Please or to access all these features

Secondary education

Connect with other parents whose children are starting secondary school on this forum.

If your roommate at a boarding school is a bully...

142 replies

BullyingAtBoardingSchool · 19/05/2019 02:19

DS is 12 and he is a weekly boarder. It was his choice and he was very happy until a boy from China joined the school in January and became his roommate.

DS told me the boy could be quite annoying but he wasn't a bad boy so they were 'OK'. He also said they sometimes clashed but they were working on their differences. He'd never badmouthed him and seemed to be genuinely trying to be on good terms with this boy.

However, when we had a parent meeting in February, literally every single teacher mentioned about the toxic relationship between them, some seemed very concerned or even apologetic. I was a bit surprised but thought they were over-reacting. DS didn't say they got on brilliantly, but he had other friends to play with anyway, so didn't seem to be too concerned about it.

However, near the end of the last term, DS got increasingly unhappy with this boy and requested to change the roommate for the next term. The housemaster previously told us half termly room change could happen when things weren't working well, and we actually saw some changes at a half term before. So asking for a room change for a new term wasn't an unreasonable request. The housemaster knew things were pretty bad between them and hinted his request would be accepted. But just before the school broke for Easter, DS was informed he had to stay with the boy for one more term. The reason for this was the headmaster believed it would be good for DS to gain more patience and resilience. DS was shocked as he expected his request would be approved, but he accepted and followed the instruction.

At the very beginning of this term, things didn't seem bad. DS actually said they were improving. However, this boy's attitude towards DS gradually became nasty and today DS told me he wouldn't cope with the situation any longer. The boy is incredibly selfish, wouldn't allow DS to use shared objects in the room, kicks, and steps on DS's belongings, swears at him day and night, badmouths his parents (us) - this particularly hurt DS, keeps saying mean things with lots of swearing when DS is trying to sleep, and more!! He can't relax when the boy is around. He also fears this boy may do something to his belongings when DS is out of the room, so has to keep going back to the room just to prevent this to happen. It's serious mental bullying to my eyes.

DS doesn't just cry away, so occasionally fights back or try to meet an agreement (most of the times he tries to ignore). But all these things are so draining for him that it's started affecting his ability to focus on study and other extracurricular activities.

I told DS I would email the school to make them act immediately. I would also request the room change after the second half, so only one more week to go, then a week off, then when he's back to school, the boy wouldn't be his roommate anymore. I also told him, if it becomes too much next week, I would come to pick him up and he would stay at home until the school sort this out. He seemed to be very relieved and went to sleep smiling.

This school is so proud of its anti-bullying policy and has a history to punish 'bullies' pretty harshly in the past. However, strangely, this boy doesn't get in any trouble, even though his general attitude is very poor and his bullying towards DS seems to be well known. DS said an older pupil told him that the boy's family is very wealthy and probably gave the school a huge amount of donation, so the headmaster wouldn't want to lose this boy. It's just a silly gossip, but I wouldn't be surprised if it's true... This boy has certainly totally different treatment from others.

I've just finished writing the email to the school. My son was very thankful when I offered to step in. However, am I too naive to expect the school takes our complaint seriously? We aren't wealthy. DS got significant financial help to pay for the fees. I know we aren't particularly attractive to the school financially. I'm worrying I may disappoint DS if I'm unsuccessful to make any significant change after I promised him everything would be fine.

OP posts:
happygardening · 19/05/2019 11:32

As far as I can see OP hadn’t said get DS could be a day pupil. The OP needs to have a proper conversation with the school before deciding not to take him back. Give them a chance to respond to her concerns and come up with a way forward. If they refuse to change the situation then think about removing him.

ziggiestardust · 19/05/2019 11:19

Yes; your opinion definitely overrules here. If it’s the well-being of your child, you know best. Your son is 12 and doesn’t really necessarily know how wrong this is and how to proceed.

I would not be dropping him back to school to board. Day school is fine; he needn’t miss classes or after school clubs. You’ll need to make transport arrangements for him of course; but as he is boarding out of choice rather than necessity I’m sure you’ll be able to be quite flexible.

Strawberrypancakes · 19/05/2019 11:13

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

BullyingAtBoardingSchool · 19/05/2019 11:08

I obviously told him he wouldn't need to go back to school on Monday but he insisted going back. He's having a nightmare with this boy which is shadowing his otherwise wonderful experience at the school. He loves the lessons, activities and holds the teaching staff in high regard. Apparently, there are lessons and classes he wouldn't dream of missing so it's almost like a punishment if I choose to keep him at home. So yes, I am taking him back to school on Monday, not willingly though as PP commented above. I told him he could ask me to come and pick him up at any time. It is not as easy obviously due to my work arrangements. However, I didn't tell him how difficult for me to rearrange things as I wouldn't like him to hesitate to ask me to come. What else I could say and do? I am trying to do everything I could do and offer.

We facetime or skype every night before bedtime, and exchange a few texts through a day. All are very brief and we don't discuss anything heavy (that's why I didn't how things were so bad until I saw him yesterday, and he doesn't usually want to talk about negative things when we are physically away from each other), but just to keep connected. We are extremely close.

OP posts:
Strawberrypancakes · 19/05/2019 10:33

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

happygardening · 19/05/2019 10:31

As someone who sees children with significant MH concerns on a daily basis, worked in a boarding school and used to see adults with MH concerns I can assure anyone unbiased enough to listen that there are many many happy well adjusted children in boarding schools who love their parents and who are also very much cared about and for by extremely dedicated house staff and who go onto to be happy well adjusted adults (with excellent life skills) and very sadly many depressed and dysfunctional children in day schools. Most of the latter in either boarding or day school have a dysfunctional family life the main problems obsessively controlling over ambitious parents, substance alcohol abuse, poverty messy divorce death of a parent sibling etc or significant illness of a parent sibling etc. Happy well adjusted children who have good relationships with their parents are likely to remain happy well adjusted children when they go to boarding school and go onto be well adjusted normal adults.
Their is the Boarding School Survivors Group an entirely self selecting group I suspect that if you set up a Day School Survivors Group you would find many keen to join. Two people I’m close to both have a very difficult relationship with their mother who falls into the controlling over ambitious category both have MH concerns and both wished they’d boarded as a way of getting from their mother!

ziggiestardust · 19/05/2019 10:31

If it was his choice to board; then presumably you could support him if he came home and no longer weekly boarded due to the situation? I’ve read your posts and couldn’t glean that you had a lifestyle that couldn’t support him as a day student? If that’s the case; remove him from boarding whilst all this is going on. He’s spending Mon-Fri (literally) with a tormentor. He’s got no safe space from it. That’s not backing down or letting the bully ‘win’, you are protecting your child because the school apparently are refusing to. Although I’m not sure all the amazing facilities would keep me a customer somewhere that was so slow to protect my child.

BullyingAtBoardingSchool · 19/05/2019 10:21

Thank you so much for taking your time to share your thoughts. I really appreciate all the responses.

I decided to start this thread, mainly to seek advice, but also in order to verify my expectation - whether I was reacting overly or being a pushover. Also, I knew the school would care about their reputation so I chose to discuss this openly in public and keep updating the situation until it's solved and see the reaction of the public towards justice.

I've also talked to a few people working in a day school as well as a boarding school. They all agreed I should be concerned and our situation should not be taken lightly. I am going to talk to some more professionals (family friends) as well as the parents of other schools. Collecting lots of opinions and advice so I know exactly what I am dealing with.

OP posts:
PrayingandHoping · 19/05/2019 10:10

I also chose to go to boarding school, I loved it and in no way have been scared from it 🙄 I loved the experience, saw and was in contact with my family constantly. None of my friends who went there with me have been damaged in any way and we all enjoy talking about our time at school.

In my experience OP it could well be that the housemaster can't think of who else to put the difficult boy with..... sadly they may see your son as the most tolerant in his year group. This isn't right and the way you've stood up for him hopefully will sort the situation. Don't be afraid to put your foot down

happygardening · 19/05/2019 10:06

Re: keeping his own territory many children struggle with this at boarding schools. We my DS changed to his senior school a couple hadn’t boarded used to very large spaces en suite bathrooms and dare I say it over indulgent parents the concept of having to share a space communal living give and take was an anathema to them most after a couple of terms got but it can be very tedious for others whilst they’re getting it. .

BullyingAtBoardingSchool · 19/05/2019 10:00

They have single rooms at the boarding house. If this boy is so incompatible and so selfish, they could give him a single room rather than insisting on keeping them together. If the school can't punish the boy as harsh as others for whatever the reasons, at least I would expect the school to accept they need to be separated. This boys' desire to keep his own territory seems to be the main reason for the bullying, so if DS isn't sharing any personal space with him I think the boy wouldn't follow DS and keeps bullying. Bedrooms should be the safest place for boarders.

OP posts:
Applesbananaspears · 19/05/2019 09:51

OP you need to be very blunt with them. They move your son immediately or you will involve the governors. You child will not be returning until this is actioned.

There is no cruelty in weekly boarding for a child who wants to do it, they’re home every weekend to get their Xbox fill and to fight with their siblings. What’s not ok is that the school know there is an issue and hasn’t actioned it

Gribbie · 19/05/2019 09:36

I would be demanding they moved him out the room today. Not next week. Today. No one should have to put up with that

Hadalifeonce · 19/05/2019 09:32

Sorry, posted too soon. She told them she was horrified as a parent that she hadn't suspected anything, but was horrified by the fact her DC was at the school for 10 hours a day, and they, trained professionals didn't spot anything either.
Children can be scarred for life by bullies, or worse. The bullies probably don't even remember their targets half the time.

BullyingAtBoardingSchool · 19/05/2019 09:30

Sorry, I mistyped housemaster as 'headmaster' a few times in the previous post.

OP posts:
Hadalifeonce · 19/05/2019 09:27

I would demand a change of roommate, as they are not looking after your child's emotional or physical wellbeing.

I know someone who discovered her DC had been bullied at school, even though the DC had now left the school, she went in and told the head or pastoral car and the housemaster.

BullyingAtBoardingSchool · 19/05/2019 09:20

I emailed the school last night. I didn't email only to the housemaster but included the houseparent, the head of pastoral care, and deputy safeguarding lead.

Because;

  1. It was not the first time I contacted the housemaster to discuss the boy's unreasonable behavior. It was not about bullying - I didn't identify his behaviour as bullying at the time. But things concerned me and it was relevant to DS's wellbeing. Those were sorted swiftly by the headmaster. Though the boy didn't stick to the instruction so I wouldn't say it was perfectly sorted. But improved the situation. Then I contacted the housemaster again when DS was told to stick to this boy one more term. Back then, the housemaster explained the reason why he believed it was the best solution. I had to accept it, mainly because DS decided to follow the instruction. But at the time, the headmaster assured me he would keep his eyes on them and would help them learn to get on with each other.
  1. The headmaster is soon leaving. He won't be there when DS is back after the half-term holiday. I needed to make sure someone other him and the houseparent know this as an on-going problem. I wouldn't like the new headmaster treats this as a new case and expects DS to put up with it 'one more term' before considering making any change.

To defend the housemaster, DS holds him in high regard and trusts him very much. The housemaster told DS (and me) he could come to talk to him at any time which DS did and has been doing so they had a fair amount of discussion. The housemaster intervenes in a situation when he recognises it's unfair or not right.

However, as he already turned down our request to change the room back in March, and also as he is leaving very soon, I needed to escalate my complaint and make it more formal by including all those people.

OP posts:
Tamsyn143 · 19/05/2019 09:11

What happened OP? X

AppleKatie · 19/05/2019 09:05

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

AlexaShutUp · 19/05/2019 08:57

Yes the OP certainly attracted the anti boarders last night!

Not surprising, really. I think it's pretty incomprehensible to most people in this country that you would choose to send your kids away from their homes and families at such a crucial stage of their development. However, that's by the by, because the OP has chosen for her DS to board, so she needs to find a way of making it work for him.

OP, the current situation sounds intolerable for your DS. I think you need to approach this very calmly but very firmly with the school and tell them that you're concerned about the impact of the current arrangements on your DS's mental health and ask them what they're going to do to address those concerns. I understand what you're saying about not wanting him to have to move when he is the victim of bullying, but ultimately, if the school will not keep him safe, you need to be prepared to remove him from the situation.

Upsydaisymummy · 19/05/2019 08:56

I think that fact that your paying for this added feature I would expect that the school acts on your complaint.
If it was my child (one they wouldn't be boarders anyway however no judgement) and two remove my child from the school or boarding part. Don't pay for your child to be unhappy.

AppleKatie · 19/05/2019 08:38

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

squee123 · 19/05/2019 08:38

I expect they're not moving your son because you and your son have tolerated it to date and solved a problem for them. If the troublemaker doesn't share with your son he will have to share with another boy and that boy and his parents might make much more fuss about it. You need to step up and make moving your son the only viable option. Stop being such a pushover.

DeffoJeffo · 19/05/2019 08:29

Ok. People are WAY overreacting on this thread! I am a house mistress in a boarding school and can 100% say that for the majority of children boarding school is amazing. There are definitely a proportion of children who it doesn't suit but doesn't sound like the OP's son is one of them. OP - yes, definitely speak to the house master again, ideally face to face and if not happy take to the deputy head. They should definitely take your concerns seriously.

BurnedToast · 19/05/2019 08:24

And if I hear one more teacher say the word 'resilience' I will scream. Its the current buzz word and should not be used as an excuse for not safeguarding their pupils. Their have a duty of care which they are failing to meet.

Swipe left for the next trending thread