Please or to access all these features

Secondary education

Connect with other parents whose children are starting secondary school on this forum.

A levels - for CS degree / tech career

37 replies

MarshaBradyo · 11/11/2020 18:04

If anyone is in this area can I ask:

Ds is doing
Maths
Further maths
Economics

Would you recommend physics or CS for tech career?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MarshaBradyo · 12/11/2020 16:04

This is great thank you

Yes I can see even a maths degree is highly valuable, psychology makes perfect sense and had not thought of that and economics may be on table still if he’s very keen.

I do feel pain at lack of economics knowledge in general in the world so will see with that one ;

OP posts:
SabrinaThwaite · 12/11/2020 13:08

We’re currently looking into all of this too, DS currently thinking of Maths, CS and Psychology at A level with a view to a CS degree.

Whilst CS doesn’t seem to be a requirement for most degrees, Lancaster (for instance) gives favourable consideration to students taking CS at A level.

30kperannum · 12/11/2020 11:06

CS A level isn't a requirement for CS degrees because many schools/colleges can't offer it (like FM).
His maths is most crucial.
DH has worked in computing for 25 years. All the best coders/architects have maths degrees and can code, not CS degrees. A maths degree will also keep options open for post-university, should he have a change of heart.
A Level CS would probably help him decide whether he really wants to go into computing or put him off for life Smile

GlacindaTheTroll · 12/11/2020 10:45

For CompSci, the far away most useful subject is maths, and FM is highly desirable. Comp Sci A level isn't usually a requirement but is useful (makes the first term or two less demanding as they recap it for those starting without it). Physics, as a kind of applied maths, is useful (esp for those who cannot take FM) but if you have maths/CS (and possibly FM) you don't exactly need it.

And I agree with previous poster that psychology is useful - the interface between human users and the tech is an important aspect, and courses which allow a module in any other discipline find that lots of student opt for psychology at that point,

But if your DC really wants to do economics, for heavens sake do it. It's important that pupils are studying what they are interested in not just slogging through subjects because they think they ought to. As long as maths (and ideally FM) is in there, there will be plenty of courses to choose from. And if he changes his mind about what he wants to do, then a subject with an essay component is useful.

The other subject not yet mentioned to consider is chemistry, because with maths/chemistry nearly every (non-biological) STEM course remains possible - again might be useful if he changes his mind

titchy · 12/11/2020 10:02

FM as an AS level may not be possible due to the way it is usually taught in conjunction with Maths - many schools timetable the entire of AL maths in year 12 and the entire FM AL in year 13 for example. If your kid is capable of AL FM, enjoys maths and is likely to get A / A star grades at A level he should do the full AL - he should be thinking about very selective universities - Imperial, Oxford etc if that suits him. So Maths, FM, then either CS or Physics as the third. No need for economics (as an economist of sorts I feel your pain Grin), but maybe that could be the AS. Ds actually developed an interest in political and current affairs as a result of doing economics AL - though he hated the subject it did have some uses.

If he doesn't want to aim that high, or is probably a B grade kid, then as others have said, no need to do FM at all. So Maths, then any two out of the other three.

MarshaBradyo · 12/11/2020 09:24

I may be biased towards economics as it’s what I studied (and arts). Will try not to influence.

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 12/11/2020 09:21

@MazarineBlue

FM could be useful for some of the algorithm heavy CS uni modules such as biological (swarm)computing and cryptography I believe from my ds as the concepts are similar? Having said that, my DS took Psychology as one of his A levels and finds it useful for elements of HCI computing! (And his supervisor specialises in data mining/nudge theory type stuff and brought it up in his interview so was a useful thing to be able to talk about that was a bit different!). For info, he's at a RG uni and a proportion of the first year was a crash course in CS basics for those who didn't take it at A level, plus a course in maths for those who needed the relevant bits for the course...
Mazarine Interesting yes I can see that re Psychology

Ds isn’t getting as high marks in English v Science / Maths so may not be for him. Does sound really good though.

Would you say Economics isn’t that useful, I’m getting the impression not, also physics?

OP posts:
MazarineBlue · 12/11/2020 08:31

FM could be useful for some of the algorithm heavy CS uni modules such as biological (swarm)computing and cryptography I believe from my ds as the concepts are similar? Having said that, my DS took Psychology as one of his A levels and finds it useful for elements of HCI computing! (And his supervisor specialises in data mining/nudge theory type stuff and brought it up in his interview so was a useful thing to be able to talk about that was a bit different!). For info, he's at a RG uni and a proportion of the first year was a crash course in CS basics for those who didn't take it at A level, plus a course in maths for those who needed the relevant bits for the course...

MarshaBradyo · 12/11/2020 08:13

@GrassWillBeGreener

Just realised I should have reloaded the window before I posted :) FM and maths, for capable kids, aren't as much work as 2 separate A levels. But would still be done as separate subjects over 2 years I believe (content could be covered sequentially depending on timetabling though). Other combinations of 4 A levels might still be done with the expectation of dropping one after a year, but the phasing out of AS exams has changed this. Though, with the way things are for exams at the moment, who knows what will change next??!

I have found it helpful to think of our final school exams as GCSEs plus; A levels are at least in some subjects slightly akin to our first year university courses. The Scottish system is closer to what we did (albeit with far more exams ...). My BSc was 4 years to do honours whereas English ones are 3 years.

Yep it’s really narrow! Plus the point system was really easy to get
OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 12/11/2020 08:12

I mean CS EPQ

And forgot to say CS!

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 12/11/2020 08:11

@GlacindaTheTroll

They can only say that maths is required as not all schools offer FM.

In practice for the top tier Comp Sci courses (eg Oxbridge, Imperial, Warwick - need 1 or 2 A* and rest at A - as do some others that aren't springing to mind right now), nearly everyone has further maths and those who don't often find the first year tough - the course goes through things very quickly, so there's a need for quite a bit of self-learning to keep up if you don't already have that level of maths.

You need to do aptitude tests for CS for Cambridge (not sure about Oxford) and Imperial, and you need STEP (I think a 2 on level 1 paper) for Imperial. A lot of maths, a lot of logic. You don't need CS A level, but it helps.

Other universities are not as maths focussed

Glacinda really helpful

I’m really interested to know which subjects you think is best out of:

Maths (definitely)
FM - should it not be an AS?

Physics or Economics

An EPQ?

OP posts:
GlacindaTheTroll · 11/11/2020 23:12

They can only say that maths is required as not all schools offer FM.

In practice for the top tier Comp Sci courses (eg Oxbridge, Imperial, Warwick - need 1 or 2 A* and rest at A - as do some others that aren't springing to mind right now), nearly everyone has further maths and those who don't often find the first year tough - the course goes through things very quickly, so there's a need for quite a bit of self-learning to keep up if you don't already have that level of maths.

You need to do aptitude tests for CS for Cambridge (not sure about Oxford) and Imperial, and you need STEP (I think a 2 on level 1 paper) for Imperial. A lot of maths, a lot of logic. You don't need CS A level, but it helps.

Other universities are not as maths focussed

User27aw · 11/11/2020 23:01

Following this as my yr11 ds is also planning to study a CS degree and is deciding on A levels.
He is planning to take Maths, physics and CS. I didnt think he would need Further maths A level. I guess we need to some more research, from the degree courses we have looked into so far, they say only maths is required so I'm a bit confused now.

GrassWillBeGreener · 11/11/2020 19:21

Just realised I should have reloaded the window before I posted :)
FM and maths, for capable kids, aren't as much work as 2 separate A levels. But would still be done as separate subjects over 2 years I believe (content could be covered sequentially depending on timetabling though). Other combinations of 4 A levels might still be done with the expectation of dropping one after a year, but the phasing out of AS exams has changed this. Though, with the way things are for exams at the moment, who knows what will change next??!

I have found it helpful to think of our final school exams as GCSEs plus; A levels are at least in some subjects slightly akin to our first year university courses. The Scottish system is closer to what we did (albeit with far more exams ...). My BSc was 4 years to do honours whereas English ones are 3 years.

MarshaBradyo · 11/11/2020 19:18

Changing mind on FM as AS though based on pp

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 11/11/2020 19:16

Ok great

Yes degree in CS is the aim (at this point anyway) but ultimately career in it

OP posts:
titchy · 11/11/2020 19:15

What's his aim degree-wise? Computer science? In which case as long as he has M and FM the third can be anything. Imperial off the top of my head prefer the third to be eithe CS or Physics. And if there's four will offer based on four.

Sorry not helpful - short answer - either! Whatever he's likely to get a better grade at.

GlacindaTheTroll · 11/11/2020 19:15

It’s a bit old though. I didn’t study in U.K. so not sure if I’m missing something

They changed the spec for Computer Science A level in about 2015. Discard any comments from before that. If serious about CS at university, do the A level - the new one has a good reputation - because if he loves the subject he'll almost certainly enjoy the course and do well.

But if 'tech' is a less specific idea, then physics might be more useful

GrasswillbeGreener · 11/11/2020 19:14

I would think that maths +_further maths is the most important if he decides to do a CS degree. Physics would seem to me to be extremely useful. CS A level is I think a less developed subject, not all schools can offer it potentially, universities won't rely on students having done it. A computer related EPQ sounds ideal.

coi - physics degree owner, my DS is probably looking at maths / FM / physics + something else, computer science is a potential destination. I think I heard him mention philosophy to his granny on the phone the other week ...

MarshaBradyo · 11/11/2020 19:11

@clary

AS no longer has any meaning/value so most schools don't do it. Increasingly schools are moving towards only three A levels, tho some (see other thread) still require four if one is FM.
Really that’s annoying. I need to check this but I think if you do four the fourth is AS

I may have misunderstood general session will ask directly

OP posts:
clary · 11/11/2020 19:09

AS no longer has any meaning/value so most schools don't do it. Increasingly schools are moving towards only three A levels, tho some (see other thread) still require four if one is FM.

MarshaBradyo · 11/11/2020 19:07

@TeenPlusTwenties

What is the school advising?
School isn’t great just says look at university website and work backwards

But a university site doesn’t really show nuances of preference (I imagine not sure what their nuances are)

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 11/11/2020 19:06

@OnTheBenchOfDoom

For Compsci at uni you need maths and further maths A levels, they do not care if you take computer science at A level . There is a content cross over with maths/FM and physics so it can be beneficial to do that.

Some unis don't consider maths and FM as 2 separate A levels if he is only sitting 3 A levels, usually FM is a 4th A level.

Ds is doing maths, FM, physics and computer science. He already has conditional offers from RG universities based on maths/FM only. Unis can't specify FM as not all sixth forms offer it but it does put a candidate at a disadvantage over others who have taken it.

But these days for computer science related jobs they do prefer you to have a degree in it as it teaches you all the basics meaning you understand when you insert/change code etc what effect it could have on other stuff. I don't understand this myself but Dh is in IT and Ds1 is heading in the same direction.

If your son takes maths, FM, physics and economics this would leave his options wide open.

Thanks Bench is the 4th an AS? Is it always

All new to me. We just did ten subjects (in Aus)

OP posts:
clary · 11/11/2020 19:06

YY Op I would advise against the EPQ - I know a lot of MN-ers love it but for my DC it was an irrelevance and I hardly know anyone who has gained any advantage from it (in terms of lower offers from uni).

Four A levels, even if one is FM, is a lot of work.

TeenPlusTwenties · 11/11/2020 19:05

What is the school advising?

Swipe left for the next trending thread