Please or to access all these features

Conflict in the Middle East

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

The brutal truth of the war in Gaza.

180 replies

Whatsinanamehey · 23/12/2024 10:19

"To find safety from Gaza, you need first to become the victim of a catastrophic injury and then be lucky enough to be identified, selected and extracted.
That's one of the many brutal truths from this long war."

This article is certainly an eye opening read on the failures of those governments who support Israel in their campaign of cruelty. It's very rare for Israel to allow even injured children with multiple limb amputations, to leave Gaza for treatment. I have read previously that despite all the difficult work to organise an evacuation.. in the last minute Israel will just refuse it with no explanation given.

It isn't enough that they torture and murder health care staff, they bomb hospitals, the routinely block medical aid, they constantly bomb residential blocks and safe zones. After all of that only a select few are given permission to leave this living nightmare.

https://news.sky.com/story/how-the-lives-of-the-few-child-amputees-allowed-to-leave-gaza-are-being-rebuilt-elsewhere-13278543

How the lives of the few child amputees allowed to leave Gaza are being rebuilt elsewhere

Sky News' US correspondent Mark Stone has followed the stories of some of the few Palestinians who have left Gaza for medical care.

https://news.sky.com/story/how-the-lives-of-the-few-child-amputees-allowed-to-leave-gaza-are-being-rebuilt-elsewhere-13278543

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
YoYoYoYo12345 · 12/01/2025 17:08

bluetonguegiraffe · 24/12/2024 16:04

So when you said the brutal truth about the war in Gaza, what you meant was one sided bias which entirely lays the blame on Israel and utterly ignores the facts that:

  1. Hamas broke a ceasefire and launched a deliberately barbaric attack on civilian children, women and men to provoke a violent reaction from Israel
  2. Having provoked a violent attack, Hamas has not sheltered its own citizens in its massive network of tunnels ( y'know, in the way Londoners could shelter in the Tube tunnels during WW2).
  3. Hamas use civilian homes and buildings to launch attacks from, meaning these buildings have to be targeted in a war against Hamas. Hamas knew this when it launched its terrorist attack on October 7th.
  4. Hamas has issued public statements actively glorying in the death of civilians ( the death it wrought in its own citizens) as necessary to fortify its fighters (the fighters cowering in the tunnels the civilians are not allowed in).
  5. Hamas could stop the war it started at any point by surrendering and handing back the hostages.

You do realise Hamas and Hezbollah have also fired tens of thousands at Israel since October 7th and would happily be bringing far more devastation to Israel than Israel is brining to Gaza, if only Israel did not have better defences.

War is horrific. Anyone can understand that. What I will never understand is the mentality which feels anger at Israel but not fury at Hamas.

Very true. Many ignore these facts though it's easier to just blame.e Israel for everything. Commendable that you persevere.

Wibble128 · 12/01/2025 17:01

Hamas still launch untargeted rockets into Israel and they still hold hostages taken on 7th Oct 23.

Lalaloveya · 12/01/2025 16:56

It's naive in the extreme to believe that handing back the hostages would end this.

Fordian · 12/01/2025 16:54

bluetonguegiraffe · 24/12/2024 16:04

So when you said the brutal truth about the war in Gaza, what you meant was one sided bias which entirely lays the blame on Israel and utterly ignores the facts that:

  1. Hamas broke a ceasefire and launched a deliberately barbaric attack on civilian children, women and men to provoke a violent reaction from Israel
  2. Having provoked a violent attack, Hamas has not sheltered its own citizens in its massive network of tunnels ( y'know, in the way Londoners could shelter in the Tube tunnels during WW2).
  3. Hamas use civilian homes and buildings to launch attacks from, meaning these buildings have to be targeted in a war against Hamas. Hamas knew this when it launched its terrorist attack on October 7th.
  4. Hamas has issued public statements actively glorying in the death of civilians ( the death it wrought in its own citizens) as necessary to fortify its fighters (the fighters cowering in the tunnels the civilians are not allowed in).
  5. Hamas could stop the war it started at any point by surrendering and handing back the hostages.

You do realise Hamas and Hezbollah have also fired tens of thousands at Israel since October 7th and would happily be bringing far more devastation to Israel than Israel is brining to Gaza, if only Israel did not have better defences.

War is horrific. Anyone can understand that. What I will never understand is the mentality which feels anger at Israel but not fury at Hamas.

This ^^ . I refuse to listen to any condemnation of Israel that does not acknowledge all this would not be happening if it weren't for the murderous barbarity of Oct 7th.

Hamas could stop this tomorrow but choose not to.

PeasfullPerson · 12/01/2025 10:49

Whatsinanamehey · 23/12/2024 10:27

Israel routinely blocks medical evacuations of children after bombing and maiming them. Why? Why does Israel block small children from leaving to access the care they need after they brutalise them? These are serious questions that governments including our own need to press on.

https://www.theguardian.com/global-development/2024/nov/15/gaza-war-children-humanitarian-aid-mazyouna-israel-refuses-medical-evacuation

💔

PeasfullPerson · 12/01/2025 10:49

Whatsinanamehey · 23/12/2024 10:25

This is Rahaf after Israel bombed her home in Gaza. Only two years old, she is considered as one of the lucky ones who was able to leave Gaza for treatment. Both of her legs amputated not long after she learned to walk.

💔

PeasfullPerson · 12/01/2025 10:48

Whatsinanamehey · 23/12/2024 10:19

"To find safety from Gaza, you need first to become the victim of a catastrophic injury and then be lucky enough to be identified, selected and extracted.
That's one of the many brutal truths from this long war."

This article is certainly an eye opening read on the failures of those governments who support Israel in their campaign of cruelty. It's very rare for Israel to allow even injured children with multiple limb amputations, to leave Gaza for treatment. I have read previously that despite all the difficult work to organise an evacuation.. in the last minute Israel will just refuse it with no explanation given.

It isn't enough that they torture and murder health care staff, they bomb hospitals, the routinely block medical aid, they constantly bomb residential blocks and safe zones. After all of that only a select few are given permission to leave this living nightmare.

https://news.sky.com/story/how-the-lives-of-the-few-child-amputees-allowed-to-leave-gaza-are-being-rebuilt-elsewhere-13278543

💔

Lalaloveya · 12/01/2025 00:23

SpunkyCritic · 11/01/2025 22:48

A poster questions why the outrage towards Israel is so much louder than for Hamas (as it was in the OP).
This leads you to question whether she cares about sick children.

Really??!!

What stupid point are you trying to make?
Whilst I don't know @bluetonguegiraffe@bluetonguegiraffe I am willing to bet she doesn't like dead kids.
Grow up.

Sounded a lot like they were ignoring what Israel has done here. They didn't get a mention. They seemed to completely ignore the entire point of the thread in fact.

I think the ones killing and maiming kids including denying them healthcare should take responsibility for their disgusting actions. Regardless of who they are.

And at this stage I think it's reasonable to question what exactly people who support the IDF are supporting. Because they're responsible for a lot of dead kids. And more every single day.

SpunkyCritic · 11/01/2025 22:48

MissyB1 · 28/12/2024 22:11

@bluetonguegiraffe could you tell us if you support Israel in not allowing seriously sick and maimed children to leave Gaza and get the healthcare they need? That was what OP started the thread about (I thought you might need reminding). Do you also support the destruction of the hospitals in Gaza, so that the sick and injured cannot seek any medical attention? If you do could you tell us why?

A poster questions why the outrage towards Israel is so much louder than for Hamas (as it was in the OP).
This leads you to question whether she cares about sick children.

Really??!!

What stupid point are you trying to make?
Whilst I don't know @bluetonguegiraffe@bluetonguegiraffe I am willing to bet she doesn't like dead kids.
Grow up.

MissyB1 · 28/12/2024 22:11

@bluetonguegiraffe could you tell us if you support Israel in not allowing seriously sick and maimed children to leave Gaza and get the healthcare they need? That was what OP started the thread about (I thought you might need reminding). Do you also support the destruction of the hospitals in Gaza, so that the sick and injured cannot seek any medical attention? If you do could you tell us why?

Martymcfly24 · 28/12/2024 22:09

ThisPearlPeer · 28/12/2024 22:05

@Martymcfly24
Why does Hamas exist? 🤔
From their Charter, and the very first points.
-Destruction of Israel: The charter explicitly calls for the destruction of Israel and rejects any peaceful resolution or negotiations that involve recognizing the state of Israel.
-Religious Motivation: It frames the conflict as a religious struggle, claiming that Palestine is an Islamic land that must not be surrendered.

It's all there for everyone to read. Don't believe it? watch the 7 October tapes. Islamists in ecstasy, their best day ever, slaughtering Jews / infidels. Screaming allahu akbar. You'll notice none were shouting 'freedom of Palestine' etc. seemed like they had another agenda. Not to mention 'normal Gazans' cheering and rejoicing at a girl, Jewish of course, contorted and bleeding. Spitting and beating her.

Prob what she deserved hey,

Why did Netanyahu support them if they wanted the destruction of Israel?

MissyB1 · 28/12/2024 22:06

Charley50 · 24/12/2024 17:29

I agree with @bluetonguegiraffe. OP why don't you start a thread about the thousands of deaths in the war in Sudan or Turkey's slaughter of Kurds for example?

Why don’t you?

ThisPearlPeer · 28/12/2024 22:05

@Martymcfly24
Why does Hamas exist? 🤔
From their Charter, and the very first points.
-Destruction of Israel: The charter explicitly calls for the destruction of Israel and rejects any peaceful resolution or negotiations that involve recognizing the state of Israel.
-Religious Motivation: It frames the conflict as a religious struggle, claiming that Palestine is an Islamic land that must not be surrendered.

It's all there for everyone to read. Don't believe it? watch the 7 October tapes. Islamists in ecstasy, their best day ever, slaughtering Jews / infidels. Screaming allahu akbar. You'll notice none were shouting 'freedom of Palestine' etc. seemed like they had another agenda. Not to mention 'normal Gazans' cheering and rejoicing at a girl, Jewish of course, contorted and bleeding. Spitting and beating her.

Prob what she deserved hey,

Martymcfly24 · 28/12/2024 21:45

SpiritAdder · 28/12/2024 21:43

Schrodinger’s maimed Palestinian children- they’re real but Israel has been forced by Hamas to attack innocent children as part of a diabolic plot to weaponise their suffering while simultaneously there are no maimed Palestinian children, it is only disgusting Hamas propagandist lies covering up IDF’s massive success with 90% of deaths definitely being terrorist combatants.

These posters can’t even keep their falsehoods from contradicting each other.

Why does Hamas exist?

SpiritAdder · 28/12/2024 21:43

wholettheturnipsburn · 26/12/2024 12:24

Hamas are disgusting and it amazes me how well their propaganda has worked

Schrodinger’s maimed Palestinian children- they’re real but Israel has been forced by Hamas to attack innocent children as part of a diabolic plot to weaponise their suffering while simultaneously there are no maimed Palestinian children, it is only disgusting Hamas propagandist lies covering up IDF’s massive success with 90% of deaths definitely being terrorist combatants.

These posters can’t even keep their falsehoods from contradicting each other.

Lalaloveya · 26/12/2024 12:28

wholettheturnipsburn · 26/12/2024 12:24

Hamas are disgusting and it amazes me how well their propaganda has worked

Maybe they're picking up tips from Israel.

wholettheturnipsburn · 26/12/2024 12:24

Switcher · 26/12/2024 12:21

I completely agree that Hamas are barbaric terrorists who will stop at nothing to destroy Israel, including weaponising the suffering of what they claim are their people. I hope this darkness of Islamism fades from the world.

Hamas are disgusting and it amazes me how well their propaganda has worked

Lalaloveya · 26/12/2024 12:23

Switcher · 26/12/2024 12:21

I completely agree that Hamas are barbaric terrorists who will stop at nothing to destroy Israel, including weaponising the suffering of what they claim are their people. I hope this darkness of Islamism fades from the world.

Any thoughts on the article this thread is about?

MrsSkylerWhite · 26/12/2024 12:22

@DonnaHadDee What a lovely family ... When one detonation sends up a particularly large cloud of smoke, Fenton exults: "How beautiful! How beautiful! How beautiful! Thanks be to God“

Sickening. With extremists on both sides it’s impossible to imagine how there will ever be resolution.

Switcher · 26/12/2024 12:21

I completely agree that Hamas are barbaric terrorists who will stop at nothing to destroy Israel, including weaponising the suffering of what they claim are their people. I hope this darkness of Islamism fades from the world.

Lalaloveya · 26/12/2024 12:15

ThisPearlPeer13 · 26/12/2024 11:17

This is truly horrific. Hamas are monsters.

Israel maimed this child.

Scirocco · 26/12/2024 11:30

ThisPearlPeer13 · 26/12/2024 11:17

This is truly horrific. Hamas are monsters.

As are the people who decided an appropriate response to Hamas's crimes would be to bomb, starve and commit atrocities against civilians. This was not the only course of action available to Israel. It still isn't. There is still time to step away from this, to commit to a ceasefire, to conduct military action within limits that protect civilian populations.

wholettheturnipsburn · 26/12/2024 11:24

bluetonguegiraffe · 24/12/2024 16:04

So when you said the brutal truth about the war in Gaza, what you meant was one sided bias which entirely lays the blame on Israel and utterly ignores the facts that:

  1. Hamas broke a ceasefire and launched a deliberately barbaric attack on civilian children, women and men to provoke a violent reaction from Israel
  2. Having provoked a violent attack, Hamas has not sheltered its own citizens in its massive network of tunnels ( y'know, in the way Londoners could shelter in the Tube tunnels during WW2).
  3. Hamas use civilian homes and buildings to launch attacks from, meaning these buildings have to be targeted in a war against Hamas. Hamas knew this when it launched its terrorist attack on October 7th.
  4. Hamas has issued public statements actively glorying in the death of civilians ( the death it wrought in its own citizens) as necessary to fortify its fighters (the fighters cowering in the tunnels the civilians are not allowed in).
  5. Hamas could stop the war it started at any point by surrendering and handing back the hostages.

You do realise Hamas and Hezbollah have also fired tens of thousands at Israel since October 7th and would happily be bringing far more devastation to Israel than Israel is brining to Gaza, if only Israel did not have better defences.

War is horrific. Anyone can understand that. What I will never understand is the mentality which feels anger at Israel but not fury at Hamas.

👏. Perfect post

However, it doesn't fit with the virtue signalling on this part of
Mumsnet from the same 6 posters.

Over and over and over and over

ThisPearlPeer13 · 26/12/2024 11:17

Whatsinanamehey · 23/12/2024 10:25

This is Rahaf after Israel bombed her home in Gaza. Only two years old, she is considered as one of the lucky ones who was able to leave Gaza for treatment. Both of her legs amputated not long after she learned to walk.

This is truly horrific. Hamas are monsters.

Whatsinanamehey · 26/12/2024 09:42

SpiritAdder · 24/12/2024 19:06

Thank you OP for posting.

In the spirit of Christmas, we should be thinking of what we can do for the wounded children many of whom will die if they are not evacuated. Many already have. We should be fighting for them to have the gift of life, the gift of hope, the gift of safety and security.

”Goodwill to all men” isn’t meant to be weaponised to mean don’t mention the horrible truth of what is happening to children trapped in Gaza in case it is upsetting.

I have a monthly donation to Heal Palestine. It is one of the US charities that funds the medical evacuation of wounded children to Egypt and the US for medical care. They also fund food and medical humanitarian aid to the strip. It’s worth a look if anyone is looking to give a gift to children in need for Christmas.

Thank you for sharing.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread