Please or to access all these features

Elderly parents

How to deal with Mum insisting on things that aren't true (when she is still mostly with it)?

29 replies

DierdreDaphne · 28/05/2026 22:15

Mum is in her 90s and after a fall and hospitalisation last year her memory has definitely taken a step downwards.

She is still mostly on top of things but a combination of the hospital stay and now needing carers means she seems to have kind of 'let go' a bit , and leaves a lot of decisions to me and dsis (and/or the carers).

This would be OK except she is inconsistent and sometimes gets very convinced that a wrong memory is right.

This hasn't happened often but it's potentially worrying eg in relation to medical issues where she insists perfectly lucidly to the hcps that for example, a particular issue has been going on for ages when it is new and deteriorating, or is certain about the medication dose she's been taking and again, has it completely wrong.

Because she is an intelligent, well-informed person still for th most part these little confabulations are pretty much undetectable unless you know different because you were there.

Unfortunately with the most recent issue (the medication dose) she has started to get a bit stroppy with us when we contradict her. Which is slightly new and quite worrying.

She has no formal diagnosis of dementia and I don't know if that would help, even if she would agree to an assessment. Which I fear she would not.

I am not really asking for advice in terms of formal steps, more just to hear from others if they recognise this sort of thing and I guess , how they dealt with it.

(We.do both have lpas for both, we do her money stuff and so far she has been fine with that, but I think it's way too early for the health one from what I've read?)

OP posts:
suki1964 · 28/05/2026 23:11

I dont want to be mean or horrid , but I would also advise on a LPA in place as soon as possible

I had to have that DNR conversation with mum 10 days before her death and 2 days previous she was asking to be kept alive - untreatable cancer and a heart attack

This stage caring for elders is heartbreaking

AnnaMagnani · 28/05/2026 23:01

A diagnosis helps as everyone dealing with her will know in advance, and hopefully avoid the endless loop of her telling them things she has made up, being believed and then predictable crisis.

In the moment however, it isn't worth correcting her. She can't remember she can't remember, you in particular are her little girl while she is an experienced adult so obviously she'd be right and you wrong to her mind.

If she's being seen at home, conversations with HCPs on the doorstep are helpful. As is vigorously shaking your head behind her back if she is getting stuff wrong.

Make sure you are down as being able to share her medical information at the GP, they usually want a letter from her to do this before the LPA kicks in. An accidental success for me is that my DM doesn't use a mobile, but my mobile is down on her record as the preferred number. Means everyone calls me first before calling her so I get to give an update.

ThunderFog · 28/05/2026 22:46

I've spent the afternoon with my Dear Elderly Relative who can still talk authoritatively about theology and philosophy. He is very insistent that he doesn't require tablets, hasn't had a fall recently, and is not in pain. He thinks the nursing home staff aren't very good, because they won't let him walk down to the library.

Sorry no suggestions - it took about five years to get a dementia diagnosis.

scoopsahoooy · 28/05/2026 22:44

My advice is push for a diagnosis if you can, because it makes certain things easier, and pick your battles.

If the untruth has no impact, just let it go. In the case of specific medical ones, a) this is where having a diagnosis would be useful and b) see if you can have a route for correcting things in a way that's not in front of her/a way of contacting them separately so you can give correct information. It can be distressing/angering/agitating for them when they're getting contradicted on something they think is true and it is almost never helpful to argue the toss, as you've found!

And I would say it's not too early for a health LPA - get it while she still has capacity. It's much more of a pain once they aren't deemed to have capacity any more!

Swipe left for the next trending thread