Israels plan for Gazas future

I was asking you to clarify that one Jewish voice doesn't speak for all Jews.

Because you seem to think that Jews in Israel should listen to Mandy Patinkin because "he is Jewish".

You are not Jewish @Anonimummy .
He is.

Absolutely vile to say he has invalidated himself and his own ethnicity because he holds a different opinion to you. Silencing his voice is shameful .

Why are you asking about the green prince? A man who was kidnapped as a boy by the IDF? And was subjected to god knows what horrors that it broke him to the level that he betrayed his own people, his friends and his family and even his own father? The anger and shame is blatant just by looking at his eyes. The reason he converted to Christianity is that he craves forgiveness as Christianity is a religion of forgiveness.

What agenda do you think I have? I’m not Jewish or Israeli and have no skin in this conflict. I can have an opinion though.

He invalidated himself by giving validation to anti-semites all around the world because Israel is fighting a war to defend its citizens and dismantle Hamas, while making no mention of Hamas who are the reason this war started in the first place.

Netanyahu is the most dangerous thing - not an Iran backed terrorist organisation who carried out Oct 7th and has been/is currently using Palestinian civilians as human shields while indoctrinating them to continue the conflict for generations to come, killing and torturing them for trying to get aid and refusing to surrender and release the rest of the hostages to enable more Palestinians to get killed?

Give me a break.

Annihilation is a term I believe to be accurate. Given pps queries here I had a look over news etc articles to see if annihilation is too aggressive a term. It seems not. This article for example notes ‘whilst states argue over terminology ‘…. People can argue but the unfolding outcome remains the same. dictionary definition number 1 then article also using annihilation to describe what’s happening in Gaza. I’ll use the terms I deem appropriate unless I believe the definition wrong. It isn’t.

You've lost me. Where is a population being annhilated?

@DrPrunesqualer ”We don’t go around thinking annihilating a population”

Where is this annihilation taking place?
It’s not happening in Gaza.

Oh really, what do you think of Mosab Hassan Yousef?

I think blaming Israel for fighting a war they didn’t start for global antisemitism and putting Jewish people worldwide in danger, rather than putting accountability on antisemites and those who wish to attack/kill Jews because they are Jews with Gaza as an excuse, is absolutely despicable.

Not at all what they were saying but one Jewish voice doesn’t speak for all Jews does he? These individual examples just look desperate to prove a point.

I was thinking the same thing, it appears a Jewish voice is only important when it agrees with them .

You don’t have to live or be in Israel to have experience of terrorist attacks. We don’t go around thinking annihilating a population or taking complete control over civilians lives is an acceptable solution to that.

Have they ever lived in Israel or experienced terrorist attacks and threats of annihilation from Palestinians?

Were they living in Israel on Oct 7th?

Don't waste your breath/energy, a response like that was predictable and it's why Kathryn Grody specifically spoke about being labelled as a "self hating Jew" in the video. Unfortunately many Jewish people who are speaking out about Palestine are bullied, called names or made fun of.

Remember this couple are in their 70s/80s, they remember experienced the racism of the older days, perhaps some heed should be paid to their experience.

Oh look. Netanyahu’s plan for Gaza, straight out of the horses mouth, ‘a solution that allows to Palestinians to govern themselves if they don’t seek the destruction of Israel’.

Who’s going to step forward to lead them do you think?

https://x.com/netanyahu/status/1944793281046429797

I was well aware. Having looked him up when he was in Homeland.

He’s got a platform as an American actor living in the US, and is using it to blame and shame his fellow Jews in Israel for a war they didn’t start, and for defending themselves against a clear and present danger, in a region he doesn’t live in.

Why do you think they should listen to him?

'Is there a reason you think Jewish people should listen or take heed from an ACTOR"

Oh I thought by this sentence you didn't know that, you know that he is one of those "Jewish people"

So what?

But he is Jewish.

I'm just thinking of how applicable that quote is to the pro-palestinian side too. There'd be no problem if enough people on both sides recognised that - but it's too lucrative for hamas to let go. The connections between Hezbollah and the South American drug trade would also suggest this is not about fairness.

Shame, I used to really love him in Homeland.

Is there a reason you think Jewish people should listen or take heed from an ACTOR, especially one who seems to think antisemitism is inevitable when the only Jewish state defends, and acts to prevent further terrorism against its citizens?

Irish Taoiseach Micheàl Martin has also described the plan as "a concentration camp idea”.

Bizarre that someone would claim that "only 30,000k" people being killed was no big deal.

Genocide is not about numbers, it is about intent. The Srebrenican genocide has around 8000 victims, it is still a genocide due to the intent of the Serbs to eliminate the Bosniak population. Intent which the Israeli government as quoted above clearly share towards the Palestinans in Gaza.

Finally, the removal of Palestinians from Gaza is ethnic cleansing, which is also a war crime.

There is no ways to practically implement it. It is quite possibly (as well as a war crime) the stupidest idea ever.