Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

Extra-curricular activities

Find advice on the best extra curricular activities in secondary schools and primary schools here.

Piano prep test - ballpark timeframe?

32 replies

kate2mum · 24/01/2012 10:42

My little dd is starting piano lessons at home, twice a week for half an hour. She is very excited and spellbound. For now. She is 4.4years. I wanted to start early as my lovely 10-year-old ds never really liked it, and then it turned out he has dyspraxia, which probably makes sight reading very challenging. And very disorganised. So he has dropped music. We are fine with this.

Little dd is highly organised... when she thinks I am rushing around trying to do 5 things at once, she stands in front of me with her fingers out and counts off things TO DO. It would be slightly irritating if I didn't delight in her beautifully organised little mind. Sigh.

The teacher, who is newly engaged, was non commital about time frames to be ready for the prep test, er one year, maybe two. Fully understand a lot depends on dd's musical aptitude, etc, but just wondering what others have experienced.

OP posts:
abittoofat · 24/01/2012 20:59

This is a joke yes??

ElphabaisWicked · 24/01/2012 13:24

I would expect a child starting about the age of 7 or 8 to be ready for the preptest after maybe a year.

dd started with me when she was 6 but not seriously. She started properly 18 months ago and is doing Grade 1 this term, she skipped the prep test.

2 lessons a week for a 4 year old is a bit extreme. If she is eager then it is fine to begin but she should be playing fun games atthe piano using a child friendly book like 10 fingers. Not working towards the prep test which isn;t an exam anyway, you can;t fail it it just acts as an introduction to the idea of going in and playing to a stranger.

You would be better off enrolling her in a general group music appreciation class and this would help with the aural/musicianship skills you need in the grades as well.

The fact that dd did music aural club at school at lunchtimes has helped her a lot.

ASByatt · 24/01/2012 13:18

Yes why on earth does it matter how long until her first exam?

Whose idea was it for 2 lessons a week?

Colleger · 24/01/2012 13:15

It is frustrating for teachers that parents can only think about the exam. I'd be a bit Hmm if a parent of a 4 year old asked such a question after a few lessons, or was it the first? Surely you want her to become a proficient pianist not an exam factory?

maggiethecat · 24/01/2012 12:53

I have got the same kind of feedback from prospective teachers for my 5yo dd (bar the Suzuki teachers).
But there was one teacher who said she did not take view that 5 was too young on the basis of handspan (she said that they would start off playing keys that were very close together anyway) or not being able to read well yet.
Think enthusiasm for the piano and ability to concentrate for at least 20 mins should be enough for a child to benefit.

PushyDad · 24/01/2012 11:37

Ditto the comment about being too young. We wanted to start DS on the piano at at 5.5 but we were told that the finger span of children that age wasn't developed enough for piano. So we stated him on the violin and delayed taking on the piano until he was 9.

DeWe · 24/01/2012 10:57

Dd1 did it in about 2.5 terms, it's not a pass/fail exam, she could have done it sooner, or later, really wouldn't have minded. Some teachers like them to be getting ready for grade 1, some prefer to do it early.

Wondering why you're giving her two lessons a week, and half an hour? It sounds quite a lot of pressure, even if she's enjoying it at present. Most teachers would start with 20 minutes once a week. She's also young to start, round here most teachers look for the child to be about age 6-7 and a competant reader, as that helps with reading music. Dd1 learnt to read music on the recorder first, which was very helpful.

Roughly, including prep test dd1 did roughly an exam a year, she's working for grade 4 now, but expects to take slightly longer between exams after this.