Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

Extra-curricular activities

Find advice on the best extra curricular activities in secondary schools and primary schools here.

Is Brownies just a bit rubbish compared to Beavers?

32 replies

Thetreeisdownnow · 05/02/2026 20:56

My DD has been going to Brownies for a year and a half and is getting increasingly disappointed and upset at how it compares to her brothers Beavers unit.

Brownies seems to be off more than it’s on, for example it finished on the 11th of December for Christmas and isn’t on again until 19th February (we still pay full fees though).

She has never done her Brownies promise despite asking and they have never earned any badges at all.
She has never been given a badge book although this is apparently paid for as part of our fees and I asked repeatedly last year and also said I was happy to buy one but was always told that they had them and would be giving them out next week and it never happened.
Activities seem to mainly be crafts or colouring, lots of the girls don’t wear uniform and there are no trips or anything.

I’ve tried to persuade her to join Cubs instead but the Cubs unit is very boy heavy (there’s only 2 girls) and she much prefers the all girl environment of Brownies.

Ive offered to volunteer but apparently they are okay for leaders at the minute and I don’t really feel I can complain too much as it’s run by volunteers. There is another unit in a nearby town and I was wondering if it would be worth trying it or whether it’s likely to be the same again?

OP posts:
Sprogonthetyne · 05/02/2026 21:04

I think it's a that unit thing, not a brownies thing, so definitely try the other unit.

My DD is still at rainbows, but they generally do a set of 3 badges each term, and have 2-3 outings a year. No camps yet due to age, but I'm pretty sure the brownies unit hers feed into do.

KnickerlessParsons · 05/02/2026 21:03

Try another Brownie unit.
The activities at Brownies/Guides and Scout/Cubs are very much dependant on the likes and dislikes and the enthusiasm of the unit’s Leaders. You could also contact the local Guiding Commissioner to complain, or better still, do what did and volunteer to help turn a crap unit into a really good one.

marcyhermit · 05/02/2026 21:03

Beavers and Brownies both just vary depending on the leaders.

CrabbyCat · 05/02/2026 21:03

That pretty much exactly was my DD's experience with Rainbows, she stopped (as did both her friends) before she made it to Brownies. Luckily our local Beavers unit is about a third girls and she's happily followed her older brother there instead.

I'm not sure you have much to loose trying a different Brownie unit if she doesn't fancy Cubs, but isn't enjoying her current unit.

ChloeCannotCanCan · 05/02/2026 21:01

Change Brownie units - they vary massively depending on the leaders. My Brownie unit is amazing! 😂

prepareforharvest · 05/02/2026 20:58

I don’t know whether this is normal but it all sounds very disappointing. I was desperate to be a brownie as a child but that’s not what I would have imagined at all!

ThatBluntZebra · 05/02/2026 20:58

That just sounds like your Unit isn't very good