Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

50 Book Challenge 2018 Part Five

996 replies

southeastdweller · 23/04/2018 20:29

Welcome to the fifth thread of the 50 Book Challenge for this year.

The challenge is to read fifty books (or more!) in 2018, though reading fifty isn't mandatory. Any type of book can count, it’s not too late to join, and please try to let us all know your thoughts on what you've read.

The first thread of the year is here, the second one here, the third one here and the fourth one here.

How're you getting on so far?

OP posts:
clarabellski · 15/05/2018 12:34

Hi everyone, been on holiday so haven't RTFT yet. Only managed to finish one book on hols though:

  1. Why Mummy Drinks by Gill Sims.
  2. Ancillary Justice by Ann Leckie
  3. Ancillary Sword by Ann Leckie.
4 Ancillary Mercy by Ann Leckie.
  1. Eleanor Oliphant Is Completely Fine by Gail Honeyman.
  2. "Blink" Malcolm Gladwell.
  3. "Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance" by Robert Pirsig.
  4. "Persepolis RIsing" by James SA Corey.
  5. “Guernica” by Dave Boling.
10. “Harvest” by Tess Gerritsen. 11. "Grit" by Angela Duckworth. 12. "The Hive" by Gill Hornby. 13. "The Nix" by Nathan Hill. I liked the descriptions and observations (some made me laugh out loud, some were a bit uncomfortable!) but the plot was a bit silly for me in the end.
TooExtraImmatureCheddar · 15/05/2018 12:02
  1. Dragon Prince, Melanie Rawn.

First novel and it shows - some good concepts but it all gets a bit long-winded towards the end. I read this a long time ago and went back to revisit it - I remember reading books 2 and 3 and not being massively gripped by them, and not bothering with the second trilogy. This time I do want to read the second trilogy, but I am struggling with the first! I can't remember very much at all about it, though, so I need to at least skim it.

whippetwoman · 15/05/2018 11:42

44. The Word for Woman is Wilderness - Abi Andrews
So, so disappointed by this. It could have been awesome. Such a great premise; 19 yr old Erin sets off on a journey to Alaska in defiance of men like Chris McCandless and Bear Grylls, to prove that women can also live and travel alone in the wilderness.
There is some great feminist writing in this novel and a lot of astute discussion around the natural world, science and the environment, but it turns from what reads like an ok travelogue to rambling cod philosophising for pages and pages. The last section is dire. This is a book that doesn't know what it wants to be and it shows. I only gave it two stars on Goodreads. So glad to finish it and move on!

SatsukiKusakabe · 15/05/2018 08:30

orangecake Catcher in the Rye maybe ticks boxes of classic and mental health if you haven’t got to it already.

Tender is the Night by Fitzgerald deals with mental health and is somewhat autobiographical about his marriage with Zelda.

Mad Bad and Sad by Lisa Appignanesi is good non fic about the history of mental health treatment in relation to women from 1800 on and takes in the cases of notable women such as Plath and Woolf.

Speaking of Woolf - To the Lighthouse

southeastdweller · 15/05/2018 07:45

Mental health books I recommend:

Reasons to Stay Alive - Matt Haig
Overcoming Depression - Paul Gilbert

Talking of which...

  1. Lost Connections: Uncovering the Real Causes of Depression – and the Unexpected Solutions - Johann Hari. Non-fiction book which attempts to debunk the notion that depression is caused by a chemical imbalance in the brain and instead by being disconnected from things like nature, other people and meaningful jobs. I broadly agree with what he's saying but I was amazed to see only one short reference about exercise helping depression, despite the many studies that have shown how beneficial it is and I also thought the author could have been more revealing about his own struggles. I'm also a bit annoyed that he's framed his ideas as something new, when they're not. But it's still an interesting read.
OP posts:
ScribblyGum · 15/05/2018 06:56

splother that is so hilarious, I had that exact same morning sickness passage from Sight, page top folded over and everything, as an example of why I found all just too much. A progression paused before the point of resolution, acting forward." Good grief, just have a ginger nut.
I agree about her long suffering husband too. Loved the bit when they went on holiday to Italy (at the wrong time so it was cold ) and she got to spend the first night alone in a nice hotel (where she felt sad introspective thoughts) and he went on ahead to get things ready for her. Grin
I've been doing holidays wrong for YEARS.

PepeLePew · 14/05/2018 22:25

Orangecake, if you want classics with protagonists with mental health issues, I’d recommend Hangover Square by Patrick Hamilton. Not sure if that’s what you are after but saw you mentioned The Bell Jar. Hangover Square is heartbreaking but one of my favourite books. It’s not widely read but should be - it’s set just before WW2 breaks out and tells the story of George Bone, a possible schizophrenic, who’s in love with one of the worst women you’ll meet in literature. Patrick Hamilton is totally under-rated, I think, and Hangover Square is his best book. Not a happy read, but an excellent exploration of love, misery and mental health.

Piggywaspushed · 14/05/2018 21:33

orange , try The Yellow Wallpaper and Girl, Interrupted?

Orangecake123 · 14/05/2018 20:38

Thank you for the replies. ;) I wouldn't mind either fiction or non fiction. I've read the bell jar. A unquiet mind and the gift of therapy.

I've read Bryony's first book "the wrong knickers" so will add that to my list. The problem is that I have too many random books on it already.

Has anyone joined scribd? They have both books and audiobooks for a set fee of around £8 a month I think. I liked the trial but I have exams coming up at the moment so didn't sign up.

Toomuchsplother · 14/05/2018 20:23

Re Ali Smith - it's 'rub' along not 'run' !

Toomuchsplother · 14/05/2018 20:23

I have a great affection for Gatsby after reading it for A level.

I think I must be in the minority with regards to Autumn. Ali Smith and I don't run along well!

70. Sight - Jessie Greengrass. I suspect I didn't really didn't do this justice. I found this just too introspective. There is no doubt that Greengrass can write but there is so much internal agonising and loooong sentences that after a while I was switching off - repeatedly!!
Some of her observations regarding grief and motherhood are insightful and beautiful but then we get this pretentious description of morning sickness...
"I had forgotten to feel sick, but now it returned, the constant queasy ostinato over which rose exhaustion's disharmonious cadence, a progression paused before the point of resolution, acting forwards."
I was rolling my eyes a lot reading this. Every time I was about to abandon it I stumbled across a gem in the prose and pressed onwards.
I can see why it was shortlisted. However I think that the author needs to stop trying so flipping hard. The whole thing feels like a creative writing exercise.
Also I have an overwhelming feeling that the narrator is flipping hard work as a person! Her husband must be a saint! I wonder how much she is based on the author's own experiences!

Piggywaspushed · 14/05/2018 19:14
  1. Closing The Vocabulary Gap : Alex Quigley. One of the new talked about books in education. Bit of a yawnfest, to be honest, important as the ideas are. Ended up skimming (ironically a skill all these literacy gurus are fond of!)
ScribblyGum · 14/05/2018 19:10

noodlezoodle I can highly recommend The Song of Achilles too, the only negative particularly on a kindle is the lack of a beautiful shiny cover.

Tarahumara · 14/05/2018 19:04

Orangecake if you are looking for non fiction I recommend Mad Girl by Bryony Gordon, about her struggles with severe OCD.

RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie · 14/05/2018 18:38

56: Eat Me: A Natural and Unnatural History of Cannibalism – Bill Schutt
Glad I got this heavily reduced! It was just about worth £3 but I’d have been v disappointed if I’d paid much more. Bits of it are good – there’s an interesting section on cannibalism and copulation in spiders and snails, and a few interesting bits about human cannibalism – the Donner party and mourning rituals in little known tribes in particular. On the whole though, I thought this failed to deliver what it promised, and (apologies for being low brow!) I’d have liked a few fewer insects etc and a bit more human gore!

Sadik · 14/05/2018 18:36

36 Balanced on the Blade's Edge by Lindsay Buroker

Enjoyable light fantasy novel. Sorceror / healer Sardelle wakes up in the mage shelter where she has taken refuge as her home was attacked - only to discover that she has been in magical stasis for 300 years, and in the interim all of her people have been wiped out, and anyone suspected of witchcraft is executed. Ridge Zirkander is a military pilot/commander who has been demoted for insubordination and posted to run the prison that Sardelle's mountain home has become - and has to figure out what to do with this strange woman who has appeared amongst his prisoners.

This is one of a trilogy, and was a kindle freebie (as The Dragon Blood Collection) - it's not perfect, and takes a while to get going, but overall I enjoyed it, and will definitely read the next two in the series

Piggywaspushed · 14/05/2018 18:24

Mental health : do you mean fictional or factual orange?

ChessieFL · 14/05/2018 17:51

Great Gatsby definitely worth reading and also quite short!

Orangecake123 · 14/05/2018 17:23

Book 14: Crime and punishment by Fyodor Dostoyevsky.

