Please or to access all these features

Conflict in the Middle East

Disgusting comments like this normalised

268 replies

jerkorperk · 27/06/2024 07:59

I see countless UK run accounts like this. Hundreds of comments just like this.

Why? It's horrendous. How can we let this be said in Britain without any consequences?

You couldn't start conversations about other communities and not end up reported to the police.

Disgusting comments like this normalised
OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Scirocco · 27/06/2024 13:11

No form of racism, religiously motivated hate or other forms of hatred should be considered acceptable. I hope that whoever posted that was reported to the relevant social media platform and had their comment removed.

TomeTome · 27/06/2024 13:05

AderynBach · 27/06/2024 12:31

Whether it's just about Zionists or Jewish people in general, it's equally unacceptable as a slur. Zionists are people who believe Jews should have a homeland. The state of Israel exists, so this is simply believing that an internationally recognised nation should continue existing. We don't usually have a special word for people who want a country to continue existing, much less one that is used as a slur or written on signs saying "not welcome here".

Edited

You’re right we don’t usually have a word like that and yet many Jewish people would describe themselves as Jews but not Zionists and of course there are many states that are not recognised by some but are by others. As I said upthread I was simply pointing out that the slang “zio “ was likely to be a shortening of Zionist. As you were.

AderynBach · 27/06/2024 12:31

TomeTome · 27/06/2024 08:55

In all honesty @Vittuunterroristit I’m not going to read a long explanation of terminology used here. Thank you for the links but I think this is derailing a thread in which @jerkorperk wanted to focus on freedom of expression (I think?). I appreciate that being anti-Zionist is seen as more acceptable than being anti-Jew (obviously!) but I felt an early nudge away from that terminology might make a more interesting discussion.

Whether it's just about Zionists or Jewish people in general, it's equally unacceptable as a slur. Zionists are people who believe Jews should have a homeland. The state of Israel exists, so this is simply believing that an internationally recognised nation should continue existing. We don't usually have a special word for people who want a country to continue existing, much less one that is used as a slur or written on signs saying "not welcome here".

Comedycook · 27/06/2024 12:28

Social media is generally a cess pit. Never fails to amaze the things people write.

What I think is interesting and different about anti semetism is that the left wing are often the ones indulging in it, in a way they wouldn't dream of doing when it comes to other forms of racism. I find this particularly irritating as the left wing tend to frame themselves as having the moral high ground and that it's simply a manifestation of their superior humanitarianism. If you object to them, you are then portrayed as some sort of genocidal maniac.

Vittuunterroristit · 27/06/2024 12:19

poshsnobtwit · 27/06/2024 12:16

Oh no, was that the Israeli lefty one?

No, a different one.

Aaron95 · 27/06/2024 12:19

You couldn't start conversations about other communities and not end up reported to the police.

Yes you can. You really don't have to search too hard to find horrible comments about any group of people. It's the internet. The police don't have the time or resources to investigate every nasty comment besides which the person making it could be from any country in the world not nexessarily the UK.

poshsnobtwit · 27/06/2024 12:16

Vittuunterroristit · 27/06/2024 12:15

There was also an AMA recently from a Jewish poster who lives in Israel. it was such a shitshow it ended up get taken down. Some of the posters who made the most blatantly antisemitic comments are still around. One of them even then went onto the Jewish Mumsnetters board to post their antisemitism there. So no, people aren't more polite to Jewish people.

Edited

Oh no, was that the Israeli lefty one?

Vittuunterroristit · 27/06/2024 12:15

poshsnobtwit · 27/06/2024 12:12

It's utterly horrendous, I assume you reported it and it should be taken down. This is simply not true though:

You couldn't start conversations about other communities and not end up reported to the police

I've read this line so many times on here, and it really makes me wonder if the people saying it live in some sort of vacuum. There is nasty, online, vile stuff spewed constantly about many communities and people not only don't report it, but they join in and add fuel to the fire, and it is normalized. This is racism/xenophobia, and it's everywhere unfortunately.
Some time ago there was a (brilliant) AMA about being an orthodox jew, and posters were falling over themselves to thank the OP and to be polite and not wanting to offend. A muslim then did one as a spin off, and the tone was completely different from the outset. The same with the Traveller one.
I live in a predominantly white area and on our local facebook group the constant shit about "You have to be Muslim/Black to get social housing" is horrendous. I could literally count on one hand the amount of muslims/black people there are, but yes of course all 120 houses are going to all 4 of them . Then people jump on to call them all dirty/thieving/immigrants and of course go on to say they aren't racist but they are sick of "our own not being looked after". Muslims around the world were murdered post 9/11, and they are still being attacked for it 23 years later. This is everywhere, it's not a problem reserved for jewish people.

ETA that social media platforms need to step up to the plate and moderate, as the more people write bile like this the more it does become normalized.

Edited

There was also an AMA recently from a Jewish poster who lives in Israel. it was such a shitshow it ended up get taken down. Some of the posters who made the most blatantly antisemitic comments are still around. One of them even then went onto the Jewish Mumsnetters board to post their antisemitism there. So no, people aren't more polite to Jewish people.

poshsnobtwit · 27/06/2024 12:12

It's utterly horrendous, I assume you reported it and it should be taken down. This is simply not true though:

You couldn't start conversations about other communities and not end up reported to the police

I've read this line so many times on here, and it really makes me wonder if the people saying it live in some sort of vacuum. There is nasty, online, vile stuff spewed constantly about many communities and people not only don't report it, but they join in and add fuel to the fire, and it is normalized. This is racism/xenophobia, and it's everywhere unfortunately.
Some time ago there was a (brilliant) AMA about being an orthodox jew, and posters were falling over themselves to thank the OP and to be polite and not wanting to offend. A muslim then did one as a spin off, and the tone was completely different from the outset. The same with the Traveller one.
I live in a predominantly white area and on our local facebook group the constant shit about "You have to be Muslim/Black to get social housing" is horrendous. I could literally count on one hand the amount of muslims/black people there are, but yes of course all 120 houses are going to all 4 of them . Then people jump on to call them all dirty/thieving/immigrants and of course go on to say they aren't racist but they are sick of "our own not being looked after". Muslims around the world were murdered post 9/11, and they are still being attacked for it 23 years later. This is everywhere, it's not a problem reserved for jewish people.

ETA that social media platforms need to step up to the plate and moderate, as the more people write bile like this the more it does become normalized.

Comedycook · 27/06/2024 09:10

Even the most vile anti semites knows they can't say certain things...like racists and islamophobes too.

You insert ethnicity xxxxxx. is socially unacceptable as well as illegal. So they need to find more subtle ways of expressing their repulsive views and thus giving them some deniability.

Vittuunterroristit · 27/06/2024 09:06

TomeTome · 27/06/2024 08:55

In all honesty @Vittuunterroristit I’m not going to read a long explanation of terminology used here. Thank you for the links but I think this is derailing a thread in which @jerkorperk wanted to focus on freedom of expression (I think?). I appreciate that being anti-Zionist is seen as more acceptable than being anti-Jew (obviously!) but I felt an early nudge away from that terminology might make a more interesting discussion.

You're the one who brought up that they meant zionist and not Jew. A dictionary entry is hardly a long explanation. But suddenly it's "stop derailing the thread".

If yoy want to believe that they purely meant zionist and its all innocent then fine. I doubt anyone can convince you otherwise, especially given some of your previously stated views on what yoy want to happen to Israel and Israelis.

TomeTome · 27/06/2024 08:55

In all honesty @Vittuunterroristit I’m not going to read a long explanation of terminology used here. Thank you for the links but I think this is derailing a thread in which @jerkorperk wanted to focus on freedom of expression (I think?). I appreciate that being anti-Zionist is seen as more acceptable than being anti-Jew (obviously!) but I felt an early nudge away from that terminology might make a more interesting discussion.

Vittuunterroristit · 27/06/2024 08:48

TomeTome · 27/06/2024 08:43

I don’t really know what “a dog whistle for” means in this context. Are you saying you think Zionist and Jewish are the same thing? Or that you think these people think there isn’t a distinction? Either way these aren’t the sort of people I would read on-line so I expect you know more about it than me.

https://www.merriam-webster.com/wordplay/dog-whistle-political-meaning

Either way these aren’t the sort of people I would read on-line so I expect you know more about it than me.

Why would you assume that these are the type of people I'd read online? Except from when they're posted on this board of course. The zionist dogwhistle is older than the Internet.

What's the Political Meaning of 'Dog Whistle'?

A message only some can hear

https://www.merriam-webster.com/wordplay/dog-whistle-political-meaning

TomeTome · 27/06/2024 08:43

I don’t really know what “a dog whistle for” means in this context. Are you saying you think Zionist and Jewish are the same thing? Or that you think these people think there isn’t a distinction? Either way these aren’t the sort of people I would read on-line so I expect you know more about it than me.

79Helene · 27/06/2024 08:39

TomeTome · 27/06/2024 08:30

I think Zionist not Jew?

Why are Jewish communities being physically attacked?

The "Zionist not Jew" bullshit is a boring trope now.

Vittuunterroristit · 27/06/2024 08:35

TomeTome · 27/06/2024 08:30

I think Zionist not Jew?

Yes and zionist has never ever been used as a dog whistle for Jew before...

TomeTome · 27/06/2024 08:30

I think Zionist not Jew?

jerkorperk · 27/06/2024 07:59

And clearly, 'Zio' is being used as a thinly veiled cover word for Jew.

OP posts: