Please or to access all these features

Secondary education

Connect with other parents whose children are starting secondary school on this forum.

Daughter not allowed to do separate Science GCSEs

31 replies

MissionImpossible3 · 28/08/2013 08:06

Dd is about to start year 11 at her private school. She took GCSEs in each Science subject this summer which she understood to be to decide on foundation or higher tier for next year. She obtained a B overall, was 1 point off an A in Chemistry and 5 points of an A in Biology. Physics is her worst subject and she obtained a C. Her Science teacher told her that this result meant she had to take combined Science. She is really upset, especially as we have always been told she can achieve in Science an d admits to not having tried very hard, as she didn't realise how important it was!!! Have emailed the school, but they are standing by their decision. Unfortunately, the teacher who felt she could do well, has left. This is my first post on here, but needed some advice on what to do next. Am a single mother with no family to discuss this with and some friends are anti private school so are a little unsupportive!
Thank you and sorry this is long

OP posts:
LIZS · 28/08/2013 09:52

Yes it will be Double not Triple , so still all 3 subjects. ds is doing Double , probably there is an element of the Science teachers wanting record best grades but also because he isn't going to purse Science A levels so doesn't need the additional pressure and can focus on the coursework so far. I'm confused though , either she has taken GCSEs and got those grades or she hasn't, she wouldn't take them again surely.

Moominmammacat · 28/08/2013 09:42

It really doesn't matter. Of my very anti-science sons, one DS did triple and got BBB, another did double and got AB with a lot less trouble. Unless she's super-top-flight scientist, double is OK for most things. I was distraught when DS2 was "put down" to double science but five years down the road, it doesn't matter one jot.

meditrina · 28/08/2013 09:01

What is the school's normal grade requirement for progressing to single sciences?

As she "admits to not trying very hard", then I think you might find an uphill battle to persuade the school.

Unfortunately, your DD is learning the hard way round that there comes a stage when achievement, not just one teacher's view of your potential, is what will matter.

You need to be prepared to support you DD should the school not drop its normal requirements for her (and it is likely they won't - requiring a certain grade and sticking to it are absolutely normal for both state and private sectors). What is it she wants to do after A levels? What is best of the choices remaining to her?

And, of course, supportive messages about self-worth in general and what she can learn from this. If you are lucky, you and she will find the motivating angles from this, and that could make a huge difference to whether she learns to apply herself consistently.

tiredaftertwo · 28/08/2013 08:50

But it won't be separate science and combined science will it? Surely double or triple - so one-third chem, biol, physics whichever option?

I'd go with the school on this unless you really feel she is very good at science and definitely wants to do science A levels. The school may feel two high grades are better than three mediocre ones, and they may well be right. The main thing is that she realises that these exams are all important and works hard this year.

BoundandRebound · 28/08/2013 08:11

The school is more worried about its results than your child. She is clearly capable of passing all triple science but possibly not getting straight As. I would speak to them again but bear in mind that their say is final

lymeregis · 28/08/2013 08:09

Stick to your guns. Meet the head - consider changing schools. Good luck.

Swipe left for the next trending thread