Please or to access all these features

Secondary education

Connect with other parents whose children are starting secondary school on this forum.

Atom users

35 replies

noughtmare · 05/10/2020 20:05

My son has been using atom for 5 months and has answered 5000 questions and gained 20,000 alp points.

Is this a lot of work?

I think he has done over 80 hours work on the platform?

He is in the top quartile of students but only just.

Weaknesses is in nvr abs English.

Tends to get 120 standardised.

But today he got 100 percent on a 15 question at olaves maths test.

Do you think he has done enough work for the grammar tests coming up in a couple of weeks time?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
noughtmare · 09/10/2020 22:13

Yes yes yes malmonter

If you are economically disadvantaged you really don't get a look in unless you really know someone who knows how it all works.

The super tutoring people do also just make it harder and harder.

OP posts:
Malmontar · 09/10/2020 11:50

@HunkyPunk

And not all private pupils are ahead of state: many will go to non academic secondary private schools. Almost none go to state grammars, which tend to be where state primary kids go.

That's not at all the case in our area, where the Grammars (1 girls' and 1 boys') are very highly regarded and considered to be the money-saving option for many with children at private schools in the area. The private schools tutor for the 11+ (unlike the state schools) and a significant number of the Grammars' intake are from that sector.

I also disagree. The grammar local to us is very selective and almost all of its pupils are from preps or high achieving states. In fact it is a known fact that parents will put their kids through prep just so they can get into the grammar. It achieves the same results as the privates and due to its impressive PTA, offers extra curriculars that are on par with the privates.

The system disadvantages from the beginning. In our case you had to sign up for the test in a 2 week window in June. Unless you know about the grammar and how it works, you wouldn't even know that as the state school doesn't inform you. You also wouldn't know the familiarisation papers are online. Once you did find them, they are over 100 pages long and specific to that school so you need access to a printer. So if youre poor or dont speak english, you have no chance, genius child or not.

bintang · 09/10/2020 11:21

@user145964508 Do have a look at the 11+ forum. There are many grammars, and they have differing entrance tests. You can check for the individual schools your child is sitting for, and see what their requirements are.

If Atom are 10points below CATS then it will go to 140.

noughtmare · 09/10/2020 11:06

Your not trout Grin

OP posts:
noughtmare · 09/10/2020 10:50

user1 I still feel like I am playing catch up and my child is in year 6.

Like me it sounds like trout primary school wasn't able to adapt to the lockdown so I think you should keep going with 11 plus and see what work your child can cover quickly. If possible it may be worthwhile getting a tutor for a couple of sessions and carrying on with Bond online or another platform like atom learning.

OP posts:
noughtmare · 09/10/2020 10:48

Hunky I agree, if not private the overwhelming number of children at grammar schools come from well off families.

OP posts:
HunkyPunk · 08/10/2020 22:21

And not all private pupils are ahead of state: many will go to non academic secondary private schools. Almost none go to state grammars, which tend to be where state primary kids go.

That's not at all the case in our area, where the Grammars (1 girls' and 1 boys') are very highly regarded and considered to be the money-saving option for many with children at private schools in the area. The private schools tutor for the 11+ (unlike the state schools) and a significant number of the Grammars' intake are from that sector.

user145964508 · 08/10/2020 21:07

Also, DS is in a state primary and a lot of the Maths has not been covered yet, they did virtually NOTHING during the whole lockdown(!!) - so compared to other schools and especially kids in prep schools he will be significantly behind. Hence, I want to make sure we do what we can to get him up to speed. We only decided on the 11plus 1-2 months ago and if I look at some of the forums on this, it seems we're already playing catchup compared to parents who start preparing their kids in Yr 4.

user145964508 · 08/10/2020 21:04

Thanks for the replies. Yes, DS will be doing paper based test and is in Year 5 so we have a year. I currently have both Bond online and the books, we're doing a mixture of both, I do like the online ones because you get a mark at the end of each set of questions/test which makes my life a bit easier and I can track his progress.

noughtmare · 08/10/2020 21:00

But as doobiedoo says most 11 plus is paper based.

For us I found keeping track of bond books and marking hard enough.

I like the dashboard for atom.

I also like the courses, some of the live teachers are brilliant and they do know what they are doing.

I guess it is horses for courses. You could get a regular atom and then add mocks closer to your child's examination.

OP posts:
noughtmare · 08/10/2020 20:58

What you can do is trial it and see how it compares.

My son got sick of the bond books - we also started late compared to many others.

OP posts:
Doobiedooo · 08/10/2020 20:56

User: atom is just online. So if your child is doing paper-based tests then what you are doing is far better.

noughtmare · 08/10/2020 20:56

When will your child sit the test?

OP posts:
user145964508 · 08/10/2020 20:52

hiya, I've only just started preparing my DS for the 11 plus for entry to grammar schools - I didn't know about Atom until a few days ago - we've just been doing the Bond books so far. The monthly price tag for Atom is quite a lot (50GBP a month) : is it really worth the money? I've already spent so much on bond books and other recommended vocab books and whatnot (it seems 11plus is a real moneymaker). Would you recommend getting it?

noughtmare · 06/10/2020 23:12

happusummer sound like you have it covered.

Well done.

And yes I can't compare, as I am sure the stress will be visible to my child.

Got to keep it positive Smile

OP posts:
Happysummer · 06/10/2020 22:27

@noughtmare they certainly are high achievers but please don't compare. I am destitute compared to Jeff Bezos. Billionaires do exist but it doesn't mean that's normal. If your child does the best for them than that is a good result.

@Stircrazyschoolmum thank you. I know my child is never going to be top of the class and I've been honest about her scores (which I'm sure some may gasp at being very low), but that is her and I wouldn't want her to be in a highly selective school where she would struggle. That wouldn't be fun for anyone.

To answer your question about the nest step the school have confirmed "We will write to you on 30 October with the outcome for xxxx. Success in the test will enable us to offer xxxx a place
subject to her achieving 60% or more in the January 2021 Common Entrance examinations and a satisfactory academic
reference from her current head teacher. We will advise you if we need to put your daughter on a waiting list or if we
feel that she would not thrive with us and that another choice of school would be wiser at this stage. Please note that
we do not give out individual results (scores etc) from the tests".

There are no interviews and the school have stressed exam result alone will not determine an offer. It's about the whole child, their potential, character and fit with the school. If it's not an option, then we shall move on with heads held high that we tried.

Stircrazyschoolmum · 06/10/2020 21:22

happy it sounds like you took a really balanced approach and thanks to that your daughter had a positive and stress free experience. The cookies and flowers were a really sweet touch!

30 Oct feels really early to find out.. I’m guessing you’ll get a straight yes/no rather than her score? Is there an interview or creative writing piece to do after or is it all on the exam? (Sorry.. being nosey!)

Stircrazyschoolmum · 06/10/2020 21:14

Is 140 the maximum score? (Like I say, we only just got the trial version!)

Malmontar · 06/10/2020 20:53

@noughtmare Don't stress about it. A lot depends on how they do on the day and the less stressed they are the less likely they are to make silly mistakes.

noughtmare · 06/10/2020 20:21

But actually my friend hangs around with really exceptional children or what I now think as over worked and over schedules children so possibly they are getting 140!

OP posts:
noughtmare · 06/10/2020 20:19

Happy summer I do have a friend who told me she knows lots of people getting full marks on atom mocks - she assured me you can get 140 .. but then she always makes me think I am not doing enough too so I take what she says with pinch of salt.

OP posts:
noughtmare · 06/10/2020 20:16

Not sure about that l stir crazy but you just have to keep going with it.

Without going over the top!

The work really is a shock if you are from the state sector ! Well I think so anyhow Smile

Best of luck!

Now atom has a mock test section so I don't think they are all adaptive for example if you chose a specific school from the mock test section.

OP posts:
Stircrazyschoolmum · 06/10/2020 18:14

Hello!

Newbie atom user here. State school DD and still in shock about imminent unprepared for ISEB!

This might be a stupid question, but if Atom mimics ISEB and is age standardised then surely the score would be adjusted some way? Thus, (thinking aloud) a child getting X% right in May would score lower on identical questions in Sept because they had gotten older.

Therefore nought if your child has continued to improve their score despite aging(!) then my sense is they are doing well?

chestnutwithshell · 06/10/2020 16:19

Happysummer Well done to your DD! You are a great parent! Hope things are going well!

OP, best luck for Saturday!

Happysummer · 06/10/2020 16:14

FYI Atom says "The Standard Age Score in the ISEB Common Pre-test will typically be about 10 points lower than the same pupils CAT test result".

If I add +10 points to my daughters average her CAT4 score would be 116 and as a guide puts her at above average ability with a possible GCSE grade 6/7 (B or A to you or I!).

There is no way most children are scoring 135+ as suggested on other treads. Those are exceptional, not the norm. There is nothing wrong with being part of the 'norm'.

We are looking at virtual open evenings for state secondary and I looked up my old school. Turns out one of the boys from my class went on to set up a very successful business, is now a millionaire and paid for a lab to be built at the school! He often required help, was in no way an academic and I remember helping him with work. Being academic does not guarantee success. Having determination and being able to try, fail and try again are also important.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread