Please or to access all these features

Elderly parents

POA/Wills - parent refusing

41 replies

Couldhavebeenme3 · 28/10/2021 18:27

Hi all. Recent (but not unexpected) diagnosis of lung cancer, second diagnosis after previous cancer 7 years ago.

I'm (for all intents and purposes) on my own dealing with mum, but am also a single parent of two, with a f/t job and health issues of my own.

We've discussed POA and wills previously, she's told us what she'd like us to do with her estate, and admits that she hated feeling incapable during her last treatment.

However is now refusing to legally finalise a will and POA. Thinks its too formal, and too final. Cannot be persuaded that it will save so much hassle for us me should she be even temporarily unable to conduct her affairs - she is looking at surgery including time in icu plus a schedule of chemo, so is likely to be somewhat limited physically nevermind emotionally to handle stuff. Acknowledges that everything is likely to land on me, and also that my sibling will still be interfering yet absent throughout. I have no ££ buffer to support her should she need any bailing out.

Does anyone have any advice/info/shock tactics I can present to her to show her that investing time now could help me out down the line?

I'm aware how heartless this might sound, but I've just spent 2 days juggling kids/work/childcare whilst I've stayed with her following a medical procedure. I'm knackered. I'm feeling a raft of emotions with regard to her health but also feeling somewhat resentful that she's refusing to do whatever we can to ease things over the next few months in the short term.

Thanks

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Mum5net · 30/10/2021 09:10

OP, I should have added that it seems so unfair everything is falling to you, and not your sibling. It’s easier said than done, to find the extra strength to sort out her finances. It is relentless. Flowers However, if you can at least get her banking online tell her she can get a mini statement 24/7. It will bring some relief.

Mum5net · 30/10/2021 08:41

I have been dealing with the Office of Public Guardian for six years as DM refused POA and sectioned. No fun, expensive an totally a waste of her hard earned savings.
However, if she refuses, it’s her right and it will make you incredibly frustrated.
I second getting internet banking set up with Direct debits and standing orders in place covering all her utilities, window cleaning and garden maintenance. It means if she goes into hospital for an extended stay her outgoings are covered by her and not by you. I’d even go as far as getting her to consider Xmas and birthday standing orders for all the family. Also look into attendance allowance. It’s non means tested and she could well be eligible. Phone up for the forms rather than downloading forms as it often works out that she gets t payment sooner.

Couldhavebeenme3 · 29/10/2021 20:05

@SlugRose

Could you suggest doing yours at the same time? To normalise it a it?
Mine's been done for 5 years, not due for a revue yet.
OP posts:
SlugRose · 29/10/2021 18:51

Could you suggest doing yours at the same time? To normalise it a it?

Wombat49 · 29/10/2021 18:35

Just be brutal.

Say she'll have to instruct solicitors to deal with it all and suggest they'll take the money.

Tell her the cost of the alternative. It took me a while to work it out but it's thousands and requires a solicitor and court.

Sounds rough but some people don't like the rocks and need to be told about the hard places. There are no good alternatives.

I will help anyone but they need to help and give you the tools.

Couldhavebeenme3 · 29/10/2021 14:51

she’s almost wilfully making your life more difficult by refusing the POA (which is the more urgent for now) but still expecting you to look after things while she’s undergoing treatment.

Yeah, this is how it feels tbh, more so that I'm struggling with health stuff (which is setting my MH off too) myself at the moment which she is aware of.

OP posts:
Couldhavebeenme3 · 29/10/2021 14:45

Perhaps op can clarify what the estate is likely to be.

Very simple - one very average house and contents, no car, no great art collections or jewellery collections, one current account, one savings account. No high finance, only necessary utilities, bills quarterly, still pays by cheque and cash.

She has stipulated what she would like to happen to her estate (eventually) but if she dies with no will I fear am 100% convinced her wishes will not be fulfilled with regards to a share directly for the dgc.

Thinking about it, and from some replies here, the utilities will simply have to wait if I refuse to go any further out of my way when her affairs are already set up to be in-person and time consuming. I need to try and disengage with the disproportionate requests (that my sibling doesn't even gets asked!)

Thanks for your insights folks, maybe I'm anticipating things will be more complicated than they are

OP posts:
JudgeRindersMinder · 29/10/2021 14:23

I’ll be forever grateful that my parents were very forward thinking with POA etc 25+ years ago, it made life so much easier in the end stages of life.

However we did need to use a large amount of emotional blackmail on my dad (we’d already lost mum) as to how much it would help us (me and sister) if he’d consider allowing Carers to assist him.

I know that’s slightly different but it comes down to the same thing, she’s almost wilfully making your life more difficult by refusing the POA (which is the more urgent for now) but still expecting you to look after things while she’s undergoing treatment.

ICouldHaveCheckedFirst · 29/10/2021 14:16

POA is often invaluable, as organisations vary in how they interact with anyone other than the account holder/policy holder / customer (and we all want some safeguards I imagine, to prevent fraud, yes?).
POA only lasts while someone is alive. Once the person has died it has no effect. At that point, the executor of the Will takes over (often the same person, in practice, but not necessarily). Definitely focus on inconvenience & cost to her if she doesn't draw up POA or a Will - and you'll be happy to help her do it, of course.

Why write a Will if there's only 2 of you, and inheritance laws would split everything equally anyway? Well the other sibling may declare after death "oh but Mum always said I was to get her diamond necklace / Rembrandt / car / 60% of her money because XYZ" and having a Will at least avoids doubt over her wishes.

knittingaddict · 29/10/2021 14:09

@Peeeas

Sometimes if intestacy means that less goes to your spouse than would have been the case with a will (e.g. intestacy provides for some to go to your children), then you can be in a worse position due to less spouse exemption. But your estate needs to be fairly big before that happens.
Ah, good point.

Perhaps op can clarify what the estate is likely to be.

knittingaddict · 29/10/2021 14:05

My parents haven't done their wills depite being in their 80's and mum having dementia. They finally agreed to POA a year ago and it's taken ages to sort out due to covid.

We had to accept that it was their decision and nothing we could do to make them.

knittingaddict · 29/10/2021 14:03

@MrsMoastyToasty

Ask her if she fancies Boris and his chums getting a chunk of her estate because she made no will....
Why would that happen?

Answer is that it won't.

PermanentTemporary · 29/10/2021 13:40

Sorry, thats no help. The problem is I think it is unimaginable to people that they might not be able to make their own decisions. But it happens every day. Ultimately if she won't trust you, you can't help her.

PermanentTemporary · 29/10/2021 13:39

Speaking as someone who is currently using my Mum's POA for finances while she is in hospital, it is a bit of a godsend. It's a lot of work doing her finances but I'm hugely relieved I can use it. It is extremely unlikely she will ever again have capacity for complex decisions. And that happened overnight.

Poa for health is less important I think, unless she has strong views on something. Mum did write to her GP a few years ago giving the GP permission to talk to us children about her. That's been really useful.

Mum definitely has a will but it's currently missing... that's less vital, it will only mean a bit of a larger tax bill plus one row will happen about a picture everyone except me wants.

Couldhavebeenme3 · 29/10/2021 13:29

if you don't get a bi-weekly mini statement then hackers will unleash hell on her account. Does she have a problem with hackers. I've never had an issue other than someone trying to buy something, presumably they cloned my card. I didn't know but the bank phoned me and said they thought it was suspicious and when I said I didn't know anything about it they just stopped it.

Ha, no she's never had any suspicious activity of any kind at all, in fact years ago when she was on holiday and doing some actual spending she was thrilled the bank called her to confirm the transactions!

But obviously there's no knowing what atrocities will happen if she can't get 2 mini-statements...

OP posts:
CovoidOfAllHumanity · 29/10/2021 12:11

Just tell her that if she won't do it then you can't help her. Bills won't get paid. You won't be ringing round explaining. She'll have to sort it herself when she is better.
Her choice. Do the PoA and I can help you or don't and I won't be able to and you deal with it yourself.
A relative can never be responsible for someone else's debt so I would never advise paying it yourself as you are not obliged to.

Plenty of people do get in this situation when they don't have relatives and it all gets sorted out in the end. I have had some elderly folk not pay their bills for years but they don't get cut off because they are mentally incapacitated and the companies know they have to wait. I have bagged up years worth of red bills from properties that look scary but in the end one phone call to say the person is incapacitated means they won't take court action or if they did it would not be enforced.

ancientgran · 29/10/2021 12:06

@Couldhavebeenme3

Thanks both. Her affairs are simple - no multiple bank accounts, very basic household bills (no Internet, I already pay her mobile bill) but if she can't get her bi-weekly mini-statement then obviously hackers will unleash hell on her account/credit rating and it becomes a huge crisis. I am going to have to practice saying no, aren't I?

I do all my banking etc online as I don't have time to be making trips to the bank, to insurance brokers, I pay bills online. If she considers personal monetary loss for late fees this may influence her if I'm not going to be allowed to act on her behalf.

I can see a will and POA would be sensible but I think it is a bit pessimistic to say if you don't get a bi-weekly mini statement then hackers will unleash hell on her account. Does she have a problem with hackers. I've never had an issue other than someone trying to buy something, presumably they cloned my card. I didn't know but the bank phoned me and said they thought it was suspicious and when I said I didn't know anything about it they just stopped it.

Can't she just give you the password so you can deal with the account?

countrygirl99 · 29/10/2021 12:01

If your mum is resisting a POA will she accept a 3rd party mandate. If she will, work with her to internet banking and you should be ok.

PlanDeRaccordement · 28/10/2021 20:10

Yes, I was focussed on the technical aspect of paying another persons bills and how it is possible without a POA. But I understand/agree that if this is not affordable then you would need a POA to use their money to pay their bill.

Couldhavebeenme3 · 28/10/2021 20:05

On a side note, I have never had trouble paying bills on behalf of someone still living. I pay my adult DDs utility bills in Scotland even though her name is on the accounts and I’m paying from France. They don’t care where the money comes from...especially if you are paying online with a credit card. You just put in invoice number, confirm the account to be credited and pay. So I am not sure you need a POA to pay a bill?

Oh I'm sure I could physically pay my mum's bills if she is unable to get to the bank, or post office, or call up the companies, but I cannot afford to without being reimbursed somehow, which short of going to hers, taking her bank card, going to the atm, withdrawing funds, going to my bank/atm to deposit into my account which takes time, effort and inclination that are all in short supply at the moment when I could deal with that sort of stuff remotely with POA. My friend's dad was incredibly ill and incapable for months before his death, without POA his affairs were in a real state before she was able to pay off and close accounts with his death cert.

I don't want to be begrudging time that could be better spent actually caring for her (and my own family) rather than an hour doing a 5 minute transaction.

OP posts:
PlanDeRaccordement · 28/10/2021 20:03

@Comefromaway

PlandeRaccord - you have no problems paying your DD’s bills because you are using YOUR money to pay for them.

The OP can’t afford to do that. She won’t be able to access her mums money to pay her mums bills. She won’t be able to deal with any errors or mistakes (like a massive over-estimated bill or the end of a fixed term utility contract). If her mother needs any care she won’t be able to get the up to date statements needed for a financial assessment.

That is true, I am using my money.
CoronaPeroni · 28/10/2021 19:56

We told my mum that the whole family were doing POAs for each other and this convinced her to go ahead, obviously with us doing all the paperwork and just presenting her with the pages to sign. Just in time! She was diagnosed with dementia shortly after and without POA we all would have been at the mercy of social services regarding residential care, her property, her bank accounts etc. With POA we were in charge not just of her finances but her entire welfare. It was such a relief. I wish you well op.

Hedgesgalore · 28/10/2021 19:28

I'm third party representative for my mother's bank account. Have my own card and she still has hers although she doesn't use it anymore.

We have LPAs in place now (her suggestion) but have been third party for a few years.

2389Champ · 28/10/2021 19:22

If your mother is like mine, it was the fear of not being in control of her affairs and having things taken out of her hands that was the reason for her reluctance. She was an avid DM reader and had seen too many stories of relatives spending all the cash and was petrified she would be fleeced - either by strangers or family!

Can you reassure her that the POA will only be used in the circumstances of her not being capable, otherwise if she is well enough, she can still run her accounts etc? That way, you’ve got all bases covered. Your mother will then feel that she can manage and it’s not being taken out of her hands but you’ve got control should the worst happen.

When we got the POA forms signed, mother’s doctor and her bank managers witnessed them (health and welfare/financial) They both explained the implications but also assured her it was very wise and sensible thing to do, otherwise outsiders might have step in. Mother was very secretive and private, so I think this finally persuaded her.

bigbluebus · 28/10/2021 19:20

@PlanDeRaccordement

My DM died intestate with no will, whereas my DF died with a will and it was not extra trouble handling my DMs estate compared to my DF. You still file the death with courts with either will to confirm being executor or to be appointed one if no will. You follow inheritance law when there is no will instead of a wills instructions, but in both cases you’re still dividing assets and transferring ownership.

On a side note, I have never had trouble paying bills on behalf of someone still living. I pay my adult DDs utility bills in Scotland even though her name is on the accounts and I’m paying from France. They don’t care where the money comes from...especially if you are paying online with a credit card. You just put in invoice number, confirm the account to be credited and pay. So I am not sure you need a POA to pay a bill?

If the person is dead, normally you need only a death certificate and be next of kin to not just pay but close mobile phone, internet accounts, not a POA. For bank accounts/assets you need either court probate approving will showing you as executor or court filing appointing you as executor if no will....six eggs or half dozen really.

So really I thought it would be easier too with will and all that and was grateful to my DF for having one, but when he passed it wasn’t actually any easier in practice in my opinion. It was actually not needed, in his case, as his will matched inheritance law anyway by giving equal shares to all his children.

Just my experience.

Whilst the OP can physically pay the bills, I'm assuming she needs access to her Mother's money to do so as she can't afford to pay the bills from her own money. She can't do this unless she is either a party to the account, has a 3rd party mandate or has POA.