Please or to access all these features

Secondary education

Connect with other parents whose children are starting secondary school on this forum.

The most Socially Selective schools in England.

316 replies

smokepole · 31/12/2014 21:46

Here is a list of the most socially selective state schools in England , total no of pupils entitled to free school meals over the last six years. Dept Of Education Characteristics

  1. Cranbrook School Kent 5
  2. Borlase Grammar Bucks 5
  3. Bishop Words Wilts 7
  4. Pate's Grammar Gloucs 8
  5. Colchester Royal Essex 10
  6. Caistor Grammar Lincs 10
  7. King Edward Louth Lincs 10
  8. Adams Grammar Shrop 11
  9. Colchester High Essex 12
  10. Kendrick Grammar Berks 12
  11. Dr Challinor High Bucks 12
12. Alyesbury Gram Bucks 13 12. Beaconsfield High Bucks 13 12. Newport High Shrop 13 15. Stratford Gram Warks 14 15.Skinners Sch Kent 14 17.Chelmsford High Essex 15 17. Judd Sch Kent 15 17. St Olaves Kent 15 20. Alcester Gram Warks 16 21. Tonbridge Gram Kent 17 22. Kegs Chelms Essex 19 22. Lancaster Girls Lancs 19 24. Skipton High Yorks 20 24. Tunbridge W Gir Kent 20 26 Hockerill Anglo Essex 21 27. Ripon Gram Yorks 22 27. Ermysteds Yorks 22 29. Altrincham Boys Ches 23 30. St Bernards Slough Berks 24
OP posts:
ArsenicFaceCream · 02/01/2015 18:40

Horse Rangers waiting lists are often 3 or more years long. A handful of city farms offer pony club and also have waiting lists measured in years. I have held roles where I need to know this stuff.

Such clubs are the exception. Equestrianism is not 'open to all' or 'egalitarian'.

But yes, such provision is fantastic, where it exists, but should remain an out-of-school thing so as not to highlight vast differences in opportunity available to pupils.

Eastpoint · 02/01/2015 18:38

Out I am on scrappy 3G but didn't one of the medalists at the 2012 Olympics get a dressage medal on a horse belonging to someone else whose stables she'd gone to work in. I can't remember her name but I think she said she'd just had great opportunities. There's a state school in Gillingham Dorset which has an equestrian team. Where we used to ride, families regularly bought ponies which were incredibly cheap (under £1k) and then ran them in fields/diy livery. No fancy cars at the stables at all, mainly K-S reg with the teens working at the stables for rides/lessons. None of the families went on holiday & teens had jobs after school as well as at the stables.

ArsenicFaceCream · 02/01/2015 18:36

Yes I know where exactly where it is. I have been there. I could stroll there from here. It isn't the point happy

They exist to do what they do, out of school, for a particular demographic.

They are not representative of equestrianism as a pursuit. Their existence is not an argument for horses in state schools.

happygardening · 02/01/2015 18:34

Again can I suggest you google Ebony Horse Club situated in the 10th most deprived UK borough clearly epode here believe horses are for "people like us".
I don't need to google the JRF website thank you I lived for over 13 years in one of the UK's most deprived boroughs and worked and still work with some of the UK's most deprived.
Don't forget it wasn't me who suggested that illegal immigrants take out health insurance before they left their countries and made long and treacherous journey to the UK.

DoctorDonnaNoble · 02/01/2015 18:32

Smoke - interestingly, my DF came from the sort of background people usually say is limiting (council estate in ex-mining community). He had teachers who encouraged him and the fact that everyone took the exam on his side.
When I was doing my teacher training, however, the attitude was very anti-grammar school. When I talked about gifted and talented work, I was often told I was expecting too much! I was fortunate enough to have one placement that believed all students should be challenged. The other was rubbish (the college thought it was the other way round Confused).
All I can say is, yes, we should be doing more but we ARE trying!

Toughasoldboots · 02/01/2015 18:27

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

happygardening · 02/01/2015 18:26

I'm just pointing out that contrary to some assertions on here that horse riding is not just for the privileged few with stacks of money and that children from all back grounds dream of being involved with horses.
It's clearly something some on here are here to talk about but very obviously know nothing about.

smokepole · 02/01/2015 18:24

I let Morethan answer that question.?

Second thoughts : Because it is inter -generational ignorance brought on by never having had the opportunities themselves, or knowing anyone who has had any opportunity . Knowing nobody who went to University or left the local town or area for a high flying or academic career , being kept in the dark about life outside their small socially deprived area (I am not talking about "Economic" but in terms of culture here.) These ideas about "why has it not crossed the mind of said parents" come out of the Metropolitan Left, Ed Milliband types who think Poverty is just about "foodbanks". It is also about poverty of thought and knowledge !.

OP posts:
ArsenicFaceCream · 02/01/2015 18:23

Why smoke would they not cross the minds of parents and teachers from socially mixed areas to offer them? Are their horizons that limited? Are the teachers that unimaginative? Or are you just making assumptions from a position of no knowledge and prejudice?

Happy it is so mean-spirited to throw insults like that at people who might have the mindset of 'not for people like us'. I've worked with and met people who have expressed exactly that sentiment. Similarly, many people might be unaware of schemes and clubs that do exist to widen participation, or they might be referal only.

Can I suggest you take yourself off to the JRF website and inform yourself a bit?

(And the repeated accusations that smoke is speaking from ignorant prejudice are wearing a bit thin too.)

DoctorDonnaNoble · 02/01/2015 18:21

More,
A lot of the issue we have is that many primary teachers (not all) disapprove of grammar schools. My own Yr6 teacher did. But my parents investigated anyway, my dad had gone to one in Scotland when there were loads and everyone did the 11+.
I would encourage anyone interested to contact these schools about admissions. I invigilate the entrance exam every year - we're very friendly, honest Grin

ArsenicFaceCream · 02/01/2015 18:17

Yes, Horse Rangers are great. They are not a state school, however.

morethanpotatoprints · 02/01/2015 18:17

Happy

I know what smoke means as have experienced this ourselves with the music and a grammar school that we just fit catchment.
Wrt the grammar school, parents don't know it exists for them, where to take the 11+ and the fact that it wouldn't be practical in terms of transport is irrelevant because they just don't know.
It doesn't matter what exists if parents don't go looking and teachers don't suggest or pass on knowledge of their existance.

happygardening · 02/01/2015 18:16

You could also google the Horse Rangers Association, horse ownership was and I'm assuming still is a bar to membership again riding for all regardless of financial back ground.

happygardening · 02/01/2015 18:12

Why smoke would they not cross the minds of parents and teachers from socially mixed areas to offer them? Are their horizons that limited? Are the teachers that unimaginative? Or are you just making assumptions from a position of no knowledge and prejudice?
Can I suggest you google Ebony Horse Club, the Emile Faurie Foundation, Mudchute Farm, Ride High, Stepney Bank Stables and there are many more all ensuring that horses are crossing the minds of deprived children if not their parents and teachers.

DoctorDonnaNoble · 02/01/2015 18:04

I think there is an issue in communicating to people what they are entitled to and this can affect selective schools more for a variety of reasons.
One of the reasons for any change between when I was at secondary and now is the cost of transport. In the 1990s, the county council gave free transport to those living more than 3 miles from grammar and religious schools. Firstly, they cut the funding to the grammars then to the church schools.
Several girls I was at sixth form with were only able to attend as travel passes were free.
Given that there are several ways to get the uniform cheaper, maybe it's now transport costs putting people off.
We do several outreach programmes with the local primary schools and secondary (for sixth form) some are very resistant to us coming in, making it harder to keep parents informed of the possibility of attending our school.

morethanpotatoprints · 02/01/2015 18:01

Smokepole

This is so true, nobody from our area except dd is involved with her choir.
They are all the Manchester grammar or good Cheshire schools and folk round here have never heard of it let alone know their dc could audition and be a part of it.
On the G&T register at her old school no musical opportunities even some offered by the LA were suggested to us.
In fact even paying for tuition wasn't an option until y3, it was just unheard of and not allowed.
Once involved with the LA groups it was different, but any parents who don't know the ropes wouldn't stand a chance.

smokepole · 02/01/2015 17:55

There is another thing to understand , even if these opportunities are affordable and attainable (which I doubt very much) they would not cross the mind of parents or teachers from any socially mixed area to offer them . The reason being Equestrian teams , Aeroplane building, trips to South Africa,China E.T.C are just not on the scope of anybody outside a very small section of society ,either of affluent means or those families who have large amounts of "Cultural capital"..

OP posts:
TotallySociallyInep · 02/01/2015 17:47

Where I grew up it was quite common for DC to have a pony. Not all cobby types. Lots of other native breeds though. The kids came from all different back grounds. Yes some lived in rented council houses. Some in suburban semi. I'm sure they and me given the opportunity would love to have represented our School. Girls who didn't have their own pony or horse use to borrow other peoples for local shows (as I guess they would for a school team too) a lot of the ponys cost very little to buy or were loaned to them as the previous owner out grew them. Not many fields rented or shared, had facilities. We just use to make jumps out of what ever we could. I found a girl a pony to ride (she was on fsm) because I had noticed a pony sitting in a field doing nothing. We went and asked about the pony and asked if my friend could spend some time with it. The lady was very happy with that as her daughter had gone to uni and lost interest a year or so earlier. It didn't cost my friend anything but time.
So if a state school in a rural area offers an equestrian team why not?

happygardening · 02/01/2015 17:41

DS1 old state comp offered various trips to a China, South Africa etc all were well in excess of £2500. DS2 (Win Coll) has never been offered a trip costing more than £700, 1 was significantly cheaper than that, I get the impression the dons try to keep costs as low as possible.

morethanpotatoprints · 02/01/2015 17:23

Brenda

Sometimes I wave my dh off knowing he is busting a gut for the small income we have, knowing that we have to pay for everything whereas some people who don't have an earner in the family get services and facilities for free and as much in benefits as we have from an income.

Never once would I think or suggest that they are less deserving or even more deserving of the help.
I don't know what it is like to worry where my next meal is coming from, how I will feed and clothe my children, how I will afford utilities.

Of course people living in poverty are more deserving.

Sparklingbrook · 02/01/2015 17:19

Ds1's state High School has an Equestrian Team but you do have to supply your own horse. They are very successful I believe. Smile

morethanpotatoprints · 02/01/2015 17:01

Smokepole

Is so correct, you can't imagine some of the disadvantaged people in the country who don't have the same opportunities as many.
We are very lucky to be able to afford the private tuition we have for dd due to the fact we are old timers and come from a time when it was easier to scrimp, save and have a mortgage, even on a low income.
If we were starting out now we wouldn't be accepted for a mortgage on our house now, how on earth is that right?

One school here offers a skiing trip it was the school ds2 attended. The same half dozen kids from each year went every year, it certainly wasn't inclusive.

I do have to say that our music service is fantastic and children unable to afford lessons, instruments and residentials are subsidised the whole lot if they are fsm. A couple of these dc every so often gain places at Chethams which offers them specialised music education on a similar footing. This is what I call inclusive.
I think it is quite rare and haven't heard of many more like this. The teachers are amazing for encouraging children and as soon as they can play anything half decent they are in a county group. There are never enough to form school orchestras and unfortunately there isn't alot of parental support here neither.

happygardening · 02/01/2015 16:56

No one has said that top level equestrianism is egalitarian because to compete at the top you do need considerable wealth, but I used to own a very nice pony who would have done well in school level competitions and I would have happily put a keen child on him and given free coaching. As he wasn't a potential Olympic Games horse and was primarily a companion for my competition horse he cost peanuts to keep.
Looking after ponies teaches children very useful life lessons as they require massive input and time in all weathers all the year round the time spent riding them is actually less than the time spent looking after them properly. Horses require enormous tact, and patience they are unpredictable, become ill at the drop of a hat and as any race horse trainer will tell you they are never a dead cert when it comes to competitions. They are also a great therapy, as anyone working for riding for the disabled will tell you. It's hardly surprising then that there are various organisations around the UK offering riding for very disadvantaged youngsters.
In the ideal world perhaps more disadvantaged children should have access to horses.

ArsenicFaceCream · 02/01/2015 16:50

It costs more for a family of four to have season tickets for a premiership football team than it does to own livestock

What's that got to do with school sports? Confused

smokepole · 02/01/2015 16:49

I think you find most families don't have four season tickets to a premiership ground. The reality is most families don't even have 1 season ticket and will borrow their friends (probably paying for its use) to attend 1 or 2 games a season if lucky . When their friend/s can't make the game.

OP posts: