Please or to access all these features

Secondary education

Connect with other parents whose children are starting secondary school on this forum.

Concerned about RC state school options (South London)

33 replies

googoogaga1 · 31/07/2018 18:08

We've been living in Oz since the early noughties. DH has a good job and as a family we have the right work life balance. DH's company want him to move back to London to work on a two year merger project (big bucks!)

DS1 is 10 now and on top of pulling him out of his fab state elementary school (primary school) here in Brisbane to put him in a secondary school in London, we are concerned about the quality of the state secondary schools.

We are RC (not hardcore or anything of the sort) and would like DS1 & DS2 to attend a good RC state school. We are confused by the Schools Admissions Code and are not clear whether academic children attend the faith schools or not. We have friends in London and they say that whereas these schools used to select their pupils giving a greater spread of academic pupils across good state comps, grammars and indies, that today all the able pupils are 'creamed off' by the few grammars.

This is a cause for concern for us as parents, as we would like DS to mix the full range of ability children in any school we choose. Have I failed to understand how the admissions process works? I went to a rural comp in the 90s and DH went to an all boys faith school in South London with an impressive alumni (he described it as a private school without the fees).

Anyone else in our position?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Pythonesque · 02/08/2018 21:55

Out of interest - I'm not in London so can't help with the real question - does Qld still start primary and secondary about a year older than NSW? I remember a friend who moved from Qld and ended up a year behind me at school despite being several months older, as she was kept with the year she was in in Qld.

If there is still that disparity, well probably regardless actually, I would be looking at curricula to work out if there were any areas to catch up a bit prior to the move. Though some areas your son may be ahead of course!

MarchingFrogs · 02/08/2018 21:10

But even though each sub category is further sub categorised by proximity, the degree of ''RC-ness' is always the most important thing. So, according to the admissions policy linked to above, even if you live miles away, baptism on or before your first birthday and having attended mass on every available occasion for at least three years will always trump living on the doorstep but having lackadaisical parents who didn't get you baptised until the day after you turned one, however often they have taken you to church since..

NewModelArmyMayhem18 · 02/08/2018 18:34

It surprises me DC are coming from so far afield PatriciaHolm - I would have thought they'd fill their quotas virtually entirely from Merton schools (with possibly a few just over the border into Kingston and Wandsworth boroughs). Sure the local non faith secondaries have tighter catchments than that?

PatriciaHolm · 01/08/2018 19:54

Nearer 7km, I meant...

PatriciaHolm · 01/08/2018 19:54

WC went out to 4.5km for cat 5 (catholic boys who do not attend mass) in 2017, which would put out much of clapham....

it was nearer 6km for those who attend mass every sunday and holy day, but as OP says they are not "hardcore" I suspect that may not be the case!

meditrina · 01/08/2018 17:59

It does have a exceptional social needs category, but the bare fact that you have moved will not be sufficient (loads of people move). You will need to demonstrate exceptional circumstances surrounding the move and - crucially - demonstrate why this school is uniquely able to meet his needs. You will need evidence from a suitable professional as evidence to back this up.

The criteria specify that Armed Forces DC wouid fall into that category (they have special treatment in the Admissions Code) together with other crown servants, and that refugees/asylum seekers might if they can demonstrate a need for this school rather than any other. I can't be sure, but extending that to include other mobile families might simply recognise that you cannot always pre-define 'exceptional'

NewModelArmyMayhem18 · 01/08/2018 17:48

All the Catholic secondaries are very over-subscribed, particularly with the large influx of families originating from Eastern European countries (particularly Poland) settling in SW London.

meditrina · 01/08/2018 17:31

You should be able to discover the greatest distance offered in the last round. But as they had 850 applicants for 199 places for 2017 admission (don't know if 2018 data has been published yet) and as tiebreak for whichever category they reach is siblings by distance, children of staff by distance, others by distance, I think you need to be realistic about the chances of being offered a place from that far away.

LimeIce · 01/08/2018 14:45

Here's the admissions policy
www.johnfisherschool.org/Admissions-and-Appeals-Prospective-Parents

MarchingFrogs · 01/08/2018 14:44

Don't think they do interviews/exam any more.

Re the interview, one hopes not, since that has been contrary to the Admissions Code for many years now

OP, I think your DH will probably find that quite a lot has changed since his school days with regard to admissions, nearly all of it a major improvement. If being interviewed to make sure that the child / parent is the right sort for a school is something which appeals, I'm afraid that you will have to go private. State schools are only allowed to request information which is pertinent to their published admissions policy- for instance, having a contact for a child is necessary, more is not, so whether that contact has a partner or not, or what their marital status is, is totally irrelevant to any school admission.

LimeIce · 01/08/2018 13:22

I think john fisher did interviews and exams in the 90s and selected on ability and how "naice" the family were. Eg. I remember a post about it on mumsnet where someone said they were rejected because their mum was a single mumConfused
Don't think they do interviews/exam any more. Just select on faith

Iamagreyhoundhearmeroar · 01/08/2018 12:47

You won’t get into Cardinal Vaughan or the Oratory on a late application. They’re hugely oversubscribed and there’s virtually no movement once the places are taken up.

googoogaga1 · 01/08/2018 12:44

DH was at John Fisher, Purley back in the 1990s. He's just told me that the school may still operate 'selection interviews' in the year prior to admittance, so maybe we've missed the boat? Are interviews normal or only practised by certain schools? What is the point of them?

Clapham to Wimbledon could be manageable for the College. Wimbledon looks luvly.

OP posts:
LimeIce · 01/08/2018 12:42

Although i suppose RC schools aren't non selective

LimeIce · 01/08/2018 12:41

There's a website where you can check the proportion of able pupils. www.compare-school-performance.service.gov.uk
There are only 4 boys' grammars in the whole of South London i think, none in Surrey, so there are still loads of able pupils in non selective schools.

marytuda · 01/08/2018 11:44

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

meditrina · 01/08/2018 11:33

And you may need a Certifucate of Catholic Practice for oversubscribed schools:

www.catholiceducation.org.uk/guidance-for-schools/admissions

You need to find out in advance if the school/s you are interested in require one, in order to prioritise applicants, and what happens to families who have moved house during any qualifying period.

meditrina · 01/08/2018 11:11

If he is 10 now (as you posted yesterday) he will be 11 next summer and therefore be going in to Y7 in September 2019. Unless he has a birthday before 1 September, in which case it is Y8 in Sept 2019.

When is it you will need him to start in the English school system?

It sounds likely you'll be making what is called an 'in year application' (ie one outside the main allocation rounds), where you can only be offered a place at a school which has a vacancy at the time you apply. You can however appeal for a place at a school you have been rejected from (that wouid be a whole other thread, though).

NewModelArmyMayhem18 · 01/08/2018 11:09

Also Wimbledon College.

I think many Catholic families don't even consider the localish super-selective grammars because the local church secondary school provision is good. Particularly true for girls, with Ursuline and St Phil's both local.

ourkidmolly · 01/08/2018 10:53

From there your son could get to LO and Cardinal Vaughan which are both highly regarded and sought after.

onholiday · 01/08/2018 10:13

Presumably he will start y7 in 2019 though so the deadline will still be 31 October this year?

onholiday · 01/08/2018 10:11

If you're only going to be here for 2 years can you afford private if you wanted to do that. Not because the schools are necessarily better but there is less pressure on where to live, admissions stress etc etc. Less of a lottery although have to do exams etc...

googoogaga1 · 01/08/2018 09:56

According to DH the Oratory and his old school in Purley were the top RC schools when he was coming up through the English school system.

I think he just has an idea that he would like this kind of schooling for DS1, but an old classmate of his has suggested the schools mentioned may be very different to how he and DH remember them.

DS1 falls in to the following school year so not as much pressure TBH.

OP posts:
SquirmOfEels · 01/08/2018 07:57

Sorry - got that rather badly round my neck, didn't I!? Glad there are people who corrected things.

Some RC schools have very good reputations and are highly sought after. Other do not, and some are actively swerved.

OP: I was wondering, do you particularly want an RC school? Or are you using 'faith school' as a proxy for 'good school' (something which might not be true)

And which English school year will you be seeking a place for, and when you you arrive? The applications round for Year 7 in 2019 will be opening in about a month and national deadline is 31 October. Applications are not normally accepted from children before they are resident in UK, so would you need to apply outside the main round?

SadieHH · 01/08/2018 07:52

Yes Wimbledon College is Catholic.