Please or to access all these features

Secondary education

Connect with other parents whose children are starting secondary school on this forum.

A-level choices: engineering-----architecture

135 replies

istherelifeafter40 · 06/11/2020 16:00

DS has to choose 4 A-levels in November. He is not decided on what he wants to do as a career, but is leaning towards engineering - or architecture (quite a spread!) There seem to be myriads of different kinds of engineering - from mechanical, aerospace, electronic, civil, to biochemical. I don't know much about any of them. (Humanities person here).
I think he might also change his mind and decide to do natural sciences, for instance... I love the idea of natsoc at Cambridge - start wide and narrow down. I am generally against early specialisation...

Currently, he has 8 in maths and all sciences, but also in eng and photography that he loves. He also likes chemistry very much and says that physics is very easy. BUT he dislikes maths, although he does well in it and is in set 2 our of 6 in a selective school.

Our current choice is Maths, Chemistry, Physics and Photography (which would open architecture if he goes this way, but is a course-based work-intensive subject). He accepts that he "has to do maths" (not my doing)

or Maths, Chemistry, Physics and Biology (he dislikes biology, but I think it might be quite a different subject at A-level?).

The school also insists on EPQ, and he will be able to drop 1 A level but can continue with 4.

He is set very much against further maths, which as I understand rules out some of the best mechanical engineering courses or general engineering at cambridge, but can still be ok for the other unis. Imperial has dozens of kinds of engineering and they all require different A levels (and different grades, from A, A, A to AAA). How do you decide at 15?

Any advice? I am worried that doing 3 sciences and an artistic course-based work will be too heavy (+epq)! I wonder if it is too much science work and pressure in case he decides to do architecture (many courses don't specify A levels whatsoever).
He doesn't want to do any humanities' subjects though, or something like economics or politics...

Any advice or just a chat would be great

OP posts:
istherelifeafter40 · 06/11/2020 19:56

Thanks everyone! Thanks for the tips about architecture - it is one of those jobs most at risk at being "automated", isn't it...

It also seems that the consensus is that if he doesn't like maths, maths-based courses are not for him. I am not sure about this. In my opinion, if you "love maths", you become a mathematician. This is "loving maths." The rest of people use maths instrumentally, i.e. you learn it to the degree that you need, but you don't work on developing it. You just apply it. I don't think you need to love it to do so - you need to love what you are doing, for which you, among other things, need maths.

OP posts:
Sweetchillijam · 06/11/2020 19:13

I wouldn’t encourage him to choose something he dislikes school is hard enough.
DS 16 doesn’t know what he wants to do and still doesn’t.
He is in year 12 and could have chosen almost anything for A levels, they did EPQ in lockdown (which has been handed in and is now thankfully out of the way). He choose Maths, Further Maths, Physics and French. I tried to sway him towards Chemistry or History rather than French but he’s always enjoyed French and was set on his subjects. Like others have said he finds a lot of crossover with Maths and Physics, but as he enjoys Maths and likes to be challenged he finds this a bit easy/boring.
I think he wishes he had chosen Chemistry (but all the kids he knows who have taken it find it very difficult) or History rather than French. But he loves Further Maths and is enjoying this the most.

jeannie46 · 06/11/2020 18:58

Be aware that jobs can be difficult to come by in architecture.
SIL got MArch, Part 3 and just about holding on to his job. Many of his year never got a job offer in architecture post qualification. A third of his firm's architects have been let go in the last year.

Ironoaks · 06/11/2020 18:52

I think he might also change his mind and decide to do natural sciences, for instance... I love the idea of natsoc at Cambridge - start wide and narrow down

BUT he dislikes maths

DS is in the first year of this course, studying physical natural sciences (physics, chemistry, materials science). The university can't ask for Further Maths A-level as an entry requirement, because many schools and sixth form colleges don't offer it. However, most applicants are taking Further Maths. In DS's offer, Further Maths was the only subject where they specified that he had to get an A*. Both interviews involved a lot of difficult maths. Now that he has started the course, he can see why. He said the most useful thing he did over the summer in terms of preparation was to teach himself extra Further Maths A-level modules which his school didn't choose as curriculum options.

dingit · 06/11/2020 18:38

At Surrey the first year is general then you diversify

dingit · 06/11/2020 18:37

My dd did maths physics and chemistry plus epq. Studying aerospace engineering at Surrey. She wishes she had done further maths as felt like everyone was ahead of her.
She's also done a placement year and has gained so much confidence and has a grad job lined up.

UniParent · 06/11/2020 18:24

How about product design engineering at Loughborough university?

It covers lots of different engineering disciplines plus there’s a lot of technical drawing in it for the design element.

www.lboro.ac.uk/study/undergraduate/courses/a-z/product-design-engineering-beng/

Svalberg · 06/11/2020 17:50

I found the most useful A levels for my engineering degree were Maths, Physics & Economics. With the economics, I didn't have to do any work for that subject at uni as I'd done it all Blush and I found it a piece of cake at Alevel. But everyone is different

istherelifeafter40 · 06/11/2020 17:41

@MagpiePi
If you don't mind, can you tell a bit more about different engineering disciplines and whether one needs to choose from the start, and how one chooses? Thank you very much

OP posts:
istherelifeafter40 · 06/11/2020 17:39

DS does not like free drawing or sculpture (Art), but he can do excellent technical drawing, modelling, etc. I had a quick chat with his photography teacher who said photography is a something like a sub-subject within Art and Design A level, and DS can apply for architecture with it.

OP posts:
randomsabreuse · 06/11/2020 17:38

Maths is one of the few A-levels I'd do without loving it, assuming you're good at it. I never loved maths, didn't do Further Maths as a result. Got an easy A though (no A* in those days). The workload isn't too horrible, if you really don't get something there's only so much you can do (time wise) and once you have the answer you're done. It's about the easiest A-Level to do as a "necessary evil" as a means to an end. Always assuming you are good enough at the subject, so getting 8s.

hopefulhalf · 06/11/2020 17:33

DH is an architect he did Art, Physics, Economics and Maths. I think most of them did art (and you certainly need to be able to draw or sketch as they call it). DS and BIL did maths, f.maths, chemistry and physics BIL did engineering DS wants to do chemical engineering.

MagpiePi · 06/11/2020 17:29

I'm a civil engineer and did Maths, Physics and Art at A level.

The different engeneering disciplines are very different even though they are all called engineering; a mechanical engineer wouldn't be able to walk into a chemical engineering job, and a structural engineer would probably struggle with fluid mechanics engineering.

However, I would say that any engineering degree opens up a lot of opportunities.

You do need maths, but we did the same 1st year maths as students on the maths degree course.

TeenPlusTwenties · 06/11/2020 17:27

re Architecture.
Double check that Photography is OK not Art.
Otherwise I'd expect Maths & Physics would be needed. Physics would be hard without Maths, and engineers need generally to be competent at maths.

Architecture at university varies (according to a friend whose DD is currently studying it). Some courses are very Art based, some very Physics based, some a mix of the two.

Just because he has to choose now, doesn't mean he can't change his mind (provided the timetabling works.)

houselikeashed · 06/11/2020 17:21

I think the big uni's will want very good maths skills for engineering. Not doing further maths might put him at a disadvantage.

DS did Maths, F maths, physics, chemistry and a Mini MBA (EPQ type thing) and said the work load was ok compared to his friends doing essay based subjects.

I personally think if you're going to do 4 A levels, then one should be F Maths, as it gets lumped in with maths and apparently (according again to DS) only feels like half an A level worth of extra work. Photog I imagine would be very time consuming???

ShowingOut · 06/11/2020 17:17

Others have given good answers re the subjects. But I will say, if he's only getting 8s and isn't in the top set in Maths then Cambridge, and certainly Imperial, may well be out of his reach.

movingonup20 · 06/11/2020 17:16

Oh and dd is doing engineering and really wishes she had further maths, most (75%) on her course do

istherelifeafter40 · 06/11/2020 17:14

The school makes them choose 4 A-levels. At least if he chooses maths, physics, chemistry and photography we can calm down for now. But then if he needs to drop one next year, it's like basically delaying the decision : drop chemistry and chemical engineering is out; drop photography and architecture is out. He will still be 16 next year at the point of decision-making, it is so early to know what you want to do!

OP posts:
movingonup20 · 06/11/2020 17:11

For engineering he needs maths, physics and usually one more science (obviously chemistry for chemical engineering etc) for architecture maths and physics are also ideal. Very few do 4 a levels now unless the 4th is further maths, (dd was only one of 2 at her college.

istherelifeafter40 · 06/11/2020 17:10

Yes, a portfolio seems to be a requirement for architecture. DS doesn't want to do Art, neither DT at A level, but Photography counts as an Art&Design A level and he can do something to do with architecture with EPQ, for instance?

OP posts:
CottonSock · 06/11/2020 17:09

I was going to say as above. Engineering is a lot of maths. Does architecture need maths?
I did a subject I didn't like and it was very painful.

istherelifeafter40 · 06/11/2020 17:08

askmeonce Thank you! What is Civil and Structural Engineering?

I know mechanical engineering is very maths based, but I feel so lost in all of these different kinds of engineering - are they all very maths-based? biochemical engineering, for instance, would every different from aerospace, right?

OP posts:
Hellohah · 06/11/2020 17:08

I would double check the requirements for Architecture - I don't think they necessarily need you to have studied an Art & Design subject at GCSE/A-Level but to be able to submit a portfolio of creative work. - Might be wrong there though, as this was a conversation I had with one of DS's friends who has wanted to be an architect since he was about 5 (so he's done a lot of research).

AskMeOnce · 06/11/2020 17:00

....just to add Engineering students also put in a huge amount of hours (DS is in a house of students taking mixed degrees and his timetable and workload is easily double what the others have on their plates) drop out rate is pretty high.

Engineering is also heavily maths centred - if your DS doesn't truly love maths he may not enjoy the course at all.

bruffin · 06/11/2020 16:57

Will he be allowed to do physics without maths? A lot of schools dont allow physics without taking maths

Swipe left for the next trending thread