadful, some have, occasionally, stepped fearlessly and with firm determined steps - yet, the author thought as he typed grimly, sweat beading his brow - with a certain hesitant insouciant carelessness, right into 'so bad they are good' territory.

Popular authors being crap is nothing new.

tobee · 22/01/2020 00:35

Oh thank god other people have said Kate Atkinson!

I thought I'd have to leave Mumsnet. Grin

TooGood2BeTrue · 21/01/2020 22:55

Tolkien
Dostoyevsky
JK Rowling
David Williams

Swipe left for the next trending thread