Please or to access all these features

Secondary education

Connect with other parents whose children are starting secondary school on this forum.

Non denominational school - ds asked to curb his atheism in RE. Quietly seething.

29 replies

Piffle · 06/12/2006 11:47

Last yr in yr 7 RE was world religions, a history of religious developement, balanced, well debated and sceptics were given equal floor time and embraced even.
now in yr 8 they focus heavily on Chrisitianity, had no issue at all as thought it was been done as a "history" type tpoic, not a We Must All Be Good Christians and Believe in God.
DS is a cynic, sceptic, and very dismissive of the god concept, being a scientist has only helped him along his path to purgatory.
He regularly challenges concepts in class, which last year was encouraged
the school does not hymns, prayers or anything
RE is COMPULSORY at GCSE at least as short course, which is also sticking in my throat as it means ds will have to drop a subject he really likes ...possibly.
So anyway enouh rambling
His RE teacher told him yesterday to keep his non Christian thoughts in his head.
Now he did wait until "any questions" session of the lesson. His questions were not offensive, related to the lesson etc
Am frankly baffled

OP posts:
PeachyIsNowAChristmasFruit · 06/12/2006 12:11

Hi, I'm doing a degree in this subject and hoping to do a PGCE after.

I am also a non Christian (not sure what I am LOL, rather like the Gnostic gospels atm )

I would ahve a chat with the teacher, clear up how accurate your son's story is- nto that he is lying but there are always two sides and as someone said, tone is everything. HOWEVER he should be allowed to make his points nd that should be encouraged: I am at Uni, and I do so rather vocally LOL!

You say he was allowed last year? that would make me speak to the teacher then, see what the change is.

KTreePee · 06/12/2006 11:59

Seems odd - even 20 or so years ago at a church school, when I was a lot like your ds, I never had any comments like that. Do you know what religion (if any) the RE teacher is? Also odd that RE is compulsory I would have thought (but have no kids at secondary level yet so don't really know how common that is at a non-church school...)

donnie · 06/12/2006 11:59

maybe it was in his tone. A lot is, you know .

BTW non GCSE RE is compulsory in all secondary schools and does not cause pupils to lose an option. They only get 1 - 2 periods a fortnight.

tribpot · 06/12/2006 11:58

Bang out of order IMO (the teacher I mean). Surely intelligent and appropriate questioning should be encouraged, whatever the topic?

Swipe left for the next trending thread