I actually enjoyed it.

I didn't finish sense and sensibility- I will go back to it eventually. I think I will start 12 years a slave which my aunt bought for me.

I want to go through a few classics. Is the great Gastby worth reading? Does anyone have any recommendations for books about mental health?

Tarahumara · 14/05/2018 16:21
  1. Bookworm: a Memoir of Childhood Reading by Lucy Mangan. I absolutely adored this. I do agree with other reviewers that a large part of the joy of reading it comes from the nostalgia element, when she talks about much-loved childhood favourites (a special mention from me for The Owl Who Was Afraid of the Dark, The Family From One End Street, the Melendy and Marlow books and Goodnight, Mister Tom), but that was not a problem for me Smile.
PandaPacer · 14/05/2018 13:29

Loving all the catch-ups here with everyone. I have four more to add since I was here last.

21. The Woman in White by Wilkie Collins - just in time to see the TV series which I did persist with, much to my to DH's displeasure as I outlined all the ways it was different to the book after every episode (annoying, right?). Let's not talk about Count Fosco in the adaptation. Why was he so young and so SLIM!?

22. The Five People you Meet in Heaven by Mitch Albom - a sweet, sad tale of an old man who dies, and goes to heaven to meet five people who he came across in his life on who's life he impacted, or who impacted on his life. It was time for people to explain each other. It was sweet but I didn't love it to death like some of the reviews I have read. A light book after finishing TWIW.

23. Peter Pan by JM Barrie - I am ashamed to admit I have never previously read this, although I know the story of course. I read it to my kids and we were much scandalised by the negligence of the parents, the nastiness of Tinkerbell, and the sadness of the Lost Boys. We laughed hard at the crocodile with the clock every time. They are 9 and 12 by the way, probably too old for this, but I was happy they loved it nevertheless (and they found out why our Wendy House is called such)

24. Autumn by Ali Smith - Much reviewed and lauded here. The first one by this author I have read. To be honest I had not heard of her until I moved to the UK, but I noticed in the library she has a whole shelf of works. I gave it four out of five stars on Goodreads (I rarely give five). She has such a way with words, but perhaps this fell victim in my head to all the hype. My expectations were high!

TWIW slowed me down, but feeling happy I am on track to get to 25 halfway through the year!

BeatriceJoanna · 14/05/2018 11:55

I just added Circe to my TBR - it seems to be receiving universal praise. I haven't seen a bad review yet.

I finished book 17 Bonnie Dundee by Rosemary Sutcliff later than intended as my family got a bit demanding. (Don't you just hate it when people insist you go out of the house and do stuff when there are books you want to read?) This is the story of a groom (who later becomes a soldier) in the service of John Graham of Claverhouse, Viscount Dundee (the 'Bonnie Dundee' of the title). Claverhouse was commisioned to root out Covenanters in the Dumfries/Galloway region in the reign of Charles II. He remained loyal to James II after the 1688 revolution and so became a 'traitor' with a price on his head and was killed at the Battle of Killiecrankie - the first 'Jacobite' battle - in 1689.
I liked the depiction of Claverhouse, and the way his relationship with his wife is developed. There was a good sense of place, particularly the descriptions of Dumfriesshire, Galloway and, later, the Highlands in the run up to the battle.
What let the book down for me was that I just could not warm to the main character/narrator and I can't quite figure out why. So, all in all, I quite liked this but didn't love it.

I was intending to read Andrew Murray Scott's biography of Claverhouse next but I've put that on hold as Katie over on is doing a Barsetshire week and it's ages since I read any Trollope so I'm going to try to read some of the Barsetshire novels over the next couple of weeks. (realistically two) starting with The Warden

TooExtraImmatureCheddar · 14/05/2018 11:19
  1. The Changeling, Victor Lavalle.

To preface, I had a stillborn baby in 2011 and the changeling myth really resonated with me at the time. I therefore spent a lot of the first part of the book mentally withdrawing to protect myself. That said, this was actually a very clever look at modern parenting, birth, expectations, pressures etc, linked in cleverly to older mythology eg changelings, trolls, witches. As a story it had massive gaping holes (how were they meant to explain eg grave-desecration, murder, returning from the dead, the outstanding warrants for arrest, things like that) but if you ignore all that and treat it as a fairy tale in the original sense (ie, tales for adults, not children) then it works really well. The hero, Apollo, was an arse (he goes around muttering I am Apollo, the god to himself), but he had to learn that his perception was not always right, and that was the focus of the story. As a side-bar, I was outraged by the paltry 6 weeks maternity leave American women get! I knew that, but this book really brings home how inhumane it is. Apollo titting around with the baby playing New Dad while his poor wife was sent off to work while expressing milk and still at the stage of keeping sanitary towels in the freezer for her sore bits gave me the rage.

  1. Autumn, Ali Smith.

I really enjoyed this. I am stunned at Ali Smith's ability to write and publish a book dealing with the impact of Brexit so swiftly after the referendum, and done so well. I said as much to my DSis, and she said that apparently Smith is notorious in publishing circles for refusing to deliver her books until about a month before publication, which is way later than most authors would get away with. But even so, to have produced a book of this calibre so quickly is incredible, even if she had most of the Elisabeth-Daniel-Pauline Boty storyline already. Again, I'd never heard of Pauline Boty and was delighted to discover that she was actually a real person. The Christine Keeler stuff was fascinating as well - especially given the timing of her death last year (post-publication of Autumn!) and her inclusion in series 2 of The Crown. I was wondering how someone who supported Leave would find the experience of reading Autumn - how different that would be from a Remainer's point of view! This was my first Ali Smith, and I'll be borrowing Winter from DSis next time I go round.

  1. Chronicles of Avonlea, LM Montgomery.

Re-read. DM moved house recently and in her new shared hall, there's a bookcase with a whole lot of hardback LM Montgomery novels, in exactly the same sort of cover/binding as the copies my granny has. I think they're Chambers editions from the 1930s or similar - will check when I get home. I borrowed this one just for the fun of getting that same reading experience as when I was a kid reading Granny's copies of Anne of the Island or the Chalet School!

CoteDAzur · 14/05/2018 10:38
  1. Light by M John Harrison (Kefahuchi Tract Trilogy #1)

I can't say I'm 100% sure re wtf I just read, but it wasn't an entirely disagreeable experience Confused

This book follows three characters. One is a theoretical physicist who is also a serial killer. He is in the past and apparently ends up discovering something major that leads to space travel in the future. Another is a girl who gives up her life to be integrated into a spacefaring ship built with alien technology as its captain, never to be herself or have a body again. The third is a bit of a con artist who seems to have a knack for telling the future. Meanwhile, there's some anomaly in space called Kefahuchi Tract. Every 10 pages or so, we are told about how it shines with different colours.

I don't know whether I should recommend it. I'm a bit dissatisfied with it because nothing much was resolved and some of it was annoying & made no sense, like "shadow operators", but there were also some interesting ideas in there.

exexpat · 14/05/2018 09:42

Flaneuse by Lauren Elkin

I think I wanted to like this book more than I really ended up liking it.

This is non-fiction, subtitled "Women Walk the City in Paris, New York, Tokyo, Venice and London".

I am a woman who has always loved meandering around cities, hanging out in cafes, reading books about people (particularly women) who do similar things. I have lived in or visited all the cities she writes about. I should have loved this.

Some parts I did like; the first chapter in particular, where she defines and discusses the concept of 'flaneuse' (a made-up female version of the word 'flaneur', which is a man of leisure and culture who strolls the city streets and ponders on life), and how women have not had the freedom to claim the streets as their own in the same way that men have, how women cannot be invisible on the streets and blend into the background as an observer, in the way that a male flaneur has always been able to do.

She writes quite a lot about her own experiences in the various cities, but just as much (if not more) about a number of female authors and the cities they walked in and wrote about: Virginia Woolf in London, George Sand and Jean Rhys in Paris etc. Some of this was interesting, but when it came to the chapter on Agnes Varda, a french film maker, she basically recounted an entire 1960s film about a woman walking around Paris for two hours, which made it feel like the longest chapter in the book. Maybe it would have helped if I had heard of Varda or seen the film. The chapter on Martha Gellhorn also seemed a bit shoehorned into the theme of the book, as if she wanted to write about Gellhorn so was going to fit her in no matter what.

And the chapter on Tokyo, where she lived off and on for a while with her ex-fiancee as their relationship fell apart, had me wanting to scream at her that of course Tokyo is an eminently walkable city, she was just in the wrong bit of it and obviously didn't pull herself together to go out to explore properly (some of my most enjoyable days of flanerie have been in the quirky backstreets and side streets and cafes of Tokyo).

Overall, I am glad I read this; there were parts that explored ideas in interesting ways and references to people and books I am likely to look up, but it turned out to be more of a mishmash of personal memoir, snippets of literary biographies and meditation on life in general than the book about women and cities that I had been expecting.