Please or to access all these features

Secondary education

Connect with other parents whose children are starting secondary school on this forum.

Entering DC for 11+ at fancy private schools which you can't afford.

52 replies

WetGrass · 19/09/2013 14:44

My argument 'pro' would be that it is good experience to compete against other bright kids - and potentially it could be a Plan B if the state schools' 11+ was a washout and we won the lottery; and she got a scholarship; and we didn't worry about her brother being envious . From DDs point of view - it would also dilute the anticipation of the single 11+ exam which decides the state schools. For private schools - she'd be well placed to go for music/sport/art scholarships - which again seems a more fun Y6 than being all about SATS and NVR.

On the 'contra' - I would guess they would find you out at interview if you weren't totally into it? Dd might fall in love with a place where she won't go...? Exam over-load? Inferiority cOmplex? We'll sign her up regardless and finish our days in the poor-house?

OP posts:
QueenOfToast · 19/09/2013 15:01

TBH, I can't see any reason why you would want your DD to sit exams for schools that you are very unlikely to send her to:-

  1. It costs £££ to even take the exam for these schools with registration fees varying from £25 to £150.
  1. You need to prepare differently for independent school exams than you do for most 11+ exams. At indy you do papers in verbal reasoning, non-verbal reasoning, maths, english (comprehension and creative writing). Also (in this area) the 11+ exams are September of Year 6 and the indy exams aren't until January of Year 6 so it's a different schedule of work/preparation.
  1. Scholarships are usually only worth 5% to 10% of the fees (and sometimes are 'just for the prestige' and have no financial award attached at all).
  1. She will be competing against people who really want places at these schools so if she is not motivated or properly prepared, her chances of success will be reduced.

On the other side:-
There are loads of bursaries available at independent schools so maybe it is a more affordable option than you think (but you need to do your research).

Good luck.

Ladymuck · 19/09/2013 14:57

Main downside round here would be that the state school exams are months before the private school exams.

The tests themselves can be very different, as are the numbers sitting, so I'm not entirely sure that the process works as a genuine mock. State schools often have multiple choice (cheaper and faster to mark), whereas private schools want to see how you write and how you think (so marks for showing working in maths etc).

I also wonder how you would incentivise someone to sit exams for a school that they wouldn't go to? Not a problem if they're not doing any extra work.

So much depends on the area and the schools. We live near superselectives which are very tough to get into, and whilst the independent schools are selective, they are relatively much easier to get into.

Swipe left for the next trending thread