Has enough been done to tackle incitement to genocide?

Read some history. Rabin was leading Israel to agreement but then was murdered by a right-wing extremist. Later, Bill Clinton said it was Arafat who scuppered the two-state proposal, which was agreed in theory and just waiting for agreement on the fine details, because he said if he accepted it he would be murdered by his own side.

Thanks. I think that response tells us clearly enough what your answer would probably be.

Maybe because it's about the thousandth thread saying all the same things.

So challenge it however you feel best when you encounter it? (Wherever that is, you haven't specified so it's difficult to make a more accurate suggestion. I don't think anyone here has a hotline to Smotrich or Ben-Gvir.)

If you find yourself in the position of constantly encountering people who are inciting, supporting or openly celebrating the deaths of Palestinians maybe it would be a good idea to take more care of the company you keep. The only people I've encountered inciting genocide have been antisemites.

My refusal to answer promptly is clearly due to some horrendous motive

More projection and unnecessary exaggeration. As you had just answered, that statement clearly didn't refer to you. This thread is packed with posters giving their opinions on the necessity or lack thereof (in their view) for a Jewish state so I found it interesting that no-one answered that particular question.

No. Are you?

It had barely been 20 minutes before the question was answered to the poster it was addressed to, that's hardly refusing to answer is it? Are you new to mumsnet?

I cannot answer for anyone else, and my opinion is not of any consequence, but I support Israel in its continued existence.

I do not support what Israel has been doing to Palestinians through illegal settlements and stealing Palestinian land, or the disproportionate destruction of Gaza, and killing there; or in general the reign of control by the extremist dishonest Prime Minister, and those whom he obeys so as to stay in power. None of this will bring Israel security.

They don't only allow it. The isrseli government sanctions the theft of Palestinian land itself. It comes directly from the government and they spend millions of shekels in establishing illegal settlements in direct violation of international law.

People have been jumping in all over the place answering questions not addressed to them and giving unsolicited opinions so I didn't think there'd be an issue. Refusing to answer is an answer in itself.

Why on Earth would I say that? That makes no sense at all. It'd be helpful if people could stop projecting.

Come off it. It's not just Netanyahu. If Israel had wanted a two state solution at any point we'd have had one by now. And the state wouldn't have allowed and supported the continued violent theft of Palestinian land which continues to this day.

I'm not answering your ridiculous fantasies. I find the use of these made up scenarios are frequently being used to justify Israel breaking International law and to minimise the actual reality of what is happening right now. I find it appalling and refuse to take part.

I’ve already said that I loathe Netanyahu and that a two-state solution woukd require a new Israeli leader.

Oh, your comment has reminded me that you still haven’t replied to my hypothetical question to you. I’ll repeat it for you.

Let’s just assume a hypothetical situation. Suppose that countries such as the US and the UK stopped selling weapons to Israel and the surrounding Arab countries then collaborated to launch an outright attack with the declared aim of wiping Israel off the map. (I’ll be generous and refrain from adding "and killing all Jews", which is an avowed aim of Hamas and some other Muslim leaders.)

If that happened, would you support a proposal for the rest of the international community to support Israel and fight against the Arab coalition? Or would you be happy for Israel to be destroyed, leaving no majority Jewish state anywhere in the world?

What about before Oct 7 as Israel was not working towards a two state solution then either?

From The Times of Israel 8 Oct 2023
https://www.timesofisrael.com/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-hamas-now-its-blown-up-in-our-faces/
( my bolding)

For years, the various governments led by Benjamin Netanyahu took an approach that divided power between the Gaza Strip and the West Bank — bringing Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas to his knees while making moves that propped up the Hamas terror group.

The idea was to prevent Abbas — or anyone else in the Palestinian Authority’s West Bank government — from advancing toward the establishment of a Palestinian state

If you bothered to notice, that question was not asked openly but aimed at one poster who has replied.

I mean the same could be said of Palestinians, why would they want a neighbouring state with people who think they have a right to steal their homes, to murder, abduct and torture their children, to restrict their access to food and water etc etc. Israel haven't been sat on their hands treating Palestinians with respect, they have been breaking international law for decades in their treatment of them.

And what people will want to continue to live under brutal illegal violent occupation? Which the Palestinians have, under the Israeli occupation for decades.

Of course they don’t want one at the moment. What country would want a neighbouring state ruled by people who have repeatedly vowed to wipe them from the face of the earth? People who came over the border to cold-bloodedly murder, torture, rape and abduct civilians?

It's very telling that no-one will answer this question.