Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

Extra-curricular activities

Find advice on the best extra curricular activities in secondary schools and primary schools here.

what age to start piano if DC is keen?

32 replies

happilyLostCareer · 03/06/2017 04:09

I'm not yet at the stage of finding DS a teacher as he is only 7 months old, and who knows, in a few years he may well prefer lego to music (though at the moment he is very keen on music and recognizes tunes — probably much like most babies).

Anyway.

Was talking to 2 friends about music lessons. Friend 1 has 3 kids, the 6yo started recorder this year, the others are 5 and 3 and more interested but apparently too young. Friend 1 played cello to semiprofessional level before kids. She thinks go with the child, some 3 yo kids are going to be ready for lessons, some 8 yo kids might still be too young — but she also says the sooner they start, the easier it is to learn everything.

Friend 2 has 2 kids. Has never played an instrument and doesn't like classical music, but is a developmental psychologist and thinks kids should learn music from age 6, no earlier. Her 7yo DD learns flute but isn't interested -possibly because she never hears classical music. Her 4yo DD would probably have the attention span, determination and interest to be learning now, but mum says she absolutely shouldn't start until 6.

Meanwhile I grew up in a demographic where kids started piano, singing and very basic theory at 3 or 4, second & third instruments at 5 or 6. Anything later was seen as too late for anything other than just doing it for fun (nothing wrong with fun, but don't expect to catch up with your peers or be a musician).

I suspect going with the individual child is sensible, looking at attention span, perseverance, interest, dexterity etc. But is any age just really way too young?

OP posts:
Minimusiciansmama · 03/06/2017 08:09

My little one started piano and recorder at 5 and clarinet at 6. She has an amazing teacher with a real affinity for teaching a little one who worked super hard to make sure she was taking at the right pace, doing things age appropriately etc. Combined with lots of live music, workshops, ensemble fun etc, my little one is making great progress but more importantly has a real love for music.
She has friends who learnt Suzuki violin age 3-4 then friends who are starting instruments age 8.... I think it's really an "individual child" decision.

happilyLostCareer · 03/06/2017 07:24

emesis -sorry to hear it didn't work out, though good to hear your boys are able to build on early piano & take up other instruments.

I would only put lots of effort in if DS loved it. He has huge hands so will be big enough to play once he has the coordination, though of course may not have the attention span or interest for some time (or at all) after. Who knows. At the moment he is basically only interested in listening to music, dancing, bashing the piano/glockenspiel, being sung or played to, and people, so it seems like we may be getting into the territory of instruments in a few years.

OP posts:
emesis · 03/06/2017 06:02

OP I came from a family like yours. You could have been describing our community.

I wanted the same for my boys but I soon realised the cost you have to weigh up. Obviously the financial and time costs are great. Then, are you willing to have battles over practice times? Willing to do musical activities at the expense of other things like sport, art or family leisure time (you need to decide priorities).

In our family of four, we were all forced to play instruments from age 3. One became a professional musician. One still plays a bit. The other two never play. My mother questions whether she would do it again because we missed out on so much so that we could invest in music.

Both my boys learnt piano from age 5, and both didn't like it, so we let them give it up. One is now learning an orchestral instrument (started at 8.5) the other is about to start one too at 8.5.

There is the most amazingly rich payoff when music lessons work well. When they don't, it can be a huge waste of time and money. I heard on Freakonomics (amazing source I know..) that of all the childhood activities, music lessons have the least reward for investment.

LuchiMangsho · 03/06/2017 05:37

Depends on the child surely. DS pestered ms when he was 3. He was/is properly musical. Started the violin at 3.5 and 2 years later is doing v well. Practises voluntarily for 20-30 mins each day. And so after a second round of pestering we are starting a 2nd instrument this summer. We are not at all musical but hugely enjoy classical music. We go to lots of concerts and DS has been exposed to it from a young age.

BobbiPins · 03/06/2017 04:56

I know serious professional pianists, they started training at 7 y.o.

JoandMax · 03/06/2017 04:55

I think if a child really wants to learn and has the enthusiasm then they'll do well at whatever age you start them.

DH and I are not from musical families at all so never really considered it for our DC until they asked - DS1 started guitar and piano at the beginning of this year when he was 8.5yo. He is absolutely loving it! Practices without being told and is flying through the theory and practical and rapidly catching up with some of his friends who've been learning longer.

DS2 is 7yo and at the moment he doesn't want to do lessons so we'll wait until he asks to.

I'm a firm believer in that if you push them too much too soon it'll backfire so child led would be my advice

barefootinkitchen · 03/06/2017 04:36

I'm interested in hearing people's views on this as I didn't want to start daughter too early in case it puts her off.( 6 years)

Swipe left for the next trending thread