Please or to access all these features

Elderly parents

Mum has dementia. Disagreement with Social Services about level of care required

140 replies

Blueuggboots · 05/11/2025 12:17

My mum has Parkinson’s and has recently been diagnosed with Parkinson’s dementia. Shes 79 and was diagnosed with Parkinson’s 4 years ago and dementia earlier this year, but it is developing quite quickly.

She currently lives in a one bedroom flat that is in an independent living block. This is up for sale because we want to move her to a care home (and she agrees with this) near us and have asked SS to fund this whilst we sell the flat.

They have refused, stating that they think she will be safe with two carers visiting a day.

My mum is currently managing but is in the brink of an emergency all the time. We feel she would be safer in a care home and this would free up her brain power to do nice things rather than worrying about attempting to shop (needs assistance), meals (reheating ready meals is all she can manage) and being in her own other than when we visit. She starts to look at her banking etc when alone and gets very muddled with this.

if ANYTHING goes wrong or doesn’t go the way my mum expected, she becomes very distressed and shakes, cries down the phone and gets herself in a state and we have to go over to sort this out. I don’t mind doing this, but if she was in a home, she would be much closer (10 minutes instead of 30-40) and would have other people on hand to assist her immediately.

SS are suggesting she can manage with automated pill dispensers but I think this is going to confuse her more because she’s not great with technology and gets very confused with her mobile phone etc.

Her medication is on a very tight schedule (she takes it 4 times a day and it HAS to be taken at certain times) and I don’t believe that carers are going to be on time to provide the medication which will cause mum further stress and increase her Parkinson’s symptoms if they weren’t provided on time.

Has anyone else been in a situation like this and what did you do?

OP posts:
countrygirl99 · 08/11/2025 11:18

Blueuggboots · 08/11/2025 10:58

@countrygirl99- no giving away here! She just doesn’t have a lot, but is over the limit for funding, but doesn’t have access to the money unless her flat sells. From what people have said here (and I AM listening!!) moving her to a care home, (regardless of our very lovely intentions) is not going to be possible. 😩😩

@Blueuggboots not saying you are giving away and you are in that awkward zone financially. But so often you see that shortsighted comment and your predicament illustrates the drawback perfectly. You know your mum would be better off in a care home, she wants to move in but without the ready cash you are stuck. At least she can once the flat is sold. If she had done what so many suggest and either spent it given away her money you would have been in an even worse position.

CandidLurker · 08/11/2025 11:07

Blueuggboots · 08/11/2025 10:58

@countrygirl99- no giving away here! She just doesn’t have a lot, but is over the limit for funding, but doesn’t have access to the money unless her flat sells. From what people have said here (and I AM listening!!) moving her to a care home, (regardless of our very lovely intentions) is not going to be possible. 😩😩

Unfortunately it is a bit of a catch 22. My uncle probably should have been in residential care I would say a year before it actually happened. But I don’t think social services would have agreed at that point. I remember having the discussion with the other LPA saying we could just decide ourselves to move him but if we do that without SS agreement what happens when the money runs out? Which it would have done within a year/18 months without the sale of his property.

we had to go down the carers route first which we didn’t think would work for him and sure enough he got worse and the whole thing clearly wasn’t working within a few months.

Blueuggboots · 08/11/2025 10:58

@countrygirl99- no giving away here! She just doesn’t have a lot, but is over the limit for funding, but doesn’t have access to the money unless her flat sells. From what people have said here (and I AM listening!!) moving her to a care home, (regardless of our very lovely intentions) is not going to be possible. 😩😩

OP posts:
countrygirl99 · 08/11/2025 10:35

@Blueuggboots those of us who've been round the block know just how terribly high the threshold for residential care is. That's why we roll our eyes when there are posts from people who say they will give away their money so their care is funded.

PropertyD · 08/11/2025 09:52

Blue - please stop taking rubbish. You will probably scare people. £250k or over £600k per year is complete shite. No one will be paying this.

Blueuggboots · 08/11/2025 09:05

@toomanydicksonthedancefloor1- I hear you. Flowers

OP posts:
CandidLurker · 08/11/2025 08:55

Blueuggboots · 08/11/2025 08:37

I just want to protect her quality of life and was a total newbie to all this, if people think I’m entitled, I’m sorry. Ignorant, yes. Entitled, no.

Yes sometimes you are thrown into it through circumstances or a sudden change with no understanding of the process.

Cheese55 · 08/11/2025 08:53

Soontobe60 · 08/11/2025 08:27

You absolutely are scaremongering.
If someone’s care needs are at the extreme level of care then the likelihood is that they would qualify for CHCF, and the LA would make sure this is applied for.
The person would have to need 2 carers 24/7 to cost £8000 a month!

I had case of someone with 2 carers over 24 hours fully funded by social care. More usual is 1:1 over 24 hours. Also not funded by CHC.Challenging behaviours are not seen as a health need.

Countsounds · 08/11/2025 08:48

Blueuggboots · 08/11/2025 08:37

I just want to protect her quality of life and was a total newbie to all this, if people think I’m entitled, I’m sorry. Ignorant, yes. Entitled, no.

You arent entitled. The threshold for funded care is dangerously high and you just wanted whats best and safest for your mum. Good luck OP.

Blueuggboots · 08/11/2025 08:37

I just want to protect her quality of life and was a total newbie to all this, if people think I’m entitled, I’m sorry. Ignorant, yes. Entitled, no.

OP posts:
Ducksurprise · 08/11/2025 08:31

hatgirl · 06/11/2025 20:47

Any social worker experienced in working with older adults will be fully aware of the importance of timed meds visits for Parkinsons. As should any domiciliary care agencies they contract with.

Unfortunately this often isn't true.

In patient hospital, SW, in home support often do not understand that every two hours means exactly that.

The worst was in hospital, we were begging for the medication (that we usually administered but they had taken off us) but they wouldn't change the order of the ward round. Took us three days to get a Parkinson's nurse in to force a change.

Cheese55 · 08/11/2025 08:29

Advocodo · 07/11/2025 21:26

I am a retired nurse and my experience is that you will have to try carers at the maximum 4 times a day that then fails before SS woukd step-in snd pay for a care home by putting a charge on her flat until sold. I believe the interest charges are quite high. It’s not right but there it is. All councils are broke!!

None of the funding decisions are made because of being broke. It's about protecting Adults from over zealous relatives forcing them into care when they fare better in terms of well being at home (not saying that is the case here but most relatives jump at the chance of resi care for solvable problems)

Soontobe60 · 08/11/2025 08:27

BlueandWhitePorcelain · 08/11/2025 05:55

I am not scaremongering! The most I ever heard of, at a workshop with a solicitor in community care law about 15 years ago was £600,000 pa. She did comment that she couldn’t help thinking, health should have been contributing to the funding!

You absolutely are scaremongering.
If someone’s care needs are at the extreme level of care then the likelihood is that they would qualify for CHCF, and the LA would make sure this is applied for.
The person would have to need 2 carers 24/7 to cost £8000 a month!

CandidLurker · 08/11/2025 08:27

Lougle · 07/11/2025 13:18

https://www.hants.gov.uk/socialcareandhealth/adultsocialcare/carehomeframework/ratesandneedsprofiles

It may differ from LA to LA, but here's a guide to the eligibility for different care levels.

Just want to say thanks for posting that. My uncle has recently moved into residential care. The other LPA was given a figure for the amount we will have to pay when the 4 week assessment period is over. It’s £1040 per week and I can now see where this figure is derived from.

The definition does fit where my uncle is at the moment in terms of his needs. it’s helpful to have the official view.

Soontobe60 · 08/11/2025 08:23

Blueuggboots · 07/11/2025 13:45

@neverevergonnaeatkale- she goes to church on a Sunday and a Wednesday, gets taken shopping on a Thursday, goes to a church group on a Thursday evening and meets up with friends on a Tuesday lunchtime (she is collected and dropped home as is not safe on public transport) and family see her about once a week minimum dependent on what is going on, so she has quite a lot of social interaction already.
but I have phone calls from her friends who are concerned about her and her poor memory/cognitive function.

Believe me, if she can do all this then she absolutely does not meet the threshold for needing residential care.
She may want to live in a residential home for company, for meals to be provided, for laundry to be done, but that’s not the same as NEED.

Soontobe60 · 08/11/2025 08:20

Blueuggboots · 06/11/2025 07:43

@PumpkinTwistyWindToots- it’s called deferred payment and it’s an accepted way of moving someone into a care home????

A deferred payment can be used if someone is professionally assessed as needing to go into a care home, not if the family think they do. The elderly person also has to be able to agree to a deferred payment scheme - if they have detention they may well be assessed as having no capacity to make that decision.

BlueandWhitePorcelain · 08/11/2025 05:55

PropertyD · 07/11/2025 20:05

Blue - that is not true. £20k plus per month??? Stop scare mongering!

I am not scaremongering! The most I ever heard of, at a workshop with a solicitor in community care law about 15 years ago was £600,000 pa. She did comment that she couldn’t help thinking, health should have been contributing to the funding!

Advocodo · 07/11/2025 21:26

I am a retired nurse and my experience is that you will have to try carers at the maximum 4 times a day that then fails before SS woukd step-in snd pay for a care home by putting a charge on her flat until sold. I believe the interest charges are quite high. It’s not right but there it is. All councils are broke!!

toomanydicksonthedancefloor1 · 07/11/2025 20:50

OP I feel for you. We are suffering crisis after crisis with my mother in law who has Alzheimer's who is currently 'caring' for my FIL who has terminal cancer and is in and out of hospital and has nearly died several times but keeps recovering and then going back home. They currently have carers 4 times a day but they are both pig headed and stubborn and refuse cleaners, meals on wheels, etc and pretend they are coping. Every time FIL goes into hospital MIL almost has a breakdown and starts being very aggressive with her family members. She is not capable of looking after herself or my FIL. Every time he goes in hospital he is malnourished and dehydrated: social services have assessed her 3 times and say even though they know she doesn't have capacity she is passing their capacity test. So they advise carers 4 times a day is sufficient. They say until something bad happens (which it will) they won't act against her will. The medication you mentioned stood out to me, she will NOT remember this on her own. Getting my MIL stable on her meds was a long and hard battle with her. They are now locked away in a safe she doesn't have the code and the carers give her meds morning and evening so if your mum needs 4 meds a day she needs 4 visits if she isn't in a home doesn't she? Like your mum she can't shop, can't make a shopping list, can't cook, can't even really put away a Tesco delivery. I really really feel for you as the system isn't working for us, basically until a crisis happens we feel like we are on our own. And the whole situation has almost broken my DH and his brother. It feels like we are fighting everything and everyone including the parents in law that we are trying to help. My MIL and FIL also get these obsessive fixations, does that sound familiar? It could be a lost phone charger that ruined their entire day (both their phones were charged and a new one could've been delivered by Amazon the day after) or their usual obsession is the Ring doorbell. It's hard to talk them down from these and it usually ends up with my DH having to leave work to resolve them. You mentioning the banking app made me think of this that's all. Anyway I have no answers but I just really wanted to tell you, you have my utmost sympathy you really do

PropertyD · 07/11/2025 20:05

Blue - that is not true. £20k plus per month??? Stop scare mongering!

BlueandWhitePorcelain · 07/11/2025 19:50

PropertyD · 07/11/2025 12:15

Having been through some of this with late parents. You are really not understanding how SS work because what you want is that:

  1. SS agree she is at a stage of needing a care home which for many many people are the very last resort
  2. They lend you the money and one day in the future you pay them back
  3. Retirement complexes are very very difficult to sell. Late parent rented so we didnt have this issue.

We are talking about £££ for people living in a care home circa £6-£8k per month.

What happens when the money runs out. If you have chosen the care home yourself you might well need to move Mum out although you do seem to indicate that you will top up when the time comes.

I always knew my late Father was topping up people who were funded by the LA. His fees when he passed were £8k PER MONTH. No LA will pay this. Could you afford a good few thousand every month.

My late DF lived in a care home for over 4 years. Late Mum only 1 month.

I dont mean to be harsh but you need to take a deep breath here and think about what is on offer as opposed to what you would like to have for Mum

They will pay more than £8,000 PCM. I have across people costing £250,000+ pa.

Mischance · 07/11/2025 19:26

hatgirl · 06/11/2025 23:19

Again

Local Authorities cannot just fund residential care for every person who feels they now require it.

Local authorities can only fund residential care where there is no other option to keep the person safe. It is an absolute last resort.

This isn't adult social care being mean or penny pinching, there is a huge range of services the OP and her mum could access before considering residential care. If the OP and Mum did have the funds to pay themselves then even then any good social worker would still be advising them to try increasing the care or considering extra care or day services first.

In my local authority care home places are scarce and many extremely frail older people with no other option are left in hospital beds on busy acute hospital wards at huge infection risk waiting for places to become available.

OP is rightly advocating for her mother but the social workers and the local authority are looking at the bigger picture and trying to keep people in the community where possible and prioritise resources for those that need to be in residential care as best they can.

Indeed. I worked in adult services and said in my post that it hinges on the LA assessment and also pointed out that the assessment often does not reflect the reality that relatives are seeing..... no-one's fault .... it is impossible to truly assessment someone's needs in the time available to the SWs .... they just see a snapshot.
Relatives often have to be very firm to get the real picture across as they do not want to achieve the safe care of a residential home only after a fall has happened.

Changename12 · 07/11/2025 18:47

My aunt, who had Parkinsons, had her medication through time release patches. This was 15 years ago though. Is that an option for your mother?

Katykaty11 · 07/11/2025 14:19

Our family went through similar with our mum. I have to agree your mum is nowhere near the threshold for residential care. We went through every type of tech/gadget to help at different stages of her cognitive decline e.g. cctv in the house and trackers in case she wandered. The decline is so hard to watch. I think you have to try the 2 (hopefully 4 visits) a day for now (although carers were never punctual). We had a different scenario as when my mum was competent she said she always wanted to be at home. This bought it's own challenges.

Blueuggboots · 07/11/2025 13:45

@neverevergonnaeatkale- she goes to church on a Sunday and a Wednesday, gets taken shopping on a Thursday, goes to a church group on a Thursday evening and meets up with friends on a Tuesday lunchtime (she is collected and dropped home as is not safe on public transport) and family see her about once a week minimum dependent on what is going on, so she has quite a lot of social interaction already.
but I have phone calls from her friends who are concerned about her and her poor memory/cognitive function.

OP posts: