Please or to access all these features

Exercise

Chat to other fitness enthusiasts on our Exercise forum.

57 yo painful knees, is it time to hang up my running shoes?

26 replies

Valleyofthedollymix · 18/10/2026 17:11

I'd really appreciate any advice about this because there seem to be two schools of thought about this sort of thing - carry on exercising to make it stronger or give it up to stop it getting worse.

I had an MCL/ACL something or other in 2020 and during covid used a stationary bike until it got better. However, my current issue is both knees so I think it's unrelated. It's worst when I'm sat down, particularly when driving, and when I stand up, I'm incredibly stiff and have to walk like a cowboy for a minute or so. I went to a physio and they gave me some exercises which help but it persists.

I think it's either runner's knee or the beginnings of arthritis.

I know various people who've stopped running at a certain age and I don't know whether that's what I should be doing to protect it from further damage. I like but don't love running - I do it because it's convenient, I have a regular catch-up with friend and it's fun when you're abroad or in a new city. I'm always counting the metres until I can stop and feel good rather than high when it's done.

In terms of speed, I currently run a c27-28 minute 5k and the 10k is comfortably under an hour. My big love is tennis and I do pilates and strength because I feel I ought to rather than any great inclination. I walk a lot too and the odd bit on a Peloton. Almost everything that gives me joy in life involves my knees so I really don't want to knacker them out.

Give up or keep going? What do you reckon?

OP posts:
Forgotthebins · 18/10/2026 21:17

Ask your physio if you can have further investigations and get advice on that basis.