Please or to access all these features

Secondary education

Connect with other parents whose children are starting secondary school on this forum.

Economics vs Business A Level

26 replies

Piggywaspushed · 30/08/2017 13:04

The backstory to this is rather long but it involves DS1 not being able to pursue the subjects he wants at his current school.

At present, subjects of choice are (in order of preference) : Spanish, Politics, French and economics.

He turned up to his second choice establishment today to be told (erroneously as it turns put) that he 's a bit dim and stands little to no chance of passing economics and so should do Business Studies. Turns out they got the stats wrong!!

But, anyhow, this has now put business into his head : a subject he has never so much as glanced at in a prospectus, did not study at GCSE and din not find out about at Open Evenings.

Personally, I find the prospect of either Economics or Business a bit dull. I have looked at specs and Exam Papers for the reformed A Levels and can't see the big differences. I do know they have different reputations and that a different student profile takes them. I do also know that some students do extremely well in business who are not so good at other A levels : but wonder if specific skills or mindsets help (and wonder how much this applied to pre reformed A level).

Can anyone without a Russell Group/ elitist axe to grind advise me impartially as to what the key differences are : and what type of student, with what kind of skills prospers in each?

For context , DSs (somewhat under predictions) GCSEs are : English Lang 5 (being remarked ) ; Lit 6 ; Maths 6 ; Spanish A* ; French A everything else C (best not talk about the D for Geography...). It may or may not be relevant that after much resitting and redoing he eventually got a C for CiDA (ICT for dummies??) and computers are not his thing. (not sure what is ...)

OP posts:
BubblesBuddy · 30/08/2017 13:26

It is perfectly possible to do Business Studies at A level without the GCSE. My DD enjoyed it. Economics too for that matter. Generally Business Studies is seen as less academic than Economics and has less Maths content. I would say that if his Maths was good, then Economics should not be a problem but a 6 is a bit iffy so I can see where the school are coming from. Where my DDs went to school, Business Studies was sleected by the less mathematically able. Economics took the A-A* mathematicians. Business studies tends to be more focussed on the world of business and Economics more on the big picture. He would struggle to do Economics at a RG University on a level 6 maths at GCSE and no Maths A level.

However, is he really taking all four to A2 level? Most schools are not doing 4 any more so Spanish, French and Politics would be fine. I would say he may struggle with Politics because he does not have a high grade in any essay subject. Politics is closer to History. Has he taken History at GCSE? If not, Politics may be a stretch unless he is really engaged with it. It is more about how Politics works than arguing the issue of the day though. Look at the syllabus very carefully to see if it is interesting.

As he seems to be more of a linguist, why can he not do Business Studies and the two languages? Universities are crying out for Language students with two A level languages so that would be an easier route into a Russell Group university. Plenty will not care too much about the third A level.

Swipe left for the next trending thread