Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

Politics

Ukip in crisis: Nigel Farage could resign again

82 replies

claig · 14/05/2015 14:05

Oh my God, what are they doing to the people's party?

They've done us up like a kipper for the second time in less than a week.
There's 4 million votes on the line and they are playing us like a fiddle, having a right laugh.

www.telegraph.co.uk/news/politics/ukip/11605216/Ukip-in-crisis-live.html

OP posts:
claig · 14/05/2015 23:45

Another stellar performance by Monsieur Fromage.
The more he appears on TV, the more votes the Establishment loses.

OP posts:
Isitmebut · 14/05/2015 23:13

"Expect these figures to be cited by those who argue that the former Tory MP has cynically jumped ship in order to avoid defeat next year."

That and the FACT THAT TO-DATE, unless UKIP turns to 'the dark side' a sitting Conservative MP, they wouldn't have ever had a Westminster MP representative.

Trust in a home grown U-kipper must be an issue and in thin margins the difference between coming first or second.

I listened to Carswell on a political programme over the weekend, and although I understand that his local approval rating is based on his work for his constituency - when talking about big picture politics he does not talk to the electorate like Farage, he gives them 'a brain fuck' and they come away thinking whaaaaat?

P.S. Farage has just been given a hard time on Question Time, and although he explained why he didn't end up resigning quite well (IMO), not ONE person clapped, which seemed to surprise him

claig · 14/05/2015 20:57

"Clacton was previously estimated by Revolt on the Right authors Matthew Goodwin and Robert Ford to be the most Ukip-friendly seat in the country (economically deprived, elderly, white, anti-immigrant) and tonight's poll vindicates that judgement. While Carswell's strong personal following has helped, 57 per cent of Ukip supporters say they are voting that way because they "like Ukip", compared to 34 per cent who say they "like Carswell" and 9 per cent who say they are casting a protest vote. Expect these figures to be cited by those who argue that the former Tory MP has cynically jumped ship in order to avoid defeat next year. Immigration is by far the main concern for Ukip voters (57 per cent), followed by the EU (13 per cent) and the cost of living (6 per cent)."

www.newstatesman.com/politics/2014/08/ukip-44-points-ahead-tories-clacton-election-poll

OP posts:
claig · 14/05/2015 20:38

Carswell has ruled himself out as a possible leader for UKIP as far as I know and i think that is a good thing because Carswell couldn't inspire or get enough ordinary people to vote for him. His ideas are too highbrow and he doesn't share the instincts of the people who vote UKIP.

Farage, on the other hand, is exceptional and that is why he has been able to transform UKIP from a fringe party to Britain's 3rd largest party. If the Establishment don't succeed in finishing UKIP and if Farage is still in charge in 2020 then UKIP will be a huge threat to Labour and possibly the Conservatives too if they mess up during their 5 years.

OP posts:
claig · 14/05/2015 20:32

'The Conservatives will not get any short money - it's only for opposition parties. '

Thanks, I didn't know that. Are the Greens taking their short money?

'Since it relates to supporting parliamentary activities, it wouldn't be appropriate for e.g. UKIP to use it for other purposes.'

Is it against the rules to employ 15 staff to do research etc?

'I'm amazed you didn't know who your MP was, when you seem very interested in politics.'

I like politics but I don't particularly care about the individuals. I vote for policies and parties. I didn't know who my UKIP candidate was or who my Tory MP was until a poster said that her UKIP candidate was an Elvis impersonator. I googled it and found that he was my candidate too and that was when I discovered who my Tory MP was, whom I had never heard of in all these years. I don't vote for them because they are good people, I vote for parties.

'Have you become politically engaged after reading that UKIP book?'

I haven't read the book. I don't get enough time to read whole books. I just flip through the net when I get time. I have liked politics since Thatcher was in power.

'What are the chances of the authors predicting UKIP success in Clacton and the existing Clacton MP defecting to UKIP?'

I read somewhere that they gave a seminar in Parliament and Carswell was there and heard them say that his seat was the most UKIP friendly. However, I think Carswell does have principles and believes in them, so it made sense for him to follow his beliefs and to defect at that time. But I don't think Carswell will do too well in UKIP because it strikes me that he does not share enough of the same instincts as most of the people who vote UKIP. But time will tell.

OP posts:
fascicle · 14/05/2015 20:15

...not to take short money which will help the party when the Conservatives and Labour will get their money.

The Conservatives will not get any short money - it's only for opposition parties. Since it relates to supporting parliamentary activities, it wouldn't be appropriate for e.g. UKIP to use it for other purposes.

I'm amazed you didn't know who your MP was, when you seem very interested in politics. Have you become politically engaged after reading that UKIP book? What are the chances of the authors predicting UKIP success in Clacton and the existing Clacton MP defecting to UKIP?

claig · 14/05/2015 19:51

I know he won for the Tories, but in general Essex is Tory.

The authors of 'Revolt on the Right' predicted that Clacton was the most UKIP friendly seat in the country and that was before Carswell defected. I think Carswell and the Tories would have lost the seat. I personally don't believe that the majority of voters vote for an MP, but for a party. I didn't even know who my MP was until last week and I think there are lots of voters like me who don't pay attention to individuals but to parties instead.

'I'm sure 'ordinary people' would approve of his refusal to waste public funds unnecessarily. It would be somewhat 'metropolitan elite' to grab it all.'

I don't and I am sure many UKIP voters don't because our party will not receive that money while Establishment parties will receive the short money which will help them defeat us. We are 4 million voters and the Conservatives and Labour are about 11 million each. I think it is arrogant of idealistic head in the clouds Carswell to decide not to take short money which will help the party when the Conservatives and Labour will get their money.

“No one is bigger than the party..."

When it comes to UKIP, that's not really true, is it?

True, because without Farage there is no party because Farage alone appeals to millions of voters and by 2020 it will be millions more than now. Banks and Desmond understand that and Wheeler (who said he would rejoin the Tories if Boris was leader) doesn't seem to understand that.

OP posts:
fascicle · 14/05/2015 19:36

claig
he doesn't have the personality to appeal to large numbers of ordinary people.

So you're unaware of his election track record, then?

But they prefer UKIP to the Conservatives in general because UKIP s more for ordinary people.

On what basis can you exclude the successful candidate from the successful result? Especially given Carswell's record in that constituency.

Re: Carswell's rejection of the full 'short money' allowance - I'm sure 'ordinary people' would approve of his refusal to waste public funds unnecessarily. It would be somewhat 'metropolitan elite' to grab it all.

Banks said. “No one is bigger than the party..."

When it comes to UKIP, that's not really true, is it?

claig · 14/05/2015 19:07

Richard Desmond says he supports Farage 101%. Fantastic, he has given £1 million to UKIP.

OP posts:
claig · 14/05/2015 19:03

'But why should he throw himself on the mercy of what will almost certainly be a hand picked anti UKIP audience'

They are always like that and will always be like that because the Establishment has to try and stop UKIP. UKIP will never get an easy time of it and the media would walk all over Carswell, Suzanne Evans or O'Flynn. Only Farage, Diane James and Paul Nuttall have the courage to face them down.

'I think he should not have withdrew his resignation but took the summer to think about it and come back for re-election. Don't know who advised him otherwise.'

I think the serious millionaires who have backed UKIP want no one but Farage. They have put millions into UKIP and they don't want to see their money go down the drain e.g Arron Banks.

OP posts:
Viviennemary · 14/05/2015 18:58

But why should he throw himself on the mercy of what will almost certainly be a hand picked anti UKIP audience. Jeering at him. I agree the establishment want him out. No longer a fringe party but a party a lot of people voted for. Nearly 4 million. Personally I think he should not have withdrew his resignation but took the summer to think about it and come back for re-election. Don't know who advised him otherwise.

claig · 14/05/2015 18:49

'My bet is he'll withdraw'

I hope he turns up and comes out fighting. Without Farage, UKIP is finished.

Notice that the media have only been showing us millionaire Stuart Wheeler who wants Farage to go They haven't put millionaire Arron Banks on TV who supports Farage.

Arron Banks is very good and spot on. He is common sense, UKIP. We want people who are UKIP through and through, not politically correct ex-Tories.

"Exclusive: Ukip donor Arron Banks calls for Douglas Carswell, Suzanne Evans and Patrick O’Flynn to leave the party
...
Banks has called on Douglas Carswell, Suzanne Evans and Patrick O’Flynn, the three main figures who do not want Farage to remain as leader, to be thrown out of the party.

“Everyone who's been involved with it should go,” Banks tells the New Statesman. “It's not very edifying and I don't believe these people should have our support. There's a proper way to do things and we don't do things this way.”

Banks is particularly furious at Suzanne Evans, the author of Ukip’s manifesto who Farage had recommended to be interim leader over the summer and many had assumed would eventually succeed Farage.

“It reflects very poorly on her - this is not the way to do things. Particularly with the party membership, all of this will be frowned upon,” he said. “It's very disappointing – I think yet again maybe someone has got a little bit above themselves. It's a party isn't it and they can't just take over. No one's disputing there's probably some change needed after the election but this is not the way to do it. They should all go on holiday.”

Banks also attacked Douglas Carswell, who he described as viewing himself as “God’s appointed representative” of the campaign to leave the EU and “probably doesn't relish the idea of Nigel being there as well.

.”Carswell’s opposition to accepting the full £650,000 of Short Money that Ukip are entitled to after the general election incited fury among many in the party who believed that the party needed the money to represent the four million who voted for Ukip last week.

“He's shown his intention that he's prepared to do that type of thing and for that reason I'd rather have no MPs than one whose interests don't like with Ukip,” Banks said. “No one is bigger than the party and the kind of shenanigans that are going on don't give me any confidence.”

O’Flynn – “a jumped up little bloke who think he's going to be the next party leader” - didn’t escape Banks’ wrath either. “The thought that Patrick O'Flynn could take over from Nigel Farage is just ridiculous,” he said, likening seeing him on TV to “watching paint dry”.

“Patrick would be well-advised to sit on Nigel's knee and learn,”he continued. “When you've got a ten out of ten, someone like Patrick O'Flynn is probably a five out of ten - it shows him up.”

www.newstatesman.com/politics/2015/05/exclusive-ukip-donor-arron-banks-calls-douglas-carswell-suzanne-evans-and-patrick-o

OP posts:
TheoriginalLEM · 14/05/2015 18:46

I can;t say i feel sorry for him - my DD called him a prick. Go DD, mature!!!! Grin She lives in Thanet (poor cahhh)

Viviennemary · 14/05/2015 18:41

It's all very strange. Something's going on that's for sure. Sabotage. Not impossible. Nigel Farage is supposed to be on Question Time tonight. My bet is he'll withdraw. The knives are out for him. No question about that.

claig · 14/05/2015 18:40

I think Patrick O'Flynn is extremely arrogant to go to the press and criticise Farage like he did. I think he will lose the vote of UKIP voters over time now.

OP posts:
claig · 14/05/2015 18:38

I think Carswell's victory was much more down to the fact that he represented UKIP than being about Carswell. UKIP is about common sense and Carswell isn't. He is an idealist with his head in the clouds about edemocracy etc. and he doesn't have the personality to appeal to large numbers of ordinary people.

'How did Carswell/UKIP win the seat if Carswell's appeal is actually to the 'metropolitan elite'?'

Because the voters there are generally right of centre working class people. But they prefer UKIP to the Conservatives in general because UKIP s more for ordinary people.

OP posts:
fascicle · 14/05/2015 18:29

claig
If Carswell became an independent, I think he would lose the seat next time to UKIP. He may appeal to Martin Bell and the metropolitan elite, but I don't think he could appeal to the people of Clacton over UKIP.

So even though Carswell won the only UKIP seat, and even though he'd won the same Clacton seat in 2010 as a Tory, you think the Clacton vote was nothing to do with Carswell and everything to do with UKIP? In terms of the Clacton electorate, what does UKIP represent, that Carswell wouldn't, if he stood as an independent? How did Carswell/UKIP win the seat if Carswell's appeal is actually to the 'metropolitan elite'?

And has Norman Smith been taking lessons from John Inverdale?

claig · 14/05/2015 17:23

Today we have had this

"Moment BBC's Assistant Political Editor flounders after accidentally calling Nigel Farage a c* during live broadcast as he discusses Ukip's in-fighting

Norman Smith accidentally said there's a 'personality c*' at head of Ukip"

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3081492/Moment-BBC-s-deputy-political-editor-flounders-accidentally-calling-Nigel-Farage-c-live-broadcast-discusses-Ukip-s-fighting.html

OP posts:
claig · 14/05/2015 17:19

OK I think I have understood the game. The Establishment want Farage out and they don't want him on TV wiping the floor with Clegg, Cameron and all the rest during the run up to the EU Referendum debates. Stuart Wheeler said he thinks UKIP need someone with a softer approach.

If they get rid of Farage and put Carswelll or O'Flynn up against Clegg and Cameron, then UKIP will lose and the Establishment will win the Referendum.

It is existential, teenager advisers hope Farage will be toppled and the media are giving it full publicity to put the pressure on.

OP posts:
claig · 14/05/2015 16:31

'feck em'

Can we try and treat UKIP voters with some respect please?

OP posts:
Isitmebut · 14/05/2015 16:29

Claig .... "He said he wanted to see Tories end up as largest party in the Commons"

Would that have been before he saw a majority Labour Party had the SNP in their pocket (or the other way around) so didn't need his UKIP seats (or 'seat' as it turned out) in a deal with the devil?

Farage had several permutations/demands in the months leading up to the election, depending on which way the wind was blowing at the time.

UKIP voters were reading the runes and no doubt made their own minds up based on the two main party Labour or Conservative alternative.

Those who wanted an EU Referendum and for some reason had thought UKIP could ever deliver one, no contest.

Those who would never come back to same sex marriage, feck em

claig · 14/05/2015 16:15

"Vote Tory where we can't win, says Farage: Ukip leader calls on backers to 'use their votes as wisely as they can'

He said he wanted to see Tories end up as largest party in the Commons
Mr Farage said the ‘stakes are very high’ in HIS South Thanet constituency
PM last week urged Ukip supporters to ‘come home’ to Conservatives"

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3036241/Vote-Tory-t-win-says-Farage-Ukip-leader-calls-backers-use-votes-wisely-can.html

OP posts:
Pispcina · 14/05/2015 16:12

You're alright Lemmy, you're a bit further away than us. Just discovered we're classed as 'Thanet North' FFS, we're not even under Thanet council!

Oh the shame.

Isitmebut · 14/05/2015 16:12

Claig .... what was the ratio of Conservative votes to every one Labour vote UKIP takes - it used to be nearly 3 to 1 - so swings and roundabouts elsewhere?

What if the Lib Dems vote hadn't dropped over 20% in many seats?

What if Labour voters had come out?

If, if, if if.......

If my grandfather had boobs, he'd be my grandmother.

claig · 14/05/2015 16:07

"Labour figures have admitted they underestimated the threat from Ukip, after it emerged that Nigel Farage’s party may have deprived Labour of victory in many seats in last week’s election"

www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/labour-figures-admit-underestimating-ukip-threat-cost-them-seats-in-the-general-election-10245479.html

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread