Please or to access all these features

Elderly parents

Dreading speaking to parents

81 replies

ScandiNoirNuit · 19/05/2024 15:45

This is going to sound really selfish, but I dread speaking to my parents. They are so negative and everything is always doom and gloom. It is understandable to some extent in that my dad has dementia (not too bad currently but obv declining) but is also pretty immobile but it seems like there is no joy in anything. Every time I call my mum is in tears and just seems really depressed, but won’t go to the doctor to consider antidepressants. My dad is on them, with a whole cocktail of other things.

I think what I find most frustrating is that they won’t do anything to make themselves feel better. They are well off but v frugal, unnecessarily so. They recently started getting attendance allowance but refuse to spend it, just putting it in bank. Isa’s maxed already. I have tried suggesting they use for taxis, photo, cleaner or whatever to help but they refuse despite having ample means. Mum pretty much refuses to drive despite being able and having car, so that really limits things. They could get taxis places but wouldn’t countenance it despite her saying she would love to get out. I don’t know what to suggest, everything has been rejected, it seems like all she wants to do is moan about how terrible life is, which I understand but there are definitely things that could be done to make it easier or more enjoyable.

does anyone else have this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SiobhanSharpe · 19/12/2024 11:25

DrJonesIpresume · 19/05/2024 22:34

I have a sneaking suspicion that they are waiting for you to step in and take over. Take them out, help with the garden and everything else, and they probably just don't 'get' that things are different nowadays and you can't because you have a job. Most women of their generation were housewives. That generation is also renowned for refusing to pay for anything if they can manage without.

I thought this too -- that they want you to help and nobody else.
Partly because that's the expectation (daughters should help elderly parents) and posibly also because it will be cheaper, if not free.
If they're not saying so they may well do so yet (or send flying monkeys emissaries to lay the guilt on you)
Sorry, it's really hard for you but it may get worse unless you have the conversation.

ScandiNoirNuit · 19/12/2024 09:04

Apparationsaythemoment · 18/12/2024 17:30

I'm sure she does, my DF has dementia and people aren't all affected in the same way and over different time scales. I could take him out (not that he'd ever go) and he'd be no problem.

Yes, this.

OP posts:
Apparationsaythemoment · 18/12/2024 17:30

Flopsythebunny · 18/12/2024 17:21

Have you any idea how difficult it is to take someone with dementia out, or even leave them alone while you go out?

I'm sure she does, my DF has dementia and people aren't all affected in the same way and over different time scales. I could take him out (not that he'd ever go) and he'd be no problem.

Flopsythebunny · 18/12/2024 17:21

ScandiNoirNuit · 19/05/2024 15:45

This is going to sound really selfish, but I dread speaking to my parents. They are so negative and everything is always doom and gloom. It is understandable to some extent in that my dad has dementia (not too bad currently but obv declining) but is also pretty immobile but it seems like there is no joy in anything. Every time I call my mum is in tears and just seems really depressed, but won’t go to the doctor to consider antidepressants. My dad is on them, with a whole cocktail of other things.

I think what I find most frustrating is that they won’t do anything to make themselves feel better. They are well off but v frugal, unnecessarily so. They recently started getting attendance allowance but refuse to spend it, just putting it in bank. Isa’s maxed already. I have tried suggesting they use for taxis, photo, cleaner or whatever to help but they refuse despite having ample means. Mum pretty much refuses to drive despite being able and having car, so that really limits things. They could get taxis places but wouldn’t countenance it despite her saying she would love to get out. I don’t know what to suggest, everything has been rejected, it seems like all she wants to do is moan about how terrible life is, which I understand but there are definitely things that could be done to make it easier or more enjoyable.

does anyone else have this?

Have you any idea how difficult it is to take someone with dementia out, or even leave them alone while you go out?

MsNik · 18/12/2024 16:45

I avoid speaking to my parents for the same reasons. I've now not spoken to them for weeks, so I'm really going to have to call them soon, and I know how that will go.

Puppetsky · 18/12/2024 16:36

I read the Telegraph, and I’m sure others do here on this board. So churning out tired clichés is both rude and ignorant. Ironically it only exposes the posters’ own arrogance and self-piety.

Puppetsky · 18/12/2024 16:30

Crikeyalmighty · 15/12/2024 12:04

@Bohemond23 well off people are often well off for a reason- in your parents case it's because they are mean as shit , both in cash and spirit -it will bite them on the arse one day - my father in law at 85 is the opposite and consequently I always want to help him out - it's not the cash - it's the generosity of spirit

Agree. Generosity of spirit.

Maybe it’s some kind of secret power - or oneupmanship at least in my relative’s case. In the case of narcissism there’s a lot of watching and withholding from others, even occasionally for themselves. I think hoarding tendencies come into play too.

But the mean spiritedness does backfire in a way. I never do anything back out of ‘generosity’ either. I do the minimum. I don’t enjoy buying presents or anything giving like that as everything is being measured and controlled.

Apparationsaythemoment · 16/12/2024 20:18

Crikeyalmighty · 21/05/2024 10:09

I can guarantee most of these moaning , mean as shit people read the express, mail or Telegraph too! These papers are full of hate on people not like themselves and I guarantee are enough to bring anyone down!! I feel very sorry for anyone with chronic illness/dementia and who genuinely has limited options- but there are so many who are actually self limiting- purely by being mean - they probably think they are doing their family a favour by leaving more cash- but they really aren't- most of us would rather they had somewhat less cash/assets - but an easier and more fulfilling later years that we could share in with them

Yup Telegraph for mine!

moggerhanger · 15/12/2024 16:09

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 21/05/2024 17:38

After she sold her car at just over 80, my DM could have taken stacks of taxis with the money she was saving on petrol, road tax, servicing, MOTs and insuarance - not to mention the sale price of the car.

But would she? Never! Not even once. She wasn’t at all hard up, but certainly had been in the past, and in her head taxis were still A Great Extravagance.
It was so frustrating!

My late DM had many faults. But I will always be grateful for her pragmatic approach to transport. Her driving ability was getting worse, and one day after a near-miss with a cyclist, she sat down and calculated how much it cost to run a car each year (including depreciation), and then translated it into taxi fares. Goggled at the number, sold the car immediately, and enjoyed door to door trips into town thereafter.

Crikeyalmighty · 15/12/2024 12:04

@Bohemond23 well off people are often well off for a reason- in your parents case it's because they are mean as shit , both in cash and spirit -it will bite them on the arse one day - my father in law at 85 is the opposite and consequently I always want to help him out - it's not the cash - it's the generosity of spirit

Bohemond23 · 15/12/2024 11:53

Joining please. I feel the same about my parents. We are 3 hours away. I reluctantly call once a week but they have nothing to talk about as their lives are so boring. Despite huge pension income and loads of cash they will not spend money on anything that isn’t physical - a lawnmower is fine but they won’t buy a coffee out or go for a meal where they can’t use a voucher. They will spend hours waiting for a free bus as dad won’t pay for parking. They have five cars and only drive one, they have a huge and decrepitating house in Surrey worth hundreds and thousands but won’t move or spend any money on to make it more suitable for them.

Everything they say drips of judgement about how I am living my life, what we spend money on, what my boy is doing etc. etc. And don’t get me started on the casual racism and snobbiness.

It’s slightly come to a head recently when I was acutely ill and in hospital for two weeks. That was nearly three months ago and they have made no effort to visit. Parents of friends have visited FFS. Neither have they made any enquiries about how we are coping financially without my income or offered to help out. A conversation is coming but it is not something that can be done on the phone. Not looking forward to it.

ohthefrostishere · 15/12/2024 11:29

You could just keep trying to persuade them to agree to start with buying in a couple of hours of care or cleaning but better would be a proper needs assessment. There might be stuff your dad needs help with that you're not aware of.

Would they be persuaded to at least talk to a professional eg local dementia uk or age uk person or a nice care company manager or someone from carers uk? There will be someone in your area who is good at this. As they sometimes just don't want advice from their well meaning daughter. Or a memory cafe type thing

rickyrickygrimes · 15/12/2024 11:01

If you already have LPA for your dad, then you can already make decisions on his behalf - decisions that would benefit your mum too.

Twelvetimes · 11/12/2024 22:06

Motherbear44 · 11/12/2024 19:52

I did a search and this thread came up. H and W is important. An inlaw of mine did not have it for a widowed parent. When it was determined that parent had dementia the state took over. His loving family member was not able to decide which care home that he would live in. He ended up a couple of hours drive away.

All I can say is that did not happen to me. My mother was self funded, so I chose the care home. The state was not involved in the process.

But maybe the case you are referring to was council funded. If the council is funding it, they source the placement and a relative having H&W LPA makes no difference because they aren't paying.

Motherbear44 · 11/12/2024 19:53

IMustDoMoreExercise · 11/07/2024 14:58

This is why AA should be means tested.

I wouldn't receive it if it was means tested but then why should I.

I think it is a sneaky Govt way of not providing more care. Cheaper to just hand out AA and not giving more support to families in need.

Motherbear44 · 11/12/2024 19:52

Twelvetimes · 10/07/2024 08:57

That's great. The finance one is the essential one. I don't have H&W for my mother and it has never been an issue, but would be good to have if you can.

I did a search and this thread came up. H and W is important. An inlaw of mine did not have it for a widowed parent. When it was determined that parent had dementia the state took over. His loving family member was not able to decide which care home that he would live in. He ended up a couple of hours drive away.

twoshedsjackson · 14/07/2024 14:46

I agree with @EmotionalBlackmail about trying the tactic of framing it as doing someone else a favour; my late uncle loved his garden, but it was getting too much for him, although he would never admit it. Funding was not an issue, but he was another from the wartime generation.
He was persuaded to enlist the efforts of a local handyman who was down on his luck, and we put it to him that he was giving him a wage so that he would not "feel like a charity case". Dignity preserved, he came to enjoy his company as well as appreciating his work in the garden.

Coldupnorth87 · 14/07/2024 12:07

Amassing savings gives a solid visible number to measure their life work?

This is a really good thread. I am really struggling with many of the same issues.

MikeRafone · 11/07/2024 17:59

IMustDoMoreExercise · 11/07/2024 14:58

This is why AA should be means tested.

I wouldn't receive it if it was means tested but then why should I.

This is part of the care the NHS used to provide, don't think it should be means tested any more than the NHS should be mens tested

IMustDoMoreExercise · 11/07/2024 14:58

This is why AA should be means tested.

I wouldn't receive it if it was means tested but then why should I.

Infracat · 11/07/2024 14:47

We just had the mrs/miss mistske on my mums and I called and they rectified it free. Because its a title and people can call themselves whatever title they like even if married.

Twelvetimes · 10/07/2024 08:57

That's great. The finance one is the essential one. I don't have H&W for my mother and it has never been an issue, but would be good to have if you can.

ScandiNoirNuit · 09/07/2024 19:53

I do have LPA for them both for finance, and for my dad for health. The health one for my mum got rejected due to an annoying mistake on the title of a witness (miss vs ms), I should do it again esp in light of recent developments.

OP posts:
Twelvetimes · 09/07/2024 09:34

@ScandiNoirNuit you are right, they will be resistant. But it will increasingly become a case of providing what they need, not what they want. I am sorry to say that it is extremely likely things are going to deteriorate significantly, so you need to be prepared for that.

If you don't have LPA, please look into that urgently, it takes months to get it registered. In time to come without LPA there will effectively be no one in charge of their finances which will be disastrous - they will have masses of cash but no way of releasing it for the care they need. You would then need to apply for a Deputyship which is far far more onerous than using an LPA.

ScandiNoirNuit · 08/07/2024 20:37

@Twelvetimes these are really practical suggestions, thank you. I am wary of trying to get too far into looking at a carer until they agree as I think they will be VERY resistant to it, mainly on cost grounds but also for pride, which is more understandable. But this is helpful to understand what might be possible.

@MikeRafone they now have the council tax discount, plus the attendance allowance, plus some other grant for my mum but haven’t spent a penny of it as far as I know.

My aunt summed it up as money being their ‘overriding addiction’, which sounds quite harsh but is actually true when they are sitting there in the cold in winter. Last winter, my mum was taking 2 buses to see my dad in hospital - one day I went round there and the thermostat said 12 degrees! Honestly, I don’t believe this is down to dementia, they have always been stingy as hell. I don’t think it is down to wanting to leave a nest egg to their family (and neither should it be), they just seem to be motivated to amass their savings.

OP posts: