Please or to access all these features

Exercise

Chat to other fitness enthusiasts on our Exercise forum.

Lifting with Caroline Girvan 2024: What's not to love?!

965 replies

BigButtons · 07/01/2024 18:48

New thread!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
35
Menora · 28/05/2024 10:41

I have a torn trap so I’m having a break.

Anjelika · 28/05/2024 09:59

I'm having a break from Intent (and any other programs) this week as I found myself just going through the motions last week. I like the Leg day format in Intent. In previous programs it's been 1 day mainly quad focused then 1 day glutes/hamstrings with endless thrusts. In Intent all the leg days seem to combine a bit of both.

BigButtons · 27/05/2024 23:33

Mr concerns with the repetition is that it will cause muscle and joint damage. Quite a few people on the main group are talking about their knees really nothing them- where they hadn’t on other series.
I don’t know where those comments came from about her showing off. I guess people are just envious.
i actually did day 50 legs today. I am picking up and dropping as I go. I did if all body weight so that I could really monitor how my knees and hip were doing.
knee was very clunky but not painful.
my right leg had shooting pains tonight. I do wonder if it is sciatica?
otheriwse I enjoyed it.
I don’t find this series boring at all. I found unleash very boring though. I love circuits so am enjoying the way she is formatting this series.

OP posts:
Anjelika · 27/05/2024 20:08

@samthebordercollie I saw that too and wondered where the "showing off" comments had come from. Not from the FB groups, that's for sure 🤣🤣. There's a bit of negativity towards Intent in one of the groups though - about it getting boring with the 90 second sets and some of the leg days being ridiculously hard.

samthebordercollie · 27/05/2024 13:47

Day 32 and 33 of Intent this morning, Day 33 was lots of curtsey and Bulgarian lunges with some hip thrusts and stability ball to break up all the lunging. Caroline loves her unilateral work! Day 32 more lateral and rear delt raises, they seem a staple of every upper body workout!
Did anyone see the knowlege post Intent week 9 HQ? Very strange, Caroline defending herself apparently having been accused of showing off with the weights she uses....not sure where the criticism came from but for me she never shows off and is capable of lifting a lot more than she does in the programs. It was very strange, not like her usual posts at all!

RosaRoja · 27/05/2024 07:51

@Cherryblossom81 I did Beastmode after Iron (without HIIT days), then started Fuel, and a while later Iron again. I’m now on about day 12 of Fuel and 6 of Iron. I do them in parallel, or alternate. I’m away atm, so I took a break for a few days. I have a resistance band with me, but I haven’t had time for it. The hotel has a gym but, again, too busy sightseeing.

thenewaveragebear1983 · 27/05/2024 06:59

@Cherryblossom81 i’m in the same position. I have 5 sessions left of iron and I’m looking for what to do next. I think I might do the ten sessions of Beastmode then do epic (if available on YT?) I have enjoyed iron but now I’m 5 weeks in and I am getting a bit bored as others have said on this thread.

I’m away at the moment, I have brought my gym stuff with me but I’m not really confident to use the hotel gym. I don’t know why, I just have this massive mental block. It’s weird. The gym itself is quite small and absolutely full of equipment and I just don’t think I feel comfortable enough to go down with my phone and do a workout. So I’m probably having a few days off and will resume Thursday morning.

BigButtons · 26/05/2024 18:52

samthebordercollie · 26/05/2024 18:47

@Cherryblossom81 good for you, Epic 3 is my favourite You Tube programme too (Endgame a close second. Go at your own pace, you will find your heart rate increases more than it did with Iron, but the workouts are more fun. Day 7 leg day is still etched in my memory as the hardest leg day I've ever done!

Ah yes- day 7 leg day. 🫣😬

OP posts:
samthebordercollie · 26/05/2024 18:47

@Cherryblossom81 good for you, Epic 3 is my favourite You Tube programme too (Endgame a close second. Go at your own pace, you will find your heart rate increases more than it did with Iron, but the workouts are more fun. Day 7 leg day is still etched in my memory as the hardest leg day I've ever done!

Cherryblossom81 · 26/05/2024 18:36

Thanks @samthebordercollie and @BigButtons

Yes, I'm not sure why, but I think I am a bit nervous. I think maybe I see myself as the small framed and not very strong person who doesn't (can't?!) lift weights, but I have completed the whole of Iron and really enjoyed it (still with tiny weights compared with Caroline). I think I will start Epic 3 tomorrow morning.

BigButtons · 26/05/2024 11:21

@Cherryblossom81 definitely do something other than iron. I did it when it first came out so just followed what came next which was fuel I think. I hated that though. Try epic three!🤩

OP posts:
samthebordercollie · 26/05/2024 09:21

@Cherryblossom81 Yes, Beastmode on You Tube is just a 2 week programme.
I would go on and try the other programmes rather than sticking with Iron on repeat which is what some people do. Are you worried about them? I was initially, but once you start the Epics are fun and varied, much more so than Iron which I found quite dull.
@BigButtons Yes, I know the couple you mean, I don't know how they have time to post daily all the photos and resumé - not to mention the awful puns - she seems to be trying to morph into Caroline physically. But then they do both look very fit and muscular so I suppose they are a great advert for Caroline's programs! I agree that the FB Community page is horribly sychophantic, any of the few posts I've made - usually about technique - are never priority over the 'how fit and pumped do I look' best contributors

Cherryblossom81 · 26/05/2024 08:34

Thanks @samthebordercollie Is Beastmode just 10 sessions (am I looking at the right series)?

@AtomicBlondeRose I wondered if you can remember what you did after Iron? From some of your previous posts, I feel like I'm a year behind you?!

Would anyone recommend simply repeating Iron or do you think it's better to add in variety and try a new series?

BigButtons · 25/05/2024 23:41

I find it much more comfortable to do rear delts standing but bent over. I think it is just my body proportion 🤷🏻‍♀️
There is that couple- the guy is the ‘psychologist’ on the app. He annoyed the hell out of me with his endless puns and jokes.
what gets me is that anything that can be construed as even a vague criticism is shut down.
I do wish she would come up with something more ‘epic’ like. Epic three suits me the most

OP posts:
Anjelika · 25/05/2024 21:14

@samthebordercollie I did the same earlier! I did 2 of the 3 sets standing and they felt much better. She seems to put them in every single upper body workout these days.

Anjelika · 25/05/2024 21:11

@BigButtons I can't believe you've been banned from the FB group. That's insane! That's a good point you make about where CG goes next. There are some insanely fit people out there for whom one CG workout a day is not enough (and don't they love to brag & tell you just how much they've done on those groups!). They'll be wanting something harder still I guess. I've managed to stay injury free, mainly as I've stuck with what I know are safe weights for me.

samthebordercollie · 25/05/2024 21:02

@BigButtons I know what you mean, I can't bear to look at the FB group now as it's so boring with the same people worshipping Caroline and saying how hard but wonderful the latest Intent workout is. I think she will lose a lot of App subscribers if she does another similar heavy/long/repetitive programme.
Today I did one of my favourite Endgame upper body workouts and loved it!
@Anjelika am totally with you on the rear delt flyes!! I do mine standing so they are easier but even so....there are other shoulder exercises!

BigButtons · 25/05/2024 15:16

@samthebordercollie I have had a semi ban on the fb group for 2 weeks. I am not allowed to post until 8/6. The mods there are a nightmare .
seems to me the only posts are ones that call Caroline Queen and basically have people posing and describing the session in detail EVERY BLOODY DAY.
there is never any interesting discussion going on.

There was a bit of a contentious thread where I said I was worried about the effect the length of the sets and the sheer repetition would have on joints etc. a lot of people do seem to be suffering because of it.
where does she even go from here? Harder and harder stuff. There will be people who simply cannot kee up and are becoming injured and others who will wants to be pushed harder and harder.

OP posts:
Anjelika · 25/05/2024 15:15

I'm doing Intent at the moment. I do 4 workouts a week so am at the end of week 6 now. I've found this last week I've got a bit bored of the long sets and doing some of the same moves every other day - she seems obsessed with those seated rear delt flyes!! I'm taking a week off just to try and get some momentum going for the final 4 weeks. I found in yesterday's leg one I couldn't be bothered challenging myself so think I need a break for a week.

samthebordercollie · 25/05/2024 13:43

Hello everyone!
@Vtm good luck with your job interview and don't worry about the weights you are lifting, you do you, and progress will be made using lighter weights.
@Cherryblossom81 Beastmode and Endgame are good follow ons from Iron. Just leave out the HIT days if you don't want to do any jumping, otherwise both programs are solid lifting. With maybe the odd maker, but I think thats more Epics 1 - 3.
@BigButtons I hope your muscles feel better soon. Using lighter weights or even body weight will work. I've started to see a lot of FB posts recently about people not loving Intent for the reason you stated, too repetitive and too long! I agree with you, I like the format and am finding it works, but it certainly isn't an easy program to do with 90 mins of lifting and as you say, endless hip thrusts, bridges and lunges on lower body days. My heart rate certainly doesn't go up like it did with the Epics, but I really feel my muscles after each workout, it's a really effective lifting programme, despite the monotony. Thank goodness there are circuit days too! I'd struggle if every workout was just the long, heavy lifting without variation.

Cherryblossom81 · 25/05/2024 10:54

I have got one more day of Iron left and then I will have completed my first CG series and the first time in my life (early 40s now) that I've ever done any strength based exercise.

I just wondered if any of you could recommend what I should do next? I still feel like a complete beginner (using very light weights!). I had wondered if I should just repeat Iron again, but maybe it's best to try a new series?

I'd prefer to not have a series that involves any jumping (not sure if she does this in any series?) as I exercise upstairs.

Cherryblossom81 · 25/05/2024 10:45

BigButtons · 25/05/2024 07:53

Hello everyone!
I have had to take yet another week off intent. I really love the way the series is formatted BUT I suspect that the repetitive nature of it is causing strain and over use injuries. I have pains still in my right hip and knee and, for the first time ever, sporadic sciatica. My left arm tennis elbow was becoming unbearably painful.
In this series she pretty well does the same exercises every day. It is VERY lunge and thrust heavy. The sets are very long. So as much as I was enjoying it, now that it is getting tougher towards the end. I am not sure I will be able to go back to it.
I am gutted. Perhaps I might try using really light weights and body weight for leg days. I dunno🤷🏻‍♀️

@BigButtons Sorry to hear about the strains and injuries. Sounds frustrating as well as painful.

BigButtons · 25/05/2024 07:53

Hello everyone!
I have had to take yet another week off intent. I really love the way the series is formatted BUT I suspect that the repetitive nature of it is causing strain and over use injuries. I have pains still in my right hip and knee and, for the first time ever, sporadic sciatica. My left arm tennis elbow was becoming unbearably painful.
In this series she pretty well does the same exercises every day. It is VERY lunge and thrust heavy. The sets are very long. So as much as I was enjoying it, now that it is getting tougher towards the end. I am not sure I will be able to go back to it.
I am gutted. Perhaps I might try using really light weights and body weight for leg days. I dunno🤷🏻‍♀️

OP posts:
Vtm · 21/05/2024 14:08

I am back after a long break from exercise. Life came in the way, my job search was not going well.

Anyway now I have atleast some interviews lined up and yesterday I started exercise again. Yesterday I did epic-2 day 18 leg pyramid set. My fav leg workout and I have got major DOMS. Today I can barely walk and I did epic-2 day 17 Arms. I am back on 5kg dumbells and at this rate I will be doing epic 2 forever!

Cherryblossom81 · 13/05/2024 21:36

Thanks for asking @samthebordercollie It felt better when I got up this morning and I thought I would be ok to do the next workout as it was glutes and hamstrings. However, I had to stop before the end as the single leg bridges started to aggravate my back again. The next workout is full body, so I think maybe I should wait a couple of days.

That's interesting to hear about the wrist straps. I've been wondering about getting some as I've got tiny wrists and wondered if they might help.

Swipe left for the next trending thread