Please or to access all these features

Conflict in the Middle East

What does 'Free Palestine' mean to you?

107 replies

TwigletsAndRadishes · 22/03/2025 17:25

I just read that Rachel Zegler shared the trailer for Snow White and commented attached to it, '....and always remember, free Palestine.'

It just got me thinking, what does 'Free Palestine' or 'A Free Palestine' mean to you?

What is it you would want to see in order to be satisfied that Palestine is free and Palestinians are free?

OP posts:
TwigletsAndRadishes · 22/03/2025 22:02

Martymcfly24 · 22/03/2025 21:48

Not one person here has said they don't want Israel to exist?

I certainly don't.

Israel exists it is a country with a people who have pride in their nationality. It is a country with a history, a government, a culture: that cannot be dismantled and people ethnically cleansed from an area that they were born into for a one state solution.

I just think people of Gaza and West Bank should also have this right.

No, you are right, not one person has said on this thread that they don't want Israel to exist. That is not evidence that 'not one person' wishes Israel didn't exist though, is it? It might just mean that the people who would like to see the destruction of Israel as a state are rather reluctant to write it down on Mumsnet.

I'm sure there plenty of people who think that dismantling Israel and ethnically cleansing the area of Jews is perfectly feasible and justifiable in the process of 'taking back' land they believe to be theirs.

So I wondered when people talk about freeing Palestine, what specific areas they are referring to, and whether it means Palestinians living 'freely' in Gaza and the West Bank alongside Israel and Israelis, or not.

OP posts:
Whatsinanamehey · 22/03/2025 21:52

Radyward · 22/03/2025 21:50

Palestine is free just that Hamas has it in a stranglehold

Is the occupied west bank free too? Even though Hamas isn't ruling there. There's plenty of Jewish settler terrorists though burning down mosques and Palestinian properly, aided and enabled by the IDF.

Radyward · 22/03/2025 21:50

Palestine is free just that Hamas has it in a stranglehold

LoyalAquaOtter · 22/03/2025 21:49

Martymcfly24 · 22/03/2025 21:39

Well just let the Israelis kill all the Palestinians horrifically instead so?

As they are doing right at this moment.
Much better solution.

Exactly. The past 19months have certainly shown us what Israel are capable of if the decades before that hadn't. Year in year, year out Israel kill more Palestinians than the other way around yet somehow Palestinians are painted as crazed killers who can't even be trusted with self determination. Year in year out Israeli settlers are the ones who steal more and more Palestinian land with the full support of the Israeli government support yet Palestinians are the ones painted as trying to stop Israel from existing. It's some crazy blinkered thinking from some.

Martymcfly24 · 22/03/2025 21:48

TwigletsAndRadishes · 22/03/2025 21:42

So by 'Palestine' what geographic area or areas in total are we talking about here? When most people talk about Palestine do they just mean Gaza and the West Bank? Or do they mean the land that is Israel as well? Was that considered Palestine by Palestinians before the modern state of Israel was formed? Is the aim to have a two state solution, or a one state solution where Israel no longer exists? Would Palestine ever be considered 'free' by most people who call for 'a free Palestine' while Israel exists?

Edited

Not one person here has said they don't want Israel to exist?

I certainly don't.

Israel exists it is a country with a people who have pride in their nationality. It is a country with a history, a government, a culture: that cannot be dismantled and people ethnically cleansed from an area that they were born into for a one state solution.

I just think people of Gaza and West Bank should also have this right.

TwigletsAndRadishes · 22/03/2025 21:42

Yazzi · 22/03/2025 21:13

Exactly, in this case free Palestine has a pretty clear meaning:

Palestinians having the right to safety, security, self determination, political and economic and property rights.

That's what "free Palestine" means.

Acting like the phrase is super complicated or (lol) anti Semitic to disguise the fact that you (a general "you") don't think Palestinians deserve those basic and fundamental human rights seems like you in fact support the ongoing oppression of Palestinians, instead.

So by 'Palestine' what geographic area or areas in total are we talking about here? When most people talk about Palestine do they just mean Gaza and the West Bank? Or do they mean the land that is Israel as well? Was that considered Palestine by Palestinians before the modern state of Israel was formed? Is the aim to have a two state solution, or a one state solution where Israel no longer exists? Would Palestine ever be considered 'free' by most people who call for 'a free Palestine' while Israel exists?

OP posts:
Martymcfly24 · 22/03/2025 21:39

MounjaroDisappointment · 22/03/2025 21:29

They could have had that 77 years ago. The Arabs (who they referred to themselves as at the time) did not want that, a horrific and catastrophic mistake for generations afterwards IMO.

To me Free Palestine means Israel taking down the border wall with Gaza, doing away with checkpoints in the West Bank, giving autonomy over their airspace and coast and Palestinians being free to kill all the Jews as horrifically as they did on Oct 7th, as they try to take control of Israel.

I’m sure the surrounding Arab states would be chomping at the bit to join in and help!

Oct 7th showed us what Palestinians are capable of when they can invade Israel.

It would be disingenuous to think otherwise.

Well just let the Israelis kill all the Palestinians horrifically instead so?

As they are doing right at this moment.
Much better solution.

AlteredStater · 22/03/2025 21:34

Doesn't mean much at all, but they do need to be free from Hamas as a pp said. A two state solution won't work, all the surrounding Arab nations want Israel gone. Trouble is going to keep on happening.

soupyspoon · 22/03/2025 21:33

FKAT · 22/03/2025 20:53

A thought terminating cliche like Transwomen Are Women and Just Stop Oil. It doesn't mean anything. Just signals your in-group status.

Oh you said it better than me.

This.

Lamelie · 22/03/2025 21:31

Comedycook · 22/03/2025 20:54

If I hear someone say free Palestine I take it to mean they wish to see the dismantling and destruction of Israel and a single Palestinian state to exist instead.

Yes that’s my understanding. Free Palestine does not mean two state solution.

soupyspoon · 22/03/2025 21:30

I certainly dont say that now, I might have done a few years ago. Its a trite, simplistic and ultimately meaningless concept

MounjaroDisappointment · 22/03/2025 21:29

Martymcfly24 · 22/03/2025 20:28

To me it means a two state solution where Israel and Palestine are merely neighbouring states. Israel will not have control over the water/electricity/movement of people/ taxes/ Internet/ imports etc.

Both countries will accept their borders and not seek to increase their land mass.

Palestine will have full control of it's people and parliament and be recognized by the world as an independent state.

But a special relationship will exist between the two that respects their integrated traditions and history.
Like Ireland and England.

They could have had that 77 years ago. The Arabs (who they referred to themselves as at the time) did not want that, a horrific and catastrophic mistake for generations afterwards IMO.

To me Free Palestine means Israel taking down the border wall with Gaza, doing away with checkpoints in the West Bank, giving autonomy over their airspace and coast and Palestinians being free to kill all the Jews as horrifically as they did on Oct 7th, as they try to take control of Israel.

I’m sure the surrounding Arab states would be chomping at the bit to join in and help!

Oct 7th showed us what Palestinians are capable of when they can invade Israel.

It would be disingenuous to think otherwise.

DontKnowAnythingAnymore · 22/03/2025 21:26

How can we say what it means? I know what it means to me, but I imagine it means very different things to all the people who say or post it.

I despair of a world that will ever be at peace with nations allowing each other to live happily.

LoyalAquaOtter · 22/03/2025 21:23

Yazzi · 22/03/2025 21:13

Exactly, in this case free Palestine has a pretty clear meaning:

Palestinians having the right to safety, security, self determination, political and economic and property rights.

That's what "free Palestine" means.

Acting like the phrase is super complicated or (lol) anti Semitic to disguise the fact that you (a general "you") don't think Palestinians deserve those basic and fundamental human rights seems like you in fact support the ongoing oppression of Palestinians, instead.

💯

Switcher · 22/03/2025 21:14

What it should mean is confronting, acknowledging and moving on from the toxic legacy of the ottoman empire. Unfortunately what it does mean is a doom loop of revenge and futility. Vergangenheitsbewältigung, for Arab states to move on, drive out Islamists and seek peace.

Yazzi · 22/03/2025 21:13

Martymcfly24 · 22/03/2025 21:09

I find people who usually oppose another country having democratic freedoms usually have the advantage of being in the position of the oppressor.

Exactly, in this case free Palestine has a pretty clear meaning:

Palestinians having the right to safety, security, self determination, political and economic and property rights.

That's what "free Palestine" means.

Acting like the phrase is super complicated or (lol) anti Semitic to disguise the fact that you (a general "you") don't think Palestinians deserve those basic and fundamental human rights seems like you in fact support the ongoing oppression of Palestinians, instead.

Azureshores · 22/03/2025 21:12

OppsUpsSide · 22/03/2025 20:29

Free Palestine from Hamas

They don't want to be free of Hamas though.

Martymcfly24 · 22/03/2025 21:09

I find people who usually oppose another country having democratic freedoms usually have the advantage of being in the position of the oppressor.

Whatsinanamehey · 22/03/2025 21:06

Free Palestine from Israeli occupation and oppression.

CarrieOnComplaining · 22/03/2025 21:02

A Two state division between Palestine and Israel and a democratically elected non terrorist government.

SassySusie · 22/03/2025 21:01

To me it means the end of the Israeli occupation (1967).

ScrollingLeaves · 22/03/2025 20:59

Martymcfly24 · 22/03/2025 20:28

To me it means a two state solution where Israel and Palestine are merely neighbouring states. Israel will not have control over the water/electricity/movement of people/ taxes/ Internet/ imports etc.

Both countries will accept their borders and not seek to increase their land mass.

Palestine will have full control of it's people and parliament and be recognized by the world as an independent state.

But a special relationship will exist between the two that respects their integrated traditions and history.
Like Ireland and England.

I agree that this is what it means to me. And all the settlers out of the West Bank.

QueenOfHiraeth · 22/03/2025 20:58

FrippEnos · 22/03/2025 20:33

Its a nonsense term, they will never be free from Israeli oppression and never be free from Hamas or groups like Hamas.
The people of the region are caught i a self perpetuating loop of hatred.

Exactly this. Those poor people are trapped in a never ending nightmare

CaptainFuture · 22/03/2025 20:56

ParsnipPuree · 22/03/2025 20:50

I just roll my eyes when I see it thinking they’re either anti semites or useful idiots who have no understanding of the situation.

Same.

Comedycook · 22/03/2025 20:54

If I hear someone say free Palestine I take it to mean they wish to see the dismantling and destruction of Israel and a single Palestinian state to exist instead.