Please or to access all these features

Secondary education

Connect with other parents whose children are starting secondary school on this forum.

Independent v State Sixth Form Dilemma

53 replies

Daltec · 03/10/2014 14:22

DD’s co-ed school doesn’t have a sixth form, so we are now looking for a school/college for her to attend in September 2015. She wants to study Maths and 2 sciences for A level. We are on a low income but could just about manage independent school fees if she were to get a very generous scholarship (no mortgage and could make cut backs and look at ways to generate income e.g.no holidays, get a lodger etc.). DD says she doesn’t want to go to private school because they will all be snobs and she won’t fit in. We went to an open day at an all girls independent recently and were made to feel very welcome by pupils and staff alike which I think changed her view. She’s still unsure though and I think it should be her decision (DH disagrees!). One of the main issues for her is that there are three girls going there from her present school and she can’t stand any of them. Worse still, they’ll be studying the same subjects and the groups will be small. Another problem is that the school has a very large intake of Asian students and DD thinks that they will stick all stick together (common culture, language and fact that they’ll be boarding together) which means that she will have a limited pool from which to make new friends.

One of the teachers said that, results wise, it doesn’t make any difference where you study A levels as A levels require much more independent learning. So now I’m wondering whether I’ll be getting value for money by sending her privately. She has some confidence issues, but would two years be enough to make a difference? Is is worth making all of the sacrifices we would need to make as a family? I’m really torn and DD said that she is worried that she’ll regret it if she doesn’t apply.

Any advice would be much appreciated.

OP posts:
3littlefrogs · 03/10/2014 15:04

I would suggest looking at 6th form college.
DD is at the local state one, which is absolutely fantastic.
Small classes, personal tutors, amazing library, loads of facilities and extracurricular activities.
I couldn't ask for better if I was paying a fortune.

Daltec · 03/10/2014 15:01

Secretsquirrels thanks for your reply. That is very interesting. I didn't know that the state sector also took overseas students. I viewed the large intake of Asian students as a positive because, in my view, they are sensible and hard-working students. Also, as you say, for someone like my DD who wants to study maths, the Asian students could be a real bonus. At DD's present state school, there are a lot of pupils with parents from various countries in South East Asia and, although they do not have a common language, they still tend to stick together (mainly Chinese, Japanese, Filipinos.) I told her that the girls coming from overseas won't know anybody else here and so will be more likely to want to make friends with her, but I can understand why she is concerned about the social side of things.

If she'll do well wherever she goes, maybe I'd be best to save my money!

OP posts:
secretsquirrels · 03/10/2014 14:44

Lots of state sixth forms have a cash generating sideline in overseas students. My two went to a huge state sixth form college with a mixed intake from all local state comps plus around 100 fee paying overseas, mainly Chinese students.
DS1 did very well there and made one or two friends among the overseas students. In Maths in particular they were streets ahead of the local DC and added a lot to the lessons.
I agree with that teacher. If she works hard she will do well wherever she chooses to go.