Please or to access all these features

Secondary education

Connect with other parents whose children are starting secondary school on this forum.

Angry with DS for quitting 6thForm but want to be supportive .

36 replies

gingeroots · 15/04/2011 12:10

Can anyone advise me here - I'm terribly upset ,disappointed ,fearful for DS future ,but feel I need to get past all this and be more positive .
DS in 3rd year of sixth form .
Last year he panicked/couldn't cope and school came up with plan for him to take one A level last summer ( plus some resits ) and then carry on and do 2 more this year .
He didn't exactly pull it out of the bag with the one A level and got a D in Biology .Resits were up by 2 grades.
This year he's been studying for Physics ,Bio and Chemistry .
He started well ,commendations from school ,but got bad unit results and mocks after Christmas .
School says massive improvement in understanding ,good in class - but it's not translating into exam grades .
Pep talk from head of science to the few who aren't doing well ," disastrous grades ,work every minute etc,etc . " .
Cue collapse of DS .
With his AS grades and one A level he has sufficient points for his insurance choice ,and they've agreed he can switch to make them a firm .
DS cannot be persuaded that it's worth taking A2 modules in summer or that even one more A level at a low grade is better than dropping out now .
He cries ,says he can't take being " the bottom rung " all the time .

( DS reports conversations with subject teachers in agreement with his choice " no point having a nervous breakdown taking the A2's if you're going to end up at insurance choice anyway " )

I suppose my stumbling block is his lack of effort . I've always felt he could try harder. For me anxiety spurs me on to work harder ,with him difficulty and failure make him give up .
How can I help him change that response ?
How can I hide my frustration and frankly anger with him and get behind his plan B ?
And we won't even get started on what a failure I feel ...

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AtYourCrucifix · 17/04/2011 11:56

that was me. my mother was utterly gutted. i was the one out of 4 of us who didn't do A levels or go to universiy. I just hated it, mostly because i didn't know what i wanted to do. so I worked a bit, did a bit of voluntary work, worked a bit more, had a year off then went back and did a BTEC diploma over 2 years, then worked some more.

since then I've gone back and done 2 degrees and have a career i really want to do. i've done so much better that i would have had i gone down the conventional A levels and university at 18 route., because i wanted to do it.

SimplySparkling · 17/04/2011 11:50

gingeroots Have you taken a look at agricultural colleges?

www.harper-adams.ac.uk/

rac.ac.uk/

www.aber.ac.uk/en/ibers/

I did a National Diploma in Agriculture. I left school after GCSEs and spent a year getting practical experience before going to college. Those that had achieved certain grades at A level did a Higher National Diploma. Both were 3 year sandwich courses at the time. I don't know how it works now. Hth.

gingeroots · 17/04/2011 11:02

snorbs - thanks for positive story .
senua - I've spoken to both the course tutor and the person who deals with HE ( the college does FE as well as HE ) and they assure me it's ok .
His firm have contacted UCAS and the Foundation Degree college have told me that they will also contact UCAS .
UCAS are not yet showing the change so I guess DS will need to chase .

OP posts:
Snorbs · 17/04/2011 10:33

I dropped out of sixth form. I wasn't doing brilliantly and the regimentation and pointless rules of school were bugging the hell out of me - a course I really wanted to do was stopped half-way through, I had to spend endless hours in school even if I didn't have lessons etc etc etc.

I then spent a few months working for a local shop then got on a YTS (if you remember them) course that turned out to be a part-time college course in IT with a qualification at the end, split with working in the IT department of a large corporate.

It worked out very, very well for me. I revelled in the greater freedom and responsibility of college compared to school. Once the course was finished, the company I was placed with offered me a full-time job and that then evolved into a very good career in IT.

In hindsight, dropping out of sixth form was a big risk and it must've worried my mother immensely. But it forced me to stand on my own two feet and find something that worked for me.

senua · 17/04/2011 10:28

I've just realised. He has the offer for a place this Sep/Oct to do a degree at £3,000pa. And we are suggesting that he has a gap year and does his degree in the future at £9000pa ... Shock
Perhaps he should just go for it.Sad

Are you absolutely sure about the offer? People are tripping over themselves trying to get in under the old fee structure. I'm sure that the CI doesn't need to do anyone any favours this year and make soft offers.

At least if you make them CF you can get on with sorting out accomodation.

gingeroots · 17/04/2011 10:19

Kez - well he knows what units are to be studied ,and he was interviewed for the course ,which is a 2 year course btw.
I'm pretty sure you keep the higher results Smile .
Glad things worked out for you !

OP posts:
Kez100 · 17/04/2011 10:14

Does he know much about the course he is going to be doing ( you say you don't, but does he?) Setting up for three years study on a
Course you don't know much about is worrying and he should look into it in more detail.

That is what happened with me and my BTEC - I did it because I didn't want to do A levels and it seemed to play to my strenghs. It was a complete success but I see many people drop out first year, so it doesn't work for all. Best for him to spend time investigating if it right for him.

It seems a pity he won't just face the next month or two and 'do his best' -'if you get worse results do you lose the original higher ones?

gingeroots · 17/04/2011 09:33

Thank you everyone - mmmm a gap year . Would need to be organised , Africa sounds a little out of our range .

He does have an offer ( based on the A level and AS grades he already has ) of a place on a Foundation Degree in Animal Management and I'm hoping that this might be the right level and mix of practical work for him .
But I don't really know and it feels a bit of a shot in the dark somehow - guess that's true of all HE courses !
Thanks vj for link and tip about careers service .

As for the school ,I don't know what to think .
Part of me feels let down - before he started sixth form I spoke to school about careers advice ( "oh they're not very good " ) and emailed connexions with no response .I asked school at that juncture whether they felt DS might cope better with B tech at college but they felt A level were the way to go .
To me DS needs encouragement and support to finish his A levels ( surely giving up is not a good life lesson to learn ) and he was set to struggle on .I feel an illjudged pep/motivational talk has pushed him over the edge .
But ....maybe they think he's had enough time and if he's still not achieving that he needs out .
Maybe they think low grades are bad for school .... I don't know .
I think the damage is done ,DS is not going back now and I'm not sure I have any confidence in the schools "help " .
Don't feel they've been much help during last few years .
( School made an Academy a 3 years ago and think sixth form has suffered due to everything being thrown at GCSE years. The subject teachers seem exhausted and the school now has a layer of new young staff in a plethora of senior positions who seem to know less than the more established staff that now report to them . Won't drone on with examples here .)
But maybe I'm looking for excuses ,maybe DS just not putting sufficient work in to cope with these hard science subjects .

OP posts:
vj32 · 16/04/2011 19:44

It sounds like he needs careers advice.
He won't be able to get an apprenticeship for just a few months and they are very very rare in animal care anyway. It would take minimum of a year to get a qualification equivalent to GCSEs - level 2. There seem to be currently 13 vacancies across the whole country.
www.apprenticeships.org.uk/Types-of-Apprenticeships/Agriculture-Horticulture-and-Animal-Care/Animal-Care.aspx
(Follow link on the right to take you to vacancies.)
It is possible but getting an apprenticeship is really hard work and can take a long time. Pay is low, below normal min wage.

If he wants to do the foundation year it sounds like voluntary work is a good idea, the local careers service might be able to tell you which local places are happy to take on young people for work experience. Plus it might be helpful for DS to talk to another adult to take some pressure off you. There should be a careers adviser attached to his school. If not try here:
www2.cxdirect.com/home.htm
I find it wierd the school haven't offered him any support about what to do next.

eatyourveg · 16/04/2011 08:25

I think the boy needs a break. 3 years in the 6th form and still struggling shouts - this is not for me.

Look into gap year placements maybe in Africa on a reservation or similar

When he comes back he will have a better idea of what direction he wants to head in. He will be that much older and more mature and if he is going to go back into studying I think a vocational course such as animal management might be more suitable, ideally somewhere that runs courses which are split between college and a work placement.

senua · 16/04/2011 07:54

I'm going to be harsh here.Blush
If he can't take the pressure at A Level and would rather give up then I don't think that a degree is such a bright idea. Is he going to take on thousands of pounds of tuition fee and accommodation debt, only to give up again in the first few months?
I think leaving the degree for a few years until he has matured a bit might be the way forward.

Kez100 · 15/04/2011 21:09

Ginger roots, I think you did the right thing . Under pressure people don't see or think clearly and giving up (or not) is best done after thought and due consideration and not when burdened and in tears.

gingeroots · 15/04/2011 19:59

Positiveattitude - thanks for the link .

OP posts:
gingeroots · 15/04/2011 19:51

I know what you're saying albania .
It was such a shock and so sudden - went into school in the morning as normal and came back that afternoon having decided that he couldn't make himself carry on and that it wasn't worth it .
He was upset and assuming he could drop out and be ok with the insurance choice , and my initial focus was on trying to get confirmation that the offer would still stand.
When things calmed down I talked to him about not giving up completely - wanted him to give it more considered thought ,especially in view of school not offering to talk it through with him and/or me .
I'm really sad ,and it just doesn't feel right to me to give up when the exams are only weeks away .
I'm not trying to force him ,but was looking for support for myself here really .

OP posts:
albania · 15/04/2011 18:40

He doesn't want to do his A2s, why are you still trying to persuade him?
Baffled, really. He's clearly unhappy, has cried about this, and you're still trying to get him to do this.
I think you need to back off and let him make his own choices.

PositiveAttitude · 15/04/2011 18:33

www.est.uk.com/ - for more information on apprenticeships if that helps.

