Reluctant boarder - will this pass?

OP, this may not be what you want to hear but personally I wouldn't push or even encourage a child to board unless they were desperate to go.

I know many children thrive in boarding schools but there are also many others who don't and would really prefer not to board.

There must be a Plan B option even if that means a local state school. You've said you could possibly consider moving? Don't discount local schools simply by their apparent reputation - go and look round for yourself. If you aren't paying school fees, you could always pay for private tuition closer to GCSEs.

I agree that you should deal with your son't unhappiness now and try to get the bottom of the problem.

You've got the option of this boarding school for 18 months' time. But please do start looking into other options now in case your ds decides boarding is not for him.

From your very first post, I guessed this school you were referring to and now I am sure. I was there yesterday with my son for the scholarship exam and my situation is a bit opposite to yours. My son pretty much broke down last night saying he wants to board (we want day), he's completely blown away by their boarding facilities and believes he won't benefit as much being a day student at the particular school. I think as your son grows older (and seeks independence), he may start to look favourably at boarding.

Haven’t read every post, so excuse me if I repeat advice already given...

Are you not able to approach the school he is due to start @13+ and see if the have a day position he could take with the view of taking up full board a term or two later. Or even a year later?

I agree with above poster. Your son is unhappy now. Currently he feels positive about boarding in his future school. Built on that relationship and move away from the issue now. Otherwise this continuing negative experience will undoubtedly start to feed into that positivity. There is no need to"get used " to boarding just because they will potentially board at a later date.

18 months is a long time isn't it?

I wouldn't allow his evident unhappiness to continue now just in case it might alleviate the possibility of unhappiness in 18 months time....

Surely if you can afford 7 years boarding, or moving to be nearer his prospective school, you could afford to move to be near a good state secondary? Or to be near enough to a private day school that he could have a social life outside of school? I'm not saying that you should do this things, but it seems strange to dismiss them as options on cost grounds.

In the short term, if you insist he keeps on boarding, he will eventually learn not to complain to you about it. Which may, or may not, solve your problem.

OP I also think small prep schools can be very stifling for some as you get older. A small pool of friends with a small pool of interests. Younger children may go along with the cricket obsessed ethos of the school the head and their friends and even try to join them but by 11/12 they are starting to develop their own ideas and start to find the whole thing tedious. Having got over the excitement of boarding and having a good time you to realise that your sharing a dorm with four others whose sole topic of conversation is England success against Pakistan last week may start to pall after a while. Changing to a secondary school assuming it’s not a small one means that you can find more like minded friends.
If your thinking about him not boarding for secondary speak to the school does it have day pupils what does their website say? Before my DS started in Winchester we went to a new boys tea three parents were going to ask if their DS could not board. I was flabbergasted it’s clearly written on their website that Winchester is full boarding only, the admission process is lengthy because of this, and one parent went to a bigger feeder for Winchester and I can’t believe they didn’t know another had an older brother already full boarding! One pulled out because her DS couldn’t be a day boy the other two always moaned all the time that their DS’s had to board. So if in doubt ask and if necessary find somewhere else but if the school is mainly boarding they often expect day pupils to stay late and come in on Saturdays and many days pupils feel they are missing out and want to join their peers and board.

Sorry I don't know how to bold text on Mumsnet! But I have copied three sentences you wrote below which stand out to me - I think you need to get to the bottom of why he used to seem to enjoy it....now doesn't like it but seems confident he will like it in his new school.
What changed for him from when he first started boarding until now? New boarding master, new boys...is someone being unkind to him?

He is currently at a very small all-boys prep school and last year did 2 nights per week boarding which he seemed to enjoy.

However, this year he has got increasingly upset about boarding these two nights.

He really likes the school he is due to go to in 2021 and says he thinks he will be fine to board then...he just doesn't want to do so now.

Do you have any other children? DH boarded and his sisters didn't, it made him very unhappy as he felt he was missing out on family life. He begged to be allowed to day school in London but his father said no (stupid reason, he and his father had been to the same school, in those days you didn't think about what was best for the child though!)

It destroyed his relationship with his father, which has never recovered.

I mention this as it might be a reason for his unhappiness. Even without siblings he might feel he is missing out on family life.

Regardless I would be prepared to move him if he really doesn't like boarding at the new school. Don't ignore him if he says he wants to move!

Pretest not pretext

OP, if it didn’t work out, I’m sure you could get him a place at a day school somewhere? Are there any international schools near you - these have a lot of movement? A friend of mine had to take her son out of weekly boarding very suddenly mid-term as he wasn’t coping, but they got him into an international school with no entrance exam etc within a week and it’s been all good ever since.

I think you do need a back up option for Year 9. Could the prep not advise you in schools that don’t require the pretext? Also, what is their take on the current situation?

Maybe he’s finding boarding too claustrophobic, being stuck with the same people all the time? Some people need their own space for their sanity.

Are state schools near you not an option as a plan B? Or a non-selective independent school?

We were once told by the head at DS2s boarding school prep that schools tend to treat all children about the age he reckoned that they treated all of them as if they were 10 around yr 7 my DS became unsettled there despite having boarded for 4+ years he has always been vey mature and independent and I think he liked it in the beginning because he was treated as if he was older than he was but grew to dislike as he got older as he was treated; as if he was much younger than he was, Does that make sense?
Secondly I think the ethos of the school has to match yours at home. His prep got a new head his ethos on life over time changed the ethos of the school and it was totally alien to him (and a few others). The new head was basically a stuffed shirt his idea of really letting his hair down was undoing the top button on his shirt! We are a hopelessly relaxed touchy feely informal family. Or for example the new head was a sports nut in particular team sports and cricket it was the heads sole topic of conversation. Many boys in his form were the same, my DS is a lone wolf, has little interest in team sports in particular cricket!
He happily carried on full boarding at senior school and settled down quickly and enjoyed but as one don at his school once said “we like lone wolfs here!”.

IME boarders are happy when the majority of students at the school are also boarders. This is now rarely the case at all but a handful of prep schools. So when all your friends go home you are left at school with a handful of overseas boarders. It is worse if you are only there for two days a week as you are a minority within a minority so you feel like an outsider.

His experience at senior school will be quite different if he is going to a school where most of the students board. Weekly boarding will also be quite different to two nights a week. And he will be older. So I would not agonise about it too much at this stage.

And I just realised it’s 18 months away. My goodness the changes he will go through in the next 18/20 months will be crazy. My sweet loving 11 year old became a spotty, tall, deep voiced talking, stinky teenager so believe me he will go through a lot of emotions about it between now and then. Lots of talking about it will help xx

One of my boys started boarding in September at age 13 and he really didn’t want to go (unfortunately he isn’t academic or sporty and London day schools are so competitive; this school seemed perfect for him) The first 2/3 weeks after he got there were hell. He would call home constantly saying he hated it and wanted to come home on a Wednesday as well as a Friday (they are very flexible with this but we went with weekly boarding) we persevered and told him kindly and lovingly that he should try and throw himself into boarding life. We sent care packages every week and drove and picked him up the first few Fridays and honestly after about three weeks and definitely after the October half term things really improved as he had made friendship connections and that made all the difference. Plus our weekends are much nicer now with a lot of family interaction instead of the usual teen grunts. Just be patient and loving with him and don’t feel the typical mummy guilt that we are all prone to. The apprehension makes them way more anxious than the actual boarding experience. It’s a major change for you all but I’m sure it will all work out to be fantastic. Good luck. Xx

Will the majority be boarding at his senior school? That might help rather than at prep where his friends are going home and he’s “stuck” at school?

As PP said, try to get him to talk about why he’s finding boarding difficult, to make sure there’s not an issue like bullying going on. And try and establish what (other than age) will change at the other school.

I would quietly start looking for a plan b day school as well, to have options there if he isn’t ready for weekly boarding in 18 months time.

I’m sure you’ve talked to him - but if he’s happy with boarding in principle then the problem must be something specific.

Something wrong either at school or at home. Bullying or teasing in the boarding house? A housemaster or matron he doesn’t get on with? A routine he finds irksome or embarrassing? Alternatively, is there any underlying domestic issue - relationships, finances, health, pets - that you’ve assumed he hasn’t picked up on? These things can loom so large in a young mind - particularly where you don’t feel you have any control.

I'd give him a break from boarding, get his anxiety levels down and give him plenty of reassurance and hopefully you'll find it's just a blip and he's ready to head off in 18 months.

I'd worry that by sticking with the 2 nights/week you're building up increasingly bad associations with boarding

Boarding at a prep school where different kids board on different nights and no guarantee that dc's friends will be there is a very different experience to secondary boarding where everyone is there all week. Also things like bed times, having own phone in school, potentially being in a mixed age dorm, (where you are at the older end of age range so rules & activities are aimed to include the younger ones) can make the experience very unlike full boarding.
If your d's likes the school and is not saying he has changed his mind about boarding at 13 then it may just be the back & forth of flexi. It may be wise to have a plan b in your pocket. There is still much emotional growth to be done in the next year & a half, don't panic yet.

My son never boarded at his prep. He was insistent that he didn't want to. Headed off to full board at a school some distance away where he knew no one at Year 9 and slotted in straight away. He expected it to be tough, but found in reality he was so busy in first few weeks that he was back home with us for half-term before he had his first wobble. Sending him back then was nerve wracking, but he had commited himself to his House and the school by then and was determined to enjoy every bit he could. This got him through any further wobbles and now he refuses to consider anywhere else for sixth form!😁