Please or to access all these features

Secondary education

Connect with other parents whose children are starting secondary school on this forum.

Is this detention (Year 7) unreasonable?

29 replies

HelenMALL2 · 13/07/2014 02:53

Ok, first of all thank you for taking time to read and answer.

Here is my problem. My son has been off for 2 1/2 weeks after having his appendix removed. Before his surgery he withdrew a book from the school library. It was due back on a Wednesday. He was absent that Wednesday
and returned to school on Thursday. On Friday he was called into the library. He'd forgotten about his book. He tells me he now has a 20 minute detention on Monday and a 20 minute detention on Tuesday. On Monday for not returning the book when he was absent, which is totally unfair. His detention on Tuesday is justified as it's the rules but surely the school can apply common sense. It was his first day back from a long absence. I'm wondering what to do as I don't think at the least the Monday detention is fair.
Please help

OP posts:
Hakluyt · 13/07/2014 09:18

Sounds utterly unfair. I would email.

But be absolutely sure that there isn't more to it. Did he explain why it was late? He wasn't rude or anything was he? Because a 20 minute detention for a late library book seems bizarre.

HibiscusIsland · 13/07/2014 09:13

Yes the first one seems unfair. What is the second one for?

2Retts · 13/07/2014 04:33

Send an email to the school (head of year or headteacher) explaining why it is inappropriate to apply a sanction for the library book given the mitigating circumstances (serious illness) and see what happens.

HelenMALL2 · 13/07/2014 03:04

Just wanted to add I know 20 minutes is nothing to have a s* fit about, but its more the basis of it. My son has said he doesn't mind going to the second but not the first.

OP posts: