Please or to access all these features

Elderly parents

Elderly mum needs a shoulder replacement and wants me to do her care afterwards but I’m not up to it

86 replies

Cardiganwearer · 06/11/2025 10:05

DM is 80. She fell on her shoulder and broke it in Feb 2023. The hospital just put her arm in a sling and hoped it would heal. It hasn’t at all, the bones are not near each other to be able to heal as far as I can understand. She is in terrible pain as you can imagine. She hoped to get away with injections as she did not want an operation with a GA as she has many other serious conditions (heart failure, stage 3 kidney disease, rheumatoid arthritis, unstable high blood pressure, under active thyroid) But yesterday she was told that injections might make her arm useless and the only thing to do is a total shoulder replacement.

She was widowed 4 years ago when my DF died. So lives alone now. When she first broke the arm she stayed with my DSis for 2 weeks broken by a weekend at her home with me staying with her. My sis was going crazy so I got meals on wheels and a fall alarm etc sorted so she could move back. She has now asked for me and my sister to look after her like we did after her original fall when she has the operation. But things are all different now. My sister has an ill teenager who is pretty much housebound and in no way could they cope with my M there again. DSis also cannot leave DN unless his dad is there and he works very long hours.

So that leaves me, effectively. She cannot come to my house (stairs, no downstairs loo, no spare bedroom) and we would all go crazy. We are me, DH and DD 17, doing A levels. DH has fragile mental and physical health and is massively affected by any stress and a very private person to boot. For all of our sakes, it is absolutely no go. I would also worry she would never leave!

So that leaves me pretty much moving in with her for however long. Our relationship is pretty dreadful although she is fairly oblivious. Everything is fine if you ignore it! I actually went LC with her in July 2024 because I couldn’t stand the belittling and nastiness anymore. She would shout at me if I suggested things to help (eg LPA, antidepressants for DF, pharmacy deliveries instead of walking miles to the chemist in all weathers) so I stopped trying to help and stepped right back. I actually had chronic pain in the skin on my arm and pelvic pain that has disappeared since going LC. She was massively affecting my health, both physical and mental. I have always been the scapegoat and my sis the favourite. This has extended to the grandchildren too. So when DF died and then my DSis was largely out of circulation, she took all her unhappiness out on me. This has been my role since I was 5 when DSis was born. The dumping ground, the emotional punchbag. M is repeating her own family patterns. She was also the oldest daughter with a favourite younger sister. She complains long and loud about this while seeing no parallels whatsoever.

The weekend I was with her, I felt I was disappearing, being erased. My personality, my interests are not acceptable to her. My DH and DD visited and I cried the whole time because I wanted to go home with them. (Completely involuntary, I am not a crier). DM would not help me with the children (I have another grown up DC) when I had life threatening post natal depression and in fact made things a lot worse. It’s lucky I’m still here. I had to have counselling to cope with her behaviour. She did childcare for my DSis of course!!

I feel weakened by the post natal depression which I had for about 6 years. It doesn’t take much at all to slide back into suicidal ideation. DH thinks doing her care would break me again.

I feel I would last a day max looking after her. And how long would it be? How long is a piece of string? Will all her other health problems? And then I’m Carer. Even if our relationship was perfect, I am not a nurse in anyway and have a repulsion of doing personal care.

So I’m going to have to tell her today, that I can’t. I’m willing to do cleaning, laundry, shopping, admin, sorting care but not the care itself. I feel very guilty as you can imagine. I feel I have been telling her by not going oh, I’ll look after you Mum! Whenever surgery has been mentioned. But no, it will need to be explicit clearly.

I don’t know what I want from writing this really. Some info about how your olds got on with a shoulder replacement. Some reassurance I’m not a monster for not wanting to do this? It’s so hard.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
OriginalUsername2 · 21/11/2025 13:36

Cardiganwearer · 06/11/2025 11:01

I am half an hour away and I drive. But not happily, I was late to driving and find it very hard and tiring. Going over everyday would take a toll just from the driving. I also don’t work (for pay, gosh I work otherwise) so from an official point of view I am thoroughly available. Truth is I’m holding up my DH, my two DDs (one hopefully off to uni, the other living away but chronically ill and needing A LOT of support, my DSis who is distraught about her DC and feeling her way through all the red tape, and my DM. At slight arms length due to the LC but really it has brought contact down to “normal” levels, we were enmeshed before. I’m just starting HRT too. It’s too much basically.

You are already a carer. This is what you have to keep saying to people, your mum, your sister, and healthcare professionals. Only you can advocate for you. Stand firm.

(She should know relationships work two ways and being abusive doesn’t make people want to care for you. But I understand that might not be something you can bring yourself to say to her.)

Lottapianos · 21/11/2025 13:05

'Do what you reasonably can (a good yardstick is what you would expect a decent MAN in your situation to offer)'

Agree this is an excellent way of giving yourself a fresh perspective on your behaviour and decisions. Helps to blast through the guilt

MysterOfwomanY · 21/11/2025 11:02

Do what you reasonably can (a good yardstick is what you would expect a decent MAN in your situation to offer!), but don't put you both at risk.
You wouldn't (at any low price!) hire a carer with your circumstances who had a known difficult relationship with your mum! It would be reckless.

gallivantsaregood · 15/11/2025 14:46

GuestBehind · 06/11/2025 14:56

Seriously, your mother needs help. You can't just abandon her. We all grow old (and sometimes feisty from pain) so just ignore her carry-on and do the needful. I see this with Anglo-Saxon families constantly. You forget who gave birth to you.

Are you also someone who would demand of their child to provide care for them simply because you gave birth to them? Have you actually read anything @Cardiganwearer has written about her mother and their relationship?

Obligation to care between parents and children goes only one way . Parent to child. Parents

If an adult child wants to and is able to care for a parent, that of course is kind and lovely, but should NEVER be expected or demanded even where relationships have been healthy and loving.

@Cardiganwearer please look after yourself first and foremost. Your mum isn't kind or loving to you generally, so telling her a flat and determined no and sticking to it isn't going to really change that landscape. If she escalates, set your boundaries and hold them. If she speaks to you disrespectfully leave the room, hang up the phone. If it continues, do not answer the phone or put yourself in a position where its possible for her to have a go at you. Sharing DNA with someone does not give them the right to command, demand from you or abuse you.

Please, take care of yourself.

DierdreDaphne · 12/11/2025 13:54

She doesn’t want to go into a rehab place because she thinks she would never come out 🙄 I’m pretty sure they boot you out when you are fit enough

Good Lord of course they will! Clue's in the name. Discharge teams in NHS facilities are pretty aggressive one they have secured the all-important cliical "all-clear" IME.

ruethewhirl · 11/11/2025 10:55

Obsdidianrose · 11/11/2025 09:31

Caregivers from all cultures who do this out of love are amazing to behold and I love and admire how extended families can work to support each other (historically this is how it worked in the UK too,this is how I lived as a young child)...but have you never met the sort of DIL or daughter who are effectively coerced into this role at risk to their own health? it's more often the women of a family who have to make the sacrifices caregiving can entail. In some cultures, families don't want to ask for outside help, especially when the patriarch or matriarch has mental health problems. No one should feel shame for asking for help and knowing their own limits.

This. My entire fifties so far have been taken up with parent care and I’m 58 now. Grateful I still have my mum, but god it’s hard.

ShaneWalshgirlfriend · 11/11/2025 09:50

Cardiganwearer · 06/11/2025 10:39

Thank you all ❤️ She is asking way too much of me. I think she always had my sister so it didn’t matter about being nice to me, but now she needs me because my sis is out of the question.

You’re right @BlueLegume I am not equipped for this, even if we got on well. She has mentioned the rehab places but I don’t know if she would get a place. I am technically available. I expect there would be pressure on me to do it. She doesn’t want to go into a rehab place because she thinks she would never come out 🙄 I’m pretty sure they boot you out when you are fit enough. She also doesn’t want carers and I get that. It must be really scary. But I can’t do it. Maybe if I was sharing the load with DSis, but I’m an only child in effect however encouraging and grateful sis would be from the sidelines. I’m going to get the guilt trip from hell aren’t I?

OP, I have not rtft.

You are not technically available. You have a huge amount in your plate.

Be kind to yourself

Obsdidianrose · 11/11/2025 09:31

GuestBehind · 06/11/2025 14:56

Seriously, your mother needs help. You can't just abandon her. We all grow old (and sometimes feisty from pain) so just ignore her carry-on and do the needful. I see this with Anglo-Saxon families constantly. You forget who gave birth to you.

Caregivers from all cultures who do this out of love are amazing to behold and I love and admire how extended families can work to support each other (historically this is how it worked in the UK too,this is how I lived as a young child)...but have you never met the sort of DIL or daughter who are effectively coerced into this role at risk to their own health? it's more often the women of a family who have to make the sacrifices caregiving can entail. In some cultures, families don't want to ask for outside help, especially when the patriarch or matriarch has mental health problems. No one should feel shame for asking for help and knowing their own limits.

ruethewhirl · 11/11/2025 00:01

Ariana12 · 10/11/2025 18:38

The comment about families of different backgrounds is really unecessary. Caring for an elderly person after a big op is quite a skilled job. The OP and her mother will both need professional support and the hospital will be able to point her towards available resources.

Agree. Although I’m not in the exact same position as OP, I care for my elderly DM who lives with me.

Ariana12 · 10/11/2025 18:38

ruethewhirl · 06/11/2025 19:22

Have you ever been in the position OP is in? Just curious.

The comment about families of different backgrounds is really unecessary. Caring for an elderly person after a big op is quite a skilled job. The OP and her mother will both need professional support and the hospital will be able to point her towards available resources.

Ariana12 · 10/11/2025 18:34

So so sorry to read this. Can you set up home help for her? The hospital may have ideas.

AnnaMagnani · 10/11/2025 18:24

OP I looked after my DM in her 80s after her shoulder replacement. I am only giving you my example as it was not what either of us expected - but also I and my DM get on well.

I took 3 weeks of work. First week she was in hospital and I visited. She was in longer due to a rare complication which also meant she had to come home in a giant sling with a wedge under her arm - normally it would be a simple sling. There was extensive physio and OT input before discharge, they were completely familiar with discharging elderly people who live on their own.

She was in much much much less pain after the operation. She also turned out to be very effective at managing with one arm as that's basically all she had before. Both of us rapidly realised she wouldn't need as much help as we were worrying about, even with the wedge contraption.

I cooked, shopped, bought random disability items off Amazon (a lot of ponchos) and did some minimal personal care - pulling up her trousers and helping with a wash.

After 2 weeks she felt I wasn't needed and I went home.

Honestly I don't think I did anything that couldn't be done better by the Reablement Team if she hadn't had me to call on for help.

If you feel able to do it then do. But don't be guilted into it by someone you don't actual like, the surgeon actually said to us his experience was that people were much better after the op as they were so disabled before and that they had already adapted to one hand living. This proved exactly true for us.

ConstitutionHill · 10/11/2025 18:09

I'm sorry. No advice really other than stick to your guns x

PermanentTemporary · 10/11/2025 14:35

I think anyone who reads your original post will see that this is about as far from a family of any ethnicity abandoning their mum as it gets. This is about a family that needs the safety net.

lolawasashitgirl · 10/11/2025 14:26

OT here posting on a very glitchy iPad so can’t quote. I agree with the physio up thread that said there are services to assist with the aftercare.

shoulder operations are complex and can be painful. Also come with restrictions/precarious about movement. Depending on the surgeon she might have the awful compression stockings for DVT. These are a hideous nightmare for people to get on/off so hopefully she won’t have them.

anyway - please don’t get co-erced into doing this for her.

even if you lived with her and loved her dearly there are still limits to the personal care that you could safely
provide. Good luck.

CaminoPlanner · 10/11/2025 14:11

Wow. That is tough. Obviously you can't drop everything for her, so you need to decide what you can do and offer that. Work out what sort of contribution would stop you feeling guilty without you feeling dissolved by her needs. E.g. Talk with her GP to have all prescriptions fulfilled by Pharmazon or a similar online pharmacy. You could ask for their emails to be sent to you, so you take responsibility for liaising with them online if you think your mother wouldn't do that.

You might interview a few people local to her who could come in once a day as home help/companions. Suggest they do an hour's worth of cleaning or admin (e.g. helping open the prescription meds and ensuring she takes them) and an hour of chatting with her over lunch or dinner each time. Ensure she can afford this and that payment is set up. And monitor their attendance, maybe with a ring doorbell linked to your phone so you can keep an eye that they do the hours paid for.

Be very direct with her about why you can't be with her 24/7:
Mum, you need support right now. Sis can't help full time as her child is ill and I can't move in with you as DS is doing A levels and needs me around. But I have sorted out your prescriptions so they will be delivered from now on, and have arranged for someone to look in once a day. If this isn't enough, would you like to look around some sheltered flats with me?

GuestBehind · 10/11/2025 14:00

Changename12 · 06/11/2025 21:02

There are other options available for OPs mother. I would not want my adult children to look after me. It was my decision to have children and my children do not owe me anything for bringing them up. Op has an obligation to her daughter who is doing her A levels.

Family first. You shouldn't be relying on the state to look after your ageing parents. It's a safety net only - well at least it should be.

thepariscrimefiles · 09/11/2025 18:19

GuestBehind · 06/11/2025 14:56

Seriously, your mother needs help. You can't just abandon her. We all grow old (and sometimes feisty from pain) so just ignore her carry-on and do the needful. I see this with Anglo-Saxon families constantly. You forget who gave birth to you.

OP's mum has always been a pretty awful mum to OP. OP is unwell herself and when she had dangerous, life-threatening PND her mum absolutely refused to help look after OP's small children while she was in hospital. Therefore, she owes her mum absolutely nothing.

Plus, this board was set up to provide support to Mumsnetters who are dealing with elderly parents, not to guilt trip and berate them.

CrazyGoatLady · 09/11/2025 17:35

GuestBehind · 06/11/2025 14:56

Seriously, your mother needs help. You can't just abandon her. We all grow old (and sometimes feisty from pain) so just ignore her carry-on and do the needful. I see this with Anglo-Saxon families constantly. You forget who gave birth to you.

Giving birth doesn't make someone a good parent.

My background is partly non-Anglo Saxon, and that culture of origin can GTFOOH with the idea that simply giving birth entitles someone to run their adult children's lives. It doesn't.

@Cardiganwearer definitely speak to the medical team in the hospital about your situation and not being able to provide care. My DGM did this to us, said family would do everything, and we were stuck until she had a crisis. The NHS can offer reablement care either at home or in a facility to get her moving again, make sure her pain is managed, food and drink, etc. Don't put yourself through having to be away from your family for weeks and messing up your MH. Do the admin and the practical things, visit once a week to check in and cook a nice meal, bring some shopping, take some batch cooking, etc. Focus on things you can do to meaningfully support but for which you don't physically have to be in situ and at her beck and call for.

Sohelpmegod25 · 06/11/2025 22:25

She may well be eligable
for 6 weeks respite care - phone your GP and ask for a referral to adult social care.

27pilates · 06/11/2025 22:22

GuestBehind · 06/11/2025 14:56

Seriously, your mother needs help. You can't just abandon her. We all grow old (and sometimes feisty from pain) so just ignore her carry-on and do the needful. I see this with Anglo-Saxon families constantly. You forget who gave birth to you.

Oh please 🙄

Changename12 · 06/11/2025 21:02

GuestBehind · 06/11/2025 14:56

Seriously, your mother needs help. You can't just abandon her. We all grow old (and sometimes feisty from pain) so just ignore her carry-on and do the needful. I see this with Anglo-Saxon families constantly. You forget who gave birth to you.

There are other options available for OPs mother. I would not want my adult children to look after me. It was my decision to have children and my children do not owe me anything for bringing them up. Op has an obligation to her daughter who is doing her A levels.

ruethewhirl · 06/11/2025 19:22

GuestBehind · 06/11/2025 14:56

Seriously, your mother needs help. You can't just abandon her. We all grow old (and sometimes feisty from pain) so just ignore her carry-on and do the needful. I see this with Anglo-Saxon families constantly. You forget who gave birth to you.

Have you ever been in the position OP is in? Just curious.

countrygirl99 · 06/11/2025 19:08

GuestBehind · 06/11/2025 14:56

Seriously, your mother needs help. You can't just abandon her. We all grow old (and sometimes feisty from pain) so just ignore her carry-on and do the needful. I see this with Anglo-Saxon families constantly. You forget who gave birth to you.

There's always one sanctimonious one lacking in empathy.

rookiemere · 06/11/2025 17:21

OP I couldn’t do this for my DPs and my relationship with them is much better than yours and my family position is much more stable ( desperately looking for a job so I am less available, but stimmied because it has to be part time as they live an hour away).
I would text back to both DM and Dsis something like “Good news that the op is being scheduled. That will be so much better for you once it’s done. I am able to come up twice a week for daytime support for the 4-6 weeks after the op ( or whatever you are prepared to do) but will not be able to stay over. Unless Dsis is able to do that it sounds like respite would be the best option. “ That way they both know upfront what you are prepared to do.