Please or to access all these features

Secondary education

Connect with other parents whose children are starting secondary school on this forum.

How to ask for more challenging work?

83 replies

dalziel1 · 23/02/2014 08:00

DS is in year 7 at an outstanding comprehensive. He says he isn't really being challenged in any of subjects like English, maths, science, MFL, geography, history, ICT etc but the ones which are streamed (or is it setted?) are better than those where he's in a mixed ability class.

The teachers do differentiate but DS rarely has to put much effort in even for the most challenging objectives.

Other parents tell me that their children are averaging three hours homework per night, whereas DS maybe does an hour per week (but he still does everything - I check).

The problem is that he's getting bored in class and it makes him feel frustrated when things get repeated over and over. Out of school, he's not bothered at all if there is no challenging work for him as it just means more time doing the things he enjoys. So, the answer is not to leave him to decide whether he fancies doing a bit of extra work at home on one of the websites for which the school has bought licences.

I know I should bring this up with the school, but my question is how do I do this without sounding a) critical that they aren't challenging him and b) like the pushy mother from hell.

OP posts:
wordfactory · 24/02/2014 11:39

dalziel the problem is that in order for high ability pupils to get the best out of their education you need a critical mass of like ability peers IMVHO.

And getting that in a comprehensive is difficult if your DC fall outside the main ability spread where 80% sit.

dalziel1 · 24/02/2014 10:12

Yes, there are many, many selective schools about. One of them is state run and the others are all in the independent sector.

The independent ones are all way beyond what we could afford, even if we did qualify for a 10%/or 25% discount (if they offered 75%, then maybe we could manage it!).

The state one, where entry is ultra-competitive - is 20 miles away, although I've heard that children travel there from up to 50 miles away. With hindsight, we should have got DS tutored in year 5, taken the entrance exam and tried to get him in there.

DH argued at the time with me about this. I just didn't realise how intelligent DS actually is until about this time last year when he did some IQ tests. Since then, he seems to have more confidence and his work has gone from quite good to really, really good.

I am finding it hard, even now, to fathom that an outstanding secondary, one which people move to our town just so that they can send their kids there, isn't meeting DS's needs.

OP posts:
wordfactory · 24/02/2014 08:44

OP the sad fact is that some high abilkity DC will find the school curriculum, even in top set, unchallenging.

Some people will say too bad. Some people will say your son should be happy he finds it all so easily. Some will say their highly able DC just adore fannying about waiting fior the others.

But none of that will help your son.

Are there any selective schools in your area?

Lottiedoubtie · 24/02/2014 08:24

I'm a teacher in a subject similar to English but not actual English.

I once introduced a shakespeare play entirely without using the text. That was week one and all pupils learnt the plot. In weeks 2-6 we of course, used extracts of the play. If I taught English to year 7 I would expect them to read all of a shortish abridged version.

If it definitely happened and the teacher has confirmed OP I would consider going to discuss it with either your child's head of year or the head of English.

dalziel1 · 24/02/2014 07:42

They read one book in the Autumn term (was supposed to be two but they ran out of time for the second).
Currently they are "doing" the Shakespeare play.

Next up, will be poetry (as yet unspecified).

OP posts:
lljkk · 24/02/2014 07:37

I hate reading Shakespeare, too. I wouldn't think it impossible they didn't read any original. But did they read nothing else since September?

DD's y7 set in English read Boy Overboard in autumn term, along with The Speckled Band (Conan Doyle), and some original Grimms Fairy Tales this term. I imagine even the lowest sets read some other texts.

dalziel1 · 24/02/2014 06:46

Umm... it did happen: the teacher confirmed it to me at parent's night. He explained that some of the children would have found the language too complex, even just to read one page.

However, Ravenak, and possibly Lottiedoubtie, you are English teachers?

So, if you both think its unlikely/ plain wouldn't have happened and yet it did happen, coupled with the two pieces of homework I've seen (i.e. design a poster and fix some basic spelling) then it does make it likely that DS is right about not being challenged?

Which would take me back to my original question: how can I go out about approaching the school to get more challenging work set for DS. He would benefit from this generally (his POV), but he especially needs it in English??

OP posts:
Lottiedoubtie · 23/02/2014 23:18

They didn't study a Shakespeare play without reading a word of it. That didnt happen OP.

ravenAK · 23/02/2014 23:15

That sounds unlikely.

dalziel1 · 23/02/2014 21:33

As far as I know they are not reading anything at the moment. Last half-term, they studied a Shakespearean play, without actually reading a word of it (obviously).

OP posts:
AhBut · 23/02/2014 21:06

I understand your frustration OP, but I also agree with others that it's about so much more than ticking boxes to get to a certain level, and much more about broadening depth and understanding of subjects.
DS entered year 7 already at level 8 in maths, and high achieving in literacy too. But tbh he still finds some new things in maths lessons/ new ways of approaching problems and is fortunate to have a maths teacher who he really respects and engages with. His target, rather than being a purely academic one, is to work better with his peers ... A skill he'll only benefit from developing.
Interestingly his maths teacher doesn't recommend the online sites you mention for children of this level, as he reckons they're not going to stimulate them. It requires a bit of lateral thinking but there's loads of interesting stuff on sites like the maths challenge website, or you can do mad things like work out the algebraic equations for each menu in the local cafe (I jest not!)
I've also found that the added interest of delving deeper and properly into subjects like history/geography, and extending himself as far as he wants to go, even if that means a ridiculously long essay, is also keeping DS really well engaged in school (so far!)

ravenAK · 23/02/2014 20:36

I'd expect to take a term over a book, tbh, to study it in depth (I'm a secondary English teacher).

Mixed ability teaching in year 7 is always going to involve some compromises. I'd be asking the teacher for an extension reading list (what are they reading atm?).

The work is likely to be quite a bit more challenging once he's set in year 8.

we have the same problem: year 7 are streamed based on KS2 results, which is a woefully inaccurate way of doing it, but necessitated by timetabling restrictions.

Once they get into year 8 we set, rather than stream, based on a more accurate idea of their abilities.

dalziel1 · 23/02/2014 20:36

lljkk - you may be right that we've chosen badly. But if we have, then he shouldn't be in a comprehensive school because this is one of the best.

Unhappy is too strong a word, even for the English lessons. He's just feeling frustrated and bored (and, unfortunately, he's begun to look around the class to see who it is that needs to have things explained so slowly and repeated so often).

OP posts:
dalziel1 · 23/02/2014 20:32

maths is one of the two subjects for which they do have a top set, so DS's experience is a lot better than some of the other subjects.

I can only go on what DS is telling me. He's not a show-off and he doesn't lie (much) but I have nothing to check what he says against, apart from the odd marked test paper.

DS says he understands everything in maths and he can do it. He doesn't feel like he is coasting and he's not bored, but he also feels that it could be more challenging (and he says that like it would be a good thing!).
Typically he gets in the high 90s for the maths tests. I think 91% was the lowest he got but I am not really sure where he was dropping the marks on that one as usually its higher.

OP posts:
lljkk · 23/02/2014 20:27

Maybe the school is a bad fit & you need to look elsewhere if your DS really is that unhappy.

DD spends entirety of some classes drawing funny faces on her finger tips.
(Why doesn't this bother me...?) because she's not bothered. She's still high achieving. She loves school. She even loves the dossy boring bits. Maybe she even loves them best.

She shares the funny finger faces with her friends later. So it's not really wasted time.

lottysmum · 23/02/2014 20:16

I would have thought that they could have stretched your son in Maths ...I know my daughter's Maths teacher (yr7 too) seems to be very good at this ....the able children do allot of work out of the GCSE books when they have finished whatever they are covering...I know quite a few of the children in her class are extremely bright and achieving level 7A and above already and the teacher;s attitude in that they will do Yr 9 work and tests now...

I did get the impression like someone else has already stated that some children have the grasp and answers to questions but dont document there findings to the level that is required so whilst it is boring its something that they need to do... My daughter is extremely good at ICT but she's been told that she now needs to concentrate on more detail and not to rush ...

dalziel1 · 23/02/2014 20:08

When he first complained about the speed, I did buy him the book and he read it at home. If I said that the teacher said there would be two books in the first term but it took so long to work through the first one that he ran out of time to even start the second, would it sound like the class was moving at a reasonable pace with appropriate differentiation for all?

Its other stuff too... DS says they did a short test recently. The teacher described what everyone needed to do, and Ds says he got it. Then they did a sample question (which never hurts, I suppose). Then he explained it again. Then twice more. Then, finally, they did the test.

Presumably the whole class repeated explanations are for the benefit of a few children who either weren't listening or who didn't understand. But is it fair, or appropriate for everyone, every day to have to sit through the same thing again and again, even though they got it the first time around??

OP posts:
Ilovegeorgeclooney · 23/02/2014 19:29

Analysing text is really stretching, indeed just enjoying the narrative is the simplistic response. As an English teacher I would say the sign of the gifted student is an enthusiasm for such analysis. Most able pupils have read the complete text at home within a week of starting it in class and use their knowledge of the plot to develop their responses. Why don't you get a copy of novels being studied and encourage DS to read?

noblegiraffe · 23/02/2014 16:35

Three hours of homework per night in Y7 would be ridiculous, kids would be burned out before GCSE. My school recommends that each piece takes a maximum of half an hour with a maximum of three pieces in an evening, so way less than that and we get fab results.

The point of English is to analyse the book, not finish it as quickly as possible so he needs to change his mindset there.

With maths, it can be hard to give extension work that is genuinely challenging to able students that doesn't require extra teaching. He needs to look at the nrich website for problem solving. But do check his normal work, it is quite common for very bright students to skimp on things and just write an answer instead of a fully worked solution. If this is the case he needs to get into better habits.

dalziel1 · 23/02/2014 16:16

I don't know if the homework stories are true, but so many mothers have said to me things about how much homework there is, how it takes hours every day etc etc. I never know how to reply since DS is in the same class as their children.

I asked DS how come he has so little and he says the other children are probably just pretending to have lots of work but really they are playing on their phones, laptops etc!

Who knows... maybe he is right!

OP posts:
Lottiedoubtie · 23/02/2014 15:06

Stopping to analyse is a feature of English all the way up to degree level though, as such he is going to have to get used to that style.

If the actual analysis isn't challenging him, then he needs to approach the teacher about what else he could be investigating.

In a mixed ability 30 in a class year 7 set, he is unlikely to get the kind of stretching he needs or you would want for him in the lesson. I think though that that is one of the compromises of universal state education... Encouraging reading and writing outside of school is a good thing to do.

dalziel1 · 23/02/2014 15:01

English homework this half term was to correct spellings in a pre-written passage. So fixing things like no/ know and they're/ their. He did it in under a minute but there was nothing that would challenge any one who can spell (and DS has a spelling age of 18+ according to the school's own testing).

OP posts:
dalziel1 · 23/02/2014 14:58

The school is good in that when it sets work it gives guidance like level 4 will do the work to this basic level, level 5 will be level 4 but with more depth and level 6 is these things on top. DS always goes for the top level and gets it.

I don't really buy it about not minding about being bored in the academic subjects until he is excelling in art and DT too. He's dyspraxic so he's never going to excel in those and he's just not interested either. However, he still has several hours a day feeling frustrated with the pace.

I think the only subject where the problem is severe is English. He says they read a page and just as he's getting into the story, they stop an analyse it over and over. Sometimes, they just run out of time and don't even finish the book.

OP posts:
HmmAnOxfordComma · 23/02/2014 14:00

I do think it's nearly impossible not to be challenged in English at school, and to a lesser degree, in subjects like RE and History.

The differentiation is by outcome.

Say, they are studying The Boy in The Striped Pyjamas and the teacher sets an essay on comparing the two main characters. You can respond to that at a level 3-4, or you can respond to it at a degree level of answer. Same with creative writing, or persuasive writing or report writing. Same with a history or RE essay. Answer them at a higher level, with evidence and reasoning.

Science can be harder to find challenging, if the teacher is pitching at a level 5 and ds has higher order skills, but I don't get it in English and the like.

CecilyP · 23/02/2014 11:28

While I don't want to comment on what your DS is or isn't doing in school, I would say that 3 hours of homework a night in Y7 would be very unusual to the point of downright unlikely - from any school. If your friend's DCs are doing that, either the work set is way too hard or the teachers have unrealistic expectations of what can be done in the time allocated.