Please or to access all these features

Secondary education

Connect with other parents whose children are starting secondary school on this forum.

Changing GCSE Options

34 replies

Anyhelpwelcome · 04/11/2014 12:57

Hi everyone,
At the end of year 8 my son was given the route 1 option which is triple science but then you could only choose one extra option. My son chose to do route 2 which is double science so he could choose 2 options (at that time he chose business studies and IT). My son changed from IT to Computing science at the beginning of year 9 as he said he would like to work in the gaming industry doing programming. He's not struggling as he is above average academically but he has announced he finds it boring and now wants to swap to Resistant Materials. I am disappointed as he is academically able and has given me no clear vision how RM will benefit him in the future. I know it's his choice but I don't want him making the wrong choices and his end target in computing science is 9.7. The GCSEs he is taking are english, maths, double science, history french, GCSE PE, business studies, philosophy and ethics(re) and (at the moment) computing science. So far I have advised him against swapping as I think some type of computer skills would be beneficial. Any advice/opinion would be appreciated.

OP posts:
skylark2 · 04/11/2014 20:38

Your son has had dreadful advice, I'm afraid. He really should be doing triple science. RM would have been a much better choice than either business studies or computer studies too (most people taking them at uni don't even have A level in them, nobody could care less if they did GCSE). That's not true for science, especially if he's been taught to a lower level because the more able students in his year are taking triple, and many sixth forms (not all) won't even let him on an A level science course with double science from a school which offers triple.

If he really wants to be a programmer, he needs to go beg to be allowed on the triple science course and to work like stink to catch up. Programmers don't have GCSE IT or even A level IT and only rarely have degrees in IT, they generally have maths and physics degrees. He's cut himself off from that and the school should have picked up on it.

cricketballs · 04/11/2014 20:01

TeenandTween - no worries but its something that as a teacher of Business I really get fed up of hearing (even from my SLT as they try to stop higher ability students from choosing the subjects but want lower ability to take it and then grill me about results Hmm) it is a 'light weight/easy subject and is not worth studying when past students of mine (including those who completed a BTEC Business) can gain places at Oxbridge I often find myself fighting the common misconception regarding the subject

Bunbaker · 04/11/2014 19:53

It's OK, I'm not at all offended. I used to think that PE was a lightweight subject, only for those who were good at sport, and I was surprised to read how academic it was.

TeenAndTween · 04/11/2014 19:42

Sorry, didn't mean to offend anyone with the 'lightweight' comment.
For what it's worth my DD would not have been able to manage the maths content of Business Studies. She would also be lucky to get an E in any DT subject or PE.

I think OPs child is only in y9, so they appear to be doing a 3 year course? Would that make a difference to being allowed to change?

catslife · 04/11/2014 19:37

I would have thought that it would be too late to change GCSE options now OP. Transferring from IT to Computer Science would be relatively straightforward as it involves similar skills.
Most DT subjects are not soft options either - they are actually quite a lot of work and involve quite a range of skills: design, understanding of technical details as well as making the products (practical skills). At dds school they have already made one set of products and had these assessed, so it wouldn't be possible to make this up after missing the whole of Term 1.

Bunbaker · 04/11/2014 18:55

According to the booklet that DD's school produced about GCSE options PE is most definitely not a lightweight option. You have to be good at writing essays, study anatomy and various other topics all related to PE. It is far more academic than most people think. Practical PE skills are only a very small part of GCSE PE.

headlesslambrini · 04/11/2014 18:35

Does he still want to do gaming?

cricketballs · 04/11/2014 18:17

Without getting into a discussion regarding the supposed 'light weight' subjects although I will say that analytical and evaluation skills coupled with high standards of literacy are needed to gain a C, never mind higher in GCSE Business you might find that the school would not allow any subject movement now - I will not accept after 3 weeks as we have already covered a lot of new learning

TeenAndTween · 04/11/2014 14:06

RM would be useful to a would-be engineer.

Computer science is probably programming, good for a mathematically minded person. I wouldn't be surprised if he has good general 'Computer skills' anyway, not sure he needs a GCSE in it to prove that.

I would (perhaps wrongly) consider PE and Business studies to be a bit 'lightweight' and, as a more practical subject, I would put RM in there too. otoh he has 8 strong subjects (assuming English is 2) already, so the rest don't matter much anyway.

Does he really know what RM would include? Or is it a case of the grass is always greener elsewhere?