Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

50 Book Challenge 2019 Part Five

991 replies

southeastdweller · 09/05/2019 22:08

Welcome to the fifth thread of the 50 Book Challenge for this year.

The challenge is to read fifty books (or more!) in 2019, though reading fifty isn't mandatory. Any type of book can count, it’s not too late to join, and please try to let us all know your thoughts on what you've read.

The first thread of the year is here, the second one here, the third one here and the fourth one here.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
southeastdweller · 24/07/2019 12:24

New thread here!

OP posts:
Tarahumara · 24/07/2019 11:41

OK, I will track down the footnotes online!

bibliomania · 24/07/2019 11:32

The October Man, by Ben Aaronovitch
A novella linked to The Rivers of London series, and the usual mash-up of police procedural and magical, although this time with a new set of characters and a move to Germany. I'm not sure the new setting and people brought much - it felt like a rehash of his normal schtick, and I initially missed a reference to a character who turned out to be important, so had to page back to find him. That said, I still enjoy spending some time in his world. Overall, one for the fans (not intended as damning with faint praise - I think authors should treat their fans!)

Sadik · 24/07/2019 09:16
  1. Hamlet, Revenge! by Michael Innes

1937 mystery novel, set in a grand Ducal house where a private production of Hamlet is taking place, with the cast and guests including various of the great and the good. Predictably, all does not go smoothly, and Inspector John Appleby is called in to resolve things.

There was lots to like about this - as might be expected, plenty of literary jokes & references, a suitably twisty mystery and decent characters. It was spoiled by (to my mind even for 1937) spectacularly racist portrayal of Mr Bose, an Indian academic. I find it hard to imagine that an academic who studied at Oxford and then worked in various universities had never met any Indian students or scholars, and was therefore completely unable to imagine them as actual people, but it seems like this must have been the case. I finished it because I was on the train (and annoyingly hadn't brought any of my paper books), but it really spoiled the book especially as his actions and supposed motivation were significant within the plot.

Sadik · 24/07/2019 09:01
  1. Uprooted by Naomi Novik I've read this previously, but listened to it as an audio book as it's available from the library online service & I think the updated fairy tale style works well read aloud.
    I enjoyed it, but of the two I liked Spinning Silver the better - both as an audio book (Uprooted is told in just one voice, and part of the pleasure of Silver was the different voices used by Katy Sobel for the different characters) and as a story. The women in Silver win out because of their cleverness, whereas in Uprooted everything gets solved by wavy-hand magic, which isn't quite as satisfying.
PepeLePew · 24/07/2019 07:47

Tara - they really do! Some just add to the general merriment but others are quite integral to the plot or important additional information (eg the one explaining subsidised time). And reading the book involves a lot of flipping back and forth which was initially annoying but ultimately part of the whole reading experience.

But that makes sense of the length - my first thought was "only 55 hours?"!

PowerBadgersUnite · 24/07/2019 07:44

I love Infinite Jest it's one of my favourite books. The footnotes are huge and wonderful.

Tarahumara · 24/07/2019 07:34

Pepe the Audible version doesn't have the footnotes so I missed out on them! Do they add a lot to the main narrative?

Terpsichore · 23/07/2019 23:13

Belatedly thinking of Cornish books for you, @PepeLePew - have you read Summer in February by Jonathan Smith? It's set in the Lamorna artists' colony which included Alfred Munnings. They made a film of it, too.

Having said all of the above, I'm completely unable to vouch for it because, although our book club 'did' it, I had to give it a miss for various reasons, so I never read it! Reviews seemed to be generally positive. And it's possibly another to add to your list, if you haven't already read it.

PepeLePew · 23/07/2019 22:34

tara, you listened to the audiobook?? I'm in awe. How do the footnotes (and footnotes to the notes) work?
If I ever read it again I'm going to do the chronological version you can find online. I'm still unscrambling my brain after finishing it in May.

Tarahumara · 23/07/2019 22:13
  1. Infinite Jest by David Foster Wallace. I listened to this as an audio book, and as it is a whopping 55 hours long and I only listen for a few hours a week it feels like I have been listening to it forever! (It has actually been since March!) It is written as a series of vignettes, some of which add to the plot or characterisation, some of which are completely random, and some of which appear to be the latter but do eventually end up contributing to the former. It is set mainly in an elite junior tennis academy in Boston and a nearby halfway house for recovering addicts, with an additional theme of Canadian separatism running through it. Wallace’s skill is in building up a scene with an incredible level of precision and detail, and I found myself completely entwined in the multiple strands of narrative. It’s also very funny at times. I loved it but would hesitate to recommend it widely - I can imagine some would hate it! Excellently read by Sean Pratt.
nowanearlyNicemum · 23/07/2019 21:05

Another thumbs up for Holes here. DD1 read it at school a couple of years back and I'd never heard of it at the time. Have since watched the film too. Great family entertainment!

Just thought of another book set in Cornwall Pepe. I'm quite a Jenny Colgan fan because I know her IRL and can just hear her voice coming through when I read her books. Little Beach Street Bakery is delightful and quite a perfect holiday read in my opinion.

grimupnorthLondon · 23/07/2019 20:53

@RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie I hope Father Christmas obliges and that you enjoy it. Been a while since I felt this evangelical about a book :)

RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie · 23/07/2019 20:52

Holes is great. The film is very good too.

TheTurnOfTheScrew · 23/07/2019 20:49

I fell off the thread again. I wish I could say there was some work or personal crisis at play, but the reality is that every few months we'll get a month's Netflix/Amazon/NowTV membership and binge-watch shite like people who have never seen TV before. It'll expire soon.

In the meantime I did read 29.Rachel's Holiday by Marian Keyes. I'd not read any of her stuff before, but when I've seen her on telly Keys seems so warm and clever and likeable that when this was on Kindle Deal I though I should try it.

Twenty something Rachel parties that bit too hard when living in New York and ends up in residential drug rehab back home in Ireland. There are some half-decent jokes, and the serious subject matter is handled sensitively. However I was irritated enormously by the two romantic storylines and the cheesy happy ending, when something more nuanced would have felt more natural. I also think i would probably have liked this more had I read it in my twenties, rather than approaching it as the wizened old crone I am now.

I have added Evening in the Palace of Reason to my wish list following all the reviews.

ScribblyGum · 23/07/2019 20:27

ShakeItOff I'm nodding away at your reviews. Undying was a tough read for me too, I was moved to tears several times.

Holes is a great family holiday car audiobook. We listened to it a few years back and yes you are right it did provoke lots of discussions with us as well. Great story.

ChessieFL · 23/07/2019 20:04

The Binding is number 130 not 140!

ChessieFL · 23/07/2019 20:03
  1. The Darksome Bounds Of A Failing World by Gareth Russell

This follows the sinking of Titanic through the eyes of several of its first class passengers, examining their experiences on the ship and wider society of the time. I’ve read lots of Titanic books and thought this was excellent. It’s detailed but interesting too - I liked reading more about what was going on in the world generally and how that impacted those on the ship - and it still managed to tell me things I didn’t already know. Highly recommended if you’re interested in Titanic.

  1. A Cornish Summer by Catherine Alliott

Flora goes to stay with her ex husband’s family at their estate in Cornwall and needless to say things don’t go to plan. Some of Alliott’s later books haven’t been quite as good but I enjoyed this - not quite as predictable as some of hers.

  1. Once Upon A River by Diane Setterfield

Set in a village along the Thames during the Victorian era. A girl is rescued from the river in winter. She appears to be dead but then comes back to life. Nobody is sure who she is and several people try to claim her. This reminded me quite a lot of The Essex Serpent. It’s not a fast paced story, meandering along like the river at the centre of the story, but if you like historical fiction with magical elements this is worth a look.

  1. At Home: A Short History of Private Life by Bill Bryson

Fascinating book - he takes a tour around his house and uses each room as a jumping off point to discuss pretty much anything! The history of gardening, why we have 4 tines on a fork, the clergy, fashion to name a few.

  1. Playgroups and Prosecco by Jo Middleton

One of these mummy diary books that seem to be popular at the moment. Nothing original about this but was quite funny.

  1. The Binding by Bridget Collins

Another one that reminded me of The Essex Serpent. In this, books are the trapped memories of people who want to forget. Emmett becomes an apprentice bookbinder but then discovers a book with his name loved the idea and the first part of the book was good, but it lost its way in parts two and three and Collins didn’t make the most of her good idea.

ShakeItOff2000 · 23/07/2019 19:19

42. Undying: A Love Story by Michel Faber.

I loved this book of poetry which actually made me cry at times. Most of the poems were written during the time his wife was unwell and dying from multiple myeloma (a type of leukaemia). It is clear that he loved her very much. I will be buying a copy to read again someday (this copy was a library book).

43. Holes by Louis Sachar.

Excellent modern classic of a children’s book. We listened to this through Audible with my two DSs (7 and 10) whilst travelling in the car on our holidays. Whilst some of it went over the head my youngest, my 10 year old loved it and it reduced the back seat bickering (result!). My DH and I loved it too. A great story with so many talking points and the narration is excellent.

Me too, Remus, although it sounds perfect for DH.

Grim - I enjoyed reading your reviews and entirely agreed with your review of TTOD.

nowanearlyNicemum · 23/07/2019 16:01

24. Breathing Lessons – Anne Tyler
Anne Tyler works her magic yet again by recounting humdrum everyday snippets from American family life and making it feel like you’ve known some of the family members forever, and genuinely care how their lives turn out.

On a personal note, I have recognised I may have a few Maggie-like tendencies Shock Confused Blush Better rein those in!

RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie · 23/07/2019 15:16

Grim - adding Berlin to my Christmas wish list!

grimupnorthLondon · 23/07/2019 13:56

In an attempt to distract myself from today's seemingly-inevitable-but-horrific-nevertheless political news, have done some long overdue catching up on reviews:

34 - A Buyer’s Market - Anthony Powell
Am well behind the thread-pack on this one and have only reached number 2 of DTMOT but enjoying it hugely. Particularly Widmerpool's appearance in the dungeons followed by his little driving mishap. Volume three (and possibly four) are on my holiday reading list.

35 - Chernobyl: History of a Tragedy - Serhii Plokhy
Opted for the book instead of the TV series and found it fascinating, if rather terrifying. I thought the detailed explanations of how decision-making worked and power was actually exercised in the Soviet state and its satellites were well done and horribly thought provoking. Particularly the section on the payments made to the divers who went in after the explosion, knowing that the job would probably kill them. Such an alien mindset for those of us living in the West and (imho) a good reminder of the value of what we have in a free society, however flawed.

36 - A Body of Work - David Hallberg
This is the autobiography of an American ballet dancer who became the first Westerner to be made a principal dancer at the Bolshoi in around 2010. I was interested since it brings together my obsession with all things Russian as well as a weakness for watching ballet. Also, his time at the Bolshoi covered the recent scandal when one of the dancers employed someone to throw acid in the director's face and the whole theatre divided into factions. However, the book was insanely bland, navel-gazing and self-regarding. Hallberg should probably stick to dancing (which faod, he does very well indeed).

37 - Berlin - Jason Lutes
My first ever graphic novel and surprise favourite book of the year so far. DH has been on at me for ages to read this book, set at the end of Weimar era, just as the Nazis are rising to power. The characters include a young art student coming to Berlin to study, a Jewish family, black jazz players from the US, social democrat activists and street children. With a bit of decadent Weimar orgy thrown in for good measure. It took the author over 25 years to write/draw and I found it astonishingly gripping, moving and powerful. Totally overcame my ignorant prejudice against graphic novels. Unfortunately the book is very heavy (500 pages) and quite expensive but it is a thing of real beauty - a major work of art.

38 - Crime and Punishment - Fyodor Dostoyevsky
Have been reading this for over a year and finally finished! Have to get into the 'Russian' mood for this one, but it is brilliant and tremendously evocative of late 19th century St Petersburg. All the male characters are fairly repulsive and the women are either repulsive or saintly/helpless victims, everyone does a lot of weeping and philosophising, the second epilogue reads as though Dostoyeveky is predicting twitter (character has a fever dream where everyone in the world is convinced that they are right and starts yelling at each other and not listening), the actual murder is not really held against anyone and it's a confusing but amazing epic. Strongly recommend, although maybe not on a beach lounger.

39 - Bolshoi Confidential - Simon Morrison
Still in the Russian/ballet mood, tried to see whether I could improve on the not-very-good-dancer's-autobiography, with a history of the Bolshoi Theatre since its founding, which happened around the time of the Napoleonic wars. This was good in places but somewhat patchy. The best bits were the stories of dancers, choreographers and composers trying to work in the early Soviet years and through the Stalin-purges and 'Great Patriotic War'. The story of Shostakovich's travails at the hands of the regime is heartbreaking. But probably mainly a book for the ballet enthusiast.

40 - This Thing of Darkness - Harry Thompson
Finally caught up to the thread. I really, really enjoyed this (for the most part) and the author successfully brought to life the times and places, both on the voyages and at home in the heart of the 'Evil Empire'. However, I think it had some serious flaws as a novel - he might have done better to stick to either Fitzroy or Darwin's point of view, rather than so much switching (although understand that would have presented difficulties with showing Darwin's trips into the South American interior) and it wore its research rather heavily. I was also very disappointed to read in the endnotes that the author had totally made up a couple of incidents, such as Sullivan's intervention in the Falklands trial. I really don't mind historical invention, where the author invents his leading characters around well known events, with the 'famous' figures in the story just making a cameo. But if a novel gives the reader the impression that it's based on true events starring the main historical figures (albeit with an understood licence to invent the characters' dialogue/thoughts) it undermines that trust to find at the end that some of it didn't happen that way. So a very interesting read but might perhaps have been better as non-fiction? Hope that doesn't bring the wrath of the thread down on my head....

41 - Anne Frank: The Biography - Melissa Muller
We were in Amsterdam recently and I picked this up to read on the train home. Nothing very new to anyone who has read Anne's diary but the background on her family's move from Germany prior to the war and on the people who helped them while in hiding was very interesting. The speculation about who might have betrayed them seemed a bit gossipy though, and when I googled the issue it seems that this author's 'theory' has been pretty much discredited.

nowanearlyNicemum · 23/07/2019 12:22

I think Kate Morton's The Forgotten Garden is set in Cornwall. Good holiday read.

grimupnorthLondon · 23/07/2019 11:38

@pepelepew On Cornwall recommendations, Zennor in Darkness by Helen Dunmore is quite good if you haven't already read it. Set during the first world war in the area around St Ives and featuring a 'star cameo' by D.H.Lawrence.

MabelParente · 23/07/2019 09:39

Great list of great books! I only read few of them (don't have much time to read now) but in future I will continue this list

Swipe left for the next trending thread