Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

Politics

independent scotland ? who gets to keep the queen?

37 replies

droves · 06/05/2011 19:56

All this talk of Scottish independence /snp ect has got me thinking. If scotland did become inedependent who would keep the Queen /royal family ect?.

Bear in mind , King james of Scotland inherited the English throne from Queen Elizabeth he first of England, who died without producing an heir.

The monachy is therefore off Scottish line of decent and really the English Royals died off centuarys ago.

The reason they live in England is King James was raised by Elizabeth in England after his mother Mary queen of scots was beheaded.

So can Scotland really be independent from England ? I dont think so , not if both countries share a Queen/King.

To me Scotland wanting to be separate from the rest of the uk is like chucking away a very special gift.
Often in Scotland i have came across the attitude , that England doesnt have Scotlands intrest at heart , that everything is geared toward London.That somehow England owns Scotland and we must rebel.( I dont agree, fecking "braveheart" has a lot to answer for imo ).

The politics of dividing a nation are mind boggeling and i admit i dont understand what exactly that would mean , but it just seems a lot of hassle for a lot of hassle and not much else.

The old saying comes to mind , together we stand ....divided we fall.Sad.

OP posts:
meditrina · 06/05/2011 20:48

droves you said: "So can Scotland really be independent from England ? I dont think so , not if both countries share a Queen/King".

That's not quite right - HMQ is also monarch of several other independent countries: Canada, Australia, New Zealand, Jamaica, Barbados, the Bahamas, Grenada, Papua New Guinea, the Solomon Islands, Tuvalu, Saint Lucia, Saint Vincent and the Grenadines, Belize, Antigua and Barbuda, and Saint Kitts and Nevis.

So all options are open.

Fuctifano · 06/05/2011 20:32

Agree with Unfit and Molly, but please can we come to your "Ding Dong the Witch is Dead Party" when Thatcher finally croaks? I think the monarchy and an obsession with it is something that puzzles most Scots. My town received NO applications for street parties for the royal wedding. No animosity just no interest.

meditrina · 06/05/2011 20:22

HMQ "let it be known" ahead of one of the Aussie referenda, that of course she'd respect the will of the people thus expressed; so with a "yes" vote, planning the logistics of handover would begin immediately.

MollysChamber · 06/05/2011 20:21

Actually I think we could if we had a referendum and that was the way the vote went.

droves · 06/05/2011 20:18

I dont think you could just sack the Queen though ???.

Whether people want her is a different thing.

OP posts:
MollysChamber · 06/05/2011 20:10

I would tend to agree unfit.

In fact I think a promise to "get rid" may well help the independence vote.

unfitmother · 06/05/2011 20:08

Well I don't want her but I'm confident the majority of Scots don't either.

MollysChamber · 06/05/2011 20:06

I suppose it would be proposed that Scotland become a commonwealth realm.

TapselteerieO · 06/05/2011 20:03

Eh last I heard the Queen/royal family was of German descent, so if no one here wants her maybe the Germans will welcome them back - they are not Scottish, that line died out a wee while ago now.

MollysChamber · 06/05/2011 20:00

^And I agree.

nethunsreject · 06/05/2011 19:59

I'm happy to be Scottish and British. Quite happy with the way things are.

Monarchy is irrelevant! Personally I neither need nor want one, British, Scottish or otherwise.

droves · 06/05/2011 19:58

Oh and alex salmond give me the creeps. i just dont trust him.

OP posts: