Please or to access all these features

Conflict in the Middle East
OP posts:
Thread gallery
30
Ineedaweebutitswarmhere · 16/01/2025 00:08

The only way there will be peace between ideal and Palestine is if hamas is not in charge. Whilst this is great news, of a ceasefire - it will happen again and Hamas will use the people of Palestine for it propaganda machine. They declare war on Israel and Israel thought back.

We need Hamas out of the picture and not some murderous terrorists in charge

Whatsinanamehey · 16/01/2025 00:07

Ineedaweebutitswarmhere · 15/01/2025 23:55

Where do you get your news from? Fro many Jews and Christian’s this land was held before any Muslim was even born

Tag the wrong poster?
As I can't see how that relates to my comment about the current PA rule.

stormy4319trevor · 16/01/2025 00:05

NoisyBear · 15/01/2025 23:57

It would be great to get some independent witnesses in to assess the situation. I would imagine that it will take many years for the full scale of what has happened to be uncovered. For instance I remember seeing a video ages ago of the IDF shooting 2 men then just burying their bodies under sand and moving on. How many people have been treated this way? How long will it take to uncover all of the bodies from who knows where. Finding the cause of death of so many people after such a long time will surely be a huge effort. Taking testimonies from the tens of thousands of victims/witnesses would also be a huge undertaking. That said the sooner the start the sooner a picture of what really happened can be built.

You are right. It will take years and require access by the press and various experts. I'm not quite sure it will be allowed, but academics and good journalists certainly have the rigour to piece things together, so I hope it happens. There must be a large amount of footage, photography, testimony to examine. Also, a lot of ground and unmarked graves to excavate. It's terrible to think about, but accurate documentation is at least some gesture of respect for the dead.

stormy4319trevor · 15/01/2025 23:58

Ineedaweebutitswarmhere · 15/01/2025 23:55

Where do you get your news from? Fro many Jews and Christian’s this land was held before any Muslim was even born

I think the point is that Hamas only ever governed Gaza, and not Palestine as a whole, since that includes the West Bank and East Jerusalem.

NoisyBear · 15/01/2025 23:57

EasterIssland · 15/01/2025 23:50

i hope international and independent journalists and organisations are allowed to go into Gaza soon. Maybe then the world will accept what locals and local journalists have been saying for year and a half

It would be great to get some independent witnesses in to assess the situation. I would imagine that it will take many years for the full scale of what has happened to be uncovered. For instance I remember seeing a video ages ago of the IDF shooting 2 men then just burying their bodies under sand and moving on. How many people have been treated this way? How long will it take to uncover all of the bodies from who knows where. Finding the cause of death of so many people after such a long time will surely be a huge effort. Taking testimonies from the tens of thousands of victims/witnesses would also be a huge undertaking. That said the sooner the start the sooner a picture of what really happened can be built.

Ineedaweebutitswarmhere · 15/01/2025 23:55

Whatsinanamehey · 15/01/2025 23:25

Yes it doesn't make sense in that context as the PA rules over the occupied west bank.

Where do you get your news from? Fro many Jews and Christian’s this land was held before any Muslim was even born

Ineedaweebutitswarmhere · 15/01/2025 23:53

I am glad the ceasefire and the release of Israelis hostages is happening. The attack in October was unprovoked and should never have happened.

I really hope as part of the next phase of negotiations are discussions on the next steps of Palestine governance - a terrorist organisation should never be in charge of a “country”, there needs to be some kind of independent oversight of the supposedly democratic process that elects these terrorists into power.

EasterIssland · 15/01/2025 23:50

Ohthatsabitshit · 15/01/2025 23:44

I think when they finally let the world see what has been happening in Gaza some posters may find they don’t feel the same way about what has been happening. I suspect the world will find it harder and harder to accept or justify on any level at all. I hope there will be an outpouring of support for the survivors of the slaughter and every individual involved is held accountable for their part in this.

i hope international and independent journalists and organisations are allowed to go into Gaza soon. Maybe then the world will accept what locals and local journalists have been saying for year and a half

AngryLikeHades · 15/01/2025 23:49

How is a ceasefire deal agreed and what laws/policies/agreements do they agree to or not.
They aren't concerned enough by ethics and they aren't seen to be rational so I'm trying to think about the incentives that might drive them to stopping the war.

NoisyBear · 15/01/2025 23:46

Oodiks · 15/01/2025 23:31

You mean Bush's War on Terror?

No. It would be great if you would stop trying to language police me now. It feels very pointless and tedious. If I say something I don't mean I will go back and correct it myself, thanks.

Ohthatsabitshit · 15/01/2025 23:44

I think when they finally let the world see what has been happening in Gaza some posters may find they don’t feel the same way about what has been happening. I suspect the world will find it harder and harder to accept or justify on any level at all. I hope there will be an outpouring of support for the survivors of the slaughter and every individual involved is held accountable for their part in this.

mouthpipette · 15/01/2025 23:43

In a speech by Blinken yesterday, he basically spelt out how Hamas couldn't be defeated without implementing a whole raft of measures that basically took away a lot of Palestinian grievances.

In a statement that must have embarrassed Israel, he stated that there are as many Hamas fighters today as there were 15 months ago.

It was a clear turnaround of US thinking, or at least public expression of that thinking. It was actually quite heartening to hear him talk about Palestinian governance and international investment in Gaza's infrastructure.

It also goes to show how the US could have stopped this at any time, had it so wanted. But that's another story.

So it does look like the US will push against Israel and will press for greater Palestinian rights, if Blinken is to be as good as his word.

tobeornottobe1 · 15/01/2025 23:38

@Oodiks not going to go round in circles with you. You know it and you are playing games. The land was taken from the indigenous Palestinians and given by the British to Jewish settlers fleeing the war. Since then there has been land grabs and illegal occupation. We all know it and ICJ has ruled it.

Oodiks · 15/01/2025 23:32

tobeornottobe1 · 15/01/2025 23:29

The state of Israel came about in 1948, before this it was known as Palestine. You can't change history to suit what you believe was in the bible/torah/quran!

Why was it known as Palestine? Who called it that and why?

Oodiks · 15/01/2025 23:31

NoisyBear · 15/01/2025 22:28

Not really. The US war on terror?

You mean Bush's War on Terror?

tobeornottobe1 · 15/01/2025 23:29

The state of Israel came about in 1948, before this it was known as Palestine. You can't change history to suit what you believe was in the bible/torah/quran!

Whatsinanamehey · 15/01/2025 23:26

NoisyBear · 15/01/2025 23:18

That doesn't make them the government of Palestine. Nothing I said was incorrect. Using Palestine as suggested by that poster in the same way I used Israel would make no sense.

It's just splitting hairs now, it's obvious you were not blaming every single Israeli but using the same language to frame the war that even the Israeli government does.

Oodiks · 15/01/2025 23:26

tobeornottobe1 · 15/01/2025 23:23

Palestine was a country long before Israel! There are indigenous Palestinians older than the state of Israel. They are occupying Palestinian land, illegally. Maybe need to re check history books again. 🤔

When did Palestine become a country?

LetThereBeLove · 15/01/2025 23:26

tobeornottobe1 · 15/01/2025 23:23

Palestine was a country long before Israel! There are indigenous Palestinians older than the state of Israel. They are occupying Palestinian land, illegally. Maybe need to re check history books again. 🤔

Perhaps you need to check the Bible before making ridiculous pronouncements like this 😂

Whatsinanamehey · 15/01/2025 23:25

NoisyBear · 15/01/2025 23:18

That doesn't make them the government of Palestine. Nothing I said was incorrect. Using Palestine as suggested by that poster in the same way I used Israel would make no sense.

Yes it doesn't make sense in that context as the PA rules over the occupied west bank.

stormy4319trevor · 15/01/2025 23:24

Hamas don't govern the West Bank or East Jerusalem, which form part of the Palestinian state recognised by the 146 UN member states.

tobeornottobe1 · 15/01/2025 23:23

Palestine was a country long before Israel! There are indigenous Palestinians older than the state of Israel. They are occupying Palestinian land, illegally. Maybe need to re check history books again. 🤔

NoisyBear · 15/01/2025 23:18

LetThereBeLove · 15/01/2025 23:10

Hamas is the elected 'government' of Gaza since the last election held in 2006.

That doesn't make them the government of Palestine. Nothing I said was incorrect. Using Palestine as suggested by that poster in the same way I used Israel would make no sense.

Oodiks · 15/01/2025 23:13

mouthpipette · 15/01/2025 23:02

A good overview of how the ceasefire suddenly came about and what the US really wants.
Some pretty good analysis, though I don't agree with some of what Michael Walker is suggesting here.

Blinken's speech yesterday is very interesting.

Who made it?

LetThereBeLove · 15/01/2025 23:10

NoisyBear · 15/01/2025 22:26

No I think I made it quite clear in one of my posts that usually when people refer to a country in that way they mean the Israeli government, the same way they mean the US government etc. Hamas are not the government of Palestine so it would make no sense to use Palestine in that way. But I think you know that.

Edited

Hamas is the elected 'government' of Gaza since the last election held in 2006.