Please or to access all these features

Elderly parents

DM wants a riser-chair costing £4.5k! Advice v welcome

583 replies

Valleyofthedollymix · 30/01/2024 14:51

DM is 82 with moderate dementia. It affects her mobility more than her cognitive abilities but I don't know how much this is to do with the dementia and how much is due to her lack of exercise over many years.

She is currently burning through finite funds by living in a large house with a very expensive live-in carer through an agency. After a lifetime of being careful with money, she's spending like Liberace and it's going to run out, especially since I think she'll live a long time. Frustratingly, the extravagance encouraged by the carer, for example endless new pairs of trousers and cashmere jumpers (one week she bought six). If we query this spending, it gets turned into a black mark against us - for someone with a failing memory, DM can keep a really good tally of the ways in which we've 'denied' her.

Anyway the latest was the carer organising for a bespoke riser recliner chair company to come round to demo. DM apparently 'fell in love' with the deluxe one and has chosen the fabric etc. It costs nearly £4600. This feels like an awful lot to me but apparently, it's tailor made for her spine, size etc.

Does anyone know if this is worth it? Of course, if it's a buy once buy the best situation and it'll change her life, fair enough, we'll find the funds. But I wouldn't spend that sort of money on anything without due diligence. I feel like we're being bounced into it. I'm also unsure of the wisdom of these chairs at all because might it exacerbate my mother's immobility?

So, if anyone has any knowledge on how much you need to spend and what's worth it, I'd be vvvv grateful.

OP posts:
moomoomoo27 · 31/01/2024 17:29

6pence · 31/01/2024 17:24

Presumably the carer doesn’t know how much money she has? Can you have a conversation saying your mum thinks she has more than she really has and that you are concerned about not being able to keep her on for as long as you’d like to as the money is running out fast. Could she discourage mum from spending unnecessarily as you’d hate to run out of money and not be able to afford her as she’s so great.

I think the carer knows exactly how much money she has, with all this requiring smoked salmon malarky.

I'd be very surprised if the carer isn't doing a deal with this chair company salesman and taking some of his commission as a referral fee. Few hundred quid x however many patients she has, then x the different product/selling companies she can get out to people with dementia.

Sickening.

Your mum may be able to afford it, but I bet there are others out there who can't.

Noped · 31/01/2024 17:27

Sounds like a really good OT and an excellent outcome for your day OP, you could just take the pressure off yourself a bit and tell your DM that the OT insists no chair until the assessment is completed because she has a much BETTER chair in mind - kick that problem into the long grass for a bit!

The point about the carer is not necessarily that she is purposefully at it but that she certainly isn't doing her professional best for your DM whatever the reasons.

nonevernotever · 31/01/2024 17:27

When my DM came home after a stroke we asked the lovely occupational therapist who came out about getting a recliner. Her advice was that it was the quickest way to kill DM off because she needed to be using her muscles not Letting everything atrophy and becoming more dependent.

6pence · 31/01/2024 17:24

Presumably the carer doesn’t know how much money she has? Can you have a conversation saying your mum thinks she has more than she really has and that you are concerned about not being able to keep her on for as long as you’d like to as the money is running out fast. Could she discourage mum from spending unnecessarily as you’d hate to run out of money and not be able to afford her as she’s so great.

NotARealWookiie · 31/01/2024 17:18

I’m glad you’ve got the OT assessment arranged. social care will also assess and make recommendations even if you are self funding - it sounds unlikely they would recommend live in care but you could consider funding whatever they do recommend as it would follow s more enabling approach - and it sounds like you DM is quite willingly becoming more dependant.

Hayliebells · 31/01/2024 17:13

I feel for you OP, I've been in a very similar situation myself unfortunately. We had to restrict my father's spending completely when his Alzheimer's got to the stage when he was just losing thousands every week, we never found out where it went. Maybe it's time for that with your DM? I'd switch carers and explain to the new carers that your DM does not have capacity to make decisions, so any financial decisions will be made by you. Your DM will hate it yes, but with dementia they'll always hate you for something, and you need to safeguard your DM. We had to take action, and it's fortunate we were able to, as in his last few years of life he needed all the money he had to pay for nursing home fees. What I would say though, is that unfortunately I think dementia care in the community is absolutely dire. Every professional we had contact with downplayed the severity of my father's Alzheimer's, until he was sectioned. As soon as he was sectioned, he was suddenly severely cognitively impaired, with Deprivation of Liberty immediate and permanent. He didn't change overnight, he'd clearly been struggling massively at home, but he got no support. He was discharged by the memory nurses! I wouldn't expect a very accurate assessment from any community services I'm afraid. Everything was 100 times easier when he moved into a care home.

Valleyofthedollymix · 31/01/2024 17:12

I got phoned by the actual OT for a triage and she was completely horrified by the cost! She concurred with people on here in saying that it would be for someone who was completely immobile rather than someone who can still go up and down stairs.

The whole house will have a proper assessment - this will include all the existing grab rails, shower seat, her bed, chair etc as it was all done for my father. Should have been done when he died but, well, obviously we were distracted. Unfortunately the wait time is a lot longer than the 2 weeks I promised so somehow I've got to manage this because I really think it would be mad to buy anything until this happens.

I think I'm painting the carer as far more Machiavellian than she is. I honestly don't think she's a bad person at all and in many ways I'm very grateful. But I think the relationship has run its course and it gives me a good reason to change agencies.

Again so many thanks to all.

OP posts:
GnomeDePlume · 31/01/2024 17:10

@Valleyofthedollymix a new care team with strict ground rules may well be beneficial all round. New brooms sweeping clean.

Being sneaky you could insist that the current carer follows much stricter rules than you expect the new team to follow. DM will not like this. Current carer will not like this.

You then introduce the idea of a change of care team. DM no longer likes current carer so may be happy to change. Current carer doesn't like the new rules so is happy to go.

New team comes in with slightly relaxed rules compared to most recent rules. DM is happy.

Mirabai · 31/01/2024 17:09

Davros · 31/01/2024 16:04

@LouisCatorze
Don't think riser recliners come on the NHS.
Yes they do

Their criteria are strict - eg oedema, scoliosis, certain neurological conditions.

Delphinium20 · 31/01/2024 17:06

I just purchased one of those chairs for my DF and it cost 1/4 the price you are being quoted. We got a nice neutral color and he's ever so comfortable in it. What you are being asked to pay is outrageous, IMO.

Olidora · 31/01/2024 17:04

asrarpolar · 31/01/2024 16:25

@SomeCatFromJapan Legally OP must do what is best for her mum with her mum's money. Safeguarding an inheritance is financial abuse.
I have seen an elderly lady live in unsuitable surroundings with only basic care and without care that would enhance the quality of her life all to safeguard inheritance.
OP though sounds like she is doing the best for her mother.

@asrarpolar this is exactly what I witnessed.

Yalta · 31/01/2024 17:04

If the carer is getting annoyed with you I would remind her that there is finite money in the bank and at the rate she is spending money the money will be home before your mothers mother does so if she isn’t going to continue to be your mothers carer for free then you don’t appreciate her encouraging your mother to spend money she will need for basic care as the years go on.

The carer might not be scamming your mother out of money but could she be subsidising her own lifestyle with a cashmere cardigan or 2 (I mean are you going to miss one or 2 if she has so many or a few packets of smoked salmon here and there etc.)

I would be trying to find out if this woman has an eBay account or is on Facebook and have a look at if she is selling anything.

It doesn‘t have to be a huge amount but over the years it does add up.

Higgeldypiggeldy35 · 31/01/2024 17:03

I work for the nhs and provide seating for people. 4.5k would purchase a chair for people with significant postural needs. If she is mobile and doesnt have a scoliosis and good sitting balance then she doesnt need a chair like this. If and when you do need specialist seating check out Care flex.

Silverfoxette · 31/01/2024 16:59

Valleyofthedollymix · 30/01/2024 15:24

In answer to q, up above, she does seem to have completely lost sense of the value of money. It's like pounds are pesetas. Like when I reduced it to one live-in carer, she just kept on saying that the additional carer did her nails. I stupidly tried to say to her - look if you have a second carer for an extra month that's going to cost you nearly £10,000 more, do you understand what most people have to do to earn that amount of money?

My mother had dementia and I do think this might be part of the disease as she became really focused on money too and would hound my father to take her to the bank to make withdrawals even with the last few hundred she had already taken out still in her purse.

SomeCatFromJapan · 31/01/2024 16:50

@asrarpolar That's a fair point. I do think preserving finances for future care is necessary.

78Summer · 31/01/2024 16:43

I would be more concerned about the carer. Have you spoken to her. If you have power of attorney over her finances any spending would have to go through you. If she has dementia this would be a good idea.

Letsgotitans · 31/01/2024 16:42

Itwasfinetillitwasnt · 30/01/2024 15:12

Rise and recliner chairs aren't always recommended for those with failing memories/health as it can cause more accidents (falling out of chair etc). It's worth seeing an nhs occupational therapist for a proper assessment of needs (not a private company whom is going to say you need the most expensive). If they think it's suitable/appropriate you could then look around and get a cheaper one because that sounds extortionate. You can often get reconditioned ones through charities that might help. I think I'd be very concerned about the influence of the carers and look at safeguarding issues, responsibilities of money, power of attorney etc.

Do you think private OT's get commission for chairs they recommend? I'd be very surprised if they did.

ItWasnaMeGuv · 31/01/2024 16:42

Valleyofthedollymix · 30/01/2024 14:51

DM is 82 with moderate dementia. It affects her mobility more than her cognitive abilities but I don't know how much this is to do with the dementia and how much is due to her lack of exercise over many years.

She is currently burning through finite funds by living in a large house with a very expensive live-in carer through an agency. After a lifetime of being careful with money, she's spending like Liberace and it's going to run out, especially since I think she'll live a long time. Frustratingly, the extravagance encouraged by the carer, for example endless new pairs of trousers and cashmere jumpers (one week she bought six). If we query this spending, it gets turned into a black mark against us - for someone with a failing memory, DM can keep a really good tally of the ways in which we've 'denied' her.

Anyway the latest was the carer organising for a bespoke riser recliner chair company to come round to demo. DM apparently 'fell in love' with the deluxe one and has chosen the fabric etc. It costs nearly £4600. This feels like an awful lot to me but apparently, it's tailor made for her spine, size etc.

Does anyone know if this is worth it? Of course, if it's a buy once buy the best situation and it'll change her life, fair enough, we'll find the funds. But I wouldn't spend that sort of money on anything without due diligence. I feel like we're being bounced into it. I'm also unsure of the wisdom of these chairs at all because might it exacerbate my mother's immobility?

So, if anyone has any knowledge on how much you need to spend and what's worth it, I'd be vvvv grateful.

Sorry OP, haven't read the full thread but as someone who has a mum (86) with early dementia, myself and brothers are organising power of attorney right at the moment. Mum is having private carers in daily now and we will be managing finances 100% to prevent any issues.

With my DH's mum,at one point her (private) carers, two sisters, made an appointment with mjum's family solicitor to change the will to include them! Got that nipped in the bud pronto after concerned call from solicitor.

Due to my experiences, I too am concerned that your mum's carer is having too much control over finances. Power of Attorney may be the way forward. Best of luck.

Noped · 31/01/2024 16:35

Valleyofthedollymix · 31/01/2024 14:03

Thank you so much again. It's been such a useful prod. As a result of all these valuable contributions I've taken a morning off work and worked the phones.

  1. The consultant's referral for OT assessment hadn't been put through, I don't know, classic NHS disjointedness. I've now made a request for a referral which the call handler dubbed 'urgent'.
  2. I've been in touch with her GP to get their advice. Also recommendations of private OTs should we need to get an assessment in a hurry.
  3. I've been in touch with an agency through which you employ carers directly (but they supply cover etc) and which costs considerably less. This is something I can push the button on should we pivot away from the current agency.
  4. I've spoken to the carer, who was pretty rude to me. I think she thinks we're penny pinching evil kids. As I keep saying, it may be that this is the right chair for her but we're not getting it without due diligence. Apparently the 'chair consultant' who came round was 'lovely'. I did keep pointing out that he's a salesman so of course he is. She then told me that it was up to me 'to break the terrible news' to DM that we weren't getting it immediately.
  5. Spoke to DM and asked her to give me two weeks to get the OT in. We need a whole house assessment for her needs rather than the piecemeal approach that was all about my dad. She was very upset and obviously angry at me.
  6. I'm going to take a day off either my family or work to go there in the next week and try to talk to her about how she'd feel about changing carers.

In answer to those questions about care assessments and adult services etc, we did have OT and equipment interventions from via NHS and social care for my father and when he died, they fell off. It's a tricky situation when you've got one very very very physically ill parent (but the 'brains') and one less ill but not compos mentis parent and then the former dies. You end up with a patched up solution that is suitable enough without being entirely suitable.

I do think she'll live a long time as she is has no other ailments. As with PP, I don't think 15 years is improbable. And nope, the money won't last that long to keep her at home as we'll need to sell it to pay for care.

@Valleyofthedollymix I am really impressed with your proactive day - your DM is lucky to have you.

From your update it seems the carer has done you a favour, her rudeness in that call is completely bonkers (really how dare she speak to you like that!) and in your shoes I would escalate immediately. A call to the agency manager explaining that you have had concerns for some time about the increase in compulsive behaviour but felt unwilling to cause your DM any grief when she seems to like the carer so much. The way you have been spoken to today has crossed a line and you are no longer happy that this specific carer has your DM's best interests at heart and you are very worried that your relationship is being undermined and your DM's mental and physical health being negatively affected. Bluntly I would ask that the carer not return and I would follow up the call with an email summarising so there is a written dated record of your complaint.

I have more to say but my ghast is just flabbered!

asrarpolar · 31/01/2024 16:25

@SomeCatFromJapan Legally OP must do what is best for her mum with her mum's money. Safeguarding an inheritance is financial abuse.
I have seen an elderly lady live in unsuitable surroundings with only basic care and without care that would enhance the quality of her life all to safeguard inheritance.
OP though sounds like she is doing the best for her mother.

SomeCatFromJapan · 31/01/2024 16:22

I'm going to go against the grain of people mentioning the OP thinking about her inheritence. I actually think it is fine to consider and give weight to the responsibility of inherited family money of whom OPs mother is the current custodian.

I think it would be an absolute waste and a great shame if all that money that was worked so hard for, is pissed away on unneeded tat by an elderly lady with dementia instead of being passed on to, say, her grandchildren to enable them to afford a property.

Her care needs must be met, she should be safe, warm, fed and confortable and she should certainly be able to have some new things and treats. But not this dreadful frivolous waste.

Mirabai · 31/01/2024 16:14

GnomeDePlume · 31/01/2024 15:22

It may well be that the shopping & 'getting one over' on OP are giving DM a pleasure 'hit'. This in turn will make her easier to deal with for the carer.

So the carer may be facilitating the spending and excess sugar eating as a way of sedating DM. The carer may not see it like this - just sees that shopping and sugar make DM happy and compliant. Denying DM makes her sad/angry and difficult.

Yes. Ime there are carers who take the easy road and let the patient do whatever they want - ie go to bed in the middle of the day so they don’t sleep at night etc, eat whatever they want; and there are more responsible, experienced carers who manage the patient so they don’t do things detrimental to themselves, even if it causes a strop - they learn how to manage the strops in that particular patient.

The spending may be driven by DM’s demands, but it could equally be that the carer has found it’s a convenient way of managing DM. DM can’t use the net or the mobile so if the carer doesn’t facilitate that she can’t go on shopping sprees full stop.

Davros · 31/01/2024 16:04

@LouisCatorze
Don't think riser recliners come on the NHS.
Yes they do

TraitorsGate · 31/01/2024 15:46

NoggintheNoggin · 31/01/2024 15:34

We are in control of my mother's finances but carer can use the card and also asks for stuff. I don't think she's dodgy, but she's deeply irritating.

Okay I've found it now @Valleyofthedollymix

This has got to stop.

It's completely wrong to allow a stranger to access your mum's credit cards and buy things for her with them.

The carer could well be buying all sorts of things that you can't keep track of.

If there was an issue with any purchases, you've not have a leg to stand on if you had to speak to the bank and admit a stranger was given your Mum's cards to buy on her behalf.

She could also order things for herself - or anyone - to be delivered to your Mum's house.

I can't believe you are allowing this.

This, you need to cancel the card and order a new one for yourself, carer will have details of the old card. You are not in control of her finances at the moment, you need to use the poa you gave been granted.

LondonLass91 · 31/01/2024 15:45

One day your mum will be dead. Buy her the chair. It is her money, after all.

But agree with others regarding the carer...the power these live in carers can wield is amazing. We had it with my father in law, so please be careful.

Also, you sound like a great daughter.