Please or to access all these features

Exercise

Chat to other fitness enthusiasts on our Exercise forum.

Bulky shoulders and neck from weights - How to reduce?

32 replies

stilllockeddownnowheretogo · 27/01/2022 09:12

Last summer I started to do some short workouts with weights at home (Caroline Girvan's Epic workouts on Youtube if that's relevant).
I loved them - around 30 minutes workout 5 times a week. Mostly using weights (one cardio or HIIT). Most weeks since then I've used them, so around five months. I've upped the weights from 3 to 5kg for arms and 8kg for legs.
I love that I'm stronger; my legs are more firm; my waist is a little smaller (though still very flabby...).
However, my issue is that my shoulders have got huge! Particularly the part at the base and around my neck (trapezius?). It looks so bulky. And I have a strapless dress to wear for my wedding soon. My upper half is not looking good in the strapless right now!

Any suggestions of how I can fix this? Get that 'long and lean' look instead of short and bulky. I'm a short person anyway, so I'll never be willowy and slender, I'm not looking for that. But I would like my neck and shoulders to look leaner in this dress.
Please help!
Should I reduce weights? Stop doing upper body workouts (might just get more flabby)? Do more reps with lower weight or fewer reps with higher weight? (I'm reading conflicting information on this online)
Thanks so much!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
stilllockeddownnowheretogo · 31/01/2022 09:36

Hi all,
Thanks for the continued support! Noted that I need to take up yoga or pilates, and yes I know I need to do more cardio too...just signed up for a 5k race, hopefully this will inspire me to run more.

No comment on the strapless dress opinions Grin. It's too late now!! LOL.

OP posts:
LaChanticleer · 28/01/2022 11:44

a strapless dress can look very nice on people who aren’t tall and thin

Fair enough @Pyri - probably a difference in tastes! I live near a Registry Office and I've seen too many hefty (not from muscles Grin ) brides in strapless dresses, with flesh spilling over their backs and underarms. Not elegant ...

WhatScratch · 28/01/2022 11:20

I did this when I fell in love with two weight machines at the gym. I was working one lot of muscles more than the others, 6 days a week, and felt like I’d started to get a ‘hump’. I mentioned it to one of the trainers and she gave me a more balanced routine that didn’t involve any machines. I think that the machines are just there to fill up floor space and lure the unwise.

Purpleavocado · 28/01/2022 11:13

I get the same way, I'm 5'3 and my upper body bulks quickly. I think people who say 'only 5kg' haven't seen how intense Caroline's workouts are.
I'd concentrate on Cardio and doing something like Tracy Anderson workouts 3 or 4 times a week. Her old mat workout is on youtube. She's a lunatic, and very boring, but her stuff does slim me down.

Chely · 28/01/2022 10:57

Put the weights down and go for a run instead.

I lift heavy and don't have muscle bulk like folk presume you get, I rarely do above 5 rep sets.

Pyri · 28/01/2022 10:47

Sorry @LaChanticleer but a strapless dress can look very nice on people who aren’t tall and thin. A bolero or shrug is very very outdated now and would look worse than bare shoulders

LaChanticleer · 28/01/2022 10:43

Good that the advice here gives you something to go forward with OP.

Frankly, though, strapless dresses really are difficult to wear unless you're tall, thin, and either full chested, or very flat chested - they flatter very few people. I'm old-fashioned and find the apparently compulsory strapless wedding dress a big no no anyway.

Far more flattering, and showing off a lovely neckline, are dresses with sleeves but a broad low cut across shoulder & collar bone.

For example:
www.silkfred.com/womens/clothing/dresses/maxi-dresses/goddiva/bardot-pleated-occasion-maxi-dress-in-emerald-green?locale=en-GB&gclid=Cj0KCQiAxc6PBhCEARIsAH8Hff0WV0AeUmWj2oF6OlmTW1QS3Cyy8Yxxcr4n5F-1V-ABec4cFJt0koEaAkCuEALw_wcB

or
www.jjshouse.co.uk/A-Line-V-Neck-Asymmetrical-Satin-Mother-Of-The-Bride-Dress-With-Beading-Sequins-Pockets-008204918-g204918/?utm_term=204918&utm_size=06&gclid=Cj0KCQiAxc6PBhCEARIsAH8Hff3TGxUbMKK2_vc1Wjk5hwRjZ23aVhcOkF8tzYC-et_t52CrLw5SdL8aAugoEALw_wcB&ucid=3858

But I guess it's too late now ...

A lovely fitted shrug or bolero style jacket will do something to soften out the strapless look, and give you a more elegant line.

MythicalBiologicalFennel · 28/01/2022 07:30

@catfunk

I've been weight training for years and find it very hard to believe someone could bulk out from home workouts with 3-5kg weights.
I bulked out quite quickly from just doing the 30 day shred with 3kg weights i am 5ft 8 and was lean at the time and it was a noticeable, obvious, fast change. As much as I loved doing weights I wasn't entirely happy with the way that looked on me OP so I can relate.

A couple of years and some health issues later I cannot do weights. I have been doing yoga for months and can see the difference in my muscle tone - yes I look more toned and stronger but it's a much more gentle shape and more forgiving and natural-looking if you have pockets of fat like I do.

So to sum up if you want to change the look of the neck / shoulder area for your wedding I would use yoga and pilates for your upper body.

stilllockeddownnowheretogo · 28/01/2022 05:56

@LaChanticleer @CloseYourEyesAndSee and others, you are all right.
I am of a short and stocky build, and I need to come to terms with that. Honestly, 99.9% of the time I am content with my body shape, but this bloomin' dress has me second guessing myself. I'm slightly regretting the dress neckline... It looks great from the front, not so much from the back Grin.

@RJnomore1 @Nevilleslongbottom thanks for the kind thoughts that I've lost weight Grin - haven't lost on the scales, but my body is a bit smaller, which is why I thought I'd lost fat and gained muscle.
With my neck, you're all right, I think scrutinizing it in the mirror / TV as I work out has made me look at it more closely and notice things which I haven't before. I have a very defined 'slope' from neck down to shoulderblades, and then a definite 'dip' where my bra straps lie. It's not a smooth nor level shoulderline. But then that's my shape, and I need to make peace with that.

@reallyworriedjobhunter, thanks, I could consider a shrug - I'll keep that as a back up plan. But I'm going to try to be happy in the dress first, just the way I am. Smile

@Deux, this is useful - for exercises like rows and RDLs, I should be pulling my shoulder blades together, and so not feeling it in my traps, is that right? Maybe also for shoulder presses?
I do wonder if my posture isn't quite right for some exercises and this is exaggerating it. I will go back to the start and recheck how I do each exercise.

@Thissucksmonkeynuts@Ahoyashipg, I'd love a pirates instructor Wink, wonder if I can find one of those down my local docks...

Everyone, thanks for the pep talk! This was just what I needed. You're amazing.

OP posts:
stilllockeddownnowheretogo · 28/01/2022 05:48

Wow, so many responses, I hadn't expected so many and I am so grateful to you all - thank you.

I am ridiculously pleased that you're all universally telling me that 5kg weights could not build muscle/bulk Grin phew this is a relief! So I can happily continue with the 5/8kg weights without stressing too much. ok, no excuses, got to get back on the exercise programme!

I will also give pilates a go - I've never done it before, just tried one video from YouTube which seemed a bit like a core / abs session? Would that be right? Anyone got any favourite pilates instructors online? I'll also have a look for classes nearby. I don't think I can manage 3 classes a week, but I'll aim for 2 to begin with. Thanks for the recommendation on this! Seems like a lot of you agree.

OP posts:
Deux · 27/01/2022 18:41

Oh and to answer your question, don’t do exercises that work your traps. Make sure you don’t use your traps when eg you should be pulling your shoulder blades together. Just some thoughts.

Deux · 27/01/2022 18:38

If you’ve lost fat, then your upper traps (I think that’s what you’re referring to) might be more visible, especially if your collar bones are more pronounced now. Ditto if your bust and upper chest are leaner. So it might be your perception and your traps are just more toned.

RJnomore1 · 27/01/2022 18:21

Yeah I really don’t believe you’ve built muscle with 5kg weights. If you have co sister taking up and competing in bodybuilding, you’d be a natural.

Have you lost fat and the muscle is more obvious perhaps?

HeyBlaby · 27/01/2022 18:21

@catfunk

I've been weight training for years and find it very hard to believe someone could bulk out from home workouts with 3-5kg weights.
Absolutely this.
reallyworriedjobhunter · 27/01/2022 18:18

Would you be happy to share a picture? I'm sure you don't look bulky.

Would a shrug help you feel more comfortable?

ShirleyPhallus · 27/01/2022 18:14

I agree with comments above that 3-5kg isn’t enough to significantly build muscle esp on shoulders

More likely that your posture is affected or that you’re shrugging your shoulders too much on movements

Ahoyashipg · 27/01/2022 18:14

I'm not sure a pirates instructor would be that helpful. Very difficult to find outside Dover. Grin

itwasntaparty · 27/01/2022 18:13

There is no way you can have bulked that much with 3-5kg handweights, NO WAY, especially traps.

You're either the hulk's offspring or have some issues around body image.

Nevilleslongbottom · 27/01/2022 18:13

Another one saying there is no way you would get that bulky with those weights. You have probably lost some weight and it’s just looking different to how it was. I’m sure you look fab.

Ohmycron · 27/01/2022 18:12

Made, 5 kg is nothing

Thissucksmonkeynuts · 27/01/2022 18:11

Pirates? Thanks for that my phone!

Thissucksmonkeynuts · 27/01/2022 18:10

A concerted effort with a pirates instructor would help I think. I am tall, but broad and do a physical job. When I did alot of pirates, a couple of people described me as willowy.
Actually, an after thought, I have realpronounced shoulder/ neck muscles these days, it's from years of lifting small children with a core that doesn't work well due to diastasis recti. Basically all the effort goes through my upper back/ neck and jaw. I wonder if you haven't been using you core strength correctly during these workouts?

Viviennemary · 27/01/2022 18:05

Try some ballet type exercises for arms. You never see a ballerina with big arms and shoulders. I think this happened to me ages ago from working on a rowing machine at the gym.

Luredbyapomegranate · 27/01/2022 18:02

5 kg is a very modest weight, there is no way it could bulk you up.
I do think you are just seeing normal muscle definition being revealed, and being very critical because wedding dress etc. Try and focus on what you want to look like overall on your wedding day - no one is going to be focusing on your neck.

CovidCurious · 27/01/2022 17:53

I'm sorry you are not happy with your results. But it is almost inconceivable that at that frequency and amount of weight you have bulked your muscle hugely more than it was already. As others have said, maybe you can see the muscle definition more if you have lost weight and if your midriff has got smaller then it will emphasise your shape.