Please or to access all these features

Elderly parents

Sibling not taking responsibility

91 replies

Willowcat77 · 26/08/2024 09:36

How common is it that when an elderly parent starts becoming needy all the responsibility for them falls on one child and the others just disappear?

This is what has happened to me. My 85 year old mother had a stroke and the OH nurse said she needs as much interaction as possible from family and friends for her brain to recover, but the only person to have stepped up is me. I am now literally the only person who helps and interacts with her. My brother doesn't even phone her any more. He was the Golden Child so my mum is distraught. He won't even answer the phone when she tries to call him. When my dad was alive he borrowed a large amount of money from them and never paid them back, despite my parents needing it and fretting about it. Now in my mum's hour of need he has simply abandoned her.

When I texted him to find out why he is ignoring my mum he didn't answer but I got an extremely nasty text from his girlfriend saying to leave him alone because he is stressed. For context I have never asked much of him, I have always been pleasant to him and his girlfriend and very rarely asked him for support with my parents. But when my mum had her stroke surely it's not unreasonable to expect him to at least call her from time to time? He was happy enough to accept help from her when she was well.

I'm not well myself and have a disability, but my brother doesn't seem to care. He is rich and successful and I am not, due to my Autism, but I am expected to do everything alone. I feel so hurt, angry and let down by my brother and overwhelmed by the responsibility for my mum. I have no choice but to help her as she is very frail but will not accept carers or any outside help.

Is this a normal dynamic, when everything falls on the one sibling and the others just abandon the needy parent?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TizerorFizz · 27/08/2024 19:57

You won’t get free help unless you are on pension credit with next to no savings. You have to pay. Community nurses only do nursing, not other needs. It’s actually a nightmare.

eggplant16 · 27/08/2024 19:55

Lampzade · 27/08/2024 17:30

I was just about to say the same thing.
They are often the most entitled to boot

This is a myth. It is unlikey to happen, What is more is that somebody will whisper in Mums ear and get the lot.

As I said, Watch your back.

TizerorFizz · 27/08/2024 19:45

@AllPrincessAnneshorses Yes. I knew it was illegal. In the end mum paid for carers and had two lovely ladies. They were great. I rather suspect MPs are impotent in this. SS just don’t have the staff.

did get a phone call after DMs last stay in hospital. Social worker said she had spoken to the hospital and DM was coming home with 4 visits a day. This wasn’t what the discharge team or OPs had said to me. They said a care home. That was clearly the only possibility! I think SS thought they were paying so 4 visits a day was their cheapest offering. Mum went to a care home and died 6 months later. She was over 100 though. I never had 1 second of help from SS or my sisters. One of whom didn’t turn up to DMs 100 th birthday, or her children. So DH and me are done with them. Sticks in my throat that they are getting half her estate.

BruFord · 27/08/2024 17:49

EmotionalBlackmail · 27/08/2024 17:26

That's what some carers do though. They might be called something like a PA more often but they can do things like shopping, assist with admin, provide companionship, drive/accompany to appointments.

@EmotionalBlackmail Ah, I didn’t realize that. I’m assuming that the Mum would need to pay for the service? That might be a sticking point.

BlueLegume · 27/08/2024 17:32

@Willowcat77 such an interesting conversation thread. Similar situation very unpleasant mother, DF was her enabler and in his defence he had no real option as she was so controlling. Sister and I have done a lot of life admin in past 3 to 5 or so years. Ridiculous requests by mother for food delivery in Covid. Refused to accept supermarket delivery so we had to keep driving over with her very specific orders. I realise we didn’t need to but it was hard to say no. Fast forward DF needed nursing home care. Sis and I spent a week calling places explaining his needs and eventually found one. DBrother kept using the excuse he was ‘supporting my Mum’. Rubbish excuse as he ‘popped in’ occasionally. He was always the blue eyed boy as a kid. Daft as to be honest-really iffy life choices but in our mother’s eyes it was never ever his fault. DSis and I are pretty broken at the moment and overwhelmed at the fact mother refuses to engage with any help except us nearly 60 year olds cleaning for her, buying food and generally stepping up. My DSis (incredibly patient and stoical) partner sent our mother a text late last year asking her to not keep bothering the adult grandchildren at all times of day as they are busy and live on the other side of the country. DBrother showed the text to “everyone “ who proceeded to be “gobsmacked” at the “cruelty”. There is nothing wrong with our mother.She has always been the same so no change in behaviour. He seems to have failed to tell “everyone “ anything my DSis and I have done - my guess is they would be right to be “gobsmacked” if they knew the truth. Like mother like son is my thought. As ever thanks for the support and option to VENT. I watched the 102 year old do the Sky dive yesterday and pondered the fact whilst our mother wouldn’t do a skydive she could live another 20 years and I’ll be nearly 80 scrubbing her shower , shopping etc. Honestly I don’t think I can.

Lampzade · 27/08/2024 17:30

crumblingschools · 26/08/2024 11:13

Bet these absent siblings won’t be so absent when the will is read

I was just about to say the same thing.
They are often the most entitled to boot

EmotionalBlackmail · 27/08/2024 17:26

That's what some carers do though. They might be called something like a PA more often but they can do things like shopping, assist with admin, provide companionship, drive/accompany to appointments.

BruFord · 27/08/2024 16:15

Her Mum doesn’t need carers in the usual sense though, she needs someone to help with shopping and admin, and she needs company. Carers typically help with physical needs, getting someone out of bed, washed, etc.

WhatNoRaisins · 27/08/2024 13:12

Honestly I'd be very reluctant to get involved caring for someone that was refusing carers. I know it's selfish but I wouldn't want to risk getting in over my head.

eggplant16 · 27/08/2024 13:11

Elderly and disabled people DO NOT HAVE THE RIGHT to turn down services and then expect their family to do the work

I'm sorry but they very much do have that right. As cognitive decline sets in and the neural pathways are less flexible, they may choose to exercise that right. Common sense leaves the building, elderly friends and neighbours collude. Other people see it as an opportunity to slag off family members ( female) who make themselves ill trying to help.

Floppyelf · 27/08/2024 05:23

YourHangryQuail · 26/08/2024 11:42

I treat people based on how they treated me in their prime, when life was easier for them.

So my dad spent his 20’s, 30’s, 40’s, 50’s and early 60’s getting high on cocaine and alcohol. He went to rehab 3 years ago and has been clean since. He is expecting everyone to rally round him and for him to basically pick up from where he left us in childhood.

I’m a parent myself and have had to sacrifice like most parents for my children, my dad never did. I can’t fully forgive him, so when he says how lonely he is I think well you made your bed.

He is very charming but once you speak to him a few times he becomes a racist who says things about how my mum stopped him seeing us which is a lie. I have to keep fact checking him it’s just that he has no excuse for why he preferred to get high to seeing his own children. When he gets like this I have to space out the calls again until he goes back to being surface level nice.

Was your mum nice to you? Were you the scape goat? If you were I would be doing the bare minimum and getting carers in.

When your children grow up and know the truth ( as they should) they will be really proud of you. I wouldn’t even keep in contact with your dad

BruFord · 26/08/2024 22:16

As your Mum doesn’t need physical help, you might want to contact Adult Social Services about someone to help her with admin., etc. After my step-mum died, my elderly Dad was struggling and a Community Assessor helped him with admin/practical matters for several weeks. They support people who are struggling with difficult situations, not just bereavement. It’s worth contacting them and seeing if that type of help is available in your area. A stroke is a life-changing event.

AllPrincessAnneshorses · 26/08/2024 22:10

TizerorFizz · 26/08/2024 15:36

@DoreenonTill8 Where we live, SS just don’t do them. They are supposed to come to
the home and assess what the elderly person can do. They don’t. DM left hospital 3 times with nothing in place. Every time - over 90. As soon as they sniff a relative, they won’t bother. So you have to pay. Then DM tells you about all those dutiful daughters she knows! The ones who simply give up their lives for their parents. I’ve got dc and a dh. DM had to accept my life was not going to be purely looking after her. Working together with give and take is what is best but not 100% on one sibling.

If they really don't, and it is not her decision to refuse an assessment (which can happen and can seem on the surface like SS refusal], that is against the law and you should contact your MP..

AllPrincessAnneshorses · 26/08/2024 22:06

Willowcat77 · 26/08/2024 09:36

How common is it that when an elderly parent starts becoming needy all the responsibility for them falls on one child and the others just disappear?

This is what has happened to me. My 85 year old mother had a stroke and the OH nurse said she needs as much interaction as possible from family and friends for her brain to recover, but the only person to have stepped up is me. I am now literally the only person who helps and interacts with her. My brother doesn't even phone her any more. He was the Golden Child so my mum is distraught. He won't even answer the phone when she tries to call him. When my dad was alive he borrowed a large amount of money from them and never paid them back, despite my parents needing it and fretting about it. Now in my mum's hour of need he has simply abandoned her.

When I texted him to find out why he is ignoring my mum he didn't answer but I got an extremely nasty text from his girlfriend saying to leave him alone because he is stressed. For context I have never asked much of him, I have always been pleasant to him and his girlfriend and very rarely asked him for support with my parents. But when my mum had her stroke surely it's not unreasonable to expect him to at least call her from time to time? He was happy enough to accept help from her when she was well.

I'm not well myself and have a disability, but my brother doesn't seem to care. He is rich and successful and I am not, due to my Autism, but I am expected to do everything alone. I feel so hurt, angry and let down by my brother and overwhelmed by the responsibility for my mum. I have no choice but to help her as she is very frail but will not accept carers or any outside help.

Is this a normal dynamic, when everything falls on the one sibling and the others just abandon the needy parent?

Former older people's social worker here. It's so common I used to expect it, and was always pleasantly surprised when siblings worked together. My sis and I have not had the best relationship over the years but we did band together to care for our dying mum. Partly because of my experiences.

GreatTheCat · 26/08/2024 22:04

I've got a very weak and pathetic mother. She used to be a rock for me and my sisters but from the age of 65 she's become unbearable.

My dad died 4 years ago. She's become old and unbearable. Doesn't move out of her chair.

But I visit 3 times a week... I can't /won't do anything to help her as I've had a Stroke!

gamerchick · 26/08/2024 22:02

You reap what you sow with your kids. Your mother is seeing that now.

You don't have to do everything though. You can step back and force her to accept outside help.

Willowcat77 · 26/08/2024 21:58

Thanks for all your replies I really appreciate it. My mum doesn't need nursing care but she is now like a frightened child so needs practical help and lots of reassurance and kindness. That's impossible to outsource, unfortunately. She has a weird ability to mask how bad she is when medical professionals are around, so they say she has 'capacity', but I don't think she has. She is a Jehovah's Witness but is too scared to go to meetings any more and they have given up on her, so she is extremely isolated and depressed. I am the only person who helps her and the responsibility is terrifying.

OP posts:
PermanentTemporary · 26/08/2024 21:22

Op please read @AnnaMagnani's post above, it's very important.

Your mum's stroke and the changes in her must have been such a shock to you. By the sound of it, she's not getting the kind of therapy she has the right to expect. I work for a stroke team and I know how we sometimes load things onto the family that they really should push back on - they should ask us to imagine what they are dealing with. But so often they want so desperately to help that they just agree without questions. And then you have this frankly unacceptable response from your brother. Not even calling your mum is pathetic. The distress that causes her, and the anger you feel, is yet more on your shoulders.

Ask the occupational therapist for more information. The stroke association, Age UK may have help, and there are often local organisations that can help too. Tell the OT what's going on.

LifeExperience · 26/08/2024 21:14

Mum needs to accept carers, and if she won't you need to back off until she will. Elderly and disabled people DO NOT HAVE THE RIGHT to turn down services and then expect their family to do the work. And I say that as a woman in my 60s with a painful physical disability. Your mum is the one being unreasonable here.

As for your brother, he's a lousy human being for not contacting his mum, but you can't change him. There are no magic words to make him step up, so stop driving yourself crazy trying to get him to do something he won't. Get carers for mum and let db make his own (poor) decisions.

AthenaBasil · 26/08/2024 21:03

SimpleSnarf · 26/08/2024 12:50

Well. Ready to be flamed for questioning an individuals right to do whatever the hell they please but…..
of course he should call her OP. And visit. And generally help. No wonder things are the state they are with all these people expecting everyone else to do the hard work. What was it one of you said ‘must do what’s right for the individual’ my goodness, what a truly depressing nihilistic selfish attitude.
if you want community, society and family support - you do rather have to participate in it.
if your parent was half decent and not abusive the idea you just walk away and do what’s right for you is beyond sickening, if you think the current NHS can provide above minimal care and you want your mum to sit in her own s**t then go for it.
Sometimes we have to do hard, unpleasant, difficult things because they are the right thing to do. But the levels of selfishness all around have now reached the heights that apparently none of us even owe care to a decent parent. Obligation and reciprocity is the bedrock of society. And frankly, most of us are rejecting it.

Completely agree!

EnchantedEspresso · 26/08/2024 20:49

I feel if you can communicate somehow with your brother mum needs a carer can he pay some at least, maybe it would ease the burden? It sounds awful I am sorry you are stuck with this. I agree with many posters about brothers being favourites then disappearing when their mum needs them. A future scenario I’m sure I’m going to encounter.

BCBird · 26/08/2024 20:46

Where possible outsource all.the things that can be done so that u can continue being daughter instead of carer. It will better for everyone all round. This will preserve your relationship. U will be able to do the 'nice' things instead of chores.

eggplant16 · 26/08/2024 20:43

Watch your back would be my advice.

BruFord · 26/08/2024 20:41

it sounds as if your brother has always been a selfish person who takes from others rather than gives. Unfortunately, people like that don’t suddenly become kind and caring when their parents become elderly.

You just have accept that he’s not a kind person. If you want to have a go at him about it, go ahead, but don’t be surprised if it doesn’t achieve anything.

Re. Social interaction. Do you have any other relatives or family friends who might be willing to ring/visit your Mum sometimes if you explained that she’s lonely? I’m quite upfront about this for my widowed Dad and have asked ppl to keep in touch with him-and most do. Just the occasional phone call can make a big difference.

DoreenonTill8 · 26/08/2024 20:13

I think @Stressmess post above has it with It's just never ending and I'd add to that, it's never enough...