Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

These Old Shades - Georgette Heyer Book Club pt2

81 replies

PrematurelyAirconditioned · 21/05/2012 15:48

Surely you must have read it by now?

To start us off, I think the thing that struck me most reading it back to back with Black Moth was how exactly she'd transposed the characters from BM. Andover's conventional best friend, his frivolous brother and sister, his boring brother-in-law, the woman he abducted, and her husband (complete with watered-down highwayman past) are all there, just as before, and it makes the melodramatic plot of These Old Shades infinitely more fun.

OP posts:
LeonieDeSaintVire · 21/05/2012 22:47

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

LeonieDeSaintVire · 21/05/2012 21:06

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

PrematurelyAirconditioned · 21/05/2012 18:27

I think Leonie does have a decent attempt at a Paris season doesn't she? She certainly flirts with the charming and handsome Prince amongst many others and she spends loads of time with Rupert. She gets far more chance to check out the field than some GH heroines.

It does show Heyer's snobbery up something chronic though, with all this Princess and the Pea "blood will out" crap.

OP posts:
SilkStalkings · 21/05/2012 18:08

Just dutifully picked it up from the library this afternoon! Back soon.

minipie · 21/05/2012 17:37

Oh dear, I might be in disgrace here as I've not read These Old Shades (read it very recently though!) and am getting stuck in to Cotillion instead...

[rebel emoticon]

I do like These Old Shades - and I think Leonie is great - but, if I'm picking holes, I slightly wish Leonie had more of a chance to consider the option of other men before she fell for Avon - her adulation of him seems mainly because he's less horrible than her previous "guardians" which doesn't seem like the ideal basis to choose a husband.

Mind you, I guess Leonie's behaviour probably wouldn't be accepted in anyone other than a Duchess Grin so probably best that she married Avon after all.

Gigondas · 21/05/2012 16:25

That's very true.

Also there is a more liberal and worldly wise air to it than other later books (except maybe Venetia where heroine is not bothered by various scandals) that arise.

I love all the romances but the tone of understanding , love and tolerance here (heroine brought up in an inn which seems to be barely better than a brothrl)is a bit different to say regency buck where heroine is in disgrace for racing alone to Brighton. Can't see Leonie putting up with being treated like Judith.

I can't decide If that reflects changing time or styles.

Also this was a much more polished book than black moth which had some fairly sketchy characters in (can't even remember heroines name off top of my head).