Please or to access all these features

Elderly parents

Refusing a Care Assessment - any advice?

91 replies

BlueLegume · 08/01/2025 08:39

Hi lovely people. I will try and keep this brief. Mother has been referred to Adult Social Care. She is self neglecting - not showering, not dressing, not eating food provided, not taking medication. Adult Social services contacted her earlier this month but she has refused to let them do a care assessment and refused them permission to contact her GP surgery. The ASW was excellent in terms of saying she will do an unannounced visit BUT what then happens if mother refuses access to them. Any experience or advice on this stage of things would be appreciated.

OP posts:
BlueLegume · 22/01/2025 07:42

@JohnPrescottsPyjamas really interesting to hear about the dementia diagnosis and the link to her normal/usual behaviour. I sense our brother is pushing for a dementia diagnosis and would not be surprised if he has already ‘diagnosed’ this himself because he refers to her as being ‘ill’ constantly. As in previous threads and messages I have taken her to the GP and to a specialist but they were not alarmed at her and did not raise any issues other than her being a bit down in the dumps and not being prepared to try and help herself. She refuses to engage in any kind of activity, she won’t read a book - in short anything put in front of her to help things she is utterly defiant in saying ‘that doesn’t work for me’. She has a superiority complex and always has. She could never buy high street clothes ‘they just don’t work for me’ - she is a normal sized person she just never wanted to be seen wearing the same thing as someone else. Always long days out to far flung towns with boutique ladies shops where she was treated like royalty. I took her a couple of years ago to her town centre department store. It was quite an insight. Grabbed some things for her to try on - she refused to go in the changing rooms - individual cubicles with lockable doors. Out loud she said ‘Blue you don’t expect me to try things on with the riff raff’. Everyone heard.

Everything is over complicated. these people end up with daughters like us, capable, imaginative and problem solvers because we have never known anything else.

Yesterday another phone call - oh I dialled you by mistake. no you did not - you dialled me because you want to keep me on my toes and you know I will call back. Much as a diagnosis might appease my brother I agree with @FiniteSagacity and the ‘bloody difficult’ comment. I have had almost 60 years of this woman and her demands - no one was looking for a diagnosis when she made my life a misery as a kid and teenager. If only.

OP posts:
HoraceGoesBonkers · 21/01/2025 21:15

@JohnPrescottsPyjamas I smiled at that. It's like they have at some point in time gotten together to plot ways to wind people up!

We stopped staying at my mums (the pandemic was an excuse) because she'd get up super early and crash about the house, do the dishes with a lot of banging of cutlery, slam the doors etc. My kids were quite young and the last thing I wanted was for them to get up early.

She'd also text us really early when Dad was ill, when of course everyone was keeping their phones on and being on edge.

The early morning thing, and turning up early for things (even when I explained I would not be available) seemed to be a sign of moral superiority. Rather than just bad manners.

FiniteSagacity · 21/01/2025 20:28

Wow so much of this resonates and in a week when I’ve had a lot of vitriol thrown at me (practical, geographically closest bad daughter). I am guilty as charged for putting him in the nursing home - but following medical advice and because we were all losing our minds.

DF is ‘sick of assessments’ and swears he is better and doesn’t need nursing care even as he presses the call button… I think the assessments are everyone trying to figure out what to diagnose him with and ‘bloody difficult’ isn’t a medical term.

DF definitely thinks his children should be doing all his care and sacrificing our lives for his (although he doesn’t need any care because he is better - but he does need us to step up).

I think there’s a bit of an obsession with ‘leaving a legacy’ that children / grandchildren should all ‘be grateful for’ when in reality the ‘legacy’ is needed now to provide 24 hour care. It all smells of wanting to keep up appearances even after death.

JohnPrescottsPyjamas · 21/01/2025 20:01

BlueLegume · 21/01/2025 18:57

@JohnPrescottsPyjamas it is so interesting putting the lifetime of jigsaw pieces together. Sadly though no one really listens to me when I say - she has always been contrary, controlling and never valued my opinions. It is all wrapped up in ‘cognitive decline’ possible ‘dementia’. All really horrible for people with it but I have lived almost 60 years of manipulative behaviours.

Always just a bit off key but to make herself seem superior.

Yep. Your experiences with your mother sound so uncannily familiar - except mine definitely did eventually have dementia, which was not recognised by anyone for quite a while because her irrational behaviour, deliberate obfuscation and contrariness were just so ‘normal’ and we were so used to it, no red flags were raised.

What is strange how some of these jigsaw pieces and forgotten incidents suddenly come back to you too. Whilst typing my reply earlier, I remembered a very odd incident some 20 years ago when I’d offered to drive her to a ladies club social do that we were both invited to. I’d agreed to pick up a friend of hers on the way, but at the last moment, my husband volunteered to drop us so I could have a drink too. When I told her this was now the arrangement, she had an absolute and illogical meltdown. She literally screamed at me and told me it was so embarrassing as she had told the other woman I was driving. It made absolutely no sense whatsoever as it made no difference to her. She did a similar thing, embarrassingly at a funeral. In order to reduce the number of cars, we arranged to share with another couple and she was included, but she threw a hissy fit because it wasn’t the way she wanted it.

BlueLegume · 21/01/2025 18:57

@JohnPrescottsPyjamas it is so interesting putting the lifetime of jigsaw pieces together. Sadly though no one really listens to me when I say - she has always been contrary, controlling and never valued my opinions. It is all wrapped up in ‘cognitive decline’ possible ‘dementia’. All really horrible for people with it but I have lived almost 60 years of manipulative behaviours.

Always just a bit off key but to make herself seem superior.

OP posts:
JohnPrescottsPyjamas · 21/01/2025 18:47

Zucker · 21/01/2025 18:29

This could be a defining moment for you all @BlueLegume
Continue to be the "bad daughter" and don't step in this time. Let the cards fall where they will. I'm going through something vaguely similar with my own father at the moment and I've now reached this point.

I think some folks need to hit rock bottom and as adults they are entitled to fall to their rock bottom if they wish. We, as the children, don't need to be the safety nets if we are going to harm ourselves in the process.

That’s very wise advice. It’s not easy, and because we’re all so programmed and expected to be respectful and kind to a parent, it goes against the grain, but it’s true, she’s an adult that’s been assessed as having full capacity and therefore able to make her own choices.

I never realised at the time, and this thread has opened my eyes to the fact that the time keeping nonsense my mother also indulged in, was a way of pushing boundaries. I always knew she would arrive at least an hour earlier than we had agreed, even if I had explained that there was a reason for a specific time. If she was staying in my house, she would get up ridiculously early and then proceed to make a lot of noise, turning up the TV or radio and crashing around until it was impossible to ignore her - this could be 5am at the weekend! She would then make comments about “laziness” and “people who are bone idle”

Zucker · 21/01/2025 18:29

This could be a defining moment for you all @BlueLegume
Continue to be the "bad daughter" and don't step in this time. Let the cards fall where they will. I'm going through something vaguely similar with my own father at the moment and I've now reached this point.

I think some folks need to hit rock bottom and as adults they are entitled to fall to their rock bottom if they wish. We, as the children, don't need to be the safety nets if we are going to harm ourselves in the process.

HoraceGoesBonkers · 21/01/2025 18:21

Yep, mine did similar about timekeeping but only ever being early, and any sort of attempt to put down boundaries (please don't turn up early/please don't book a hotel in the town we live in without checking dates) resulted in a huff and/or tears.

I think she's made her position really clear so if you haven't already, tell her there is no way you're moving in and leave her to stew for a bit, and make this clear to your brother.

I think any attempt to help her now, at least until it's sunk in, will be interpreted as you leaving the door open to becoming a live in carer.

My mum had quite a few goes at hinting about me caring for my Dad, the one time she outright told me I had to do it I phoned her back the next day and said I couldn't, she then pretended she hadn't asked me! Then she started again a bit later.

BlueLegume · 21/01/2025 16:34

@JohnPrescottsPyjamas @EmotionalBlackmail if it wasn't so horrible to live with it would be incredibly fascinating. As to the over complicating of invitations she has also always been really odd around them…’oh but you are busy’ ‘it’s too much work for you’ the list is endless BUT then she massively outstays her welcome - think me inviting them - I am going back to the early 2000s so well before ‘old age’ kicked in…Sunday lunch. Mum and Dad I will be serving the roast dinner around 2pm. If you come for say 1.30 that will be great. The children have school tomorrow so it would be helpful if we wound the afternoon up around 5 ish so we can get school ready and have an early night.

The various incidents off the back of this type of exchange include:
Being late by an hour at least.
Arriving an hour early but expecting to be entertained.
Saying ‘if you are laying down rules and times we’ll not bother as it’s clearly inconvenient having us.
Coming in their car but arranging a taxi home ‘so we can enjoy some wine with our meal’ and said taxi being ordered far later than is convenient when you have young children and refusing to budge when you say you will sort a taxi for them because they will only use the taxi firm local to them
The last one also then came with the next day message of ‘oh Blue can you come and pick Dad up so he can get our car from your house?’……an hour away on a good day.

So yet more examples of transactional behaviour well before ‘old age’ kicked in.

What I will say is how impressed I have been with the attitudes of the social workers. Zero expectations of us in fact very much advising to ‘let the ball drop’ and then they can intervene - within reason obviously. Yet another conversation with our mother today where my sister asked about the carers our brother keeps telling mum he will organise if she doesn’t start trying…apparently he hasn’t organised anything yet but he is planning on talking to mum about it next week. Rather like his parents head in the sand and keep putting things off until one of the bad daughters eventually sorts it.

OP posts:
EmotionalBlackmail · 21/01/2025 16:01

This transactional relationship stuff is very familiar. Not only with [female] children but there's a weird transactional thing going on with friends where she can't accept an invitation to do something as she then has to invite them back and she can't be doing with that, so she doesn't accept the invitation. Or she decided the invitation would "put them out" even though they're the ones doing the inviting so she declines out of pity for them. It's a completely warped view of relationships.

I definitely don't keep tabs on relationships with friends and whose turn it is for whatever!

JohnPrescottsPyjamas · 21/01/2025 15:08

@BlueLegume That’s really helpful and clearly very cognisant advice from the SW. They’ve obviously come across this similar behaviour before, which hopefully is of some reassurance to you?

Fascinated by this reference to ‘transactional behaviour’ as I recognise it so well. I always referred to it as my mother’s ‘payback’ routine. Everything always had a metaphorical price. If she did me a perceived favour - even one not asked for - she would almost set up a tab and call in my emotional debts. She would endlessly refer to the ‘sacrifices’ she made for me as a child, how she gave up a career, her social life, overseas holidays etc etc to ensure she was always there for me. Ironically, she wasn’t interested in a career, had very transient friendships and never wanted to go overseas as she didn’t like anything foreign anyway. My father brought wealth into the marriage so she never wanted for anything and always had the financial clout to do everything she always wanted, so she never actually forfeited or had to compromise on anything.

i must be a very similar age group to you as I was brought up in the same era and so much resonates the same way.

“I never want to be a burden to you” was a regular mantra too, despite her being incredibly needy, pretending she couldn’t cope and then, once she’d got my attention, demanding everything was done her way or we’d have the temper tantrum and sulks. Followed then by the reminders about how much she’d done for me when I was a child. Once I became a mother myself, I realised that being parent does involve giving up certain things and compromising on others, but that’s entirely the life choice I’ve made and I don’t hold my children responsible for those choices and I certainly didn’t have them for insurance and to recruit as free carers for my old age.

BlueLegume · 21/01/2025 13:57

Thought I would update you lovely people. Adult Social services have been in touch to tell us that our mother cannot be forced to have a care / needs assessment. The social worker was incredibly helpful and answered my questions when I asked how my mother reacted. It was no surprise to hear that my mother had told the SW that she would not accepts carers as and I quote ‘I did not put any of my 3 children in care when they were babies or children and I gave up my job to be a housewife to look after them myself’. The SW told me that mum clearly expects this ‘transactional behaviour’ to be repaid now she requires care. SW was clear there is absolutely no expectation from them for us to do this but we do have choices and one of those choices can be to back away and let the crisis happen.

My mother’s response speaks volumes about her. She clearly feels she is ‘owed’ this care from family because of ‘sacrifices’ we did not ask her to make when we were babies. The reality is that in the 1960s she just did what most parents did and IF she did it because she was ‘banking’ on us ‘looking after her’ in old age she should have made it clear to us and not spend her life telling us and anyone who would listen that ‘I will never ever be a burden to Blue, Blues sis and Blue baby brother’.

OP posts:
BlueLegume · 20/01/2025 13:06

Thanks @JohnPrescottsPyjamas she definitely has always lacked empathy but sadly I think her personality ‘thrives’ on negativity. @HoraceGoesBonkers I am comfortable knowing I cannot do anything right for her so if people see fit to criticise then I will just have to suck it up. We are now at a stage where all her half truths to family, neighbours and friends are getting found out. Her response is always ‘oh I didn’t mean to give them that impression’. But she did because in the moment she portrayed herself as a victim and garnered sympathy and attention. A recent one was a neighbour who explained our mother had said 18 months ago ‘Blue isn’t speaking to me because I put (Blues Dads name) in a home and Blue wanted me to look after him at home.’ This is the absolute opposite of what happened I had to fight tooth and nail for my mother and brother to see he needed residential care. I even offered to pay the fees…we luckily got CHC so that never happened but you get that I wanted him in the home so he could be properly cared for. I have tried to contact ASS today again as I am so fed up and whilst walking away seems easy on paper it is so hard to do in real life.

OP posts:
HoraceGoesBonkers · 20/01/2025 12:37

Also, she only owns all the cards if you let her. At the end of the day if you don't see her you can have a nicer life without her. She on the other hand loses a lot of support.

HoraceGoesBonkers · 20/01/2025 12:33

I remember finding out my "D"M had been badmouthing me to other family members despite all the travel I'd put in, I wish I'd said something at the time but didn't and it just really festered away at me.

I would have a think about whether it's worth telling your brother that things he has said are getting back to you. And also whether it's worth saying that you're going to do nothing whatsoever until you they both start meeting some conditions (reasonable expectations, self care, whatever). And then just sack the pair of them off until their attitude gets better.

Expecting you to give up your life and move in is a ludicrous expectation and you need to make it very clear that it's not ever happening, and they need to get the idea out of their heads.

BlueLegume · 19/01/2025 21:09

@Lastknownaddress yeah totally get it. Kind of have my stuff in hand as you say. Just the expectations of a very superior SIL - and our brother who seems to also have expectations but never voices them until I/we sis ‘fail’ is exhausting. Savage is a brilliant word. ☺️

OP posts:
Lastknownaddress · 19/01/2025 21:01

@BlueLegume so sorry to hear this. It feels awfully familiar. For what it is worth the bit I am finding hardest at the moment is not M. She is so frail right now that it is hard to see anything of her former self, but other family members behaviour is nothing but accusatory. It is savage.

Have a hand hold.

willowthecat · 19/01/2025 18:03

It's extremely difficult. As long as the elderly person is deemed to have the capacity to make the decision to refuse help then you cannot force this on them. All you can do is to make it very clear to anyone who criticises you that your dm is refusing help, that this is very upsetting for you; but unless they can suggest a way to break the logjam then they should not ask the impossible of you either. Ask them if they have personal experience of help refusal in an elderly relative - what do they suggest ? At least you can put the ball back in their court if nothing else.

JohnPrescottsPyjamas · 19/01/2025 12:47

BlueLegume · 19/01/2025 11:26

@Bonbon21 wise words.Thank you. Brother just keeps saying things like ‘but she is your Mum’, or telling people that ‘Blue just doesn’t care like I do’. It is so frustrating-over the years I have been the one who did all the ‘boring stuff’ like admin etc around LPAs etc. Suddenly he is the Messiah all knowing and caring wonderful son who only a few years ago admitted when he spoke to Mum he just put her on speaker and ‘got on with jobs’. He has zero concept of the support my sister and I have given over our whole life whilst he was allowed to swan off and do his own thing yet we were expected to be dutiful daughters. Grrr. thanks for listening/reading and reiterating sensible boundaries.

I’m truly sorry that things haven’t improved whatsoever. Unfortunately, these type of personalities don’t ‘get better’ and have no empathy or concept of the impact they are having on those around them.

@Bonbon21 is absolutely right too. Just because she’s your mother doesn’t mean she gets to treat you like this either. I know it’s not easy, but try and block out comments from relatives and outsiders. They see a very short snapshot and are very judgemental when there’s a whole backstory and bigger picture. I’m sure your brother skirts around the edges because he feels he’s done his bit and therefore absolved of any responsibility.

The fact your mother is happy for you to give up your life to look after her might be an opportunity to call her bluff. Acknowledge that she’s possibly right, but as you are not “a professional or qualified” it would make sense to get a third party involved who can provide far better “quality service” My mother was a inveterate snob and loved to be queen bee. She was also
ferociously and aggressively against any form of outside care, but once she realised it was all about her, she was getting undivided attention and someone was pandering to her every whim, she loved it! Could you possibly sell it to her as “just someone who is popping in to help with housework” rather than a carer, which has negative connotations to older people?

I wish I could offer some more practical advice, but just to let you know I empathise absolutely. I remember so much the damned if you do, damned if you don’t scenarios, the guilt tripping by others and regularly leaving after a visit sobbing with tears of impotent anger and frustration because I’d let her get under my skin.

xxx

BlueLegume · 19/01/2025 11:26

@Bonbon21 wise words.Thank you. Brother just keeps saying things like ‘but she is your Mum’, or telling people that ‘Blue just doesn’t care like I do’. It is so frustrating-over the years I have been the one who did all the ‘boring stuff’ like admin etc around LPAs etc. Suddenly he is the Messiah all knowing and caring wonderful son who only a few years ago admitted when he spoke to Mum he just put her on speaker and ‘got on with jobs’. He has zero concept of the support my sister and I have given over our whole life whilst he was allowed to swan off and do his own thing yet we were expected to be dutiful daughters. Grrr. thanks for listening/reading and reiterating sensible boundaries.

OP posts:
Bonbon21 · 19/01/2025 11:02

Ask yourself if you would accept this behaviour from ANY other person on the planet?

Then why from someone who is your mother ONLY because she gave birth to you.
That biological fact does not give her special rights to manipulate you AND your family for her own purposes.
Consider the damage she is inflicting on YOUR kids and extended family, not only on yourself. Then step away from her... protect them.. the way a Mother should behave.
Other people will always believe what they want to believe.. no matter what you do, say or want. You do not have to answer to them.
Look after yourself.

BlueLegume · 19/01/2025 10:45

@FiniteSagacity thank you - half the problem is that our brother isn’t necessarily ’useless’ he does do things BUT he just criticises absolutely everything we do and listens to half truths from Mum, such as that she has not heard from us. He then has a massive go at both of us and when we or I me specifically point out 1) we speak to our mother regularly - he responds with ‘oh I didn’t know that 2) we send him updates on things we have done for/with Mum just so he knows and doesn’t waste his time repeating them- his response is ‘we are all doing things we just don’t keep telling everyone’. The problem with not sharing factual information is she ends up with 3 loaves for example because she has told each of us she doesn’t have any bread so we turn up with one. She won’t use the freezer so that is not an option.
I have weeks where I really stand firm with boundaries but even so every call with my mother is fraught. She uses such cliched hyperbolic language she would have you believe she has zero food, no clothes to wear, no access to her money. The list is endless. She would love to be able to tell people that one of us had no choice but to move in as it would make her feel special. Sadly, I also discovered that our brother has been badmouthing me in particular to anyone who will listen. It appears he is also relishing in the fact he is the only one doing anything to support her and people are ‘aghast’ at how awful Blue has been - perhaps put my shoes on and walk in them for 60 years.
The phone one is tricky. She has a habit of ringing and hanging up then when you call back she says it is a mistake but of course she then has you and has another list of problems. I will revisit all the advice as I know it is invaluable. Thank you again

OP posts:
FiniteSagacity · 19/01/2025 10:25

@BlueLegume I’m so sorry, most especially that your brother is being useless in working with you and your sister as a team - which would show your mother that manipulating each of you is useless because you all talk to each other.

Have you thought about your boundaries, simply what you are prepared to do and no more beyond that? I know in all the endless ‘need’ that it can be hard to draw those lines but it gives you back some sense of control.

Are you taking back the little bits of control, such as turning your phone off at night (I have it set so only my DC could reach me during do not disturb/sleep).

BlueLegume · 19/01/2025 08:09

Morning all and thanks @JohnPrescottsPyjamas for asking how things are. Grim to be honest. The post from @Lastknownaddress was incredibly sobering. It made me realise however proactive I am my mother is holding all the cards and is gradually reeling us in so we do things her way. As it stands and she admitted this to me last week, she would agree to one of us moving in as she doesn’t like being alone. When I clarified it with her and asked if she was prepared to accept that would see one of us having to leave our partners of many decades, our homes, our own lives etc her response was ‘it’s terrible isn’t ;t it Blue but I think it the only thing that will work’. She has form of pushing people to their limits and I am convinced she gets a buzz out of seeing that she has done this. I make that point as our brother is convinced she has dementia or some cognitive decline. We have no diagnosis and having reflected on her lifetime of behaviour this is just the same. Our brother utterly dismisses this point which has not only been made by my sister and I but various extended family members, neighbours, all of whom she has had run ins with and family friends - all of whom stuck around for our Dad’s sake but now he is in residential care they are nowhere to be seen.
I received a call out of the blue a few weeks ago from an old friend of the family who had called to the house and was shocked at what they saw. The call began as a ‘why aren’t you supporting her’ rant. I calmly explained that we have tried absolutely everything and nothing ever meets with Mums approval. If anything she is utterly defiant towards every single bit of help or support. The wrong washing cycle was used; the food supplied is ‘inedible’.
Adult social care have contacted her she has refused to engage. She will not attend a GP appointment she will not do anything to help herself at all. But she is prepared to ruin our lives. Our brother is impossible. He keeps threatening her saying he will ‘use his POA’ but he doesn’t get that whilst she is deemed to have capacity he cannot do so. Previous posts and threads mention that this behaviour and poor choices are likely dementia - then in our case our mother has had this her whole life. She is no different than normal just more defiant and quietly demanding knowing which buttons to press to ‘frighten’ and guilt trip us into driving across - an hour in my case on a good run. Yes it is obvious we need to leave her but the fear of ignoring the obligation and guilt this situation brings is hard to deal with. So in answer to the kind question - things are grim and there is absolutely no light at the end of the tunnel. She has sabotaged our lives and is holding us to ransom continually moving the goal posts until one of us caves, likely me or my sister and up sticks from our husbands to become her full time carers. She has made it clear she will not allow carers in even though our brother has said he is going to have some sorted. He won’t he is full of hot air. I have offered to pay for a PA type carer - she has refused to even consider it. It is very clear her expectations- and that of our brother - is that as two early retired sister we should be available to step in. It is utterly awful. Thanks for reading I needed that vent.

OP posts:
BlueLegume · 18/01/2025 13:04

Ah thanks @JohnPrescottsPyjamas just nipping out for some much needed exercise but I will do an update this weekend.

OP posts: