Please or to access all these features

Secondary education

Connect with other parents whose children are starting secondary school on this forum.

Homework at highly academic schools

52 replies

1sttodie · 31/01/2023 21:34

If you have a child at a highly-selective grammar or indie, please could you share how much homework they are expected to complete per day, in Year 7 and subsequent years? Obviously, some children will work faster than others but it'd be useful to have an idea. I'm also curious whether your child is able to have extra-curricular activities throughout the week?

My post is prompted by a thread I've just come across about pressure/homework at QE school (North London). It talks about intense homework, with mention of 2 to 3 hours a day in Year 7. Does this reflect expectations for most pupils at high-performing schools? I'm thinking that surely not, as this wouldn't leave significant time for sports, etc - and would cause undue stress? And doing homework while exhausted can't be productive.

My son (Year 6) has not applied for QE but for other highly selective schools in South London. However academically driven and capable he is, I am now wondering if I should be concerned about the weight of homework.

Thank you!

OP posts:
1sttodie · 31/01/2023 23:06

@Replyingnow Thank you. I really appreciate the comprehensive answer, which highlights that the question of homework is not as simplistic as a number of hours per day or week. It relates to quality of teaching, quality of homework, homework 'policing', homework corrections and follow-ups, support at school, etc. All good points.

I do worry about how much grammars (at least some grammars) may be relying on the quality of their intake, and families' ability/willingness to pay for private tutoring.

OP posts:
Replyingnow · 31/01/2023 22:02

At my son’s school they are “supposed” to get about 2x2 hours a week per subject.

Some children spend less than an hour, some more. Some don’t do it at all. The teacher might give a detention, but usually not.

Once they get into yr9 and they’re on the GCSE course snd they’re expected to revise on top of this eg make sure what they’ve learnt that week they know. This increases as they move through yr11.

Homework per se largely depends on the teacher. Some are excellent. Really engaged and bring their subjects alive. The homework they set is good to do. Others are not. They’re either underwhelmed by their job, emotionally elsewhere, possibly mid-divorce, waiting for retirement or struggle to make the subject anything more than words on a page. Their homework is usually a chore to do.

More often than not, the homework isn’t marked. I was surprised by this. Secondary is very different to primary. Grammar is even more self governed. It’s easy to fall behind. Grammar’s are focused on results and league tables. The number they can get into Oxbridge.

if your son is just over the pass mark, I’d think long and hard. It’s easy to become disillusioned and very average. Bright at primary doesn’t necessarily mean bright at Grammar.

My son is in yr11. I would say he’s pretty middle of the road in Year “ranking.” There are many who will likely struggle to get the GCSEs grades at the grammar that they would have at the non selective. The teaching at the other school in our town seems to be better in the sense that all children who want to do well are nurtured and can.

At the grammar, if you’re struggling in a subject or falling behind the solution usually is a tutor.

Don't for a minute think a grammar is a ticket to 10 x 9*. I think I thought it might be. If you’re a 6, you’re a six.

I appreciate it doesn’t answer your question, but I wish I’d have known this when my son was yr6. I’d have made different choices.

Swipe left for the next trending thread