Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

Extra-curricular activities

Find advice on the best extra curricular activities in secondary schools and primary schools here.

How to respond to "hothousing" comments?

51 replies

ItsHarryTheDirtyDog · 18/09/2018 02:46

Other than smile and ignore, of course...

I am involved in setting up a fairly niche extracurricular activity - a primary-level Classics club - in a small town where education isn't particularly valued by quite a lot of the population. Coming from a background that would see this as being an obviously good thing, I have been perplexed by repeatedly being told that the club is a stupid idea and can only possibly be for parents who want to "hothouse" their poor children.

I've said in response that actually it's a lot easier for children to learn both English and foreign languages if they have a reasonable grasp of grammar and vocab roots, and that Latin is a great way to learn it, as well as being interesting in its own right. That it's far easier to learn a foreign language before age 10 than after. And that teaching kids basic skills in something that adults do isn't hothousing, it's teaching them basic skills in something that they're interested in.

None of this seems to get through, though.

I am going to be interviewed by the local paper, which is a bit of a redneck rag, and I bet this will come up.

Anyone got any suggestions as to what to say to people who seem to disapprove of extracurricular activities that actually involve any form of brain activity?

OP posts:
penisbeakers · 18/09/2018 03:19

My best friend was hothoused so i shall say this; whilst I appreciate that teaching children foreign language skills early on is beneficial, it should be done in an agreed collective environment where everyone is on board. If you want to teach your child another language early on then so be it, but like it or not, if you form a club where children are pushed into learning something before their designated time, I'm afraid it's hothousing, and it's deeply unpleasant if a child cannot perform.

I like the fact that in Europe, children are taught several different languages from the moment they walk into school, but that a properly organised educational environment. I believe we should be teaching kids languages earlier than we are, but it seems like tour approach might have gotten stuck in your town's craw a bit. Latin is extremely complicated and frankly, not really something a small child is going to need.