Please or to access all these features

Conflict in the Middle East

Trumps senior counter terrorism officer resigns due to the war with Iran and has said they only went to war because of Israeli pressure, not because of any imminent threat from Iran.

212 replies

BerthaPotts · 17/03/2026 15:49

If that is really the case will this not be very damning for Trump? How will he respond to this?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
ThreeDeafMice · 18/03/2026 18:44

Boolabus · 18/03/2026 17:55

It’s crossing a line when you imply that the Israel lobby is trying to influence American policy knowingly and deliberately to the detriment of the USA.

AIPAC's spending is designed to influence US foreign policy and maintain strong American support for Israel. They are knowingly and deliberately trying to influence American foreign policy it's up to American citizens to decide whether it is to their detriment or not, a lot of what I'm reading from America is that people are not happy with it.

Pro-Israel lobby group lobbies US administration to support Israel. And in other news, it rained, somewhere.

Boolabus · 18/03/2026 17:55

ThreeDeafMice · 18/03/2026 16:53

Obviously there’s an Israel lobby, and nobody thinks it’s not powerful and influential. Of course it’s legitimate to believe and say that you don’t agree with it. As it is to say you don’t agree with Bibi. Especially if you’re Israeli, and if you are, there’s a ballot box to make your point. Likewise Trump and his actions, if you’re a citizen of the USA (In contrast with Iran, at present).

It’s crossing a line when you imply that the Israel lobby is trying to influence American policy knowingly and deliberately to the detriment of the USA.

And “captured”? Captured by whom, exactly?

Edited

It’s crossing a line when you imply that the Israel lobby is trying to influence American policy knowingly and deliberately to the detriment of the USA.

AIPAC's spending is designed to influence US foreign policy and maintain strong American support for Israel. They are knowingly and deliberately trying to influence American foreign policy it's up to American citizens to decide whether it is to their detriment or not, a lot of what I'm reading from America is that people are not happy with it.

ThreeDeafMice · 18/03/2026 16:53

Obviously there’s an Israel lobby, and nobody thinks it’s not powerful and influential. Of course it’s legitimate to believe and say that you don’t agree with it. As it is to say you don’t agree with Bibi. Especially if you’re Israeli, and if you are, there’s a ballot box to make your point. Likewise Trump and his actions, if you’re a citizen of the USA (In contrast with Iran, at present).

It’s crossing a line when you imply that the Israel lobby is trying to influence American policy knowingly and deliberately to the detriment of the USA.

And “captured”? Captured by whom, exactly?

inamarina · 18/03/2026 16:05

ThreeDeafMice · 18/03/2026 09:17

Bibi? Or “the Israel lobby”? Legitimately persuaded by force of argument or “captured”, mesmerized and brainwashed?

Bibi persuading Trump or anyone else is a perfectly legitimate thing to do, and to complain about and discuss. Bibi has his own and his country’s interests to consider and must do what he considers best, including persuading foreign leaders to help him. That’s rational and above-board. If Trump is persuaded to do so because Trump believes it’s in America’s (or his own) interests, more power to Bibi’s power of rhetoric.

Allegations that there’s an “Israel lobby” of Americans working nefariously and deliberately to further the interests of a foreign country over their own, that’s entirely different and wholly illegitimate thing to suggest. And once you get to “captured” then we’re talking about supernatural powers and things only Jews can do.

I think what’s going on here is that you’re so convinced that nobody rational could disagree with your position on the Middle East that if someone does disagree with you then there must be a Jewish conspiracy at the heart of it.

Jews usually gets a capital J, by the way. Christians and Muslims, mutatis mutandis.

Edited

Well said.

user112256479 · 18/03/2026 15:00

ThreeDeafMice · 18/03/2026 09:17

Bibi? Or “the Israel lobby”? Legitimately persuaded by force of argument or “captured”, mesmerized and brainwashed?

Bibi persuading Trump or anyone else is a perfectly legitimate thing to do, and to complain about and discuss. Bibi has his own and his country’s interests to consider and must do what he considers best, including persuading foreign leaders to help him. That’s rational and above-board. If Trump is persuaded to do so because Trump believes it’s in America’s (or his own) interests, more power to Bibi’s power of rhetoric.

Allegations that there’s an “Israel lobby” of Americans working nefariously and deliberately to further the interests of a foreign country over their own, that’s entirely different and wholly illegitimate thing to suggest. And once you get to “captured” then we’re talking about supernatural powers and things only Jews can do.

I think what’s going on here is that you’re so convinced that nobody rational could disagree with your position on the Middle East that if someone does disagree with you then there must be a Jewish conspiracy at the heart of it.

Jews usually gets a capital J, by the way. Christians and Muslims, mutatis mutandis.

Edited

Well Trump did not go before the American people, as he's constitutionally required to do, so we have no idea of what case was or wasn't made to him. I do know what Marco Rubio said. In addition, I also know, as an American taxpayer, that my taxes are funding this fucking shit show, not to mention the absolute clusterfuck AIPAC is making of US elections at all levels, so I don't think it's illegitimate in the least to suggest there's a lobby - there's literally a lobby.

I actually have no position on the Middle East, other than, putting historic issues aside, Israel had the right to defend itself after October 7 and managed to do it in a way that alienated a considerable portion of the world. That Hamas, Bibi and Trump are all pretty much equal, all belong in prison, and the citizens of all three countries deserve better.

I'm jewish, by the way and have close relatives in Israel. They're no more enamoured of Bibi and his wars than I am with Trump.

dairydebris · 18/03/2026 10:01

ThreeDeafMice · 18/03/2026 09:17

Bibi? Or “the Israel lobby”? Legitimately persuaded by force of argument or “captured”, mesmerized and brainwashed?

Bibi persuading Trump or anyone else is a perfectly legitimate thing to do, and to complain about and discuss. Bibi has his own and his country’s interests to consider and must do what he considers best, including persuading foreign leaders to help him. That’s rational and above-board. If Trump is persuaded to do so because Trump believes it’s in America’s (or his own) interests, more power to Bibi’s power of rhetoric.

Allegations that there’s an “Israel lobby” of Americans working nefariously and deliberately to further the interests of a foreign country over their own, that’s entirely different and wholly illegitimate thing to suggest. And once you get to “captured” then we’re talking about supernatural powers and things only Jews can do.

I think what’s going on here is that you’re so convinced that nobody rational could disagree with your position on the Middle East that if someone does disagree with you then there must be a Jewish conspiracy at the heart of it.

Jews usually gets a capital J, by the way. Christians and Muslims, mutatis mutandis.

Edited

Thanks for putting this so eloquently- I see it so often on here... subtle differences in language amounts to so much more than semantics in current climate.

ThreeDeafMice · 18/03/2026 09:17

user112256479 · 18/03/2026 08:29

No, it's nothing to do with jews controlling the world or drinking blood or running Hollywood or Soros. It's about Trump and Bibi essentially being criminals willing to do anything to cling to power and stay out of prison. One is smart, one is stupid. You choose.

Bibi? Or “the Israel lobby”? Legitimately persuaded by force of argument or “captured”, mesmerized and brainwashed?

Bibi persuading Trump or anyone else is a perfectly legitimate thing to do, and to complain about and discuss. Bibi has his own and his country’s interests to consider and must do what he considers best, including persuading foreign leaders to help him. That’s rational and above-board. If Trump is persuaded to do so because Trump believes it’s in America’s (or his own) interests, more power to Bibi’s power of rhetoric.

Allegations that there’s an “Israel lobby” of Americans working nefariously and deliberately to further the interests of a foreign country over their own, that’s entirely different and wholly illegitimate thing to suggest. And once you get to “captured” then we’re talking about supernatural powers and things only Jews can do.

I think what’s going on here is that you’re so convinced that nobody rational could disagree with your position on the Middle East that if someone does disagree with you then there must be a Jewish conspiracy at the heart of it.

Jews usually gets a capital J, by the way. Christians and Muslims, mutatis mutandis.

MushMonster · 18/03/2026 09:11

dairydebris · 18/03/2026 08:28

Its clear that as long as you're prepared to toady up to Trump and toe the line on his various lies you'll be considered for any position regardless of whether or not you're qualified. See also Kash Patel.

It's awful to see the disruption already bought by Trump and he's not even halfway through term. Let's hope those saying MAGA is finished are right- imo Trump is the most dangerous man in the world.

I fully agree.
Kent is perfectly "normal and good" in Trump's realm. Till yesterday, that is.
Journalists keep posting how much they are spending on food and drink and it is insane! He bribes them wiith lobster, for the look of it!

Twiglets1 · 18/03/2026 09:00

user112256479 · 18/03/2026 08:47

So, to be clear, you're telling me what I think?

No I'm talking about how the old tropes of Jews drinking blood etc get updated for the modern age. No one would believe THAT anymore would they.

So the current equivalent is they have superhuman powers to make Trump do exactly what they want. Maybe Netanyahu controls his brain, that seems a lot more believable.

user112256479 · 18/03/2026 08:47

Twiglets1 · 18/03/2026 08:41

It has been updated for modern times.

People still assuming Israel has an almost supernatural amount of power.

The drinking blood thing is old hat now so they have moved on to Netanyahu pulling Trump's strings. Because one is stupid and one is smart, apparently.

So, to be clear, you're telling me what I think?

XelaM · 18/03/2026 08:46

user112256479 · 18/03/2026 08:29

No, it's nothing to do with jews controlling the world or drinking blood or running Hollywood or Soros. It's about Trump and Bibi essentially being criminals willing to do anything to cling to power and stay out of prison. One is smart, one is stupid. You choose.

Absolutely this 👏🏼

Twiglets1 · 18/03/2026 08:41

user112256479 · 18/03/2026 08:29

No, it's nothing to do with jews controlling the world or drinking blood or running Hollywood or Soros. It's about Trump and Bibi essentially being criminals willing to do anything to cling to power and stay out of prison. One is smart, one is stupid. You choose.

It has been updated for modern times.

People still assuming Israel has an almost supernatural amount of power.

The drinking blood thing is old hat now so they have moved on to Netanyahu pulling Trump's strings. Because one is stupid and one is smart, apparently.

Twiglets1 · 18/03/2026 08:35

user112256479 · 18/03/2026 08:26

As someone who has diametrically opposed opinions to you, I can assure you, I don't consider him a remotely credible person. One could say equally, that he would normally be beloved by those now rushing to revile him because that suits their current agenda.

Doubt there are many on these threads who would ever find him "beloved". He holds some seriously shady views and not many of us on here are fans of Trump, which Kent very much used to be.

dairydebris · 18/03/2026 08:31

Notonthestairs · 18/03/2026 08:30

MAGA will move to Vance (who has been remarkably quiet of late). He'll sell them the same America First line.

Stop the world I want to get off.

Notonthestairs · 18/03/2026 08:30

dairydebris · 18/03/2026 08:28

Its clear that as long as you're prepared to toady up to Trump and toe the line on his various lies you'll be considered for any position regardless of whether or not you're qualified. See also Kash Patel.

It's awful to see the disruption already bought by Trump and he's not even halfway through term. Let's hope those saying MAGA is finished are right- imo Trump is the most dangerous man in the world.

MAGA will move to Vance (who has been remarkably quiet of late). He'll sell them the same America First line.

user112256479 · 18/03/2026 08:29

ThreeDeafMice · 18/03/2026 02:21

Does it not disturb anyone that the “captured by Israel” meme is basically the Protocols, rewritten for the 21st century?

I’m curious: what is the difference between that, and that pesky Jewish octopus manipulating the dumb Americans to carry out its dastardly plan to enslave the world (mu ha ha ha)?

No, it's nothing to do with jews controlling the world or drinking blood or running Hollywood or Soros. It's about Trump and Bibi essentially being criminals willing to do anything to cling to power and stay out of prison. One is smart, one is stupid. You choose.

dairydebris · 18/03/2026 08:28

MushMonster · 18/03/2026 07:57

Kent's "profile" is not looking any good already. But, yet, he was good enough to run the counter terrorism centre just yesterday....
It is clear there is a deep division between Trump and the US intel and security councils. How deep is to be seen. And how it will affect him with his voters.

Its clear that as long as you're prepared to toady up to Trump and toe the line on his various lies you'll be considered for any position regardless of whether or not you're qualified. See also Kash Patel.

It's awful to see the disruption already bought by Trump and he's not even halfway through term. Let's hope those saying MAGA is finished are right- imo Trump is the most dangerous man in the world.

user112256479 · 18/03/2026 08:26

Twiglets1 · 18/03/2026 06:12

Kent has links to white supremists and said Trump won the 2020 election… he wouldn’t normally be considered a credible person by those now rushing to believe his current words because that suits their agenda.

As someone who has diametrically opposed opinions to you, I can assure you, I don't consider him a remotely credible person. One could say equally, that he would normally be beloved by those now rushing to revile him because that suits their current agenda.

Twiglets1 · 18/03/2026 08:22

TerracottaPots · 18/03/2026 07:39

Suggesting that we shouldn’t discuss Israel’s influence over America because “it’s antisemitic” to do so probably isn’t going to work anymore. No country and no country’s foreign policy should be above criticism.

No issue with people discussing the influence of Israel on America's foreign policy. They are very strong allies.

What is antisemitic is repeating the same old lies about Israel being all powerful and Jews apparently running the world - able to make a poodle out of Trump apparently.

No - Trump does what he wants to do - more than any US president in history.

MushMonster · 18/03/2026 07:57

EmeraldShamrock000 · 18/03/2026 07:10

Trump and his team will start a smear campaign against him soon, “he lost his mind” “ he was a threat to national security” “he was an Iranian spy” there’s no end to the lies Trump is willing to tell.
Or he might get randomly shot by a college student. 🤐 corruption at its finest.

Kent's "profile" is not looking any good already. But, yet, he was good enough to run the counter terrorism centre just yesterday....
It is clear there is a deep division between Trump and the US intel and security councils. How deep is to be seen. And how it will affect him with his voters.

TerracottaPots · 18/03/2026 07:39

ThreeDeafMice · 18/03/2026 02:21

Does it not disturb anyone that the “captured by Israel” meme is basically the Protocols, rewritten for the 21st century?

I’m curious: what is the difference between that, and that pesky Jewish octopus manipulating the dumb Americans to carry out its dastardly plan to enslave the world (mu ha ha ha)?

Suggesting that we shouldn’t discuss Israel’s influence over America because “it’s antisemitic” to do so probably isn’t going to work anymore. No country and no country’s foreign policy should be above criticism.

EasternStandard · 18/03/2026 07:10

KatiePricesKnickers · 18/03/2026 07:06

And for Israel’s sake, it needs to stay this way.

Not just Israel. If the weapons were used it’s likely others would retaliate and we’d all be in dire straits. It’s pretty existential that they don’t.

EmeraldShamrock000 · 18/03/2026 07:10

Trump and his team will start a smear campaign against him soon, “he lost his mind” “ he was a threat to national security” “he was an Iranian spy” there’s no end to the lies Trump is willing to tell.
Or he might get randomly shot by a college student. 🤐 corruption at its finest.

KatiePricesKnickers · 18/03/2026 07:06

Flomingho · 18/03/2026 07:03

Exactly!

And for Israel’s sake, it needs to stay this way.

Flomingho · 18/03/2026 07:03

KatiePricesKnickers · 18/03/2026 06:28

@Flomingho ”and are there actually any nukes?”
No, because if they had one, they’d have already fired it at Tel Aviv.

Exactly!