Please or to access all these features

Secondary education

Connect with other parents whose children are starting secondary school on this forum.

A question for Toby Young and Thomas Packer at the West London Free School

58 replies

livinginchiswick · 21/10/2012 15:23

Dear Mr. Young and Mr. Packer,
I understand you don't set for Maths till Year 8 and for English till Year 9. I have a child who will be sitting Level 6 Maths and English in Year 6. He has been set by his primary school for three years and is used to work at a certain level. If he goes to your school he will be in the same class with some children who may be finishing Year 6 with level 4. My question is: how will the teacher manage to run a class like that? What topics will be covered? Will my child be revising level 5 for a whole year Hmm or will the level 4 child be pushed two levels ahead Hmm ?

I am confused. Your vision is a successful academic school for all. Then why have you decided not to follow the sample of other academic successful London comprehensives such as Graveney, Fortismere, Holland Park...? They all sit the children in different bands in most or all subjects from day 1. This way, they can all get the help they need and progress at the speed they need. A proven and tested formula.

Do you band the children in any way? And if not, why not? Would really appreciate an answer before I fill the CAF. I really like the school but this concerns me and many parents I have talked to. Thank you.

OP posts:
pointyfangs · 21/10/2012 18:45

And has anyone seen the puff piece the DM has written about TY's free school? Honestly, it is nauseating - about the only thing they didn't do was gush about how wonderful TY was in bed... Not linking to it, too disgusted.

Having said that, DD1 got L6 in Yr6 last year - she was in a maths top set, but the range of ability spanned 4C to 6C. Her maths teacher handled it, so clearly it is possible for some very able teachers.

Her secondary does not set for maths until Yr8 but classes are broadly grouped by ability in core subjects, and the spread is narrower now, but still wide enough.

HanSolo · 21/10/2012 16:29

Couldn't you just email him? Hmm
I'm sick of that oxygen thief getting thread-time on here Angry

titchy · 21/10/2012 16:08

Plenty do though - last year ds' year 6 teacher had one child who got l3, 12 who got l4, 12 at l5 and half a dozen l6!!! (Maths btw, but English similar)

kylesmybaby · 21/10/2012 16:02

same at chiswick school in literacy. i cannot understand it for a second.

livinginchiswick · 21/10/2012 15:50

Thanks Titchy but they have two sets at his primary, they do not have children working 2 levels apart in the same class.

OP posts:
titchy · 21/10/2012 15:46

Presumably they will argue that your child's current teacher has been able to successfully differentiate, as demonstrated by the fact that your child is aiming for level 6, whilst others will be aiming for level 4, and so WLFS teachers can also differentiate.

I do agree setting is better though Grin

livinginchiswick · 21/10/2012 15:40

Well, it's not a selective school. Places are allocated by distance/lottery plus 10% musical aptitude....

OP posts:
seeker · 21/10/2012 15:29

Will they let anyone who hasn't got a level 5 in?

Swipe left for the next trending thread