Please or to access all these features

Secondary education

Connect with other parents whose children are starting secondary school on this forum.

Moving from state to private in year 8

32 replies

isteaready · 06/11/2012 18:50

I will try and keep this post short although the story goes back a long way. DD3 is in year 8. DD1 and DD2 both went to a brilliant grammar and are now both at good Unis. DD3 didnt get into the grammar and has been at the local average comp (results 52% A-C at GCSE)the last year and a bit.

We have accepted this although we have some issues with the children's behaviour and are not overly happy with some of the teaching, our DD seems to be coasting, hasn't made much progress and often dosen't have homework or it isn't marked. The school is huge, 300 per year group and covers a wide catchment, it's lost out recently to a more popular comp a mile away that has better results but is impossible to get into unless you live on it's doorstep, we went on the waiting list but didn't climb higher than 59.

Fast forward to 3 weeks ago. Lovely Mother in Law others to pay for DD3 to go to private school!!! We have a lovely girls school a short bus ride away that would suit our DD down to the ground and offer her amazing opportunities. They have a vacancy in year 8 and would like DD3 to sit some entrance exams and have an interview.

We now have to decide whether to put our daughter through this process knowing she a) may not get through the exams (she didn't pass the 11 plus) and hence not get offered the place and b) have to explain why we want her to move schools when she might have to stay at her current school anyway. She does have some nice friends and is happy at her school but we don't feel she is currently having the same opportunities and standard of education as her sisters.

We need to decide within the next few days. Just realised the post is huge, sorry, please be kind, it's my first one.

OP posts:
Buckeyee · 06/11/2012 20:16

Don't even look back.

eatyourveg · 06/11/2012 20:08

Is your MIL's offer solely for one particular school? I'd look around to see what your options are, there maybe a school where the entrance exam is one which your dd has a realistic chance of passing. It need not be an all or nothing. You could just tell her honestly that granny has offered to fund a private school and we are going to look at a few different schools and see which one you think you will be happiest at.

joanbyers · 06/11/2012 20:07

Do you know, diabolo, if the schools getting only 2-3% A*s just haven't got many able kids, or are there any statistical anomalies re IGCSE or whatever?

Some of the scores seem painfully low, even compared to schools that have a reputation for SEN.

diabolo · 06/11/2012 19:50

How good is the private school?

Have a look on this website and see - if it is in the top 150 or so, the the entrance exams are likely to be challenging, but perhaps not impossible. Lower than about 150 and they will be looking for decent intellect, but have a more all round approach.

www.telegraph.co.uk/education/leaguetables/9551003/GCSE-results-2012-Independent-school-results-table.htm

joanbyers · 06/11/2012 19:35

Which school is it? Lots of private schools are less selective than the grammar might have been. Howe far was she from passing the 11+?

Umeboshi · 06/11/2012 19:33

Welcome, isteaready!

Why not ask the school about the difficulty of the exams? Don't be shy about asking them all the questions you have. As far as I know, independent schools tend to set fewer exams for pupils coming from state schools - they do realise she won't have been prepared by a prep school and should make allowance for that.

As for the move, I can only share my experience. Our DS moved from a comp much like your daughter's at the end of Year 8 to an private school where I'm happy to say he is thriving. The contrast in terms of teaching, pastoral care and school ethos is just breathtaking.

Obviously every school is individual, so it's up to you and your daughter to listen to your intuition here. Some good advice is to observe the children at the school - their behaviour, how they interact with the adults in the school and with each other.

Why not ask the school if you could get in touch with some of their current parents?

Swipe left for the next trending thread