PositiveAttitude · 15/04/2011 18:31

Its hard Ginger, I know. DD1 struggled through one year of 6th form, never really settling and hating it, then decided to move to a college instead, where she gave up after the first term. I was so worried about her future, but she did an apprenticeship, (rubbish money but she enjoyed the work), has now got a "proper" job, and is doing an accountancy course aswell. It was just not right for her a few years ago, but now she is loving the learning and doing really well.

Have you looked into any apprenticeships? These are hands on and he might enjoy doing one for a year. They do childcare ones, not sure about animal care though, but worth a look.

Dont worry, he will come out fine. Not all young people are the same and need the same route to get to their career choice.

gingeroots · 15/04/2011 18:02

oblomov - have you details of online careers guidance you mentioned ?

OP posts:
gingeroots · 15/04/2011 18:01

Thank you everyone .
I've not been able to persuade him to go back and concentrate on even one A2 .Sad
He's kind of isolated , only has a couple of friends and they are younger than him and at college ,so lacks any peer pressure to go back IYSWIM.
I'd like the school to talk with him ,but it's really only his subject teachers who know him and they've not suggested anything which makes me think they feel it's the right decision to go .
I've just looked on his school website - they have 13 people in a pastoral team ,plus 4 " pastoral support managers " ,plus a post 16 leader ,plus a head of house ,plus his form tutor .
I've never met or spoken to any of them - it's a new set up since school became an Academy a couple of years ago and they don't attend the yearly parents evening - and none of them have contacted us ,so it doesn't feel like they'd be much help .

Think will have to keep him busy - voluntary work ( unsuccesful at Battersea Dogs Home ,but trying a City Farm and a couple of Animal Rescue centres ) ,swimming ,learning to drive .
Try and make this period positive ...

OP posts:
SkinittingFluffyBunnyBonnets · 15/04/2011 16:33

I second the Btech idea....it would be fresh start.

Oblomov · 15/04/2011 16:32

Most of dh's old schoolfriends are brick'ies and tilers. Most of them are millionaires. One of them owns 12 houses. And has no mortgage. Exams results are not the only think in life. But it does sure HELP, if you have some sort of idea. And well paid, jobs, choices, is ONE of the very key issues.

Oblomov · 15/04/2011 16:29

We all feel your pain. Part of me would probably want to strangle him, and tell him to grow up, but I fear that would not be helpful.
Along with not being very mature, he also sounds a bit 'lost'.
I mean its all very well if you realise you want to be an ... architect at age 13, but if like me you didn't have a clue, even whilst doing a'levels, you are kind of scuppered.
Maybe one of those online career things. My friend told about 2 that were very good. Really took onboard what your personality is etc, what you want out of life. No point killing yourself to be a barrister, if what you really want is babies/travel/easy ride of life.
Xenia would say you do need to think about the money, where this is going to take you in life. I agree. Teenagers career advice today seems even more abysmal than mine was !

FrumpyintheFrost · 15/04/2011 15:57

I really feel for you, but with the exams only a few weeks away now, would your DS consider taking just 1 A2 in the subject he enjoys most (poss Biology from your post)?

I would echo belle and ask if he (or even better both of you) can see the head of pastoral care to talk through his options. It would be such a shame to stop now after 3 years hard work. Sad

peteneras · 15/04/2011 13:10

It is clear he's going through a difficult stage of his life. Some people are just not cut out for academic studies; I hasten to add this does not imply they are thick or dim. I have a few friends like this and they became millionaires before the age of 30! On the contrary, sometimes these individuals have a clear insight in what they want to do in life and make a great success of it and that A-Levels and universities are not the only path to get there. For example, I've read and just confirmed again by the man himself recently in a Piers Morgan interview that Lord Andrew Lloyd-Webber spent a very brief period at Oxford and very quickly decided Oxford wasn't for him and wouldn't help him in what he actually wanted to do. His track record today speaks for itself.

Does your DS know what he wants to do? It seems to me he had opted for some very hard academic science subjects and the fact is that if he's struggling at AS and A2 levels now, pursuing the same subjects at university would be nothing short of 3 or 4 years of hell at university. A break from academia e.g. a gap year (extended foreign holiday/work experience) may help matters immensely. But both of you need to be open and discuss the issue(s) with a cool head. Good luck!

Kez100 · 15/04/2011 13:04

Like Vivalabeaver, I also didn't do A levels but BTEC in Business and Finance. Hard work but in a very different and more vocational way. I never wanted to go to University, so I then got a job and trained to a chartered accountant whilst working. It was very low paid but, hey, who cares...they gave me experience and paid for my professional courses and exams. Now I have my own practice. Through work, I see all manner of personalities many of whom never had an academic bent but they are very successful all the same.

Animal studies does sound a great course for his strengths.