Please or to access all these features

Secondary education

Connect with other parents whose children are starting secondary school on this forum.

GCSE Music - help!!

30 replies

marmitesandwiches · 28/01/2025 10:15

Hi there,

I know there are some very knowledgeable people here on this topic. Hoping for some guidance (many thanks in advance!).

DS is Yr 9 and about to do options. He is artistic and reasonably bright with some ND and for the last 6-12 months his special interest has been music. He spends almost all his free time composing on various DAWS and a little on piano also (though he has not had lessons and can't read music). He also sings in the school choir. As a younger child he was very resistant to activities outside school (school itself was enough!) and has therefore never had any instrument lessons. Anyway, he has now decided that his No 1 choice of GCSE is Music.

I think we can teach him enough music theory for GCSE but, for the performance element, his school ask for Grade 4 level (ABRSM/equivalent) at the start of Yr 10. I am now considering our options and whether Music is going to be feasible for him - before potentially discussing with school. He is very keen on piano but I can see that getting to Grade 4 (or being able to play 2 grade 4 pieces) by March of Year 11 is unrealistic. One option would be to now get him some singing lessons and to assess whether he could reach the required standard in this (not sure what Grade 4 looks like in voice). The other possibility is to consider the 'DJing' option that I think his board (Edexcel) offer.

Does anyone know what is permitted in the Edexcel DJing element? I am probably going to explain this really poorly, but he says that he could use his laptop to set off various clips of music and beats he has composed and to layer them as a live performance. Is this the sort of thing examiners are expecting - and would it be possible to get decent marks doing this? I'm happy to get him some music production lessons to help him along (assuming this is what I should be looking at?). Also interested in any views on the singing option.

Thanks so much for any help. I did lots of traditional music as a child, but now v lapsed and a bit lost!!

OP posts:
marmitesandwiches · 28/01/2025 10:55

Thanks @SSRI for your comments re piano. That's amazing that you managed to get those results! I have been asking around for the names of teachers so I guess I'll try to schedule some trial lessons. He is certainly very keen, which should help (assuming that continues when required to practice).

Fair comment re school's music tech expertise. I think they may ow have a youngish music tech person on-board but that would be something to discuss in any meeting with them!

OP posts:
marmitesandwiches · 28/01/2025 10:48

Many thanks @Octavia64 That book is a great suggestion. I'm going to order and have a look at it.

@AngelsWithSilverWings Thank you. DS is also not amazing or confident - good that your daughter succeeded! I know DS's school expected GCSE music students to participate in school concerts and I know that DS will not be confident enough to sing for an audience, other than in choir. Singing for the teacher and having this recorded will probably be enough for him!

OP posts:
SSRI · 28/01/2025 10:47

Most GCSE boards expect grade 3 standard. So if grade 3 pieces are performed perfectly he would get full marks if that makes sense.

The DJing option could be good for him IF the school are experienced in submitting this sort of performance. I'd avoid choosing this if they don't seem confident with music tech in general.

If he enjoys piano I'd definitely look at getting him lessons - no reason at all he couldn't get to the required standard, the school are being weirdly perfectionist there. I've taught beginner pianists myself as a GCSE teacher where the parents couldn't pay for a private teacher and got them high A*s for the performance aspect.

AngelsWithSilverWings · 28/01/2025 10:40

My daughter did singing for the performance element. We paid for weekly singing lessons at school to get her performance ready ( she's an ok singer - not amazing and not a confident performer but she did well enough to get a level 4 over all - can't remember what her actual performance was graded at ( the theory part was a real struggle due to her processing issues)

Octavia64 · 28/01/2025 10:25

Can't comment on the DJ ing option but my DC did music gcse with singing.

If he has sung in a choir before it's likely he can reach the required standard quite easily.

BTW their required standard is quite high, the usual thing is to say students should be between grade 3 and grade 5 at the point of exam.

Abrsm publish books for low voice and high voice for each grade - maybe look at something like this?

amzn.eu/d/4YH16eQ